A Ghost in the Minimalist Machine

When a new recording of Henry Górecki’s Symphony No. 3, the ‘Symphony of Sorrowful Songs’, was released in 1992, it sparked a phenomenon in popularity that begged to be studied and understood within the cultural and musical context of its time. Most critics labelled the work as a kind of minimalism—‘holy’, ‘mystical’, or ‘spiritual’—and that label seems to have stuck. Since then, scholars have questioned the appropriateness of such labels, interrogating whether the symphony is distinctively ‘spiritual’ or even ‘minimalist’. But they seem resigned to the category’s continued use. This article reexamines the question, and the early reception history of Górecki’s Symphony No. 3, not so much decide whether the music deserves the label, but rather to consider what the application and usage of terms such as ‘mystical’ or ‘minimalist’ reveal about how critics and audiences perceived Górecki’s music, and what roles it played in their experience of it. Though stylistically the category of ‘mystical minimalist’ might remain problematic, its currency today continues to provide a useful lens for the examination of the Górecki phenomenon of the mid-1990s

Performance art · Central European Literary Studies · European Cultural and National Identity · Polish Historical and Cultural Studies

• Performing Rites

  Frith, Simon Frith•Performing rites•1996

  Add to list

• To be God with God

  Maria Anna Harley•Contemporary Music Review•1995

  Add to list