Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Coproducing urban space

Rethinking the formal/informal dichotomy

Bibliographic Data

ID20154069
AuthorsMartijn Koster (0000-0003-0003-5345, Anthropology and Development Studies Radboud University Nijmegen the Netherlands, corresponding author), Monique Nuijten (Sociology of Development and Change Wageningen University Wageningen the Netherlands)
Year2016
Volume37
Issue3
Pages282-294
Publication date2016-09-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueSingapore Journal of Tropical Geography (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0129-7619 • E-ISSN: 1467-9493
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/sjtg.12160
OpenAlexW2537095184
LanguageEN
Citations received34
References cited47

Providing an introduction to the special section ‘Close encounters: ethnographies of the coproduction of space by the urban poor’, this article sets out to argue that the image of ‘the informal’ as unruly, messy and dirty continues to inform urban planning around the world. As a reaction to this view, it contends that the informal and formal should be analysed as interconnected and that the informal sphere should be revalued. Urban development is studied as close encounters between established practices, with a locus and a history (tree‐like), and newly emerging, unstable and untraceable practices (rhizomatic). Contrary to the tendency in urban planning to conflate the formal with the tree and the informal with the rhizome, we argue that from the perspective of marginal urbanites, formal planning tends to be very arbitrary and frightening (rhizomatic), whereas informal practices can be very predictable and stable (arboreal). The article analyses residents of marginalized urban areas as inventive navigators who explore the changing physical, spatial and sociopolitical environment, avoiding threats and looking for opportunities, grounded in their everyday practices and life histories. The article concludes that marginal urbanites should be acknowledged as coproducers of urban space and that the right to ‘coproduce’ the city lies at the heart of the call for the right to the city

Coproduction · Ethnography · Social science · Sociology · Space (punctuation) · Anthropological Studies and Insights · Anthropology · Urban and Rural Development Challenges · Urban Planning and Governance

  • Assembling the Urban Frontier

    Open Access•D Roy•City & Society•2026

  • Fijian infrastructural citizenship

    Open Access•Lucas Watt, Ronnie Donaldson•Cogent Social Sciences•2020

  • “Activism Is a Good Means to Connect Things”

    Open Access•Lieke Van Der Veer•Urban Planning•2024

  • Disrupting Risk Governance? A Post-Disaster Politics of Inclusion in the Urban Margins

    Open Access•Ricardo Fuentealba, Hebe Verrest•Urban Planning•2020

  • Genealogy of the gray spaces discourse in contemporary urban planning

    Ayda Kianfar, Mojtaba Rafieian•International Planning Studies•2025

  • Planning for Exclusion

    Open Access•Ricardo Fuentealba, Hebe Verrest et al.•Politics and Governance•2020

  • Selling hope on credit

    Marie Kolling•Contemporary Social Science•2021

  • Zoning and the ‘ Right ’ City

    Open Access•Hs Geyer•International Journal of Urban…•2024

  • Informal and Unserviceable

    Open Access•Tapiwa Tania Shoniwa, Thebe•Urban Forum•2020

  • Roadside death memorials revisited

    Open Access•Koyi Mchunu, Lincoln Geraghty•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2020

  • ‘The law is not for the poor’

    Open Access•Pétur Waldorff•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2016

  • Participatory slum upgrading as a disjunctive process in Recife, Brazil

    Open Access•Pieter De Vries•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2016

  • Towards a political economy of urban coproduction

    Open Access•D Rodgers•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2016

  • The Delhi Bias

    Open Access•N P Narayanan•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2020

  • Decoding dispossession

    Open Access•Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon, Matthew Wilhelm‐Solomon•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2016

  • Closing down bars in the inner city centre

    Open Access•Helene Risør•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2016

  • Postrevolutionary land encroachments in Cairo

    Open Access•Jamie Furniss•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2016

  • Institutional coalescence and illegal small scale gold mining in Ghana

    Open Access•Paul Stacey, Paul Austin Stacey•World Development•2024

  • Disrupting self-censorship, inventing public space through interactive performances in Luanda, Angola

    Chloé Buire•Anthropology Southern Africa•2023

  • Non-compliance and non-enforcement

    Open Access•Josje Anna Bouwmeester, Jean-David Gerber et al.•Land Use Policy•2023

  • Implication of institutional informality in the historical urban evolution of Morocco

    Open Access•Noussayba Rahmouni, Izuru Saizen•Cities•2024

  • Unraveling the self-made city

    Open Access•Josje Anna Bouwmeester, Josje Bouwmeester et al.•Cities•2021

  • The disintegration and reproduction of communities

    Open Access•Xueying Chen, Zhikui Cao et al.•Cities•2024

  • Food for thought

    Open Access•Paul Stacey, Richard Grant et al.•Habitat International•2021

  • From Sectors to Circuits

    Open Access•J Schapendonk, Marieke Ekenhorst•Tijdschrift voor Economische en…•2020

  • Welfare ruination, debris and Europeans’ make-shift practices

    Open Access•Marguerite Van Den Berg•Environment and Planning A…•2025

  • Assembling territories of floods and slums in Pontianak, Indonesia

    Open Access•Elizabeth Macafee, Tara Saharan et al.•Urban Geography•2025

  • Roadside death memorials

    Koyi Mchunu•African Identities•2020

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Jordan Sand•City & Society•2020

  • Informal governance and the spatial management of street-based sex work in Aotearoa New Zealand

    Open Access•Caitlin Neuwelt-Kearns, T Baker et al.•Political Geography•2020

  • Informal production of the city

    Open Access•N P Narayanan, R Véron•Environment and Planning D…•2018

  • From Visible Informality to Splintered Informalities

    Open Access•Raffael Beier•International Journal of Urban…•2021

  • An Ethnographic Perspective on Urban Planning in Brazil

    Open Access•Martijn Koster•International Journal of Urban…•2020

  • Informality as the Ur-Form of Urbanity

    Open Access•Kim Dovey•International Journal of Urban…•2025

  • Changing Properties of Property

    M G Wiber, Keebet Von Benda-Beckmann et al.•Changing Properties of Property•2006

  • Development Sociology

    Norman Long•Development Sociology•2003

  • A ‘Rhizomic’ Model of Organizational Change and Transformation

    Open Access•Roland Chia, Robert Chia•British Journal of Management•1999

  • Rethinking Informality

    Colin Mcfarlane•Planning Theory & Practice•2012

  • Planet of Slums

    Open Access•Mike Davis•New Perspectives Quarterly•2006

  • Encounters at the Interface

    N Long•Encounters at the Interface•1989

  • ‘The law is not for the poor’

    Open Access•Pétur Waldorff•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2016

  • Forced Evictions in Tropical Cities

    Open Access•Kris Olds, Tim Bunnell et al.•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2002

  • Participatory slum upgrading as a disjunctive process in Recife, Brazil

    Open Access•Pieter De Vries•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2016

  • Regimes of spatial ordering in Brazil

    Open Access•Monique Nuijten, Martijn Koster et al.•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2012

  • Wastelands, degraded lands and forests, and the class(ification) struggle

    Open Access•E Harms, Ian G Baird•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2014

  • Decoding dispossession

    Open Access•Matthew Wilhelm-Solomon, Matthew Wilhelm‐Solomon•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2016

  • Closing down bars in the inner city centre

    Open Access•Helene Risør•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2016

  • Postrevolutionary land encroachments in Cairo

    Open Access•Jamie Furniss•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2016

  • Thinking Through Sociality

    Vered Amit•Thinking through sociality•2015

  • Misteri i Kapitalit

    Open Access•Hernando De Soto, Co-PLAN Co-PLAN et al.•Misteri i Kapitalit•2000

  • An Anthropological Critique of Development

    Mark Hobart•An Anthropological Critique of…•2002

  • Informal urbanism and complex adaptive assemblage

    Kim Dovey•International Development…•2012

  • Re-viewing informality

    Tim Bunnell, Andrew Harris•International Development…•2012

  • Theoretical Notes On `Gray Cities

    Open Access•Oren Yiftachel•Planning Theory•2009

  • Slumming about

    G A Jones•City•2011

  • The Politics of the Evicted

    Open Access•Sapana Doshi•Antipode•2013

  • Speculating on Slums

    Open Access•Vandana Desai, Alex Loftus•Antipode•2013

  • From Preamble to Post‐project Frustrations

    Open Access•Martijn Koster, Monique Nuijten•Antipode•2012

  • Enacting immanent potentialities

    Open Access•Christian Vium•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2016

  • Neoliberal privatisation? Remapping the public and the private in Sydney's masterplanned residential estates

    Open Access•Pauline Mcguirk, Robyn Dowling•Political Geography•2009

  • Urban Informality

    Ananya Roy•Journal of the American Planning…•2005

  • Slum-free cities of the Asian century

    Open Access•Ananya Roy•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2013

  • Informal Urbanism and the Taste for Slums

    Kim Dovey, Ross King•Tourism Geographies•2012

  • The Political Construction of Wasteland

    Open Access•Jennifer Baka•Development and Change•2013

  • The City as Assemblage

    Open Access•Colin Mcfarlane•Environment and Planning D…•2011

  • Bangkok Space, and Conditions of Possibility

    Open Access•Ross King•Environment and Planning D…•2008

  • Postcolonialising Informality

    Open Access•Ann Varley•Environment and Planning D…•2013

  • Private or public

    Open Access•Ann Varley•International Journal of Urban…•2002

  • Changing Times, Changing Places

    Open Access•Mike Raco, Steven R Henderson et al.•Environment and Planning A…•2008

  • Sanitation in Mumbai's Informal Settlements

    Open Access•Colin Mcfarlane•Environment and Planning A…•2008

  • Access and Property

    Open Access•Thomas Sikor, Christian Lund•Development and Change•2009

  • Occupancy Urbanism

    Open Access•Solomon Benjamin•International Journal of Urban…•2008

  • Government of Paper

    Matthew Hull, Matthew S Hull•Government of paper•2012

  • The Politics of the Governed

    Open Access•John Borneman•American Anthropologist•2005

  • Motion squared

    Open Access•H Vigh•Anthropological Theory•2009

  • Introduction - Urban Charisma

    Open Access•T B Hansen, Oskar Verkaaik•Critique of Anthropology•2009

  • Fear and Intimacy

    Martijn Koster•Ethnos•2014

Unique citing works34
Citations per year3,4
Citation span2016 - 2026 (11)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 33

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae