Positive Treatment Expectations Shape Perceived Medication Efficacy in a Translational Placebo Paradigm for the Gut-Brain Axis

Placebo research has established the pivotal role of treatment expectations in shaping symptom experience and patient-reported treatment outcomes. Perceived treatment efficacy constitutes a relevant yet understudied aspect, especially in the context of the gut-brain axis with visceral pain as key symptom. Using a clinically relevant experimental model of visceral pain, we elucidated effects of pre-treatment expectations on post-treatment perceived treatment efficacy as an indicator of treatment satisfaction in a translational placebo intervention. We implemented positive suggestions regarding intravenous treatment with a spasmolytic drug (in reality saline), herein applied in combination with two series of individually calibrated rectal distensions in healthy volunteers. The first series used distension pressures inducing pain (pain phase). In the second series, pressures were surreptitiously reduced, modeling pain relief (pain relief phase). Using visual analog scales (VAS), expected and perceived treatment efficacy were assessed, along with perceived pain intensity. Manipulation checks supported that the induction of positive pre-treatment expectations and the modeling of pain relief were successful. Generalized Linear Models (GLM) were implemented to assess the role of inter-individual variability in positive pre-treatment expectations in perceived treatment efficacy and pain perception. GLM indicated no association between pre-treatment expectations and perceived treatment efficacy or perceived pain for the pain phase. For the relief phase, pre-treatment expectations ( p = 0.024) as well as efficacy ratings assessed after the preceding pain phase ( p p = 0.057) in the relief phase. Our data from an experimental translational placebo intervention in visceral pain support that reported post-treatment medication efficacy is shaped by pre-treatment expectations. The observation that individuals with higher positive expectations reported less pain and higher treatment satisfaction after pain relief may provide first evidence that perceived symptom improvement may facilitate treatment satisfaction. The immediate experience of symptoms within a given psychosocial treatment context may dynamically change perceptions about treatment, with implications for treatment satisfaction, compliance and adherence of patients with conditions of the gut-brain axis

Alternative medicine · Disease · Gut–brain axis · Pathology · Physical medicine and rehabilitation · Placebo · Translational research · Complementary and Alternative Medicine Studies · Diet and metabolism studies · Medicine · Pain Management and Placebo Effect · Psychology · Internal Medicine

• Patient reported outcome measures could help transform healthcare

  Open Access•Nick Black•BMJ•2013

  Add to list

• The Role of Chronic Stress in Normal Visceroception

  Open Access•Adriane Icenhour, Franziska Labrenz et al.•Frontiers in Psychiatry•2020

  Add to list

• No Reason to Feel Sick? Nocebo Responses in the Placebo Arms of Experimental Endotoxemia Studies

  Open Access•Sven Benson, Sigrid Elsenbruch•Frontiers in Psychiatry•2019

  Add to list

• Can a Brief Relaxation Exercise Modulate Placebo or Nocebo Effects in a Visceral Pain Model

  Open Access•Sigrid Elsenbruch, Till Roderigo et al.•Frontiers in Psychiatry•2019

  Add to list