Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Lessons from Reckwitz and Rosa

Towards a Constructive Dialogue between Critical Analytics and Critical Theory

Bibliographic Data

ID21503634
AuthorsSimon Susen (0000-0003-0643-1891, University of London, corresponding author)
Year2023
Volume37
Issue5
Pages545-591
Publication date2023-09-03
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueSocial Epistemology (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0269-1728 • E-ISSN: 1464-5297
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/02691728.2023.2201578
OpenAlexW4383878610
LanguageEN
Citations received5
References cited241

It is hard to overstate the growing impact of the works of Andreas Reckwitz and Hartmut Rosa on contemporary social theory. Given the quality and originality of their intellectual contributions, it is no accident that they can be regarded as two towering figures of contemporary German social theory. The far-reaching significance of their respective approaches is reflected not only in their numerous publications but also in the fast-evolving secondary literature engaging with their writings. All of this should be reason enough to take note of their collaborative work, which, most recently, has culminated in the publication of their co-authored book Spätmoderne in der Krise: Was leistet die Gesellschaftstheorie? (Berlin: Suhrkamp, 2021). The main purpose of this paper is to demonstrate that the latest exchange between Reckwitz and Rosa contains valuable insights into recent and ongoing trends in society in general and social theory in particular. The first part comprises an outline of the central matters at stake in, and the core lessons learnt from, the constructive dialogue between Reckwitz’s critical analytics and Rosa’s critical theory, before moving, in the second part, to an assessment of the most significant limitations of their respective views and propositions

Analytics · Constructive · Critical theory · Data science · Epistemology · German · Linguistics · Originality · Social science · Social theory · Sociology · Computer Science · Critical Theory and Philosophy · Economic and Social Issues · Philosophy · Sociology and Education Studies

  • The Interpretation of Cultures

    Open Access•Simon Susen•SSRN Electronic Journal•2024

  • Understanding the internet-famous tourist city

    Open Access•Hong‐lei Jin, Pengfei Zhang et al.•Cities•2025

  • The Long Arc, the Wrong Swerve, and the Theoretical Moment

    Isaac Ariail Reed•Critical Historical Studies•2026

  • The resonance of hostility

    Open Access•Maximiliano Vial, Iván Vial•Human Studies•2025

  • A New Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere? With, against, and beyond Habermas

    Open Access•Simon Susen•Society•2023

  • On the Pragmatics of Social Interaction

    Jürgen Habermas•On the Pragmatics of Social…•2014

  • Social action and human nature

    Axel Honneth•Social action and human nature•1988

  • Science in action

    Bruno Latour•Science in action•1987

  • Anthony Giddens

    Celia Modgil, Jon Ph D Clark et al.•Anthony Giddens•1990

  • The origins of totalitarian democracy

    Jacob Leib Talmon•The origins of totalitarian…•1960

  • Exploring Hartmut Rosa's Concept of Resonance

    Open Access•Mathijs Peters, Bareez Majid•Exploring Hartmut Rosa's Concept…•2022

  • Poststructuralism

    Catherine Belsey•Post-structuralism•2002

  • Xii Responsibility for Self

    Charles Taylor•Identities of Persons•1976

  • Boltanski, Luc (1940–)

    Open Access•Simon Susen•International Encyclopedia of the…•2015

  • Contemporary German social theory

    Hauke Brunkhorst•Handbook of Contemporary European…•2006

  • Adolescent tobacco menace

    Open Access•Preeti Sharma, Vijay Wadhwan et al.•Indian Journal of Dental Research•2017

  • Karl Marx

    Open Access•David Mclellan•Interviews and Recollections of…•1981

  • Populism in Europe and the Americas

    Open Access•Cas Mudde, Cristóbal Rovira Kaltwasser•Populism in Europe and the Americas•2012

  • Ideas

    Edmund Husserl•Ideas•2012

  • Skillful Coping

    Hubert L Dreyfus, Mark A Wrathall•Skillful Coping•2014

  • Social Practices

    Open Access•Theodore R Schatzki•Social practices•1996

  • Radical Right-Wing Populism in Western Europe

    Open Access•Hans-Georg Betz, Hans‐georg Betz•Radical Right-Wing Populism in…•1994

  • Kritik der reinen Vernunft

    Immanuel Kant, Immanuel Immanuel et al.•Philosophische Bibliothek, Band 505•1998

  • Technosystem

    Andrew Feenberg•Technosystem•2017

  • Right-Wing Populism in Europe

    Open Access•R Wodak, Majid Khosravinik et al.•Right-Wing Populism in Europe•2013

  • Leviathan

    Thomas Hobbes, Noel Malcolm•Leviathan•2012

  • A Reply to my Critics

    Open Access•Jürgen Habermas•Habermas•1982

  • From on “ Time and Being ”

    Martin Heidegger•Continental Philosophy of Science•2005

  • What is human agency?

    Charles Taylor•Philosophical Papers•2012

  • Self-interpreting animals

    Charles Taylor•Philosophical Papers•2012

  • The End of Progress

    Amy Allen•End of Progress•2016

  • Populism in Western Europe

    Teun Pauwels•Populism in Western Europe•2014

  • The system of modern societies.

    Talcott Parsons•The system of modern societies.•1971

  • Futures Past

    Keith Tribe, Reinhart Koselleck•Futures Past•2004

  • Bourdieu

    Craig Calhoun, Craig J Calhoun et al.•Bourdieu•1993

  • Structure of Social Action

    Talcott Parsons•Structure of Social Action•1967

  • The authoritarian personality

    Theodor W Adorno•The authoritarian personality•1969

  • From Redistribution to Recognition?

    Nancy Fraser•Marx and Modernity•2003

  • Truth and Progress

    Open Access•Richard Rorty•Truth and Progress : Volume 3•1998

  • Warum Kritik?

    Sven Ellmers, Philip Hogh•Warum Kritik?•2017

  • Core Sociological Dichotomies

    C Jenks•Core Sociological Dichotomies•1998

  • Rational Choice Theory

    Open Access•Lina Eriksson•Rational Choice Theory•2011

  • What's wrong with negative liberty

    Charles Taylor•Philosophical Papers•2012

  • Nancy Fraser and Axel Honneth , Redistribution or Recognition? A Political-Philosophical Exchange (London and New York

    Paul Voice•Politics and Ethics Review•2005

  • Slowing Down Society? Theoretical Reflections on Social Deceleration in Pandemic Times (and Beyond)

    Frédéric Torrès, Felipe Torres et al.•KronoScope•2022

  • The Dialectic of Progress and the Cultivation of Resistance in Critical Social Theory

    Open Access•Iaan Reynolds•Social Epistemology•2026

  • Creativity in perpetual personal and cultural motion

    Open Access•Tom Strong•Theory & Psychology•2019

  • Hartmut Rosa, Resonance

    Open Access•Andreas He, Andreas Hess•Irish Journal of Sociology•2020

  • The Society of Singularities

    Open Access•Andreas Reckwitz•Futures of the Study of Culture•2020

  • Reconstructing the Self

    Simon Susen•Reconstructing Social Theory,…•2016

  • Reflections on Patrick Baert’s The Existentialist Moment

    Open Access•Simon Susen, Patrick Baert•The Sociology of Intellectuals•2017

  • Remarks on the Nature of Justification

    Open Access•Simon Susen•Justification, Evaluation and…•2017

  • Outline of a Theory of Practice

    Open Access•Pierre Bourdieu, Richard Nice•On Violence•2007

  • Happiness is the Wrong Metric

    Open Access•Amitai Etzioni•Happiness is the Wrong Metric•2018

  • The Politics of Crowds

    Open Access•C Borch•Politics of Crowds•2012

  • Towards a theory of communicative competence

    Jürgen Habermas, Nicole Curato•Inquiry•1970

  • Totalitarian Dictatorship and Autocracy

    Carl Joachim Friedrich, Zbigniew Brzezinski•Totalitarian Dictatorship and…•1965

  • Debating Humanity

    Open Access•Daniel Chernilo•Debating Humanity•2017

  • Headlines of Nation, Subtexts of Class

    Don Kalb, Gábor Halmai•Headlines of nation, subtexts of…•2011

  • The Routledge Companion to Actor-Network Theory

    Anders Blok, Ignacio Farías et al.•Routledge Companion to…•2019

  • The Site of the Social

    Theodore R Schatzki•The Site of the Social•2002

  • Critique of Forms of Life

    Open Access•R Jaeggi, Ciaran Cronin•Critique of Forms of Life•2018

  • Democracy and Authoritarianism in the Postcommunist World

    Open Access•Kathryn Stoner, Valerie Bunce et al.•Democracy and Authoritarianism in…•2009

  • Religion and Modern Society

    Open Access•B Turner, Bryan S Turner•Religion and Modern Society•2011

  • Between Reason and History

    D Owens, David Owen•Between Reason and History•2002

  • Adorno's Practical Philosophy

    Open Access•Fabian Freyenhagen•Adorno's Practical Philosophy•2013

  • The Anthem Companion to Pierre Bourdieu

    D V Robbins, Derek Robbins•Anthem Companion to Pierre Bourdieu•2016

  • Postmodernism. What Moment

    Pelagia Goulimari•Postmodernism. What Moment?•2024

  • Risk Society

    Ulrich Beck•Encyclopedia of Social Theory•2005

  • The 'Postmodern Turn' in the Social Sciences

    Open Access•Simon Susen•'Postmodern Turn' in the Social…•2015

  • Resonanz. Eine Soziologie der Weltbeziehung

    Madalina Diaconu, Romanian Society for Phenomenology•Studia Phaenomenologica•2017

  • The phenomenology of the social world

    Open Access•Alfred Schutz, Fredrick Lehnert et al.•Phenomenology of the Social World•1967

  • The Blank Slate

    Fulano de Tal, Placeholder Author•Mankind Quarterly•2002

  • A Secular Age

    Open Access•Charles Taylor•Secular Age•2007

  • Pathologies of Reason

    A Honneth•Pathologies of reason•2009

  • A Contemporary Critique of Historical Materialism

    Open Access•Anthony Giddens•A Contemporary Critique of…•1995

  • Reassembling the Social

    Bruno Latour•REASSEMBLING THE SOCIAL: AN…•2005

  • The Human Condition

    Hannah Arendt, Margaret Canovan•Human Condition•1998

  • The Order of Things

    Michel Foucault•The Order of Things•2018

  • Social Acceleration. A New Theory of Modernity

    Open Access•Emma Torres, Esteban Torres•Persona y Sociedad•2016

  • Une sociologie sans société

    Luc Boltanski•Le Genre humain•1999

  • Reification and the Critical Theory of Contemporary Society

    Chris O’kane•Critical Historical Studies•2021

  • Following the footprints of the ‘postmodern turn’

    Simon Susen•European Journal of Cultural and…•2017

  • The uncontrollability of the world

    Open Access•Lee Yu-sum•European Journal of Cultural and…•2021

  • Beethoven, the Sailor, the Boy and the Nazi. A reply to my critics

    Hartmut Rosa•Journal of Political Power•2020

  • A path to the future, or ambivalent payoffs

    John O’brien•Journal of Political Power•2020

  • Intimations of humanity and the case for a philosophical sociology

    Simon Susen•Journal of Political Power•2020

  • Resonance, dissonance, and the EU’s ‘soul’

    K Keohane•Journal of Political Power•2020

  • Sounding for resonance

    K Keohane, Mark Haugaard•Journal of Political Power•2020

  • Pragmatism defended

    Patrick Baert, F C Da Silva•Distinktion Journal of Social…•2012

  • The dual-edged sword of sociological theory

    Chris Thorpe•Distinktion Journal of Social…•2011

  • Applying practice theory to the study of consumption

    Open Access•Bente Halkier, T Katz-Gerro et al.•Journal of Consumer Culture•2011

  • Dispute, Uncertainty and Institution in Recent French Debates

    Open Access•Peter Wagner•Journal of Political Philosophy•1994

  • International Law After Postmodernism

    Open Access•Andreas Paulus, Andreas L Paulus•Leiden Journal of International Law•2001

  • The Resonance of Resonance

    Open Access•Simon Susen•International Journal of Politics…•2019

  • Sociology, Capitalism, Critique

    Peter Seybold•Socialism and Democracy•2016

  • Further Reflections on the “Postmodern Turn” in the Social Sciences

    Open Access•Simon Susen•International Journal of Politics…•2016

  • Hartmut Rosa, Resonance

    Open Access•Cheng Tsuo-Yu, Shuwen Zhang et al.•International Sociology•2021

  • Critique and crisis

    Peter Burke•History of European Ideas•1988

  • Power struggles and friendships

    Open Access•Hartmut Rosa•Philosophy & Social Criticism•2017

  • No escape from the technosystem

    Open Access•Simon Susen•Philosophy & Social Criticism•2020

  • Sincerity, authenticity and profilicity

    Open Access•Hans-Georg Moeller, Paul J D''Ambrosio et al.•Philosophy & Social Criticism•2019

  • Mapping Charles Taylor

    Open Access•Ulf Bohmann, Gesche Keding et al.•Philosophy & Social Criticism•2018

  • The Society of Singularities—10 Theses

    Open Access•Andreas Reckwitz•Analyse & Kritik•2022

  • The Theory of Everything

    Open Access•Patrick Baert•Analyse & Kritik•2022

Unique citing works5
Citations per year1,67
Citation span2023 - 2026 (4)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 4

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae