Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Rags, Riches, and Bootstraps

Beliefs about the Causes of Wealth and Poverty

Bibliographic Data

ID2276503
AuthorsKatherine B Smith (0000-0003-0312-2284, Lamar University), Kevin B Smith (0000-0003-0424-9367, Lamar University), Lorene H Stone (Lamar University)
Year1989
Volume30
Issue1
Pages93-107
Publication date1989-03-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueSociological Quarterly (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0038-0253 • E-ISSN: 1533-8525
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/j.1533-8525.1989.tb01513.x
OpenAlexW1909830202
LanguageEN
Citations received84
References cited21

Specific beliefs pertaining to wealth and poverty emanate from metatheories about socioeconomic inequalities. As cognitions, these metatheories filter social perceptions and generate beliefs about the specific causes of wealth and poverty. Four metatheories coexist in American culture and compete for public support. The four are individualism, culturalism, structuralism/situationalism, and fatalism. Using public opinion data on beliefs about 38 often-mentioned causes of wealth and poverty, the degree of support for each metatheory was determined. Individualism was the metatheory of choice in specifying the causes of poverty, whereas culturalism and individualism vied for superiority in identifying the causes of wealth

Basic needs · Culturalism · Culture of poverty · Economic growth · Economics · Epistemology · Fatalism · Individualism · Metatheory · Political science · Positive economics · Poverty · Social science · Socioeconomic status · Sociology · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Psychology · Social and Cultural Dynamics · Social and Intergroup Psychology · Social Psychology

  • Explicaciones sobre el origen de la pobreza según área de formación profesional

    Open Access•J Christopher Cohrs, Belén Cañadas et al.•Propósitos y Representaciones•2019

  • Development and Validation of A Short Form of the Attitude Toward Poverty Scale

    Open Access•Sung Hyun Yun, Robert D Weaver•Advances in Social Work•2010

  • Developing critical consciousness or justifying the system? A qualitative analysis of attributions for poverty and wealth among low-income racial/ethnic minority and immigrant women

    Open Access•Erin B Godfrey, Sharon Wolf•Cultural Diversity & Ethnic…•2015

  • A View From the Inside Out

    Mark Robert Rank•The Journal of Sociology & Social…•1994

  • Sociodemographic and Political Correlates of University Students’ Causal Attributions for Poverty

    Open Access•William E Griffin, Yaw Oheneba-Sakyi•Psychological Reports•1993

  • Impact of Meritocratic Beliefs of Newcomers on Creativity

    Open Access•Zhongqiu Li, Liang Liang et al.•Psychological Reports•2022

  • The Cambridge Handbook of the International Psychology of Women

    Open Access•Fanny M Cheung, Diane F Halpern•Cambridge Handbook of the…•2020

  • An Attributional Analysis of Reactions to Poverty

    Open Access•Bernard Weiner, Douglas Osborne et al.•Personality and Social Psychology…•2011

  • Do Middle-Class Students Perceive Poor Women and Poor Men Differently

    Open Access•Catherine Cozzarelli, Michael J Tagler et al.•Sex Roles•2002

  • Sociodemographic and Political Correlates of University Students' Causal Attributions for Poverty

    William E Griffin, Yaw Oheneba-Sakyi•Psychological Reports•1993

  • Reliability and Validity of Aids Victim Blaming Scales

    Open Access•Charles L Mulford, Motoko Y Lee•Psychological Reports•1996

  • Discrimination and anger control as pathways linking socioeconomic disadvantage to allostatic load in midlife

    Open Access•Samuele Zilioli, Ledina Imami et al.•Journal of Psychosomatic Research•2017

  • Public beliefs about the black/white socioeconomic status gap

    Open Access•Matthew O Hunt, Paul R Croll et al.•Social Science Quarterly•2021

  • Attributions of Responsibility for Poverty Among Lebanese and Portuguese University Students

    Open Access•Kamal Abouchedid, Ramzi Nasser•Social Behavior and Personality…•2002

  • Bir Sosyalleşme ve Kişilik Oluşturma Aracı Olarak Sosyal Sınıflar

    Open Access•Turhan Yörükân•Erdem•2009

  • Pobreza, desigualdad y religión

    Open Access•David Eduardo Vilchis Carrillo•Revista Temas Sociológicos•2022

  • “Why Don't You Go Down to Wall Street and Get Some Real Crooks?”

    Ciara Moloney•Journal of Film and Video•2023

  • Perception of the reasons for living in poverty in Hungary

    Open Access•Eszter Siposn•Hungarian Studies•2021

  • Buying into Dominant Ideas About Wealth and Poverty

    Open Access•Agata Soroko•Teachers College Record The Voice…•2020

  • The relationship between meritocratic beliefs and career outcomes

    Open Access•Shi Hu, Xueping Shen et al.•Journal of Vocational Behavior•2020

  • The Associations Between Neoliberal Policies and Attributions for Poverty in 13 Countries

    Open Access•Shahrzad Goudarzi, Jaime L Napier•Social Psychological and…•2026

  • Causal attributions of poverty

    Open Access•Lionel Marquis, Ursina Kuhn et al.•Frontiers in Sociology•2025

  • Cultural attributions for racial inequality

    Open Access•Thomas E Nelson, Darlley Joselus•Politics Groups and Identities•2022

  • Agentic selves, agentic stories

    Open Access•Jacqueline S Ho•American Journal of Cultural…•2023

  • Causes and Remedies for Poverty

    Open Access•Lihi Lahat, Gila Menahem•Poverty & Public Policy•2009

  • A New Face of Poverty? Economic Crises and Poverty Discourses

    Open Access•H Abbie Erler•Poverty & Public Policy•2012

  • Poverty and Social Policy

    Open Access•Miki Malul•Poverty & Public Policy•2019

  • Public Attributions for Poverty in Canada

    Open Access•Linda Reutter, Gerry Veenstra et al.•Canadian Review of Sociology/Revue…•2008

  • Paradigms, Policies, and People

    Open Access•Drew Hyman, Jeffrey C Bridger et al.•Review of Policy Research•2001

  • Too Much Democracy? Exploring the Link between Majoritarian Institutions and Disparities in the American States

    Open Access•Julianna Pacheco, Scott James Lacombe•State Politics & Policy Quarterly•2024

  • The rich—love them or hate them? Divergent implicit and explicit attitudes toward the wealthy

    Open Access•Suzanne R Horwitz, John F Dovidio•Group Processes & Intergroup…•2015

  • Exploring the Relationships Between Multicultural Training, Racial Attitudes, and Attributions of Poverty Among Graduate Counseling Trainees

    Rebecca L Toporek, Donald B Pope‐Davis et al.•Cultural Diversity & Ethnic…•2005

  • Single Welfare Mothers' Resistance

    Yvonne M Luna•Journal of Poverty•2009

  • Predicting Support for Welfare Policies

    Heather E Bullock, Wendy R Williams et al.•Journal of Poverty•2003

  • Go It Alone” Poverty in a Small City

    Brenda Solomon•Journal of Poverty•2007

  • So Many People are Struggling”

    Sharon Y Nickols, Robert B Nielsen•Journal of Poverty•2011

  • Pride, Prejudice, and a Dose of Shame

    Open Access•Karen A Gray•Affilia•2005

  • Behavioral Shifts in Students' Awareness and Reactions to the Homeless

    Luke M Tse, Michael W Firmin et al.•Journal of Social Distress and…•2010

  • One Nation, Underprivileged

    Mark Robert Rank•One Nation, Underprivileged•2004

  • Sisphyean Struggles

    Open Access•E Gubrium, Sabina Dhakal et al.•International Journal of Social…•2016

  • How Causal Attributions for Income Status Moderate the Link Between Income and Subjective Well‐Being

    Open Access•Qin Zhao, Tao Chen•Journal of Community & Applied…•2025

  • Linking cause and solution

    Open Access•Brianne Hastie•Australian Psychologist•2010

  • Whites Aren’t Bad, Asian Americans Are Just Better

    Rick Sperling, Jennifer Zwahr-Castro et al.•Journal of Latinos and Education•2016

  • Belief in Supernatural Agents and Lay Explanations About the Causes of Poverty

    Open Access•J H Jung, Muhan Chen et al.•Journal for the Scientific Study…•2026

  • Being and Becoming Poor

    P Homan, L Valentino et al.•Social Forces•2017

  • Gendered Realities of Poverty

    Roni Strier•Social Service Review•2005

  • The Role of Race and Birth Place in Welfare Usage among Comparable Women

    Open Access•Ruth Uwaifo Oyelere, Maharouf Oyolola•The Review of Black Political…•2011

  • How can leaders’ perceptions guide policy analysis in an era of governance

    Open Access•Lihi Lahat•Policy Sciences•2010

  • Teaching Strategies for Addressing Poverty Awareness With Aspiring Helping Professionals

    Open Access•Othelia Eun-Kyoung Lee, Othelia Eunkyoung Lee et al.•SAGE Open•2016

  • Cristianismo y pobreza

    Open Access•David Eduardo Vilchis Carrillo•Cultura y religión•2023

  • Psycho-social dimensions of poverty

    Open Access•Yongmie Nicola Jo•Critical Social Policy•2013

  • Poverty Attributions and the Perceived Justice of Income Inequality

    Open Access•Simone M Schneider, Simone Schneider et al.•Social Psychology Quarterly•2015

  • Poverty attitudes and their determinants in Lebanon's plural society

    Open Access•Kamal Abouchedid, Ramzi Nasser•Journal of Economic Psychology•2001

  • Typology of causes of poverty

    Open Access•Dariush Hayati, Ezatollah Karami•Journal of Economic Psychology•2005

  • The Effects of Knowledge about Poverty, Exposure to Poverty and Trust on Policymakers’ Perceptions about Poverty

    Open Access•Lihi Lahat•Social Policy and Administration•2018

  • Making Sense of a Globalizing World

    John P Myers•Theory & Research in Social…•2008

  • The development of the Systems and Individual Responsibility for Poverty (Sirp) Scale

    Open Access•Rachel Shor, Jenna M Calton et al.•Journal of Community Psychology•2018

  • Race/Ethnicity and Beliefs about Wealth and Poverty

    Open Access•Matthew O Hunt•Social Science Quarterly•2004

  • Scaling the Socioeconomic Ladder

    Open Access•Heather E Bullock, Wendy M Limbert•Journal of Social Issues•2003

  • Do rich people “deserve” to be rich? Charitable giving, internal attributions of wealth, and judgments of economic deservingness

    Open Access•Juliana F Black, Shai Davidai•Journal of Experimental Social…•2020

  • When Explanations for Poverty Help Explain Social Policy Preferences

    Open Access•Lionel Marquis, Jan Rosset•Social Justice Research•2021

  • Inequality Attribution and Political Participation

    Open Access•Yongshun Cai, Jennifer Sin Yu Hung•Journal of East Asian Studies•2026

  • Popular Explanations of Poverty

    Open Access•Dorota Lepianka, Wim Van Oorschot et al.•Journal of Social Policy•2009

  • Redistributive Policy Preferences

    Open Access•Moriah Harman•Political Research Quarterly•2025

  • Does the American Dream Matter for Members of Congress

    Open Access•Jacob M Grumbach•Political Research Quarterly•2015

  • Locus of Control and Anti‐Immigrant Sentiment in Canada, the United States, and the United Kingdom

    Open Access•Allison Harell, Stuart Soroka et al.•Political Psychology•2017

  • Thinking for Themselves

    Cindy Ma•Political Communication•2024

  • Social Inequality, State-centered Grievances, and Protest

    Open Access•Alexander De Juan, Eva Wegner•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2019

  • Working Twice as Hard to Get Half as Far

    Open Access•Christopher D Desante•American Journal of Political…•2013

  • Get Up, Get Out, and Git Sumthin

    Open Access•Jason E Shelton, A D Greene•American Behavioral Scientist•2012

  • Alone in the crowd

    Open Access•Bob Heyman, Jon Swain et al.•Social Science & Medicine•1997

  • The Relationship Between Counselors' Multicultural Counseling Competence and Poverty Beliefs

    Open Access•Madeline Clark, Jeff Moe et al.•Counselor Education and Supervision•2017

  • Religious and Spiritual Beliefs Uniquely Predict Poverty Attributions

    Open Access•Brett A Boeh Bergmann, Nathan R Todd•Social Justice Research•2019

  • Race, Ethnicity, and Lay Explanations of Poverty in the United States

    Open Access•Matthew O Hunt•Sociology of Race and Ethnicity•2016

  • Families in Poverty in the 1990s

    Open Access•Karen Seccombe•Journal of Marriage and the Family•2000

  • Toward A Revised Framework for Examining Beliefs About the Causes of Poverty

    Open Access•George Wilson•Sociological Quarterly•1996

  • Are the Homeless to Blame

    Open Access•Barrett A Lee, David W Lewis et al.•Sociological Quarterly•1992

  • The Perception of Poverty and Social Welfare Policies among Undergraduate and Graduate Social Work Students in the United States

    Jason T Castillo, Jason Castillo et al.•Journal of Human Behavior in the…•2012

  • American Poverty Cause Beliefs and Structured Inequality Legitimation

    J W Robinson•Sociological Spectrum•2009

  • Public opinion, prejudice and the racialization of welfare in Canada

    Allison Harell, Stuart Soroka et al.•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2014

  • Intergenerational Social Mobility and Popular Explanations of Poverty

    Open Access•Alexi Gugushvili•Social Justice Research•2016

  • Determinants of the Attribution of Poverty in Turkey

    Open Access•Şansel Özpinar, Sacit Hadi Akdede•Social Indicators Research•2022

  • Monitoring Perceptions of the Causes of Poverty in South Africa

    Open Access•Yul Derek Davids, Amanda Gouws•Social Indicators Research•2013

  • Social position, ideology, and distributive justice

    Open Access•Leo D''Anjou, Leo D'Anjou et al.•Social Justice Research•1995

  • Income and ideology

    Joan Huber•Income and ideology•1973

  • Inequality

    Christopher Jencks•Inequality•1975

  • Philadelphia Gentlemen

    E Digby Baltzell, Roger L Geiger•Philadelphia Gentlemen•2017

  • Explanations of poverty in Australian and American samples

    Open Access•N T Feather•Australian Journal of Psychology•1974

  • Why are the poor always with us? Explanations for poverty in Britain

    Open Access•A Furnham•British Journal of Social…•1982

  • Class Structure in the Social Consciousness (International Library of Society)

    Stanislaw Ossowski•Class Structure in the Social…•1980

  • Five Families

    Oscar Lewis•Five Families•1976

  • Sociological theories in progress

    Joseph Berger, Bo Anderson et al.•Sociological theories in progress•1966

  • Attitude prototypes as determinants of attitude–behavior consistency

    Charles G Lord, Mark R Lepper et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•1984

  • Cognitive processes in the revision of stereotypic beliefs

    Renee Weber, R Jack Weber et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•1983

  • Education and Intergroup Attitudes

    Mary R Jackman, Michael J Muha•American Sociological Review•1984

  • Whites' Beliefs about Blacks' Opportunity

    James R Kluegel, Eliot R Smith•American Sociological Review•1982

  • Self-serving biases in the attribution of causality

    Dale T Miller, M G Ro et al.•Psychological Bulletin•1975

  • Beliefs about the Motivation of the Poor and Attitudes toward Poverty Policy

    John B Williamson•Social Problems•1974

  • Reconsidering Ideological Lines

    Open Access•Lina Burzotta Nilson•Sociological Quarterly•1981

  • I made It Because of Me

    Katherine B Smith, Kevin B Smith•Sociological Spectrum•1985

  • Seeing justice in poverty

    Katherine B Smith, Kevin B Smith•Sociological Spectrum•1985

Unique citing works84
Citations per year2,47
Citation span1992 - 2026 (35)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 80

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae