Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Partition of the Soul

Epicurus, Demetrius Lacon, and Diogenes of Oinoanda

Bibliographic Data

ID23201738
AuthorsFrancesco Verde (0000-0002-3249-7133, corresponding author)
Year2020
Pages89-112
Publication date2020-05-31
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeCHAPTER
VenueBody and Soul in Hellenistic Philosophy (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherCambridge University Press (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1017/9781108641487.005
OpenAlexW3028101586
ISBN9781108641487
LanguageEN
Citations received2
References cited167

Much has been written about Epicurus' psychology. However, despite the enduring popularity of the theme, to the best of my knowledge no contribution has yet specifically been devoted to the reception of Epicurus' psychology within the Epicurean tradition outside of Lucretius. The present essay therefore begins with some paragraphs of Epicurus' Letter to Herodotus devoted to the soul, in order to ascertain how Epicurus' psychology was represented by certain later Epicureans, most notably Demetrius Lacon (second to first century bc) and Diogenes of Oinoanda (second century ad), who lived not just in different ages but in very different places (the former, who never became scholarch, lived between Miletus and the mother school of Athens; the latter, between Oinoanda and Rhodes). In particular, I will set out to determine what the Epicureans made of the so-called bipartition between a rational and a non-rational part of the soul. While this theory is nowhere to be found in the Letter to Herodotus, it is espoused by Lucretius through the distinction between animus (the rational part) and anima (the non-rational part). In order to present as comprehensive a picture of the context as possible, it is best to start with Epicurus, and in particular with a challenging passage in §§ 63–4 of the Letter to Herodotus.

Archaeology · Art · Context (archaeology) · Epicureanism · Epistemology · Literature · Order (exchange) · Popularity · Soul · Theme (computing) · Classical Antiquity Studies · Classical Philosophy and Thought · Classics · Computer Science · Historical, Religious, and Philosophical Studies · History · Philosophy · Psychology · Social Psychology

  • Order without Teleology

    Francesco Verde•Oxford Handbook of Hellenistic…•2025

  • Why Epicurean happiness is not for everyone

    Jan Maximilian Robitzsch•British Journal for the History…•2024

  • Science, folklore, and ideology

    G E R Lloyd•Science, folklore, and ideology•1986

  • The Greek atomists and Epicurus

    Cyril Bailey•The Greek atomists and Epicurus•1964

  • The Pythagorean texts of the Hellenistic period

    Holger Thesleff•The Pythagorean texts of the…•1965

  • Herophilus

    Heinrich Von Staden•Herophilus•1989

  • The Norms of Nature

    Malcolm Schofield, Gisela Striker•The Norms of Nature•1986

  • L' Aristotele perduto e la formazione filosofica di Epicuro.

    Ettore Bignone•L' Aristotele perduto e la…•1973

  • Ethics and Human Action in Early Stoicism

    Brad Inwood•Ethics and Human Action in Early…•1987

  • Cosmic problems

    David J Furley•Cosmic problems•1989

  • Aristotle's criticism of Plato and the Academy

    Harold Fredrik Cherniss•Aristotle's criticism of Plato…•1962

  • Aëtiana

    Jaap Mansfeld, Douwe Runia•Aëtiana•2009

  • Cicero’s sceptical methods

    Open Access•Charles Brittain•Cicero's de Finibus•2015

  • Ciceronian dialogue

    Open Access•Malcolm Schofield•End of Dialogue in Antiquity•2009

  • Aristotle on the Sense-Organs

    Open Access•Thomas Johansen, T K Johansen•Aristotle on the Sense-Organs•1997

  • Erasistratus’ Triplokia of Arteries, Veins and Nerves

    David Leith•Apeiron•2015

  • Epicurus and the Placita

    David T Runia•Aëtiana IV•2018

  • Aristotle in the Aëtian Placita

    Open Access•Jaap Mansfeld•Brill’s Companion to the…•2016

  • Psychic Disharmony

    James Warren•Oxford Studies in Ancient…•2006

  • Plotinus and Epicurus

    Cinzia Arruzza, Mathesis Publications•Ancient Philosophy•2017

  • Panaetius Rhodius

    van Straaten van Straaten, Van Straaten•Panaetius Rhodius•1952

  • Diocles of Carystus. Volume One, Text and Translation

    Philip J Van Der Eijk•Diocles of Carystus. Volume One,…•2000

  • La « prohairesis » chez Épictète

    Open Access•Jean-Baptiste Gourinat•Philosophie antique•2005

  • Due postille a Demetrio Lacone ( Pherc . 1012, col. XLVI 7-8 Puglia) e Filotimo (2 Steckerl)

    Francesco Verde•Rivista di Filologia e di…•2017

  • II. Der Πλατωνικός des Eratosthenes

    E Hiller•Philologus•1870

  • All Voids Large and Small, Being a Discussion of Place and Void in Strato of Lampsacus's Matter Theory

    Daryn Lehoux•Apeiron•1999

  • Cicero

    Open Access•A E Douglas, Cicero Cicero•Tusculan disputations II & V with…•1989

  • Eratosthenes as Platonist and Poet

    Friedrich Solmsen•Transactions and Proceedings of…•1942

  • Lucretius and the Transformation of Greek Wisdom

    Open Access•David Sedley, David N Sedley•Lucretius and the Transformation…•1998

  • A New Work by Apuleius: The Lost Third Book of the De Platone

    Apuleius [Lucius Apuleius Madaurensis], Justin A Stover•New Work by Apuleius - The Lost…•2015

  • Essays on Hellenistic Epistemology and Ethics

    Open Access•Gisela Striker•Essays on Hellenistic Epistemology…•1996

  • Philosophy, science and medicine

    Open Access•Giuseppe Cambiano•The Cambridge history of…•1999

  • Galen and Chrysippus on the Soul

    Teun Tieleman•Galen and Chrysippus on the Soul•1996

  • Medicine and Philosophy in Classical Antiquity

    Open Access•Philip J Van Der Eijk•Medicine and Philosophy in…•2005

  • Platonist Philosophy 80 BC to AD 250

    Charles Brittain, George Boys-Stones et al.•Platonist Philosophy 80 BC to AD…•2017

  • The Mechanical Hypothesis in Ancient Greek Natural Philosophy

    Open Access•Sylvia Berryman•Mechanical Hypothesis in Ancient…•2009

  • Greek Medicine from Hippocrates to Galen

    Jacques Jouanna•Greek medicine from Hippocrates…•2012

  • The Emotions in Hellenistic Philosophy

    Open Access•Juha Sihvola, Troels Engberg-Pedersen•Emotions in Hellenistic Philosophy•1998

  • Science and philosophy in Aristotle'sGeneration of Animals

    Open Access•Anthony Preus•Journal of the History of Biology•1970

  • Lucretius’ Reception of Epicurus

    Elizabeth Asmis•Hermès•2016

  • Creationism and Its Critics in Antiquity

    David Sedley, D N Sedley•Creationism and Its Critics in…•2007

  • Posidonius as historian of philosophy

    Open Access•ANNA EUNYOUNG JU•Aristotle, Plato and Pythagoreanism…•2013

  • The Stoics

    John M Rist•Stoics•1978

  • Galen

    Open Access•Mark Schiefsky, Piero Tassinari et al.•Galen : Works on Human Nature•2019

  • The Cambridge History of Hellenistic Philosophy

    Open Access•Tiziano Dorandi, D M Schenkeveld et al.•The Cambridge history of…•1999

  • Aristotle on Pneuma and Animal Self-Motion

    Sylvia Berryman•Oxford Studies in Ancient…•2002

  • Matter, Medicine, and the Mind

    Roberto Polito•Oxford Studies in Ancient…•2006

  • How Industrious can Zeus be?

    Thomas Bénatouïl•God and cosmos in stoicism•2009

  • The School, from Zeno to Arius Didymus

    Open Access•David Sedley•Cambridge Companion to the Stoics•2003

  • From Platonism to Neoplatonism

    Open Access•Philip Merlan•From Platonism to Neoplatonism•1968

  • Sextus Empiricus

    Open Access•Richard Bett•Sextus Empiricus•2012

  • Determinism and Freedom in Stoic Philosophy

    John M Rist, John Μ Rist et al.•International Philosophical…•2000

  • Hellenistic Philosophy of Mind

    Julia Annas, Julia E Annas•Hellenistic Philosophy of Mind•1992

  • Body, Soul, and Nerves

    Heinrich Von Staden•Psyche and soma•2000

  • Philosophy and the Sciences in Antiquity

    R W Sharples•Philosophy and the Sciences in…•2019

  • The Lost Theory of Asclepiades of Bithynia

    J T Vallance•The lost theory of Asclepiades of…•1990

  • Chrysippus’ On Affections

    Teun Tieleman•Chrysippus’ On Affections•2003

  • Demiurge and Providence. Stoic and Platonist Readings of Plato's Timaeus

    Gretchen Reydams‐Schils, Gretchen J Reydams-Schils et al.•Demiurge and Providence•1999

  • Colloquium 1

    Stephen Menn•Proceedings of the Boston Area…•1995

  • La notion de mélange dans la pensée médicale de Galien

    Véronique Boudon-Millot•Revue des Études Grecques•2011

  • De Aristotelis librorum ordine et auctoritate

    Valentini Rose•De Aristotelis Librorum Ordine et…•1854

  • Epicurean Meteorology

    Fredericus Antonius Bakker•Epicurean Meteorology•2016

  • Lucretius and His Sources

    Francesco Montarese•Lucretius and His Sources•2012

  • The Cambridge Companion to Galen

    Open Access•R J Hankinson•The Cambridge Companion to Galen…•2008

  • The Platonic Origins Of Stoic Theology

    Francesco Ademollo•Oxford Studies in Ancient…•2012

  • Iamblichus' De Anima

    John F Finamore, John Finamore et al.•Iamblichus' de Anima•2002

  • Academic Therapy

    Malcolm Schofield•Philosophy and power in the…•2002

  • Platonismus und hellenistische Philosophie

    Hans-Joachim Krämer•Platonismus und Hellenistische…•1971

  • Teleology Without Tears

    Open Access•Sylvia Berryman•Canadian Journal of Philosophy•2007

  • Aristotle, On the Life-Bearing Spirit ( De spiritu )

    Abraham P Bos, A P Bos et al.•Aristotle, On the Life-Bearing…•2008

  • Stoic ethics

    Open Access•Brad Inwood, Pierluigi Donini•The Cambridge history of…•1999

  • Form and Content in the Tusculan Disputations

    A E Douglas•Cicero the philosopher•1995

  • Aristotle

    Aristotle Aristotle, Aristotle  et al.•De anima•1961

  • The Cambridge Companion to the Stoics

    Open Access•David Sedley, Christopher Gill et al.•Cambridge Companion to the Stoics•2003

  • Aristotle's Man

    Stephen R L Clark•Aristotle's man•1975

  • Galen and the Mechanical Philosophy

    Sylvia Berryman•Apeiron•2002

  • Philosophical Life in Cicero's Letters

    Open Access•Sean Mcconnell•Philosophical Life in Cicero's…•2014

  • The Stoic Theory of Categories

    Stephen Menn•Oxford Studies in Ancient…•1999

  • The Composition of the World-Soul in Timaeus 35 A-B

    G M A Grube•Classical Philology•1932

  • Walking and Talking

    Brad Inwood•Partitioning the Soul•2014

  • Passions & Perceptions

    Martha Nussbaum, Gisela Striker et al.•Passions and Perceptions•1993

  • Cosmological Ethics In The Timaeus And Early Stoicism

    Gábor Betegh•Oxford Studies in Ancient…•2003

  • Galen and the World of Knowledge

    Open Access•Christopher Gill, Tim Whitmarsh et al.•Galen and the World of Knowledge•2009

  • Interaction of Body and Soul

    Christof Rapp•Common to Body and Soul•2006

  • The Cratylus of Plato

    Francesco Ademollo•Cratylus of Plato•2011

  • Alcinous. The Handbook of Platonism

    Sara Rappe, Inc Mathesis Publications•Ancient Philosophy•1998

  • Reason and Emotion

    Open Access•John M Cooper, John Milton Cooper Jr•Reason and Emotion•1999

  • The Heirs of Plato

    Jessica Dillon, John Dillon•The Heirs of Plato•2003

  • The Stoic Sage

    Open Access•René Brouwer•Stoic Sage•2014

  • Psychology

    Open Access•Pierluigi Donini•The Cambridge Companion to Galen…•2008

  • The Intricate Translation of the Epicurean Doctrine of Ψυχη in Book 3 of Lucretius

    David Mehl•Philologus•1999

  • The Stoics on Identity, Identification, and Peculiar Qualities

    Tamer Nawar•Proceedings of the Boston Area…•2017

  • Gesammelte Aufsätze zu Platon

    Dagmar Mirbach, HansHG Krämer et al.•Gesammelte Aufsätze Zu Platon•2014

  • The Structured Self in Hellenistic and Roman Thought

    Christopher Gill•STRUCTURED SELF IN HELLENISTIC…•2006

  • Philoponus and the Rejection of Aristotelian Science

    Edward Grant, Richard Sorabji•The American Historical Review•1988

  • On Sterility (‘ HA X ’), a medical work by Aristotle?

    Open Access•Philip J Van Der Eijk•The Classical Quarterly•1999

  • Elements and Uniform Parts in Early Alexandrian Medicine

    David Leith•Phronesis•2015

  • The Syllogisms of Zeno of Citium

    Malcolm Schofield•Phronesis•1983

  • On the Physical Aspect of Heraclitus' Psychology

    Gábor Betegh•Phronesis•2007

  • Ancient Automata and Mechanical Explanation

    Sylvia Berryman•Phronesis•2003

  • Die gespannte Seele

    Julia Trompeter•Phronesis•2016

  • Body and Cosmos in Galen’s Account of the Soul

    Matyáš Havrda•Phronesis•2017

Unique citing works2
Citations per year1
Citation span2024 - 2025 (2)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 2

Tools

Open DOILibgen
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae