The Road to Peace in Northeast Asia - Prospects and Pitfalls

The shutdown of the DPRK plutonium reactor, the New York Times noted angrily recently, shows that 'real nonproliferation diplomacy can produce real results' as long as it is stripped of 'empty, ideological posturing'. The target of the Times' fulminations was not, as is usually the case, and as it will probably be again tomorrow, the government in Pyongyang, but that in Washington. Tearing up the agreement it had inherited from the Clinton administration had only produced an 'embarrassing outcome for the hard-line tactics favored by Vice-President Dick Cheney'. The Bush administration, recalled the Times, had 'walked away from Mr. Clinton's deal in 2002, with sensational charges, from which it has since retreated, that North Korea was pursuing a second, secret bomb-making program based on uranium enrichment.' We might recall that the newspaper had itself published an embarrassed mea culpa that the administration's 'sensational charges' about Iraq, subsequently proven fraudulent, had misled it into enthusiastically supported the disastrous invasion. Were the charges against the DPRK equally fraudulent? Probably, but since they cannot be disproved - and there's the rub - the Times is left with nagging doubt, and anger about 'the six bombs' worth of nuclear fuel Pyongyang produced - and the nuclear test - while Washington strutted and postured

Geography · Political science · Regional science · Asian Geopolitics and Ethnography · Southeast Asian Sociopolitical Studies · Vietnamese History and Culture Studies

• Did North Korea Cheat

  Selig S Harrison•Foreign Affairs•2005

  Add to list