Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Sufficient Citizens

Moderation and the Politics of Sustainable Development in Thailand

Bibliographic Data

ID2290465
AuthorsEli Elinoff (0000-0001-5356-5003, National University of Singapore)
Year2014
Volume37
Issue1
Pages89-108
Publication date2014-05-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenuePoLAR Political and Legal Anthropology Review (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1081-6976 • E-ISSN: 1555-2934
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/plar.12052
OpenAlexW1892218885
LanguageEN
Citations received29
References cited26

After the 1997 Asian markets crash, the theory of the 'sufficiency economy' altered the discourse of development in Thailand. Emphasizing Buddhist notions of moderation and 'enough' sufficiency recast development as a means to temper socio-economic volatility by reforming consumer affect. Sufficiency theory pinned the nation's economic upheaval on excessive desires, attempting to intervene in these impulses through projects rooted in personal moderation and communality. In this article, I explore the relationship between politics, citizenship, and sufficiency. Through ethnographic analysis of cases from urban squatter settlements taking part in state-driven participatory urban planning policies, I argue that sufficiency has become central to debates over citizenship in contemporary Thailand. Urban planners use sufficiency to attempt to produce what they term 'personal development' and to attempt to defuse political claims by training the poor to moderate their demands by learning 'enough.' I also show how residents of squatter communities use the language and practices of sufficiency to make political claims and to demonstrate their legitimacy as citizens with rights to the city. In doing so, I demonstrate how notions of sustainable development tied to moderation extend and potentially interrupt social inequalities

Anthropological Studies and Insights · Southeast Asian Sociopolitical Studies · Water Governance and Infrastructure

  • Siege of the Spirits

    Benjamin Tausig•Anthropological Quarterly•2016

  • Mapping an alternative community river

    Open Access•Rita Padawangi, Etienne Turpin et al.•Sustainable Cities and Society•2016

  • “… They Can’t Occupy the Sun …”

    Open Access•Samir Harb•Geoforum•2025

  • Unmaking Civil Society

    Eli Elinoff•Contemporary Southeast Asia•2014

  • Whose and what futures? Navigating the contested coproduction of Thailand’s energy sociotechnical imaginaries

    Open Access•Laurence L Delina•Energy Research & Social Science•2017

  • Energy democracy in a continuum

    Open Access•Laurence L Delina•Energy Research & Social Science•2018

  • Reimagining energy futures

    Open Access•Jens Marquardt, Laurence L Delina•Energy Research & Social Science•2018

  • A rural energy collaboratory

    Open Access•Laurence L Delina•Journal of Environmental Studies…•2019

  • From Traction to Friction in Thailand

    Open Access•Jonathan Riggs•TRaNS Trans -Regional and…•2017

  • Commoning or being commoned? Institutions, politics, and the role of the state in collective housing policy in Bangkok, Thailand

    Open Access•Hayden Shelby•Planning Theory•2021

  • Forced evictions, spatial (un)certainties and the making of exemplary centres in Indonesia

    Open Access•Rita Padawangi•Asia Pacific Viewpoint•2019

  • Domestic volunteer tourism in Thailand

    Open Access•Nattaka Chaisinthop•South East Asia Research•2017

  • Bangkok middle-class spectatorship and social realist media

    Treepon Kirdnark•South East Asia Research•2022

  • Alternative Development Concepts and Their Political Embedding

    Wolfram Schaffar•Forum for Development Studies•2018

  • The Dilemmas of Equity Planning in the Global South

    Open Access•Luisa Sotomayor, Amrita Danière•Journal of Planning Education and…•2017

  • Insurgent Co ‐ Production

    Open Access•Hayden Shelby•International Journal of Urban…•2024

  • Thailand

    Michelle Tan, Edward Vickers•Compare A Journal of Comparative…•2024

  • From fragmentation to framework

    Open Access•Xinyi Wang, Chye Kiang Heng et al.•Habitat International•2025

  • Can food self-reliance support urban sustainability? The lessons from urban gardening in North Korea

    Open Access•Pavel P Em•Cities•2024

  • The imaginary of a modern city

    Open Access•Timothy Wells, Vanessa Lamb•Urban Studies•2022

  • Holding Public Procurement Socially Accountable

    Dhiyathad Prateeppornnarong•Public Integrity•2022

  • Une maison, c'est bien plus qu'une maison

    Eli Elinoff, Sarah Carton De Grammont•Monde commun•2020

  • Cukup for me to be successful in this country

    Open Access•Bittiandra Chand Somaiah, B S A Yeoh et al.•Global Networks•2020

  • Religion in the Age of Development

    Open Access•R M Feener, Philip Fountain•Religions•2018

  • Subjects of politics

    Open Access•Eli Elinoff•Anthropological Theory•2019

  • Sufficiency Economy and Backdated Claims of its Application

    Open Access•Pagorn Singsuriya•Journal of Asian and African…•2017

  • Urban Space and Exclusion in Asia

    E Harms•Annual Review of Anthropology•2016

  • Displacement through the Commons

    Open Access•Hayden Shelby, Trude Renwick•City & Society•2023

  • A house is more than a house

    Open Access•Eli Elinoff•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•2016

  • Chumchon /Community in Thailand

    Open Access•Craig J Reynolds•Words in Motion•2009

  • The Funeral Casino

    Alan Klima•Funeral Casino•2002

  • The Will to Improve

    Tania Murray Li•Will to Improve•2007

  • Thailand

    Thak Chaloemtiarana•Thailand•2007

  • The green governmentality in an Indonesian metropolis

    Open Access•Abidin Kusno•Singapore Journal of Tropical…•2011

  • Ordinary Affects

    Open Access•Karie Stewart, Kathleen Stewart•Ordinary Affects•2007

  • Smouldering Aspirations

    Open Access•Eli Elinoff•South East Asia Research•2012

  • Burning Red Desires

    Open Access•Claudio Sopranzetti•South East Asia Research•2012

  • Resisting globalization

    Kevin Hewison•The Pacific Review•2000

  • The autonomy of Thai housing policy, 1945–1996

    Open Access•Ceinwen Giles•Habitat International•2003

  • Sufficiency Economy and the Bourgeois Virtues

    Danny Unger•Asian Affairs An American Review•2009

  • The Dialectics of Village and State in Modern Thailand

    Open Access•Jeremy H Kemp, Jeremy Kemp•Journal of Southeast Asian Studies•1991

  • Parables for the Virtual

    Open Access•B Massumi, Stanley Fish et al.•Parables for the Virtual•2002

  • The Crown Property Bureau in Thailand and the crisis of 1997

    Porphant Ouyyanont•Journal of Contemporary Asia•2008

  • Spirits of 'Dark Finance' in Thailand

    Open Access•Alan Klima•Cultural Dynamics•2006

  • Unraveling the Myth of the Subsistence Economy

    Open Access•Katherine A Bowie•The Journal of Asian Studies•1992

  • Expectations of Modernity

    James Ferguson•Expectations of Modernity•2019

  • Autoconstruction in Working-Class Brazil

    Open Access•James Holston•Cultural Anthropology•1991

  • Empowerment Money

    Julia Elyachar•Public Culture•2002

  • Graduated Sovereignty in South-East Asia

    Open Access•Aihwa Ong•Theory Culture & Society•2000

  • Progress and Its Ruins

    Open Access•Andrew Johnson, Andrew Alan Johnson•Cultural Anthropology•2013

  • Inventiveness in politics

    Nikolas Rose•Economy and Society•1999

  • The Misrule of Law

    Open Access•James Holston•Comparative Studies in Society…•1991

Unique citing works29
Citations per year2,42
Citation span2014 - 2025 (12)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 28

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae