Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Lineages of Paternalism

An Introduction

Bibliographic Data

ID2285482
AuthorsPeter Gibbons, Peter Gibbon (Danish Institute for International Studies Copenhagen and University of Manchester Strandgade 56 Copenhagen 1401 K Denmark, corresponding author), Benoit Daviron (CIRAD 73 rue J.F. Breton 34398 Montpellier Cedex 5 France), Stephanie Barral (0000-0002-0557-5941, CIRAD 73 rue J.F. Breton 34398 Montpellier Cedex 5 France)
Year2014
Volume14
Issue2
Pages165-189
Publication date2014-04-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Agrarian Change (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1471-0358 • E-ISSN: 1471-0366
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/joac.12066
OpenAlexW1820634014
LanguageEN
Citations received16
References cited68

This introductory paper argues that, for most of the period since 1914, paternalism has been the most enduring influence over labour management in large-scale agriculture in Africa and South-East Asia. On the other hand, paternalism appears in a number of variants, with considerable differences in terms of protagonists, degrees of comprehensiveness, emphases and relations to alternative approaches to labour management. After a brief preliminary section, the paper falls into three sections. The first argues for a specific definition of paternalism, against an account of the term's intellectual history. The second provides a sketch of paternalism's lines of development in African and South-East Asian agriculture. The third introduces the other papers in this collection by identifying their contributions to three central questions that arise from these discussions: how paternalism has been contested and by whom, whether paternalism will persist and if so in what form, and the implications of paternalism for citizenship

Citizenship · Economics · Law and economics · Paternalism · Political science · Politics · Positive economics · Sketch · Sociology · Law · Political Economy and Marxism

  • Le nouveau capitalisme agricole

    Stephanie Barral•Le nouveau capitalisme agricole•2017

  • The Politics of Children’s Rights and Representation

    Open Access•Balagopalan, Bengt Sandin et al.•The Politics of Children’s Rights…•2023

  • Articulations of inferiority

    Open Access•Koot, Stasja Koot•History and Anthropology•2023

  • Cashing in or driving development? Cross‐border traders and maize contract farming in northeast Laos

    Open Access•Robert Coles•Journal of Agrarian Change•2022

  • Introduction to symposium on labor, gender and new sources of agrarian change

    Open Access•L Addison, Matthew A Schnurr et al.•Agriculture and Human Values•2015

  • Rethinking exploitation and control in migrant labour regimes

    Open Access•Carlo John B Arceo, Caroline Hambloch et al.•Agriculture and Human Values•2025

  • Perpetuating power through autoethnography

    Open Access•Koot•Critical Arts•2016

  • Ethnobotanical memory of Cinchona among the Sundanese in the highland of West Java, Indonesia

    Open Access•ALISSA WIRANOVA, Dede Mulyanto et al.•Asian Journal of Ethnobiology•2026

  • Unraveling how intermediary‐beneficiary interaction shapes policy implementation

    Open Access•Cynthia L Michel•Regulation & Governance•2025

  • Supporting Children, Blaming Parents

    Open Access•Clara Siagian, Sandra Arifiani et al.•Social Sciences•2019

  • Labour after Land Reform

    Open Access•I Scoones, Blasio Mavedzenge et al.•Development and Change•2019

  • How Intersecting State Paternalism, Low Aspirations and Relative Satisfaction Preserve the Inertia of Rural Livelihoods in Odisha

    Open Access•Takuya Nakagawa, Josef Novotný•Journal of Agrarian Change•2025

  • Land outsourcing and labour contracting

    Open Access•Chen Yiyuan•Journal of Agrarian Change•2020

  • Can Capitalist Farms Defeat Family Farms? The Dynamics of Capitalist Accumulation in Shrimp Aquaculture inSouthChina

    Open Access•Yu Huang•Journal of Agrarian Change•2015

  • The state as a whiteman, the whiteman as a/'hun

    Open Access•Velina Ninkova•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•2022

  • White Namibians in tourism and the politics of belonging through Bushmen

    Koot, Stasja P Koot•Anthropology Southern Africa•2015

  • Capitalism and colonialism in Mozambique

    Leroy Vail•Capitalism and colonialism in…•1980

  • Indentured labor in the age of imperialism, 1834-1922

    David Northrup•Indentured labor in the age of…•1995

  • In red and black

    Eugene D Genovese•In red and black•1971

  • Doctrines Of Development

    Michael Cowen, M P Cowen et al.•Doctrines Of Development•2003

  • Value Chain Struggles

    Open Access•John Neilson, Jeff Neilson et al.•Value Chain Struggles•2009

  • Roll, Jordan, roll

    Eugene D Genovese•Roll, Jordan, roll•1974

  • The enigma of colonialism

    Anne Phillips•The enigma of colonialism•1989

  • Uncle Tom's Cabin; or, Life Among The Lowly

    Inc Wolfram Research•Wolfram Research Data Repository•2017

  • Les métamorphoses du paternalisme

    Open Access•Annie Lamanthe•Les métamorphoses du paternalisme•2011

  • Paternalism

    Gerald Dworkin, Sherwood J B Sugden•The Monist•1972

  • Paternalistic Behavior

    Bernard Gert, Charles M Culver•Medicine and Moral Philosophy•1982

  • Colonialism and Migration; Indentured Labour Before and After Slavery

    Open Access•P C Emmer•Colonialism and Migration;…•1986

  • Capitalism and Confrontation in Sumatra's Plantation Belt, 1870-1979

    Ann Stoler, Ann Laura Stoler•Capitalism and confrontation in…•1995

  • The Settler Economies

    Open Access•Paul Mosley•Settler Economies•1983

  • Travail, capitalisme et société esclavagiste

    Caroline Oudin-Bastide•Travail, capitalisme et société…•2005

  • Development as Freedom

    Open Access•Alan M Rugman, Amartya Sen•Rugman reviews international…•2009

  • Decolonization and African Society

    Open Access•Frederick Cooper, Faith Cooper•Decolonization and African Society•1996

  • The Financial Crisis in South African Agriculture and Post-Apartheid Agrarian Transformation

    Mike De Klerk•Canadian Journal of African…•1993

  • "The Long-Averted Clash"

    J Crush•Canadian Journal of African…•1993

  • “The Long-Averted Clash”

    J Crush•Canadian Journal of African…•1993

  • L'histoire et l'étude de la culture

    Carl E Schorske, Michel Charlot•Genèses•1990

  • Le paternalisme revisité en Europe occidentale (seconde moitié du XIXe siècle, début du XXe siècle)

    André Gueslin•Genèses•1992

  • Zimbabwean Farm Workers in Northern South Africa

    Open Access•B Rutherford, L Addison•Review of African Political Economy•2007

  • The Conference on Capitalist Plantations in Colonial Asia, Amsterdam, September 26-29, 1990, Amsterdam. A Report

    Paul E Baak•Archipel•1991

  • Pere plutot que maitre

    Open Access•Judy Lown, Jacques Debouzy et al.•Le Mouvement social•1988

  • Ideology and Death on a Savannah River Rice Plantation, 1833-1867

    Jeffrey R Young•The Journal of Southern History•1993

  • Labor Costs, Paternalism, and Loyalty in Southern Agriculture

    Open Access•Lee J Alston, Joseph P Ferrie•The Journal of Economic History•1985

  • An Economic Survey of the Sisal Industry of Tanganyika

    D T Jack, C W Guillebaud•The Economic Journal•1960

  • History of East Africa, Volume III

    M Wright, David A Low et al.•African Economic History•1977

  • Law, State and the Working Class in Tanzania

    August H Nimtz, August Nimtz et al.•African Economic History•1989

  • From Slaves to Squatters. Plantation Labour and Agriculture in Zanzibar and Coastal Kenya, 1890-1925

    P E Lovejoy, Frederick Cooper et al.•African Economic History•1982

  • Mobilizing labour in African agriculture

    Open Access•Benoit Daviron•Journal of Global History•2010

  • Slaves, Peasants and Capitalists in Southern Angola 1840-1926

    Douglas L Wheeler, W G Clarence-Smith et al.•African Economic History•1981

  • Activists beyond borders

    Margaret E Keck•Activists beyond borders•1998

  • Unilever Overseas

    Frederick Pedler•African Affairs•1979

  • Libertarian Paternalism Is Not an Oxymoron

    Cass R Sunstein, Richard H Thaler•The University of Chicago Law…•2003

  • A Deepening Divide in the Countryside

    Joachim Ewert, Andries Du Toit•Journal of Southern African Studies•2005

  • In the Name of the Father

    Donald Reid•History Workshop Journal•1994

  • The Conceptualization of Farm Family Business

    Open Access•Andrienetta Kritzinger, Jan Vorster•Sociologia Ruralis•1997

  • Histoire d'une « réforme morale » de la politique coloniale des Pays-Bas

    R Bertrand•Revue d’histoire moderne et…•2007

  • Dynamics of labour transformation

    Alec Gordon•Journal of Contemporary Asia•2004

  • Towards a model of asian plantation systems

    Alec Gordon•Journal of Contemporary Asia•2001

  • Vuta Kamba

    Arie Shirom, William H Friedland•Industrial and Labor Relations…•1970

  • Codifying Manamba

    Open Access•Hanan Sabea•Journal of Historical Sociology•2010

  • Labour Migration and Rural Transformation in Colonial Asia

    G V Scammell, Jan Breman•The Economic History Review•1991

  • The Atlantic Slave Trade. A Census

    Woodrow Borah, Philip D Curtin•Hispanic American Historical Review•1970

  • Le patronat francais a-t-il ete malthusien

    Open Access•Maurice Lévy-Leboyer, Maurice Lévy–leboyer•Le Mouvement social•1974

  • Du "patronage" au "paternalisme

    Open Access•Gérard Noiriel•Le Mouvement social•1988

  • Permanence du paternalisme

    Open Access•Marianne Debouzy•Le Mouvement social•1988

  • Plantations de palmiers à huile en Indonésie et déprolétarisation

    Stephanie Barral•Études rurales•2012

  • An Economic History of West Africa

    Patrick Manning, A G Hopkins•Economic History of West Africa•2014

  • Hegemony on a shoestring

    Open Access•Sara Berry•Africa•1992

  • Who Needs Immigrant Farm Workers? A South African Case Study

    Open Access•Deborah Johnston•Journal of Agrarian Change•2007

  • Commercial Farm Workers and the Politics of (Dis)placement in Zimbabwe

    Open Access•B Rutherford•Journal of Agrarian Change•2001

  • The development of capitalism in South African agriculture

    Mike Morris, M L Morris•Economy and Society•1976

  • Labour organisation in Western cape agriculture

    Joachim Ewert, Johann Hamman•The Journal of Peasant Studies•1996

  • The political economy of the maizefilière

    Henry Bernstein•The Journal of Peasant Studies•1996

  • Gender, Farmwork, and Women's Migration from Lesotho to the New South Africa

    Open Access•Theresa Ulicki, J Crush•Canadian Journal of African…•2000

  • Motives for mechanisation in South African agriculture, c1940-1980

    Stefan Schirmer•African Studies•2004

Unique citing works16
Citations per year1,45
Citation span2015 - 2026 (12)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 16

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae