All the Pretty Noir Horses

Introduction The fusion of noir and Western elements in All the Pretty Horses (McCarthy) presents an anomalous hybrid, bridging the fatalism and existential despair of noir with the rugged individualism and pastoral decline of the Western. This relationship complicates traditional narrative boundaries, inviting readers to reconsider the archetypes and thematic constructs at play. Situated within a frontier grappling with industrial encroachment, All the Pretty Horses presents a world caught between preservation and progress. By focussing on the role of horses, this article explores their symbolic and material roles, highlighting the ideological fissures in rural and cowboy identities. This study addresses a critical gap in noir scholarship, by examining how noir texts can help in understanding the myth-making process, and the role of animals in these narratives. The article examines how horses in All the Pretty Horses are transformed into mythic constructs that intertwine freedom with entrapment, mirroring the fatalistic cycles of noir protagonists. Further, the objectified horses can replace the femmes fatales as seductive catalysts of noir stories. Drawing on Barthes’s theory of myth, the article interrogates how these constructs naturalise cultural contradictions, capable of transforming acts of control and violence into symbols of nobility and authenticity. Noir and the Western: A Hybrid Aesthetic The noir and the Western are noted as having an anomalous hybrid (sensu Monticone). That is, noir’s preoccupation with fatalism, moral ambiguity, and existential despair aligns with the Western’s exploration of individualism, frontier ethics, and the erosion of pastoral ideals (Kaminsky; Springhall; Conard). All the Pretty Horses presents the Western landscape as the site of noir’s entrapment and disillusionment, where characters grapple with the fatalistic loss of both personal and cultural identity. While noir traditionally thrives in urban environments, its themes resonate powerfully in McCarthy’s rural settings. The sale of the Grady family ranch, prompted by modern economic pressures, signals the encroachment of industrialisation and the demise of the agrarian heritage John Grady Cole values so deeply. As Somogyi observes, McCarthy’s descriptions of environmental decay and cultural erosion reflect broader concerns about humanity’s impact on the natural world. Grady’s journey to Mexico, ostensibly a boy’s quest for freedom, instead becomes an encounter with the dystopian underbelly of the romanticised frontier, aligning with Owens’s portrayal of McCarthy’s Mexico as a perilous and lawless space (65). The fated end of the cowboy myth and the taming of the wild has been prophesised in fiction for over one hundred years. John Ford’s 1924 film The Iron Horse chronicles Davy Brandon’s (George O’Brien) quest to fulfil his father’s dream of taming the wilderness through the construction of a transcontinental railroad. Dedicated to the memory of Abraham Lincoln and the pioneers of a “greater nation”, the film positions industrial progress as a civilising force. More recently, the rural noir series Yellowstone echoes this fatalism when career cowboy Rip Wheeler (Cole Hauser) observes, “you know, in 30 years from now ... nobody’s gonna be doing this, nobody” (Voros). Grady’s character combines the archetypes of the noir antihero and the Western cowboy. His adherence to a personal moral code, even in the face of betrayal and violence, evokes noir’s thematic exploration of agency and fate. Lee suggests that Grady’s actions, though noble, are rendered futile by the overwhelming forces of modernity and corruption that define his surroundings. The violent episodes he endures, from reclaiming Blevins’s horse to his survival in the penitentiary, highlight noir’s fatalistic motif of constrained choice. Pippin argues that noir protagonists are often trapped by the illusion of agency – their fates seemingly predetermined by a world beyond their control (49). The combination of noir and western themes reframes the conceptualisation of the cowboy and the frontier, exposing the coexisting but competing ideals of preservation and progress extant in many western narratives (Lee). Grady’s ideals repeatedly clash with the harsh realities of survival and human fallibility as the romanticised veneer of the authentic cowboy life progressively deteriorates. Horses occupy a central role in this dynamic, embodying both the promise of an unspoiled past and the inevitability of its demise (Hoy; Somogyi). Their presence in the narrative bridges the expansive romanticism of the Western with the pessimistic determinism of noir. As the novel unfolds, the layered significance of the horses deepens. They become not just symbols of freedom or nostalgia but also objects of ideological tension, reflecting a broader human tendency to mythologise nature (sensu Nolan, Hackett, and Coghlan). This clash between the romanticised and the real, when viewed through the noir lens, provides a unique perspective from which to explore human interactions with horses and the myth of horses. Barthesian Myths and the Equestrian Allure Roland Barthes’s theory of myth provides a critical lens for examining the portrayal of horses in All the Pretty Horses (Barthes). Barthes defines myth as a system of meaning that naturalises cultural constructs, transforming historical realities into self-evident truths. In All the Pretty Horses, horses are romanticised as symbols of freedom, authenticity, and the cowboy ethos, yet their depiction simultaneously reveals inherent contradictions and violence underpinning these ideals (Kaminsky; Somogyi). Horses thus become sites where myth and materiality collide, highlighting a human tendency to mythologise the goodness of nature while simultaneously exploiting it. Horses in All the Pretty Horses embody an idealised vision of the cowboy life that Grady seeks. Grady’s devotion to horses reflects his yearning for a different life, viewing them as essential to his identity. They anchor him to a vanishing past, representing a world of unspoiled beauty and simplicity that is increasingly threatened by industrialisation and cultural erosion. However, horses exist in both versions of the rural idyll, whether in utopian landscapes providing a safe escape from urbanisation, or within the same landscape represented as dystopian and steeped in crime and violence (Traub; Lee). As an extended connection to the cowboy’s horse, another horse myth All the Pretty Horses perpetuates is the myth of the warhorse, stating “horses also love war” (111). Grady’s father asserts that “no man who has not gone to war on horseback can ever truly understand the horse” (111) exemplifying a deep connection between horses and soldiers. The connection between war and horses creates an existential problem for Grady, the self-titled “comandante de las yeguas” (128), whose identity is intimately tied to horses, but who has not been to war. This bond between horse and soldier has deep romantic roots in literature, as illustrated in Black Beauty, where an old war horse recounts stories of loyalty and shared hardships with his master (Sewell). However, there is definitive evidence of companionship and respect for horses in a post-war cultural memory which could have informed the myth-making. Nathan Wise provides a valuable framework for understanding this evolution, tracing how horses, initially integral to human survival in war and work, became mythologised symbols of resilience, freedom, and nobility. In military contexts, horses were celebrated not only for their utility but also for their perceived virtues, which mirrored the aspirations of their human counterparts. Gullett observes that “there has never been a closer bond between man and animal than that between the veteran Light Horseman and his Waler” (in Wise 65). Wise’s exploration of the human-horse relationship reveals a nuanced dynamic that varied depending on the nature of the working relationship between the horse and human. In some working environments, such as in artillery or supply units, horses were commonly viewed as a military tool or resource that could be worked to near exhaustion and death if needed. In other environments, such as cavalry and light horse, a long, close bond and working relationship with a horse was central to the wellbeing and success of the individual and their unit, and thus, horses were viewed in more sentimental and often anthropomorphic ways: as friends, ‘pals’, comrades, and symbols of endurance (Wise). Of course, the romance, reverence, and respect demonstrated towards horses are potentially one-sided, leading scholars like Somogyi to question, do the horses want to be at war? The romanticisation of the horse-myth obscures some of the harsh realities of the human-horse relationship, particularly the violence and control involved in domestication and taming. The language of horsemanship, with terms like breaking and taming, reflects a dynamic of control that strips horses of their autonomy. The process of breaking and taming horses is an important motif in the novel. On a Mexican hacienda, Grady and Rawlins attempt to break 16 horses in four days, demonstrating their prowess and mastery of horses and therefore affirming their worth in the foreign land (100). The conflict between these actions of control and the image of the horse as a symbol of freedom is a familiar contradiction embedded in the horse-myth of the cowboy life and the warhorse. When Grady is breaking a wild Mexican horse, he notes, “they did not smell like horses. They smelled like they were, wild animals” (103). Grady suggests that a horse’s true nature emerges only after domestication. For Grady, the act of breaking horses is not merely a demonstration of skill and mastery but a way of bringing forth true nature; a nature that exists subordinate to humans. The act of breaking a horse broadly mirrors a human impulse to dominate and impose order on the entire natural world. As myths, horses are objectified and imbued with an almost sacred quality, their beauty and nobility elevating them beyond a material reality. This mythic allure blinds characters to the practical and often brutal realities of their relationships with horses, such as Jimmy Blevins’s attachment to his stolen horse. The horse’s exceptional quality is a source of pride and a symbol of status, yet it also precipitates Blevins’s downfall. His inability to maintain, reclaim, and again, maintain his horse demonstrates the power of myth to entrap individuals in cycles of obsession and self-destruction. Grady’s relationship with horses is similarly shaped by their mythic constructs. His deep connection to his horse represents his adherence to a personal, frontier moral code, rooted in ideals of loyalty and justice. However, this connection also compels him to act in ways that deepen his entanglement in violence and loss. Grady justifies his decision to help Blevins reclaim his horse by asking Rawlins “what if it was you?” (76). Because of the relationship between Rawlins and Grady, “what if it was you?” is ostensibly the same as what if it were me. The trio’s efforts to rescue Blevins’s horse, in a land foreign to their customs and laws, highlight the innate bond between horse and rider, suggesting that their separation constitutes a fundamental injustice. Through its portrayal of horses, All the Pretty Horses helps in the understanding of the myths underpinning rural and cowboy identities. Barthes’s theory of myth reveals how these constructs “empty reality” (142) and the material conditions of human-animal relationships, transforming acts of control and violence into symbols of nobility and authenticity. All the Pretty Horses opens the romanticised ideals of freedom and individuality that define the cowboy ethos for critique. This critique positions horses as central to the novel’s noir exploration of identity, morality, and the human condition. The Filly Fatale: Horses as Noir Catalysts The mythic horses function as noir catalysts, analogous to the femme fatale archetype, compelling the protagonists into fatalistic cycles of desire, conflict, and inevitable downfall. Unlike the human femme fatale, however, the horses’ agency lies not in intentional manipulation but in their mythic allure and their integral role within the narrative. The comparison between horses and women is made explicit by Rawlins when he explains that “a goodlookin horse is like a goodlookin woman... They’re always more trouble than what they’re worth. What a man needs is just one that will get the job done” (89). This comparison underscores the horses’ dual function as objects of desire and sources of peril. The femme fatale archetype traditionally symbolises the destabilisation of male authority and rationality (Pippin; Creed). Much like the femme fatale, the horses draw the characters into morally complex situations, forcing them to confront the dissonance between their ideals and their realities. The role of the femme fatale has been criticised. Creed underscores the concept of the objectified woman, arguing that patriarchal ideologies in popular narratives reduce women to their sexuality, framing them as enigmatic and alien figures who by their nature disrupt the rational order of male-dominated society (10). Feminist theorists further assert that this objectification serves as a mechanism of control, suppressing female potential (Fiedler). Palmer argues that in noir the taming process is a male act, while domestication is cast as female destiny. Drawing on Lévi-Strauss’s theory of exchange, which conceptualises women as signs exchanged among men (Lévi-Strauss), Cook and Johnston argue that noir heroines exist solely within the discourse of male characters: depicted as only having an existence within the discourse of men: she is “spoken”, she does not speak. As an object of exchange between men, a sign oscillating between the images of prostitute and mother-figure, she represents the means through which men express their relationship with each other, the means through which they come to understand themselves and each other. (95) In All the Pretty Horses, horses partially supplant women as objects in the narrative’s discourse. The exchanges of horses between men become measures of character, as illustrated when Grady and Rawlins judge Blevins unworthy of his horse, assuming its exceptional quality exceeds his status. Like the femme fatale who lures the noir protagonist to his downfall, the trio of Grady, Rawlins, and Blevins are drawn to their respective fates through their relationships with horses. From their initial encounter with Blevins, whose horse's magnificence precedes recognition of the rider himself, ultimately, Blevins’s horse precipitates his death, echoing noir themes in which women—or their symbolic equivalents—lead men to ruin. By reimagining the femme fatale archetype through the figure of the horse, the interplay between allure, danger, and destruction that defines noir storytelling is recontextualised. Horses in All the Pretty Horses are not mere narrative elements; they are dynamic forces that shape the characters’ trajectories and challenge their autonomy. Thus, in All the Pretty Horses, horses transcend their roles as mere animals, becoming pivotal symbolic objects within the narrative's noir framework. Their allure, like that of the femme fatale, embodies both promise and peril, drawing the protagonists toward the fatalistic undercurrents that cause the protagonists to suffer. Cycles of Suffering and the Returning Home When Rawlins states, “you think about all the stuff that can happen to you... There ain’t no end to it” (91), he evokes noir’s characteristic circularity, where protagonists often return to their starting point (Palmer). This circularity is echoed in Hughes’s Ride the Pink Horse, where the titular pink horse, part of a carousel, symbolises a cyclical journey: “you go a long way in a circle and end up in the same place as you started” (Silver 232). Similarly, Grady’s return to Texas captures a cyclical fatalism important to many noir narratives. Silver uses the case study of Ride the Pink Horse to explore noir texts and “Schopenhauer’s belief in validation and redemption” (232). Schopenhauer’s philosophy of suffering as an intrinsic aspect of existence offers an interpretive framework for Grady’s hardships. For Schopenhauer, suffering is not incidental but integral to life, a consequence of the cyclical, endless striving that defines human will (Schopenhauer). While Grady never renounces Schopenhauer’s will, and while he never went to war per se, he appears to have sufficiently suffered to finally understand the horse. At the close of the story, Grady and his horse are silhouetted as one against a blood red sky. Through this interplay of themes, All the Pretty Horses bridges the spiritual and fatalistic dimensions of noir and Western traditions. Horses, often anthropomorphised with human and even divine traits, encapsulate this duality. Grady’s belief that “God put horses on earth to work cattle” (127) imbues them with a theological significance that contrasts with noir’s secular fatalism. In a similar fashion Grady believes there is no wealth worth having other than cattle, so a theological connection between worth and horses is aligned in opposition to classic “godless” existential crises of noir narratives (Sanders and Porfirio 96). The noir Western blends religious determinism with the cyclical despair of noir. Ultimately, horses in All the Pretty Horses are more than narrative elements; they are pivotal constructs that shape the characters’ fates and challenge the myths underpinning their identities. By weaving the fatalism of noir with the mythic resonance of the Western, McCarthy’s narrative offers a profound commentary on the human condition. Horses, as both symbols of freedom and agents of entrapment, embody the collapse of the cowboy myth against the inevitable civilising forces of industrialisation. All the Pretty Horses uses its horses to reflect a broader existential struggle to reconcile the idealised past with an unrelenting present. Conclusion Through its intricate melding of noir and Western elements, All the Pretty Horses illustrates the collapse of the romanticised ideals of freedom and individualism central to the cowboy ethos. Horses, as mythic constructs, serve as narrative catalysts that intertwine human ambition with cycles of suffering, drawing characters toward their fatalistic ends. Noir hybrid texts such as All the Pretty Horses can reframe the human-animal relationship, exposing the violence and control inherent in the domestication process while critiquing the myths that sustain these practices. By applying Barthes’s theory of myth, this analysis reveals how horses transcend their material reality to become symbols laden with ideological tension. These constructs, both alluring and perilous, align with noir’s femme fatale archetype, recontextualising the interplay between allure, danger, and destruction that defines the genre. The protagonist’s journey underscores noir’s fatalism, illustrating how mythic ideals can entrap individuals in cycles of loss and disillusionment. References Barthes, Roland. Mythologies. Trans. Lavers, Annette. New York: Noonday Press, 1970. Conard, Mark T. The Philosophy of Film Noir. UP of Kentucky, 2005. Cook, Pam, and Claire Johnston. "The Place of Woman in the Cinema of Raoul Walsh." Feminism and Film Theory. Ed. Constance Penley. Routledge, 2013. 25-35. Creed, Barbara. Pandora's Box: Essays in Film Theory. Victoria: Australian Centre for the Moving Image, 2004. Fiedler, Leslie A. The Stranger in Shakespeare. London: Croom Helm, 1973. The Iron Horse. Dir. J. Ford. 16mm by Films Inc. and the Museum of Modern Art, 1924. Hoy, Jim. "The Americanisation of the Outback: Cowboys and Stockmen." Journal of Australian Studies 24.66 (2000): 205-10. Hughes, Dorothy B. Ride the Pink Horse. New York: Penzler, 1946. Kaminsky, Stuart M. American Film Genres: Approaches to a Critical Theory of Popular Film. New York: Dell Publishing, 1977. Lee, Susan Savage. "The Cost of Dreams of Utopia: Neocolonialism in Juan Rulfo's 'Pedro Páramo' and Cormac McCarthy's 'All the Pretty Horses'." Confluencia 30.1 (2014): 152-70. Lévi-Strauss, Claude. The Elementary Structures of Kinship. Beacon Press, 1971. McCarthy, Cormac. All the Pretty Horses. London: Pan Books, 1992. Monticone, Paul. "The Noir Western: Genre Theory and the Problem of the Anomalous Hybrid." Quarterly Review of Film and Video 31.4 (2014): 336-49. Nolan, Huw, Lisa J. Hackett, and Jo Coghlan. "Ethics and Post-Evolution: The Role of Hyperreal Adaptations in Shaping Cultural Perceptions of Animals." Journal of Australasian Popular Culture 13.2 (2024): 119-124. Owens, Barcley. Cormac McCarthy's Western Novels. U of Arizona P, 2000. Palmer, R Barton. "Moral Man in the Dark City: Film Noir, the Postwar Religious Revival, and the Accused." The Philosophy of Film Noir (2006): 187-206. Pippin, Robert B. Fatalism in American Film Noir: Some Cinematic Philosophy. Page-Barbour Lectures for 2010. Charlottesville: U of Virginia P, 2012. Sanders, Steven M., and Robert Porfirio. "Film Noir and the Meaning of Life." The Philosophy of Film Noir. Ed. Mark T. Conard. UP of Kentucky, 2006. 91-106. Schopenhauer, Arthur. The World as Will and Representation. Aegitas, 2016. Sewell, Anna. Black Beauty. Harmondsworth: Puffin, 1954. Silver, Alain. "Ride the Pink Horse: Money, Mischance, Murder, and the Monads of Film Noir." The Philosophy of Film Noir. Ed. Mark T. Conard. UP of Kentucky, 2006. 223-37. Somogyi, Kitti. The Rewriting of the Western Myth in Four Novels by Cormac McCarthy. PhD Dissertation. University of Pécs, 2022. Springhall, John. "Have Gun, Will Travel: The Myth of the Frontier in the Hollywood Western." Historian 112 (2011): 20. Traub, Stuart H. "Rewards, Bounty Hunting, and Criminal Justice in the West: 1865-1900." The Western Historical Quarterly 19.3 (1988): 287-301. “Desire Is All you Need.” Yellowstone. Dir. C.A. Voros. Paramount, 2024. Wise, Nathan. "‘A Good Faithful Pal’: Working Relationships between Humans and Horses during the First World War." First World War Studies 12.1 (2021): 53-70. We also acknowledge the two anonymous peer reviewers for their time and thorough critique of our article. Their efforts and diligence have strengthened our work and contributed to the broader academic discourse. Finally, we thank the team at Australia’s Popular Culture Network (PopCRN) for their commitment to advancing scholarly research in Popular Culture

Art · Crime and Detective Fiction Studies · Gothic Literature and Media Analysis · Modern American Literature Studies