Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Mapping Participant Frameworks in the Aitys of Birzhan and Sara

Bibliographic Data

ID2286360
AuthorsEva‐marie Dubuisson (0000-0003-3482-7594, Nazarbayev University)
Year2021
Volume31
Issue3
Pages357-381
Publication date2021-12-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Linguistic Anthropology (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1055-1360 • E-ISSN: 1548-1395
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/jola.12349
OpenAlexW4200462166
LanguageEN
Citations received3
References cited58

Here the lens of the "mapping problem" described by Judith Irvine in participant framework studies is used to analyze shifts in the cultural tale "The Aitys of Birzhan and Sara" from its origin as an improvisational verbal duel in the late 19th century, to a Kazakh socialist opera during the Soviet period, to a nationalized historical reference in Kazakhstan. During the multiple recontextualizations of that social text, its discursive pragmatics and characters are preserved within the expanding and shifting participant frameworks enabled by the genre of aitys poetry. Birzhan and Sara are able to "speak"-as poets, characters, and ancestors-to a changing series of audiences, all of whom become involved and implicated in their words and story as a result. They-like all aitys poets and the tradition itself-become a source of cultural authority. Thus the mapping of this social text over time is used as an example, in order to explain why and how an oral tradition is able to overcome or absorb even serious intertextual gaps resulting from shifting historical and political contexts over a long twentieth century

Folklore, Mythology, and Literature Studies · Philippine History and Culture · Rhetoric and Communication Studies

  • Interdiscursivity

    Open Access•Jillian R Cavanaugh, Stephanie V Love et al.•Annual Review of Anthropology•2025

  • Gender Balance in School Literature

    Open Access•Ainur Toleu, Bekarys NURİMANOV et al.•SAGE Open•2026

  • Voices of Dissent

    Assem Kalkamanova, Akylai Otkulbek Kyzy•Central Asian Affairs•2025

  • The Spectacular State

    Open Access•Laura L Adams•Spectacular State•2010

  • The Affirmative Action Empire

    Terry Martin•Affirmative Action Empire•2018

  • Responsibility and Evidence in Oral Discourse

    Jane H Hill, Judith T Irvine•Responsibility and Evidence in…•2021

  • The Soviet Legacy and Women's Rights in Central Asia

    M Kamp•Current History•2016

  • A Telling Tradition

    James Plumtree•Medieval Stories and Storytelling•2021

  • Registers in Circulation

    Open Access•Gal•Signs and Society•2018

  • Nation Branding in Central Asia

    Erica Marat•Europe Asia Studies•2009

  • Mass Spectacle and Styles of Governmentality in Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan

    Laura L Adams, Assel Rustemova•Europe Asia Studies•2009

  • The Philology of the Vernacular

    Richard Bauman•Journal of Folklore Research•2008

  • Global Astana

    Adrien Fauve•Central Asian Survey•2015

  • Practices of traditionalization in Central Asia

    Judith Beyer, Peter Finke et al.•Central Asian Survey•2019

  • Socialist in Form, “National” in Content? Art and Ideology in Soviet Tajikistan

    Open Access•Karolina Kluczewska, Niso Hojieva•Nationalities Papers•2022

  • Socialist in content, national in form

    Open Access•Maria Tagangaeva•Nationalities Papers•2017

  • Music and Identity in Central Asia

    Razia Sultanova•British Journal of Ethnomusicology•2005

  • Native California Languages as Semiotic Resources in the Performance of Identity

    Open Access•Jocelyn Ahlers•Journal of Linguistic Anthropology•2017

  • Commentary

    Open Access•Judith T Irvine•Journal of Linguistic Anthropology•2005

  • Commentary

    Open Access•Richard Bauman•Journal of Linguistic Anthropology•2005

  • Narrative Reproductions

    Open Access•Paul V Kroskrity•Journal of Linguistic Anthropology•2009

  • Narrating the Self

    Elinor Ochs, Lisa Capps•Annual Review of Anthropology•1996

  • Aqyn agha?Abai Zholyas socialist realism and as literary history

    Open Access•Gabriel Mcguire•Journal of Eurasian Studies•2017

  • How Tatiana's voice rang across the steppe

    Open Access•Naomi Caffee•Journal of Eurasian Studies•2017

  • Misunderstanding Abai and the legacy of the canon

    Open Access•Diana T Kudaibergenova•Journal of Eurasian Studies•2017

  • Mapping loss, remembering ancestors

    Guldana Salimjan•Asian Ethnicity•2021

  • Talking the Dog

    Deborah Tannen•Research on Language and Social…•2004

  • Language and Social Relations

    Open Access•Asif Agha•Language and Social Relations•2006

  • Debating gender and Kazakhness

    Guldana Salimjan•Central Asian Survey•2017

  • The Art of Dueling with Words

    Open Access•Valentina Pagliai•Oral tradition•2009

  • The Soviet Union as a Work-in-Progress

    Open Access•Francine Hirsch•Slavic Review•1997

  • The social life of cultural value

    Open Access•Asif Agha•Language & Communication•2003

  • The USSR as a Communal Apartment, or How a Socialist State Promoted Ethnic Particularism

    Open Access•Yuri Slezkine•Slavic Review•1994

  • "Routes and Roots" of Kazakh Identity

    Open Access•Saulesh Yessenova•The Russian Review•2005

  • Staging language

    Open Access•Allan Bell, Andy Gibson•Journal of Sociolinguistics•2011

  • Gender, Uyghur Identity, and the Story of Nuzugum

    Open Access•Kara Abramson•The Journal of Asian Studies•2012

  • Literacy under Authority

    Open Access•Phillip P Marzluf•The Journal of Asian Studies•2017

  • Whorish Old Man" and "One (Animal) Gentleman

    Open Access•John B Haviland•Journal of Linguistic Anthropology•2005

  • Traditional Laments and Postmodern Regrets

    Open Access•James M Wilce•Journal of Linguistic Anthropology•2005

  • Voice, Footing, Enregisterment

    Open Access•Asif Agha•Journal of Linguistic Anthropology•2005

  • Genre, Intertextuality, and Social Power

    Open Access•Charles L Briggs, Richard Bauman•Journal of Linguistic Anthropology•1992

  • When Talk Isn't Cheap

    Open Access•Judith T Irvine•American Ethnologist•1989

  • Discourse Genres in a Theory of Practice

    Open Access•William F Hanks•American Ethnologist•1987

  • Ritual Contingency

    Open Access•Nikolas Sweet•Journal of Linguistic Anthropology•2020

  • Cultivating Participation and the Varieties of Reflexivity in Stand-Up Comedy

    Open Access•Antti Lindfors•Journal of Linguistic Anthropology•2019

  • Poetics of Praise and Image-Texts of Cinematic Encompassment

    Open Access•Constantine V Nakassis•Journal of Linguistic Anthropology•2019

  • Confrontation in and through the Nation in Kazakh Aitys Poetry

    Open Access•Eva‐marie Dubuisson•Journal of Linguistic Anthropology•2010

Unique citing works3
Citations per year3
Citation span2025 - 2026 (2)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 2

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae