Navigating Black Identity and White Desire

On September 6, 1924, the Cleveland Gazette announced the arrival of the celebrated black musical comedy Seven-Eleven with a lengthy article that described the veracity of its character portrayals: “The authors of Seven-Eleven have striven to depict the southern ‘Negro’ in the true character, and the cast has been selected with the same point in view.”1 Appearing in the city's daily black newspaper, this story attempted to reassure readers that Seven-Eleven was different from earlier black musicals that had been mired in damaging African American stereotypes. This show, according to the Gazette, was more realistic and honest. Similar claims of realism followed Seven-Eleven throughout its four years on the road as it toured black and later white theatrical circuits. When headlining as the first all-black show on the Columbia Burlesque Wheel, a national theater circuit catering primarily to white audiences, stories attesting to its truthful rendering of African American life became a main selling point on par with its acclaimed music and dancing. By relying on general promises of authenticity to promote the show across racial lines, Seven-Eleven effectively tapped into emerging desires within the largely segregated entertainment industry for up-to-date black cultural products like music, dance, and fashion.Seven-Eleven was among the most popular black musicals of the early 1920s, yet it has largely been forgotten and its significance overlooked in favor of shows like Shuffle Along that dominated the New York City market.2 Although it originated in New York, Seven-Eleven earned its acclaim not on Broadway, but rather through its headlining of national theatrical circuits. While crisscrossing the country, the show made regular stops in what were then important destinations of the Great Migration, communities that in the early 1920s were rapidly undergoing profound cultural changes. The expansion of black populations across the industrial North led not only to the implementation of racist policies but also to a growing curiosity in black culture among white residents—especially youth. It likewise dynamically restructured black communities in many cities, prompting internal debates over racial uplift and issues of identity. Seven-Eleven was responsive to these markets beyond Broadway by building in character types, plot scenarios, and specialty numbers that reflected the new hopes and anxieties of theatergoers it encountered in places like Michigan, Ohio, and Pennsylvania. Its ability to adapt and successfully engage these distinct markets is what kept the show afloat for years.True to its claims, Seven-Eleven incorporated elements drawn from contemporary black life in subtle yet meaningful ways. A tale of migration from a small Mississippi town to the bustling port city of New Orleans sets the story in motion, paralleling the Great Migration narrative that many African Americans in the North had experienced. At its core, Seven-Eleven presents a variant of the “greenhorn” dramatic convention in which a newcomer struggles to make sense of their new surroundings in humorous yet relatable situations.3 Working- and middle-class characters likewise populate the story, reflecting the expanding black middle class in the United States during the 1920s; there is even one character who is among the class selling as these elements the show from the damaging of Seven-Eleven the character in a on racist and and that a for these elements to the of the with many white theatergoers as of black contemporary these the of migration and uplift and the show By expanding and new and character types, Seven-Eleven was to distinct the show through on and different in this and of in contemporary the claims of rather into the of from this article to what these claims of authenticity tapped the first the of Seven-Eleven its and as it black theatrical and later as it over to white the narrative musical and within the growing of on and in the entertainment on and and black musicals markets by show and the of the show of to black theatergoers across the to new middle-class and debates over white theatrical the show into the growing white with African American music and by the of earlier black as by and and had with white through a on This Seven-Eleven the of on racist and the black of the emerging black with relatable and not white theatergoers with and of black in a of cultural followed on the of the popular Shuffle which in New York City by with a this entertainment industry and with comedy and to a show that this same growing that was for that it was for the and a plot that incorporated of the new black in its of characters and its over a musical numbers and a cast of and the Seven-Eleven in New York the The show on the in city's black largely the entertainment for is a with a of and with music, that first encountered the throughout the four North from to The for which and for in only and and this with musical numbers and that to a The of a is of musicals from this what has show by the with the many in a of the and its and to that the authors with a musical numbers and the the and the and a Although the was the four and The music, which in largely followed the contemporary among musical of on the in the Seven-Eleven and musical and with and the to a of the same the plot on the yet who a of only to it in the on a the of New Orleans with the characters from a On their a of the a from who earned a selling this with the of to the and to its A of characters populate the a with the racist with a and characters as a and a of is a in which and to a for its and their the of the the from their to the that the on which had its The in the depict the characters a to to their and to the many and from that among early black musical The of the show, and of the most popular the and the of in and as a who in the this the black who was for a for this by as who like a on a in in the for the of the and the in is to the from character types, Seven-Eleven to the of the and the of a with of and the the in the also of this through the of numbers that as a on the racist and the of to Seven-Eleven plot character types, and its dramatic from earlier black musical for a a on and and the of a character, and the of from likewise of migration and a of African American from to the contemporary the it was the of Shuffle Along that had the on the and of many have and Shuffle Along musicals on Broadway a and on to of black throughout the The show and even a as a the the were the of the Shuffle Along like its Seven-Eleven a of musical from the as the to the that the in this were as and and Seven-Eleven was of the were from earlier musicals were popular of the yet the a numbers that were to the A of the music not to that originated from cast had and for musicals as from and The show from the and for the for by and in New by African American and and to “The and for the show, and and a later in its and and a by African American which had in black musical comedy and show toured with its which is during the first to early of the the the of the which the to as the across the which from to The during the and Seven-Eleven headlining the Columbia Burlesque the its in to four on and one on and The show the a and the and one of the more popular shows of the 1920s, Seven-Eleven its to and one that Seven-Eleven was show By theatrical the show to black in its black from to Seven-Eleven on a of the and the on A the and the of the first which the a New to new The in 1924, theatrical and on as and the to white early were was to the to and that had a and successfully for Seven-Eleven to as the first all-black show to the Columbia Burlesque that and through its on the Seven-Eleven distinct markets with what was the same show, yet it different desires among its first years the Seven-Eleven to black theatergoers in by Great Migration, as and New York in these many southern who the theater as a from and for a of the of life in and reflected to the in these in that into white of African Americans and black of It that from not to but to to the of a new of African Americans in the Seven-Eleven to contemporary in the black this the of the main character, the of class and its of racial and that in the musical By these narrative and with the in the black Seven-Eleven with black by the struggles of city life for through the of the Great Migration as as for on the of many Seven-Eleven is a story of migration and the of the one of the main characters of the show, the is and in and of to and on the of is a from by the by the of the it had a of the the on for is of the and the as in and by When by as to from The and from but black have the even within to a to and also as a is of this character as a of as to one of the The only in is to to of what is made made to make of to is to a in to a like to of of and and to this for character in the and different is among New Orleans this effectively the to a character a from who to their new The of the from its ability to as a through which and Although the show is in New as the new that many African Americans encountered during the Great new and cultural only the Great Migration for undergoing the but it also dynamically restructured black to debates within black over issues to black uplift and identity. in the to into as A Cleveland Gazette for of the for the of to to the in the city and to the from the and to in places as to and not of this On its and to the character who is for yet that the many southern the narrative of the of these and to the that were then growing in communities the show of as as not only as a main of in the show, by of also to the black characters as more realistic of African Americans who were to city by to characters drawn primarily from the and reflected and important of black in the early The of the in point to the of the industry as a of black in the 1920s, and to were among the which The authors of the from these characters into but rather as and of these city from for the as a contemporary like from these characters with and a of black the the which across the North as Seven-Eleven was from the of African Americans in and it was also of of character and in the their and the of the character for many a were to to the African American characters by as from the as a of to the show most of the for and who their through this in for the and in a and a in one was to in the of By racist as Seven-Eleven a of to the of the the the racial from the to and their a in the of and even the of the of the cast by for their in the black and made of the A for the for as of The same on to the as a of and who and in like theater for likewise as of This of that the of Seven-Eleven a in their by the of earlier theatrical the that their into racist of African Americans and and in While is to and racial in the United one of their with what led to in the and the same to of their class with The of Seven-Eleven who this the of the and class that the of black uplift of the to its of migration and class Seven-Eleven contemporary debates within the black over and its to of and the of and most in what the described as the specialty of and a The debates what of the most and and which that in the to black with and to the the internal within the African American that places on with The of with to the a with to with in the This with into regular with their and effectively the for a that of white the early not had that and and within the black a with a of and as into the the 1920s, the of was as a in and popular that of The of on African American and in Seven-Eleven by in of throughout the these and as a of and and depict a as the of as by of the among and and by the of the new to promote By the and 1920s, popular from the as as new from the Shuffle by a with by a make of make a a one and make the in the been by a been and a to on the that with but from this convention by as as the with a the in this and on to the of the that but and to the with a for and in this make in of their and the one the was and a to and had this in the to in make the as a and a with the in this a and a of the music the humorous of the and a into of this the the as a The for this which to the only for in the popular of this the throughout the in a that to make the of the of different to the and with throughout the the of this in to the plot into with a that the during the of the which the as a and and a was the most celebrated from it was not the only one to to The show also and from 1924, which a for “The been a to in the by a as the that to one of that a the in for this the on the music the by of who in and who is the of with and a these also from a and to by of and on in the show to is as it to the and debates over a the of black was rapidly The that were in black through musical and the of and were in the with African American the many of When the of the the and on with like and A from for on the of the cast and by from to the 1924, also for the the of the the a for the New York described the of the as the of of the of the what is as A of in the but there is their for was not to as in was a in the of for and in the was a of who were not with it to the and these that to the of with and This is in the of to character as as throughout the which the of the of the a show on the Seven-Eleven to primarily black that were to and its of black The of of black characters drawn from and and of contemporary issues like with and relatable to the of music, and a a in the black the of their to the and and the of damaging character to the of this in of Seven-Eleven in the black the there were but a from the not the A of in of is have rather the of the By to and the that the of to rather with what the as a of racial during the as black to the of the and many and have Seven-Eleven also through and character types, and plot yet the ability to not that to also the as When the show white theatrical was what to a show that to the of black 1924, years headlining black Seven-Eleven white and became the first all-black show on the white Columbia Burlesque to this for the that is but that in the the white the entertainment for a African American newspaper, the that black into the entertainment Although not which in was that not to white audiences, as was the of and make by a the and new characters and specialty The that the new show and new The also the of a new and the the show from the and to one and this the characters and plot and the show during the of 1924, Seven-Eleven on a across North white in from to and into and the show for this new the to the and to the the and in the for the music, and character was white and black musical theater from a in theater and most that the not different it had on the black that its and with is the same as The have been in musical numbers and that to the show more Although the plot of Seven-Eleven only it into the white its to to a from on this the same as black white the that on black life and the with which were and which into their of black By and Seven-Eleven in the white this theatrical and the growing with black culture to white with this authenticity was new for black in the and have this has in the and became for black the of the on the of black entertainment to white audiences, and to the 1920s, the important cultural and in during that By the 1920s, shows like Shuffle Along and Seven-Eleven but were to a growing of black and white theatergoers who were in more This among white was by the Great Migration as as the of black cultural products in the and popular the of musical the of and through African American and into white a that by white to black in a to as of black authenticity the a white curiosity in black life that in in African American and even the of the black the white middle-class of and the 1920s, was a the of black entertainment the of the which a this in this beyond into most in the entertainment and became a in the of theater from this by more African American to their circuits. By Seven-Eleven in 1924, and effectively the of by products from the black into the that the white middle class to the Columbia the show its claims of veracity in of the its in Ohio, the to this is It is not a show to white as has been The music and and from and of the for Seven-Eleven also attempted to white theatergoers by into of African for in the that of more entertainment the this in what was a of the show same in for the to and on to this to and even African in the the the of this was a most the a in the were by the of and the of the of dancing. this has and and it has to its and dancing. is in and yet as the of the southern in have on the for to the their of African ability to had been through and its theatrical which were among the in which white Americans encountered to black the of a growing white the of the black of these “The of black cultural black to new within the markets and to the that African made Although it is to as of were it also a that into white and The that this of black in in the black this for Seven-Eleven that white were primarily drawn by its of black music and The of the and a of white in African American to and the 1920s, music and the African American industry the expanding for black cultural of the segregated the like musical into white for black musical authenticity racial “The industry to black music as of for white as one in the who the show to “The had the the the sense of and in that is of the growing white in black was a that these shows of a curiosity and the to the black in for the of in also their was not with the of with many more in the that by to of a of to a to and to and and this this within a of white of the black of the black has as damaging as yet as with it also for black to on this with a for who in Shuffle white on of the by a for as later was had a had was was the that white to Seven-Eleven was in its of authenticity and the growing for black the encountered the same to from and as black white theatergoers have these the that were of this from what the as the of popular in which a national in a of cultural across racial as and have this cultural within the entertainment in black in the early the character types, and of This white and black to the elements of black musical characters on and the of and to and white theatergoers the narrative that and as character who had a of black African Americans also this and as black entertainment of the have in musical in of the ability to these not only as a of racial but to of and life important the and of and for a show as Seven-Eleven white and black its most culture a of to by in and there many elements of Seven-Eleven that with of have with the of and in characters the of the the to that in popular culture also new of and that rather to like and white have the but not the of and not the of by their the of and as of and one a that of was realistic that in the is a of the likewise that have a years in this by the the of the ability for black musical to and also and not of the white for black musical and in incorporated to this of this is Seven-Eleven only it white of the in the from of who described as a in the of the show The of this to the narrative of black not only in its of a but also in its in to which has to a in black also for through as has been with and as even musical like Shuffle Along and Seven-Eleven to to black theatrical to a While Seven-Eleven to and even as to were to these to only the When of the it a of black that black was to the of in the white who to what white in a black celebrated that Seven-Eleven to the of earlier musical that white theatergoers were not in the growing of by black as of the that theatergoers more in the in the of and that is within that is a and and that for a with these general the Seven-Eleven by that that is for the a in many of these the to their and the white The by Seven-Eleven is with The with that of their the in comedy and not in only to in and what to black of the in to white has kept on and By of black entertainment for a largely white as these effectively and shows the ability to from the of white like and the black to the and black musicals into a the among and within that Seven-Eleven was in its of black as and and and the many black shows on Broadway in the early the the of black in of the was that there in a The this in the that a not a white as The in to the that to but in of in more white This a for black shows to white as on the from white The first show to this on Broadway, according to and was Shuffle Along in with its a and of The to the by earlier black and a by the which became a with African American and white It is the as it its with a from the musical as as from but it is that and into the of the attempted to white what in a black musical even that largely stereotypes. This is not to that the of shows were by the of racist had the of a white that with it to for as in a have of music in the to have for is a these to to make and to their and for the same the white is the of black within the that the for from these and first what the 1920s, what white was largely the same as in promises of black entertainment of its in it to the of black and white with different of the same musical The ability for to what to in the show is largely what led to its as and was by that were this the for black uplift by migration and the white in black popular not of the its to a more of character and engage contemporary It was a that in audiences, but effectively as it for Seven-Eleven and Shuffle is across the of the with characters and plot elements life and theatrical Seven-Eleven incorporated of class types, the black which was expanding as a of new in the and It is not to a in Shuffle Along and The of Seven-Eleven character on and but by their to the black characters as more character as is more a contemporary of the life of the city a to black theatergoers who had to characters not only reflected elements drawn from African American but also of issues to black as the show on their for a black musical in the 1920s, one of the of was to engage black and white Seven-Eleven By authenticity in it effectively tapped into new desires among white as as of among black This was a in the Great Migration had black and white populations into became of black new and and growing the for African American beyond the of the black white populations were more in black the and theatrical the products that into their were in to not beyond This of made it for black to there of identity. yet their markets life the of this and of within the segregated entertainment to the Cleveland Gazette on Seven-Eleven that the which that the show the southern ‘Negro’ in the true to the of the cast in to earlier white the the of that there true of ‘Negro’ characters but the ‘Negro’ is to but to it in the southern is of a different and is and the only for is that The and that what were was not as as in white the black The of this to their point the show true southern African this from the that the this Seven-Eleven was to white its to Seven-Eleven by black characters also of in a African American and the of a white who earned in this to the and of black and white in the 1920s a of that to of black musical Shuffle Along with the and as a its has cast a over to the popular that musicals of this were and a of the of to its white Broadway have largely overlooked shows like Seven-Eleven their and as have and even to desires and anxieties within this of cultural that more North and cultural to audiences, Seven-Eleven and black musicals as beyond New York the many destinations of the Great Migration, which black and new of these were By these black musical that theatrical to the narrative of musical theater from Broadway, which and which has a as the only of black by these forgotten cultural to make in the for on the and in the a of on African and more one Seven-Eleven a into the of its the in this a it to a a a one the was a to and had this the like in in make the the like a a a the a the with a for in this make a and a for a and a what in this a and a

Aesthetics · Art · Art history · Biology · Comedy · Crossover · Musical · Visual arts · Computer Science · Music History and Culture · Race, History, and American Society · Theater, Performance, and Music History

• The Year’s Work in American Humor Studies, 2022

  Jonathan P Rossing, Jonathan Rossing et al.•Studies in American Humor•2024

  Add to list