Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Living in an age of online incivility

Examining the conditional indirect effects of online discussion on political flaming

Bibliographic Data

ID20508596
AuthorsJay D Hmielowski (0000-0001-6449-4714, University of Arizona, corresponding author), Myiah J Hutchens (0000-0002-5424-7012, University of Arizona), Vincent Cicchirillo (The University of Texas at Austin), Vincent J Cicchirillo
Year2014
Volume17
Issue10
Pages1196-1211
Publication date2014-11-26
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueInformation Communication & Society (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1369-118X • E-ISSN: 1468-4462
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/1369118x.2014.899609
OpenAlexW2160058911
LanguageEN
Citations received67
References cited64

Communication scholars have examined the potential pitfalls and rewards associated with the ability to communicate in online spaces. We continue in that line of research by proposing a mediated moderated communication process model focused on what conditions lead people to engage in aggressive online communication behaviors, otherwise known as flaming. Specifically, we argue that online political discussion socializes individuals to see flaming as an acceptable behavior. This increase in perceived acceptability in turn increases intention to flame. Results demonstrate that this increase in intention to flame is greater among those with high levels of verbal aggression. To test our model, we conducted two surveys that asked students and blog users questions about their online media behaviors. Results replicate across both surveys.Keywords: flamingpoliticsquantitativesurveycomputer-mediated communicationpoliticscommunication studies Notes on contributorsJay D. Hmielowski is an assistant professor of communication at the University of Arizona. His research interests include the study of science communication, with interest in how specific message factors generate attitudinal ambivalence, and how ambivalence affects information processing, information seeking, and political engagement. [email: [email protected]]Myiah J. Hutchens is an assistant professor of journalism at the University of Arizona. Dr Hutchens' research focuses on the antecedents and consequences of exposure to counter-attitudinal information. [email: [email protected]]Vincent J. Cicchirillo is an assistant professor of advertising at the University of Texas at Austin. Dr Cicchirillo's research focuses upon the study of media technologies. Primarily, he focuses on the influence of video game play features and contexts on post-game play outcomes. [email: [email protected]]

Ambivalence · Incivility · Journalism · Media studies · Political science · Politics · Sociology · Bullying, Victimization, and Aggression · Hate Speech and Cyberbullying Detection · Psychology · Social Media and Politics · Social Psychology

  • Incivility makes me angrier than uncivil disagreement

    Andrés Rosenberg•Journal of Information Technology…•2024

  • Linguistic Impoliteness and Interpersonal Positioning in Nigerian Online Political Forum

    Open Access•Rotimi Taiwo, Alaba Akinwotu et al.•Linguistik Online•2021

  • Armed Victims

    Brett Lunceford•Rhetoric and Public Affairs•2015

  • Incivility on Facebook and political polarization

    Open Access•Yonghwan Kim, Youngju Kim•Computers in Human Behavior•2019

  • Perceptions of Uncivil Discourse Online

    Open Access•Kate Kenski, Kevin Coe et al.•Communication Research•2020

  • Characterizing Disagreement in Online Political Talk

    Open Access•Patrícia Rossini, Rousiley C M Maia et al.•Journal of Deliberative Democracy•2021

  • The Distorting Prism of Social Media

    Open Access•Jin Woo Kim, Allison M Gue et al.•Journal of Communication•2021

  • The Thin Line Between Harmful and Benign

    Open Access•U K Schmid, Simon Greipl•Media Psychology•2025

  • Negativity vs. Incivility

    Open Access•Yujin Kim•Mass Communication & Society•2026

  • Fear, Anger, and Political Advertisement Engagement

    Open Access•Chris J Vargo, Toby Hopp•Journalism & Mass Communication…•2020

  • Online incivility

    Open Access•Seo Yoon Lee, Weizi Liu et al.•The Communication Review•2026

  • Discussions That Divide

    Open Access•Patrícia Rossini, Jennifer Stromer‐galley et al.•Journal of Broadcasting &…•2025

  • Contagion of offensive speech online

    Open Access•Y Song, Q Lin et al.•Computers in Human Behavior•2022

  • Seeing red

    Open Access•Arthur D Santana, Toby Hopp•Newspaper Research Journal•2022

  • Online incivility, argument quality and public expression in China

    Open Access•Chen Min, Fei Shen•Telematics and Informatics•2023

  • Are narcissists trolls? A cross-sectional study about aggression, trolling behavior, narcissism, and the moderating role of self-esteem

    Open Access•Elke Rohmann, Sarah Marie Winkler et al.•Telematics and Informatics•2024

  • Resolving the Ethical Tension Between Creating a Civil Environment and Facilitating Free Expression Online

    Open Access•Dena Yadin, Inbal Yahav et al.•Journal of Business Ethics•2024

  • Stitch incoming

    B Mclaughlin, Joshua Cloudy et al.•Behaviour and Information…•2025

  • When Disagreement Becomes Uncivil on Social Media

    Open Access•Hsuan-Ting Chen, Y Song et al.•Communication Research•2026

  • Appraising Uncivil Comments in Online Political Discussions

    Open Access•Jan P Kluck, Nicole C Krämer•Communication Research•2023

  • Beyond Incivility

    Open Access•Patrícia Rossini•Communication Research•2022

  • Barriers to Participation in Polarized Online Discussions About Covid-19 and the Russo-Ukrainian War

    Open Access•Martina Novotná, Alena Macková et al.•Media and Communication•2023

  • Examining the Role of Online Uncivil Discussion and Ideological Extremity on Illegal Protest

    Open Access•Bingbing Zhang, Isabel Inguanzo et al.•Media and Communication•2022

  • Inflammatory Comments Elicit Less Outrage When Made in Anonymous Online Contexts

    Open Access•Curtis Puryear, Joseph A Vandello•Social Psychological and…•2019

  • The Language of Extremism on Social Media

    Open Access•Dan Hiaeshutter-Rice, Ian Hawkins•Frontiers in Political Science•2022

  • Incivility and Intolerance in Covid-19 Discussions on Facebook

    Open Access•Martina Novotná, Alena Macková et al.•Social Media + Society•2023

  • Incivility in Online Discussion

    Open Access•Rossella Rega, Rita Marchetti et al.•Social Media + Society•2023

  • Belief in Instrumental Extremism and Social Media Incivility

    Manuel Goyanes, Jeffry Oktavianus et al.•Mass Communication & Society•2026

  • From “thank god for helping this person” to “libtards really jumped the shark”

    Open Access•Deana A Rohlinger, Cynthia Williams et al.•New Media & Society•2019

  • Faith and reason

    Open Access•M A Bock, Ever Josue Figueroa•New Media & Society•2017

  • Does online incivility cancel out the spiral of silence? A moderated mediation model of willingness to speak out

    Open Access•Gina M Masullo, Shuning Lu et al.•New Media & Society•2020

  • More aggressive, more retweets? Exploring the effects of aggressive climate change messages on Twitter

    Open Access•Shupei Yuan, Yingying Chen et al.•New Media & Society•2022

  • Change is an emotional state of mind

    Open Access•Abby Koenig, B Mclaughlin•New Media & Society•2017

  • Beyond ‘pseudonymity’

    Open Access•Sarah Maltby, Helen Thornham et al.•New Media & Society•2017

  • IamMetiria

    Open Access•Leon Salter•New Media & Society•2021

  • The silent majority online

    Open Access•Marína Urbániková, Manuel Goyanes et al.•Information Communication & Society•2026

  • Unpacking the complexity of online incivility

    Open Access•Baiqi Li, Y Song et al.•Internet Research•2024

  • Socioeconomic Status, Social Capital, and Partisan Polarity as Predictors of Political Incivility on Twitter

    Open Access•Chris J Vargo, Toby Hopp•Social Science Computer Review•2016

  • Selective Avoidance on Social Media

    Open Access•Marko Škorić, Marko M Skoric et al.•Social Science Computer Review•2021

  • Online and Unkind

    Open Access•Luke R Mungall, Scott Pruyser et al.•Social Science Computer Review•2024

  • Social Norms and the Dynamics of Online Incivility

    Open Access•Yotam Shmargad, Kevin Coe et al.•Social Science Computer Review•2021

  • Incivility in Reddit’s Top Political and News Subreddits

    Open Access•Chris J Vargo, Tobias Hopp•Social Science Computer Review•2025

  • Removing Incivility from Google

    Open Access•Chen Min, Fei Shen et al.•Government Information Quarterly•2020

  • What is political incivility

    R Stryker, Bethany Anne Conway et al.•Communication Monographs•2016

  • ‘Crafting a way forward’

    I Literat, Sandra Markus•Information Communication & Society•2020

  • Women behaving badly

    Rebecca Kern, Rebecca L Kern et al.•Information Communication & Society•2017

  • Helping populism win? Social media use, filter bubbles, and support for populist presidential candidates in the 2016 US election campaign

    Jacob Groshek, Karolina Koc-Michalska•Information Communication & Society•2017

  • From ‘Please sir, stay out of it’ to ‘You are an abomination’

    Deana A Rohlinger, Deana Rohlinger et al.•Information Communication & Society•2021

  • An assemblage of avatars

    Open Access•Sine Nørholm Just•Organization•2019

  • Recontextualising partisan outrage online

    Open Access•Anthony Kelly•AI & Society•2023

  • Does the Internet Make the World Worse? Depression, Aggression and Polarization in the Social Media Age

    Open Access•Christopher J Ferguson•Bulletin of Science Technology &…•2021

  • A wall of incivility? Public discourse and immigration in the 2016 U.S. Primaries

    Patrícia Rossini, Heloisa Sturm Wilkerson et al.•Journal of Information Technology…•2020

  • What’s in a username? Civility, group identification, and norms

    Myiah J Hutchens, David E Silva et al.•Journal of Information Technology…•2019

  • Discourse, incivility and language aggression in social media debates on Biafra separatist agitation

    Open Access•Ebuka A Ifeanyichukwu, Lindsay H Hoffman•Media Culture & Society•2025

  • Incivility and disrespectfulness in online political discussion

    Open Access•Angga Prawadika Aji, Ari Sapto•Masyarakat Kebudayaan dan Politik•2020

  • Who fuels the fire? Predicting amplifiers, copycats, and attenuators in the networked spread of toxicity in immigration discourse

    Open Access•Yiqi Li, Aimei Yang•New Media & Society•2026

  • The expression effects of uncivil disagreement

    Open Access•Hai Liang, Yee Man Margaret Ng•Human Communication Research•2023

  • Exploring the Relationship Between Campaign Discourse on Facebook and the Public’s Comments

    Open Access•Patrícia Rossini, Jennifer Stromer-Galley et al.•Political Studies•2020

  • Representation and Aggression in Digital Racial Conflict

    Open Access•Nathan P Kalmoe, P Brooks Fuller et al.•Perspectives on Politics•2022

  • Unraveling the Relationships Among Individual Tendencies, Media Consumption, and Network Characteristics in the Self-Selective Dynamics of Online Political Discussions

    Open Access•Chingching Chang•International Journal of Public…•2025

  • Thinking Fast and Furious

    Open Access•David Asker, Elias Dinas•Public Opinion Quarterly•2019

  • How Do Silent Trolls Become Overt Trolls? Fear of Punishment and Online Disinhibition Moderate the Trolling Path

    Open Access•Daniel Montez, D H Kim•Social Media + Society•2025

  • What Will They Think If I Post This? Risks and Returns for Political Expression Across Platforms

    Open Access•Elnaz Parviz, Cameron W Piercy•Social Media + Society•2021

  • More Than Just Shouting? Distinguishing Interpersonal-Directed and Elite-Directed Incivility in Online Political Talk

    Open Access•Patrícia Rossini•Social Media + Society•2021

  • The Power of Schadenfreude

    Open Access•Pamela Jo Brubaker, Daniel Montez et al.•Social Media + Society•2021

  • Religious Identity, Expression, and Civility in Social Media

    Open Access•Royce Kimmons, Kristin Mcguire et al.•Journal for the Scientific Study…•2017

  • The Role of Emotion Discourse and Pathic Stigma in the Delegitimization of Consumer Practices

    Open Access•Carmen Valor, Javier Lloveras et al.•Journal of Consumer Research•2021

  • The psychology of attitudes

    Alice Hendrickson Eagly•The psychology of attitudes•1993

  • The Effects of Reward and Punishment in Violent Video Games on Aggressive Affect, Cognition, and Behavior

    Open Access•Nicholas L Carnagey, C Arnold Anderson•Psychological Science•2005

  • Adolescent alcohol-related risk cognitions

    D Litt, Dana M Litt et al.•Psychology of Addictive Behaviors•2011

  • Breaching or Building Social Boundaries?

    Open Access•Tom Postmes, Russell Spears et al.•Communication Research•1998

  • Personal Influence

    Elihu Katz, Paul F Lazarsfeld•Personal Influence•2017

  • Online Harassment Among College Students

    Megan Lindsay, Judy Krysik•Information Communication & Society•2012

  • The political use of the internet

    Davide Calenda, Lorenzo Mosca•Information Communication & Society•2007

  • Harmony and Tension on Social Network Sites

    Jens F Binder, Jens Binder et al.•Information Communication & Society•2012

  • Beyond Deliberation

    Open Access•W P Eveland, Alyssa C Morey et al.•Journal of Communication•2011

  • Political Discussion Frequency, Network Size, and “Heterogeneity” of Discussion as Predictors of Political Knowledge and Participation

    Open Access•W P Eveland, Myiah J Hutchens et al.•Journal of Communication•2009

  • Personal Influence. The Part Played by the People in the Flow of Mass Communication

    Open Access•Jens Woelke, Sebastian Koch•Schlüsselwerke der Medienwirkungsfo…•2016

  • A Focus Theory of Normative Conduct

    Robert B Cialdini, Carl A Kallgren et al.•Advances in Experimental Social…•1991

  • Hearing the Other Side

    Open Access•Diana C Mutz•Hearing the Other Side•2006

  • Identity and impoliteness in computer-mediated reader responses

    Shiv R Upadhyay•Journal of Politeness Research•2010

  • Trolling in asynchronous computer-mediated communication

    Claire Hardaker•Journal of Politeness Research•2010

  • Hot Diggity Blog

    Barbara K Kaye, Thomas J Johnson•Mass Communication & Society•2011

  • How could you think that

    Open Access•Myiah J Hutchens, Vincent Cicchirillo et al.•New Media & Society•2014

  • Acceptability of domestic violence against women in the European Union

    Enrique Gracia, Juan Herrero•Journal of Epidemiology and…•2006

  • Exposure to violent video games and aggression in German adolescents

    Open Access•Ingrid Möller, Barbara Krahé•Aggressive Behavior•2009

  • Effects of violent movies and trait hostility on hostile feelings and aggressive thoughts

    Open Access•C Arnold Anderson•Aggressive Behavior•1997

  • Student victimization by school staff in the context of an Israeli national school safety campaign

    Open Access•Mona Khoury‐Kassabri, Ron Avi Astor et al.•Aggressive Behavior•2008

  • The interactive relations between trait hostility, pain, and aggressive thoughts

    Open Access•Kathryn B Anderson, C Arnold Anderson et al.•Aggressive Behavior•1998

  • In defense of external invalidity

    Douglas G Mook•American Psychologist•1983

  • Social psychological aspects of computer-mediated communication

    Sara Kiesler, Jane Siegel et al.•American Psychologist•1984

  • Democracy online

    Open Access•Zizi Papacharissi•New Media & Society•2004

  • High-Conflict Television News and Public Opinion

    Open Access•Richard Forgette, Jonathan S Morris•Political Research Quarterly•2006

  • From Incivility to Outrage

    Sarah Sobieraj, Jeffrey M Berry•Political Communication•2011

  • Intramedia Mediation

    R L Holbert•Political Communication•2005

  • Beyond Negativity

    Open Access•Deborah Jordan Brooks, John G Geer•American Journal of Political…•2007

  • The transsituational influence of social norms

    Raymond R Reno, Robert B Cialdini et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•1993

  • Social-information-processing factors in reactive and proactive aggression in children's peer groups

    Kenneth A Dodge, John D Coie•Journal of Personality and Social…•1987

  • Moderating role of trait aggressiveness in the effects of violent media on aggression

    Brad J Bushman•Journal of Personality and Social…•1995

  • Children's normative beliefs about aggression and aggressive behavior

    L Rowell Huesmann, Nancy G Guerra•Journal of Personality and Social…•1997

  • The Aggression Questionnaire

    Arnold H Bu, Arnold H Buss et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•1992

  • Deindividuation and antinormative behavior

    Tom Postmes, Russell Spears•Psychological Bulletin•1998

  • The New Videomalaise

    Open Access•Diana C Mutz, Byron Reeves•American Political Science Review•2005

  • Everyday Incivility

    Open Access•Tim Phillips, Philip Smith•The Sociological Review•2003

  • Cross-cutting Social Networks

    Open Access•Diana C Mutz•American Political Science Review•2002

  • Effects of "In-Your-Face" Television Discourse on Perceptions of a Legitimate Opposition

    Open Access•Diana C Mutz•American Political Science Review•2007

Unique citing works67
Citations per year6,09
Citation span2015 - 2026 (12)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 64

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae