Effect and cost-effectiveness of human-centred design-based approaches to increase adolescent uptake of modern contraceptives in Nigeria, Ethiopia and Tanzania

Around half of adolescent pregnancies in low- and middle-income countries are unintended, contributing to millions of unsafe abortions per year. Adolescents 360 (A360), a girl-centred initiative, aimed to increase voluntary uptake of modern contraceptives among adolescents in Nigeria, Ethiopia and Tanzania. We evaluated the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of A360 in increasing modern contraceptive use in selected geographies. We used before-and-after cross-sectional studies of adolescent girls in four settings. Two Nigerian settings had purposefully selected comparison areas. Baseline and endline household surveys were conducted. The primary study outcome was modern contraceptive prevalence rate (mCPR). Secondary outcomes mapped onto the A360 Theory of Change. Interpretation was aided by a process evaluation along with secular mCPR trends and self-reported A360 exposure data. Incremental design and implementation costs were calculated from implementer systems, site visits, surveys, and interviews. mCPR change was modelled into maternal disability-adjusted life years (DALY) averted to calculate incremental cost-effectiveness ratios. In Oromia, Ethiopia, mCPR increased by 5% points (95% CI 1–10; n = 1,697). In Nigeria, there was no evidence of an effect of A360 on mCPR in Nasarawa (risk ratio: 0·96, 95% CI: 0·76–1·21; n = 5,414) or in Ogun (risk ratio: 1·08, 95% CI: 0·92–1·26; n = 3,230). In Mwanza, Tanzania, mCPR decreased by 9% points (-17 to -0.3; n = 1,973). Incremental cost per DALY averted were $30,855 in Oromia, $111,416 in Nasarawa, $30,114 in Ogun, and $25,579 in Mwanza. Costs per DALY averted were 14–53 times gross domestic product per capita. A360 did not lead to increased adolescent use of modern contraceptives at a population level, except in Oromia, and was not cost-effective. This novel adolescent-centred design approach showed some promise in addressing the reproductive health needs of adolescents, but must be accompanied by efforts to address the contextual drivers of low modern contraceptive use

Cost effectiveness · Developing country · Economic growth · Economics · Environmental health · Population · Socioeconomics · Tanzania · Adolescent Sexual and Reproductive Health · Demography · Global Maternal and Child Health · Medicine · Poverty, Education, and Child Welfare

• Single group, pre- and post-test research designs

  Emma Marsden, Carole Torgerson et al.•Oxford Review of Education•2012

  Add to list

• What Does Not Work in Adolescent Sexual and Reproductive Health

  Open Access•Venkatraman Chandra‐Mouli, Catherine Lane et al.•Global Health: Science and Practice•2015

  Add to list

• Use of Interrupted Time Series Analysis in Evaluating Health Care Quality Improvements

  Open Access•Robert B Penfold, Fang Zhang•Academic Pediatrics•2013

  Add to list

• Better reporting of interventions

  Open Access•Tom Hoffmann, T C Hoffmann et al.•BMJ•2014

  Add to list

• Young Women’s Access to and Use of Contraceptives

  Estelle M Sidze, Estelle Sidze et al.•International Perspectives on…•2014

  Add to list

• Examining long-term effects of Cuídate-a sexual risk reduction program in Mexican youth

  Open Access•Antonia M Villarruel, Yan Zhou et al.•Revista Panamericana de Salud…•2010

  Add to list