Is Talmudic Law a Religious Legal System? A Provisional Analysis

The claim that talmudic law is a religious legal system has long been, and continues to be, put forward by both traditional scholars of Jewish law and contemporary academic researchers. The question of whether talmudic law is a religious legal system most certainly did not engage the Sages of the Talmud, but addressing it will help us grasp the nature of talmudic law. Furthermore, juxtaposing talmudic law to Biblical law will help us delineate the concept of religious law, and shed light on certain developments in the evolution of Jewish law. Let us consider what this claim entails. Sometimes the assertion that a given legal system is a religious legal system merely seeks to indicate that it is part of a certain religion or was created within the framework of that religion. Such an assertion does not provide any information about the nature of the said system, just as the phrase “French law” says nothing more than that the system is used in France

Comparative law · Islam · Judaism · Political science · Public law · Religious Law · Sociology · Sources of law · Talmud · Theology · Archaeology and Historical Studies · Biblical Studies and Interpretation · Jewish and Middle Eastern Studies · Law · Philosophy

• Reckoning with theoretical research

  Nuri Heckler, Ryan Rouse•Administrative Theory & Praxis•2023

  Add to list

• The Problem of Jewish Law in a Jewish State

  Open Access•Izhak Englard•Israel Law Review•1968

  Add to list