The Mistreatment of Women during Childbirth in Health Facilities Globally: A Mixed-Methods Systematic Review

Meghan A Bohren; Joshua P Vogel; Erin C Hunter; Olha Lutsiv; Suprita K Makh; João Paulo Souza; Carolina Aguiar; Fernando Saraiva Coneglian; Alex Luíz Araújo Diniz; Özge Tunçalp; Dena Javadi; Olufemi T Oladapo; Rajat Khosla; Michelle J Hindin; A Metin Gülmezoglu

doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1001847

The Mistreatment of Women during Childbirth in Health Facilities Globally

A Mixed-Methods Systematic Review

Bibliographic Data

ID	23316065
Authors	Meghan A Bohren (0000-0002-4179-4682), Joshua P Vogel (0000-0002-3214-7096), Erin C Hunter (0000-0001-6073-8646), Olha Lutsiv, Suprita K Makh, João Paulo Souza (0000-0002-1583-7933), Carolina Aguiar, Fernando Saraiva Coneglian, Alex Luíz Araújo Diniz, Özge Tunçalp (0000-0002-5370-682X), Dena Javadi (0000-0002-8445-547X), Olufemi T Oladapo (0000-0002-3371-5892), Rajat Khosla (0000-0002-4960-4994), Michelle J Hindin (0000-0001-9941-7639), A Metin Gülmezoglu (0000-0003-4674-0998)
Editors	Rachel Jewkes (0000-0002-4330-6267)
Year	2015
Volume	12
Issue	6
Pages	e1001847
Publication date	2015-06-30
Peer Reviewed	Yes
Open Access	Yes
Type	ARTICLE
Venue	PLoS Medicine (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiers	ISSN: 1549-1277 • E-ISSN: 1549-1676
Publisher	Public Library of Science (PLoS) (PUBLISHER)
DOI	10.1371/journal.pmed.1001847
PMID	26126110
PMCID	PMC4488322
Language	EN
Citations received	286
References cited	61

Strengthening Teamwork and Respect (STAR)
Open AccessChristiane Horwood, Lyn Haskins et al.Global Health Action2026
Evidence of ‘obstetric violence’ in India
Open AccessSurbhi Shrivastava, M SivakamiJournal of Biosocial Science2020
How is obstetric violence conceptualised and understood in the academic literature? A meta-narrative review
Camilla Pickles, Gemma Mckenzie et al.Medical Humanities2026
Respectful Maternity Care Practices During Normal Delivery at the Public Health Facilities in Tamil Nadu, Southern India
Open AccessSrinivas Govindarajulu, M Jagadeesan et al.Maternal and Child Health Journal2023
Maternal Health Infrastructure and Interpersonal Quality of Care During Childbirth
Open AccessStephanie A KujawskiMaternal and Child Health Journal2020
Provider perceptions of lack of supportive care during childbirth
Open AccessLaura Buback, Joyceline Kinyua et al.Health Care For Women International2021
Implementation research
Open AccessSally Theobald, Neal Brandes et al.The Lancet2018
The Giving Voice to Mothers study
Open AccessSaraswathi Vedam, the GVtM-US Steering Council et al.Reproductive Health2019
Beyond too little, too late and too much, too soon
Open AccessSuellen Miller, Edgardo Abalos et al.The Lancet2016
How women are treated during facility-based childbirth in four countries
Open AccessMeghan A Bohren, Hedieh Mehrtash et al.The Lancet2019
Quality of basic maternal care functions in health facilities of five African countries
Open AccessMargaret E Kruk, Hannah H Leslie et al.The Lancet Global Health2016
Accelerate progress—sexual and reproductive health and rights for all
Open AccessANN M STARRS, Alex C Ezeh et al.The Lancet2018
A global analysis of the determinants of maternal health and transitions in maternal mortality
Open AccessJuliano P Souza, João Paulo Souza et al.The Lancet Global Health2024
The scale, scope, coverage, and capability of childbirth care
Open AccessOona M R Campbell, Clara Calvert et al.The Lancet2016
Gender inequality and restrictive gender norms
Open AccessLori Heise, Margaret E Greene et al.The Lancet2019
Continuous support for women during childbirth
Open AccessMeghan A Bohren, G Justus Hofmeyr et al.Cochrane Database of Systematic…2017
Using Qualitative Evidence in Decision Making for Health and Social Interventions
Open AccessSimon Lewin, Claire Glenton et al.PLoS Medicine2015
Understanding Factors that Shape Gender Attitudes in Early Adolescence Globally
Open AccessAnna E Kågesten, Susannah Gibbs et al.PLoS ONE2016
Applying GRADE-Cerqual to qualitative evidence synthesis findings
Open AccessSimon Lewin, Andrew Booth et al.Implementation Science2018
High-quality health systems in the Sustainable Development Goals era
Open AccessMargaret E Kruk, Anna D Gage et al.The Lancet Global Health2018
Cover Up That “Baby Bump”
Open AccessKaitlyn Ligman, Emily P Courtney et al.Sex Roles2025
Quality of Informed Consent Practices around the Time of Childbirth
Open AccessEmanuelle Pessa Valente, Ilaria Mariani et al.International Journal of…2022
Early postnatal home visits
Open AccessYared Amare, Pauline FD Scheelbeek et al.BMC Public Health2018
Cross-cultural adaptation and validation of the German version of the Birth Satisfaction Scale-Revised (BSS-R)
Open AccessLara Seefeld, Amera Mojahed et al.BMC Public Health2025
Exploring the relationship between obstetric violence, postpartum depression, and breastfeeding through structural equation modelling
Open AccessMarilia Arndt Mesenburg, Emanuely Santos Marques et al.BMC Public Health2025
Feasibility of Participatory Theater Workshops to Increase Staff Awareness of and Readiness to Respond to Abuse in Health Care
Open AccessJennifer J Infanti, Anke Zbikowski et al.International Journal of…2020
Obstetric Violence Is Prevalent in Routine Maternity Care
Open AccessDinusha Perera, Muzrif Munas et al.International Journal of…2022
Obstetric Violence in Spain (Part III)
Open AccessDesirée Mena‐Tudela, Susana Iglesias-Casás et al.International Journal of…2021
Obstetric Violence as an Infringement on Basic Bioethical Principles. Reflections Inspired by Focus Groups with Midwives
Open AccessJúlia Martín Badia, Noemí Obregón Gutiérrez et al.International Journal of…2021
As long as you are married you cannot protect yourself against syphilis”
Open AccessAmanda P Miller, Stephen Mugamba et al.BMC Public Health2026
Female Genital Mutilation/Cutting among Somali Women in the U.S. State of Arizona
Open AccessGeorgia J Michlig, Nicole Warren et al.International Journal of…2021
Perinatal care in Sars-CoV-2 infected women
Open AccessEdoardo Corsi Decenti, Michele Antonio Salvatore et al.BMC Public Health2023
Respectful Maternity Care in the United States—Characterizing Inequities Experienced by Birthing People
Open AccessSuha Patel, Suha J Patel et al.Maternal and Child Health Journal2024
Mistreatment of Women during Childbirth and Associated Factors in Northern West Bank, Palestine
Open AccessIbtesam Medhat Mohamad Dwekat, Tengku Alina Tengku Ismail et al.International Journal of…2022
Assessing respectful maternity care in a fragile, conflict-affected context
Open AccessSheena Currie, Laila Natiq et al.Health Care For Women International2021
Improving apgar scores and reducing perineal injuries through midwife-led quality improvements
Open AccessJohanna Blomgren, Michael B Wells et al.BMC Public Health2025
Continuous Labor Support and Person-Centered Maternity Care
Open AccessGift Kiti, Ndola Prata et al.Maternal and Child Health Journal2021
Risk Factors for Positive Appraisal of Mistreatment during Childbirth among Ethiopian Midwifery Students
Open AccessRena Bakker, Ephrem Daniel Sheferaw et al.International Journal of…2020
Violences obstétricales pendant l’accouchement
Lucile AbiolaRevue française d éthique appliquée2025
Effect of person-centered intervention on women’s knowledge and attitude towards obstetric violence during facility childbirth in southwest Ethiopia
Open AccessAyanos Taye, Tefera BelachewBMC Public Health2025
Intimate partner violence and maternal health services utilization
Open AccessJessica Leight, Nicholas WilsonBMC Public Health2021
Medical pluralism in maternal health-seeking behavior of rural women in Southern Ecuador
Jessica Arnold, Julia Flint et al.Health Care For Women International2019
Obstetric Violence in Spain (Part II)
Open AccessDesirée Mena‐Tudela, Susana Iglesias-Casás et al.International Journal of…2020
Providers’ Perceptions of Respectful Maternity Care and Enabling Conditions in a Regional Hospital
Open AccessSthembile P Zwane, Lawrence ChaukeInternational Journal of…2025
Women’s Experience of Disrespect and Abuse during Institutional Delivery in Biratnagar, Nepal
Open AccessNarayani Paudel, Sunil Kumar Joshi et al.International Journal of…2021
Women who desire ‘natural childbirth’ in hospitals in a highly medicalized birth care system
Ema HrešanováHealth Care For Women International2024
Findings from a mixed-methods journey map study of barriers to family planning in western Kenya
Laura E Britton, Katherine Tumlinson et al.Health Care For Women International2022
Examining the Role of Quality of Institutionalized Healthcare on Maternal Mortality in the Dominican Republic
Open AccessMaria De Jesus, Nora Sullivan et al.International Journal of…2023
Striving for Respectful Maternity Care Everywhere
Open AccessRose L Molina, Suha Patel et al.Maternal and Child Health Journal2016
Postpartum depression symptoms
Open AccessBatoul Mattar, Niveen M E Abu-Rmeileh et al.BMC Public Health2024
Sociocultural aspects of risk to pregnant women during the 2013–2015 multinational Ebola virus outbreak in West Africa
A E Strong, Adrienne Strong et al.Health Care For Women International2016
Consistency of Delivery Mode Increases Chinese Mothers’ Maternal Satisfaction
Open AccessNan Zhang, Shanshan AnInternational Journal of…2022
Associations Between Mistreatment by a Provider during Childbirth and Maternal Health Complications in Uttar Pradesh, India
Open AccessAnita Raj, A K Dey et al.Maternal and Child Health Journal2017
Understanding Women’s Choices
Open AccessJackline Oluoch-Aridi, Francis Wafula et al.Maternal and Child Health Journal2021
A Multi-Methods Qualitative Study of the Delivery Care Experiences of Congolese Refugees in Uganda
Open AccessRuth Nara, Amanda Banura et al.Maternal and Child Health Journal2020
Sociocultural and health system determinants of maternal mortality in Ghana
Open AccessDonald Babamomba Amenah, Agani Afaya et al.BMC Public Health2026
“I felt like they were doing things to me, not with me”
Wendy A Adjei, Esther Apreku et al.Western Journal of Communication2026
Pattern of couples’ childbearing behaviors
Open AccessF Safdari Dehcheshmeh, Faranak Safdari-Dehcheshmeh et al.BMC Public Health2025
Equity-centred, nurse-led implementation of artificial intelligence in community maternal and child health nursing
Open AccessManar Fayez Alruwaili, Ugwu Okechukwu Paul-ChimaFrontiers in Public Health2026
Catching babies, carrying traditions
Open AccessEnid Kawala Kagoya, Proscovia Auma et al.Reproductive Health2026
Woman-centred care in conflict-affected and fragile states
Open AccessSalma A E Ahmed, Angela Dawson et al.Reproductive Health2026
Development and validation of the person-centered postnatal care scale for low- and middle-income countries
Open AccessPatience A Afulani, Anthony Gerald Akanlu et al.Reproductive Health2026
Childbirth experience and its relationship with postpartum depression and anxiety
Open AccessAlaa M Ismail, Tayseer Afifi et al.Reproductive Health2026
Expériences d’un cancer du sein avancé en Mauritanie
Dave Fearon, Hélène KaneL’Ouest Saharien2025
Barriers and interventions on the way to empower women through financial inclusion
Open AccessOmika Bhalla Saluja, Priyanka Singh et al.Humanities and Social Sciences…2023
Addressing obstetric violence
Open AccessAbena Asefuaba Yalley, Gabija Jarašiūnaitė-Fedosejeva et al.Frontiers in Public Health2024
Abuse and humiliation in the delivery room
Open AccessAbena Asefuaba Yalley, Dare Abioye et al.Frontiers in Public Health2023
Mothers’ experiences and perceptions about care provided during home deliveries in Alwa sub county, Kaberamaido district, Uganda– a qualitative study
Open AccessBenbella Dektar, Anita Normans Beckford et al.Frontiers in Public Health2023
Rethinking trust in the context of mistreatment of women during childbirth
Open AccessVeloshnee Govender, Stephanie M Topp et al.BMJ Global Health2022
Adolescent experiences of mistreatment during childbirth in health facilities
Open AccessTheresa Azonima Irinyenikan, Adeniyi Kolade Aderoba et al.BMJ Global Health2022
Comparing observed occurrence of mistreatment during childbirth with women’s self-report
Open AccessHedieh Mehrtash, Meghan A Bohren et al.BMJ Global Health2023
Labour companionship and women’s experiences of mistreatment during childbirth
Open AccessMamadou Diouldé Baldé, Khalidha Nasiri et al.BMJ Global Health2022
Health workforce governance for compassionate and respectful care
Open AccessGiorgio Cometto, Samuel Assegid et al.BMJ Global Health2022
Vaginal examinations and mistreatment of women during facility-based childbirth in health facilities
Open AccessKwame Adu-Bonsaffoh, Hedieh Mehrtash et al.BMJ Global Health2021
Dignity and respect in maternity care
Open AccessMary Ellen Stanton, Aparajita GogoiBMJ Global Health2022
Measuring experiences of facility-based care for pregnant women and newborns
Open AccessE Larson, Jigyasa Sharma et al.BMJ Global Health2020
Development of measures for assessing mistreatment of women during facility-based childbirth based on labour observations
Open AccessBlair O Berger, Donna M Strobino et al.BMJ Global Health2022
Mistreatment of women during childbirth and postpartum depression
Open AccessChris Guure, Philomina Akandity Aviisah et al.BMJ Global Health2023
Unveiling respectful maternity care as a way to address global inequities in maternal health
Open AccessAnteneh AsefaBMJ Global Health2021
Implementing maternal and newborn health quality of care standards in healthcare facilities to improve the adoption of respectful maternity care in Bangladesh, Ghana and Tanzania
Open AccessAlexander Manu, Veronica Pingray et al.BMJ Global Health2023
Toward improving respectful maternity care
Open AccessNasir Umar, Matthew Quaife et al.BMJ Global Health2020
Spatial patterns and inequalities in skilled birth attendance and caesarean delivery in sub-Saharan Africa
Open AccessFirew Tekle Bobo, Augustine Asante et al.BMJ Global Health2021
Factors that influence the uptake of postnatal care among adolescent girls
Open AccessDena Javadi, Emma Sacks et al.BMJ Global Health2023
To call or not to call
Open AccessNasir Umar, J Schellenberg et al.BMJ Global Health2022
Measuring experience of and satisfaction with newborn care
Open AccessNicole Minckas, Rashmi Kharel et al.BMJ Global Health2023
Women’s report of mistreatment during facility-based childbirth
Open AccessHannah H Leslie, Jigyasa Sharma et al.BMJ Global Health2022
Respectful care an added extra
Open AccessTina Lavender, Carol Bedwell et al.BMJ Global Health2021
Inequalities in use of hospitals for childbirth among rural women in sub-Saharan Africa
Open AccessManuela Straneo, Claudia Hanson et al.BMJ Global Health2024
Women’s experiences of mistreatment during childbirth and their satisfaction with care
Open AccessThae Maung Maung, Nwe Oo Mon et al.BMJ Global Health2022
Institutionalising maternal and newborn quality-of-care standards in Bangladesh, Ghana and Tanzania
Open AccessAlexander Manu, Sk Massum Billah et al.BMJ Global Health2022
Revisiting health systems to integrate perinatal mental health into maternal and child health services
Open AccessAnteneh Asefa, C Hanlon et al.BMJ Global Health2024
Exploration of obstetric violence against women
Open AccessDinh Duc Nguyen, Tien Thi My Chau et al.Griffith Law Review2026
Birth Justice. Die Bedeutung von Intersektionalität für die Begleitung von Schwangerschaft, Geburt und früher Elternschaft
Open AccessChristiane Winkler, Emine BabacÖsterreichische Zeitschrift für…2022
Trends and antecedents of inequalities in maternal healthcare coverage in four African countries
Open AccessDerek Asuman, Ama Pokuaa Fenny et al.Journal of International…2021
Racismo obstétrico em Portugal
Open AccessKarla Adriana Oliveira Da Costa, Laura Elisabete Figueiredo Brito et al.Forum Sociológico2022
Pregnancy, pain and pathology
Open AccessTeresa BaronJournal of Medical Ethics2025
The good parent
Open AccessAlessandra Minello, Concetta RussoFamily Relations2025
Participatory simulation training design
Open AccessSusanna R Cohen, Virginie Marchand et al.Evaluation and Program Planning2025
What factors are associated with forms of mistreatment during facility-based childbirth? A survey of referral health facilities in south-east Nigeria
Open AccessIjeoma Nkem Okedo‐Alex, Ifeyinwa Chizoba Akamike et al.Journal of Biosocial Science2022
Women’s narratives of disrespect and abuse during facility-based childbirth in Kolkata, India
Open AccessPiya Roy, M Sivakami et al.Journal of Biosocial Science2025

Unique citing works	286
Citations per year	26
Citation span	2015 - 2026 (12)
Citation velocity	current
Highly cited	Yes
Citation types	Neutral: 283