Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Marx's Concept of Life

Bibliographic Data

ID21603103
AuthorsChristopher Shambaugh (0009-0009-7168-1222, Department of Philosophy University of Oregon Eugene Oregon USA, corresponding author)
Year2026
Volume34
Issue1
Pages163-190
Publication date2026-03-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEuropean Journal of Philosophy (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0966-8373 • E-ISSN: 1468-0378
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/ejop.70025
OpenAlexW4414578192
LanguageEN
References cited69

This essay aims to reveal the conceptual unity of an ensemble of concepts of organic, animal, and anthropological life articulated by the young Karl Marx between 1842 and 1844. To lay the groundwork for my analysis, I begin with Marx's general account of “life as activity.” I argue that Marx articulates a hylomorphic theory of organic form in 1842 and 1843, and a Left Hegelian conception of organismal agency as productive activity in 1844. I then interpret Marx's organismic conception of “productive life‐activity” as the guiding thread of his scala naturae in the Manuscripts . More precisely, I examine how Marx distinguishes plant, animal, and human life through the organism's production of its life and the life of its species ( Gattung ). I then redefine Marx's concept of species‐being as the unfulfilled power of an animal organism to self‐consciously pursue its productive life‐activity as its species‐life. In making this argument for the unity of Marx's concept of life, I hope to clarify the Aristotelian and Left Hegelian roots of his materialism

Hegelianism · Human being · Human life · Critical Realism in Sociology · Critical Theory and Philosophy · Political Economy and Marxism

  • Marx's Ecology

    John Bellamy Foster, John Buckingham Foster•Marx's Ecology•2000

  • The Activity of Being

    Aryeh Kosman•The Activity of Being•2013

  • Diagnosing Social Pathology

    Open Access•Frederick Neuhouser•Diagnosing Social Pathology•2022

  • Absolute Ethical Life

    Michael Lazarus•Absolute Ethical Life•2025

  • Marx

    Jaime Edwards, Brian Leiter•Marx•2024

  • Practical Reason in Historical and Systematic Perspective

    James Conant, Dawa Ometto•Practical Reason•2023

  • Karl Marx and the Actualization of Philosophy

    Open Access•Christoph Schuringa•Karl Marx and the Actualization…•2025

  • Organisms, Agency, and Evolution

    Open Access•D M Walsh•Organisms, Agency, and Evolution•2015

  • Hegel's Ethical Thought

    Open Access•Allen W Wood•Hegel's Ethical Thought•1990

  • Kant on Beauty and Biology

    Open Access•Rachel Zuckert•Kant on Beauty and Biology•2007

  • Cooperation between non-kin in animal societies

    Open Access•Tim Clutton‐brock, Tim Clutton-Brock•Nature•2009

  • Adaptation

    Richard C Lewontin•Scientific American•1978

  • Recognition As The Social Grammar Of Species Being In Marx

    Michael Quante•Recognition and social ontology•2011

  • Bios and Explanatory Unity in Aristotle's Biology

    James G Lennox•Definition in Greek Philosophy•2010

  • Organisms, agency and Aristotle

    Open Access•James G Lennox•Ratio•2024

  • The Importance of Others

    Jan Kandiyali•Ethics•2020

  • Practically Self-Conscious Life

    Open Access•Matthias Haase•Philippa Foot on Goodness and…•2018

  • From Aristotle to Marx

    Jon Pike, Jonathan E Pike•From Aristotle to Marx•2019

  • Freedom and Perfection

    Open Access•Douglas Moggach•Freedom and Perfection•2025

  • The Young Hegelians and Karl Marx

    Open Access•David Mclellan•The Young Hegelians and Karl Marx•1969

  • Marx

    Open Access•Michael Henry•Marx•2021

  • Marx’s Attempt to Leave Philosophy

    Open Access•Daniel Brudney•Marx's Attempt to Leave Philosophy•1998

  • Hegel on Philosophy in History

    Open Access•John Mcdowell, Sally Sedgwick et al.•Hegel on Philosophy in History•2016

  • Marx's Temporalities

    Massimiliano Tomba, Peter D Thomas et al.•Marx's Temporalities•2013

  • The Young Karl Marx

    Open Access•David Leopold, David A Leopold•Young Karl Marx•2007

  • Life and Action

    Michael Thompson•Life and Action•2008

  • Karl Marx

    Allen W Wood, Allen Wood•Karl Marx•2004

  • Hegel's Philosophy of Biology? A Programmatic Overview

    Open Access•Andrea Gambarotto, Luca Illetterati•Hegel Bulletin•2020

  • On Origins and Species

    Open Access•Daniel Lindquist•Hegel Bulletin•2020

  • Freedom, Desire, and Necessity

    Open Access•Pascal Brixel•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2023

  • Marx's Ethical Vision

    Vanessa Christina Wills, Wills Wills•Marx's Ethical Vision•2024

  • The Human Condition

    Hannah Arendt, Margaret Canovan•Human Condition•1998

  • Unalienated labor as cooperative self‐determination

    Open Access•Kyle Scott•European Journal of Philosophy•2025

  • The Early Life of Marx's “Mode of Production”

    Open Access•Johnson•Modern Intellectual History•2019

  • Humans and Other Political Animals in Aristotle's History of Animals

    David Depew, David J Depew•Phronesis•1995

  • The intelligence of the people’

    Open Access•Charles Barbour•History of European Ideas•2024

  • Aristotle’s De Anima and Marx’s Theory of Man

    David J Depew•Graduate Faculty Philosophy Journal•1982

  • Moses Hess and the Problems of the Idealist Dialectic (1926)

    Gábor Lukács•Telos•1971

  • The Unity of Marx’s Concept of Alienated Labor

    Pascal Brixel•The Philosophical Review•2024

  • Reason in Nature

    Open Access•David Gordon•The Philosophical Quarterly•2023

  • Marx's Ethical Anthropology

    Alan G Nasser•Philosophy and Phenomenological…•1975

  • Radical ethical naturalism

    Open Access•Tom Whyman•Philosophy & Social Criticism•2017

  • Hegel's Concept of Life

    Karen Ng•Hegels Concept of Life•2020

  • Natural Goodness

    Philippa Foot•Natural goodness•2001

  • Fellow Creatures

    Christine M Korsgaard•Fellow Creatures•2018

  • Species-Being, Metabolism, and Natural Limits

    Karen Ng•Qui Parle•2025

  • Productive forces, the passions and natural philosophy

    Open Access•Erik Van Ree•Journal of Political Ideologies•2020

  • Ideology Critique from Hegel and Marx to Critical Theory

    Open Access•Karen Ng•Constellations•2015

  • "The History of "Hylomorphism

    Gideon Manning•Journal of the History of Ideas•2013

  • Life Death

    Jacques Derrida, Pascale-Anne Brault et al.•Life Death•2020

  • The Romantic Conception of Life

    Robert J Richards•The Romantic Conception of Life•2002

Citation velocityhistorical
Highly citedNo

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae