Tradeoffs between soil conservation and soil‐water retention

Balancing erosion control and the water conservation service is the primary goal of intensive revegetation in water‐limited conditions. In this study, a field experiment was conducted in the dryland Chinese Loess Plateau (CLP), to investigate the role of vegetation pattern and density in their tradeoff between soil conservation (SC) and soil water retention (SWR). Five vegetation patterns (up‐slope covered, downslope covered, low and high uniformly covered, no coverage) with three levels of grass density (220 g m −2 , 110 g m −2 , and 0) were designed and implemented. A novel indicator EEW (the exchange between erosion reduction and water consumption), as the cost of any extra depletion of soil water to improve each unit of soil conservation, was used to represent the tradeoff during a complete dry‐wet‐dry soil water convert cycle. The higher EEW, the poorer tradeoff between SC and SWR. It was illustrated that higher vegetation density could promote SC but not inevitably suppress EEW. The present typical grass density in CLP, round 220 g m −2 , was redundant in optimizing the SC‐SWR tradeoff. A concentrated and centralized vegetation distribution mainly in the downslope obtained an EEW at 11.6 mm m 2 kg −1 and was confirmed as a favoured vegetation pattern. The simulated typical density and spatial pattern in CLP (about 220 g m −2 and uniformly distribution) had EEW at 20.5 mm m 2 kg −1 , by reducing the density to about 110 g m −2 and a downslope centralized vegetation redistribution, the EEW was reduced by 43.4%. Under long‐term drought conditions at dry‐wet‐dry cycles, soil water decreased more sharply in the Full‐covered plots, due to more evapotranspiration and vertical water loss caused by higher plant density, compared with half‐covered and bare soil plots. The present study confirmed that planted density and vegetation pattern can manipulate SC‐SWR tradeoff and it was thus possible to optimize it by adjusting revegetation's intensity and structures in practice

Bulk density · Ecological succession · Geotechnical engineering · Revegetation · Soil conservation · Soil water · Water conservation · Water resources · Environmental Science · Hydrology and Sediment Transport Processes · Plant Water Relations and Carbon Dynamics · Soil erosion and sediment transport · Ecology · Geology · Soil Science

• Understanding the balance between soil conservation and soil water storage capacity during the process of vegetation restoration in semi‐arid watersheds in the Loess Plateau, China

  Open Access•Yang Yu, Ruipeng Zhu et al.•Land Degradation and Development•2023

  Add to list

• Reduced sediment transport in the Yellow River due to anthropogenic changes

  Open Access•Shuai Wang, Bojie Fu et al.•Nature Geoscience•2016

  Add to list

• An assessment of the global impact of 21st century land use change on soil erosion

  Open Access•Pasquale Borrelli, David A Robinson et al.•Nature Communications•2017

  Add to list

• Recognizing trade‐offs in multi‐objective land management

  Open Access•JOHN B BRADFORD, Anthony W D’Amato et al.•Frontiers in Ecology and the…•2012

  Add to list