The Shapes of Cinderella

This study leverages emotional arc modeling along with close reading to examine the Chinese Ye Xian, Perrault’s Cendrillon, and two Grimm versions. While computational modeling suggests that Cinderella tales share similar “recognition scaffolds,” their emotional architectures reflect distinct moral universes. Story peaks and valleys vary according to individual narrative resolutions to a universal problem of virtue unrecognized. Ye Xian descends to maximum negative sentiment when sacred bonds rupture, aligning with Buddhist-Daoist ethics in which divine-human reciprocity supersedes other bonds. Perrault’s arc offers surprising asymmetry: linguistic violence (Culcendron) defines every valley, while material transformation marks every peak. The 1812 Grimm tale oscillates between degradation and elevation with peaks and valleys suggestive of a syncretism between folk magic and Protestant theology. The 1857 version flattens into a rough semblance of Perrault’s emotional architecture, but peaks and valleys reflect Protestant, rather than aristocratic, values. These many shapes of Cinderella suggest fairy tales may serve as a flexible emotional technology. Themes of good and evil are key features of these emotional architectures, but how they are expressed vary from tale to tale

Narrative · Protestantism · Virtue · Architecture and Cultural Influences

• The Irresistible Fairy Tale

  Open Access•Jack Zipes•The irresistible fairy tale•2012

  Add to list

• The Uses of Enchantment

  Bruno Bettelheim•PsycEXTRA Dataset•1976

  Add to list

• The emotional arcs of stories are dominated by six basic shapes

  Open Access•Andrew J Reagan, Lewis Mitchell et al.•EPJ Data Science•2016

  Add to list

• The Computational Case against Computational Literary Studies

  Nan Z Da•Critical Inquiry•2019

  Add to list