Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Managerial Strategies of Domination. Power in Soft Bureaucracies

Bibliographic Data

ID23318092
AuthorsDavid Courpasson (0000-0002-1961-0496, Ecole de Management, Lyon, France, corresponding author)
Year2000
Volume21
Issue1
Pages141-161
Publication date2000-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueOrganization Studies (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0170-8406 • E-ISSN: 1741-3044
PublisherSAGE Publications (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/0170840600211001
OpenAlexW2136287514
LanguageEN
Citations received128
References cited12

This paper discusses the emergence and reinforcement of organizational political regimes based on domination and centralization in French organizations. Domination and power are old concepts in organizational sociology, but the confrontation of two well-known approaches to politics in organizations, that of Weber and that of Crozier, suggests that an `archaic' notion such as domination is still very useful for understanding how business leaders `govern' organizations today. Based on empirical studies, the paper proposes that organizations should be seen as `soft bureaucracies', in which centralization and entrepreneurial forms of governance are combined. Thus, choosing a Weberian point of view, this paper simultaneously describes organizations as `structures of domination' and as `structures of legitimacy'. It defends the idea that, in spite of the success of the network form utopia, the re-emergence of bureaucracies is a sign that organizations are more and more politically centralized and governed.

Bureaucracy · Corporate governance · Economics · Epistemology · Legitimacy · Management · Organization studies · Political science · Politics · Power (physics) · Sign (mathematics) · Sociology · Utopia · Accounting and Organizational Management · Law · Management and Organizational Studies · Social Sciences and Governance

  • As modernas competênciasprofissionais como forma de dissimulação da antiga exploração do trabalhador

    Open Access•Cleverson Molinari Mello•Germinal Marxismo e Educação em…•2019

  • The Iron Cage and the Gaze

    Open Access•Mark Exworthy•Professions and Professionalism•2015

  • Organization as containment of acquisitive mimetic rivalry

    John F Desmond, John Desmond et al.•Culture and Organization•2003

  • Beyond decline

    Willem Tousijn•Health Sociology Review•2006

  • Medical dominance in a changing world

    Judith Allsop•Health Sociology Review•2006

  • Mediatization of Power

    Open Access•Anu Kantola•Nordicom review/NORDICOM review•2014

  • The effects of the economic crisis and managerialism in social work

    Open Access•Giovanni Cellini, Alice Scavarda•Alternativas Cuadernos de trabajo…•2020

  • A study of the operationalization of management controls in United Kingdom Private Finance Initiative contracts

    Open Access•Salman Ahmad, Ciarán Connolly et al.•Public Administration•2018

  • Leader, you first’

    Open Access•Zhongyuan Zhang, André Spicer•Human Relations•2014

  • From gardeners to revolutionaries

    Open Access•Anu Kantola•Journalism•2012

  • Control and Dignity in Professional, Manual and Service-Sector Employment

    Open Access•Martha Crowley•Organization Studies•2012

  • Overview Of Public Policy

    Robert E Goodin, Robert Goodin et al.•The Oxford handbook of political…•2013

  • Organizational capacities for health promotion implementation

    Open Access•Florian Röthlin, Hermann Schmied et al.•Health Promotion International•2015

  • Decoding Organization

    Christopher Grey•Decoding Organization•2012

  • China’s capitalist transformation

    Open Access•Yuan Li•China's Capitalist Transformation•2023

  • Norbert Elias's Impact on Organization Studies

    Ad Van Iterson•The Oxford handbook of sociology…•2009

  • The British Regulatory State

    Michael Moran•The British regulatory state•2003

  • Knowledge, Higher Education, and the New Managerialism

    Rosemary Deem, Sam Hillyard et al.•Knowledge, Higher Education, and…•2007

  • Formal and Informal Hierarchy in Different Types of Organization

    Open Access•Thomas Diefenbach, John A A Sillince•Organization Studies•2011

  • Managing Expert Knowledge

    Open Access•J Waring, Graeme Currie•Organization Studies•2009

  • Power in Management and Organization Science

    Peter Fleming, André Spicer•Academy of Management Annals•2014

  • Personal Branding and Identity Norms in the Popular Business Press

    Open Access•Steven Peter Valla, Steven P Vallas et al.•Organization Studies•2015

  • Who Sustains Whose Development? Sustainable Development and the Reinvention of Nature

    Open Access•Subhabrata Bobby Banerjee•Organization Studies•2003

  • Empires, Federated Arrangements, and Kingdoms

    Open Access•Karen Barkey, F Godart et al.•Organization Studies•2013

  • Machine justice

    Rik Peeters, Marc Schuilenburg•Information Polity•2018

  • Why do Social Workers Leave? A Moderated Mediation of Professionalism, Job Satisfaction, and Managerialism

    Open Access•Ziyu Liu, Hung Wong et al.•International Journal of…•2022

  • Pathways to Power

    Open Access•Morag Maclean, Mairi Maclean et al.•Organization Studies•2014

  • Reclaiming critique

    Muhammad Ifan Fadillah, Edi Suryadi et al.•Qualitative Research in…•2026

  • Spacing Resistance in a Business School Relocation

    Ari Kuismin, Janne Tienari et al.•Academy of Management Learning &…•2026

  • Management

    Open Access•Stewart Clegg, Stewart R Clegg•The Blackwell Encyclopedia of…•2019

  • Re-Imagining Leadership Roles beyond the Shadow of Bureaucracy

    Open Access•Lisa C Ehrich, Fenwick W English•Education Sciences•2024

  • The Impact of Structure and Corporate Ideology on Leader–Follower Relations in the Bureaucratic Organization

    Open Access•Konstantinos Kakavelakis, Timothy James Edwards•Journal of Business Ethics•2022

  • Clinical governance and governmentality

    Rob Flynn•Health Risk & Society•2002

  • On ‘risk work’

    Tom Horlick-Jones, Tom Horlick‐Jones•Health Risk & Society•2005

  • Compassion, power and organization

    Ace Volkmann Simpson, S R Clegg et al.•Journal of Political Power•2013

  • Governing spaces

    Open Access•Pam Carter•Critical Policy Studies•2016

  • Gender and the production of elites in the Nordic countries

    Open Access•Jorid Hovden, Elin Kvande et al.•Gender in Management An…•2011

  • The rise of charismatic authority styles in corporate capitalism

    Anu Kantola•Journal of Power•2009

  • Towards a Sociology of Disclosure

    Open Access•Jonathan Gabe, Mark Exworthy et al.•Sociology Compass•2012

  • Does personalization of officeholders undermine the legitimacy of the office? On perceptions of objectivity in legal decisionmaking

    Open Access•Ori Aronson, Julia Elad-Strenger et al.•Regulation & Governance•2022

  • Historicising knowledge-intensive organizations

    Christopher Grey, Andrew Sturdy•Management & Organizational History•2009

  • The Medical Council in Belgian hospitals

    Gregory Gourdin, Rita Schepers•Management & Organizational History•2011

  • Stability and change in managerial elites

    Ragnhild Kvålshaugen, Rolv Petter Amdam•Management & Organizational History•2014

  • Lessons for leaders

    Open Access•Miguel Pina E Cunha, Stewart Clegg et al.•Leadership•2013

  • Combating infections at Maine Medical Center

    Open Access•Christer Lindberg, Marguerite Schneider•Leadership•2013

  • The grammar of governance

    Jane Mulderrig•Critical Discourse Studies•2011

  • Revisiting Organizational Politics

    Open Access•Frank Fischer•Policy and Society•2004

  • The Dutch way of New Public Management

    Open Access•Jody Enders, Don F Westerheijden et al.•Policy and Society•2014

  • Branded revolutionaries

    Open Access•Anu Kantola•European Journal of Cultural…•2013

  • Risk-based regulation and reforms to fitness to practise tribunals in the United Kingdom

    J M Chamberlain•Health Risk & Society•2016

  • Liberalist Fantasies

    Open Access•Christian De Cock, Steffen Böhm•Organization•2007

  • Understanding Enterprise

    Open Access•Graeme Salaman, Jennifer Storey et al.•Organization•2008

  • Dissolving the Iron Cages? Tocqueville, Michels, Bureaucracy and the Perpetuation of Elite Power

    Open Access•David Courpasson, Stewart Clegg•Organization•2006

  • Managers as consultants

    Open Access•Andrew Sturdy, C Wright et al.•Organization•2016

  • Back to the (invisible) Académie ? The organization of poetry as a “pure” art form

    Open Access•Sébastien Dubois•Organization•2022

  • Resisting the ‘protest business’

    Open Access•Alexander Hensby, Joanne Sibthorpe et al.•Organization•2012

  • Introduction

    Open Access•David Courpasson, Mike Reed•Organization•2004

  • The naked manager

    Open Access•Bent Sørensen, Bent Meier Sørensen et al.•Organization•2015

  • Going Public

    Open Access•Maxine Robertson, Jacky Swan•Organization•2004

  • Spaces of possibilities

    Open Access•George Kokkinidis•Organization•2015

  • Against ‘Enterprise’ (but not against ‘enterprise’, for that would make no sense)

    Open Access•Paul Du Gay•Organization•2004

  • The Best and the Brightest

    Open Access•Mats Alvesson, Maxine Robertson•Organization•2006

  • Giddens à la Carte? Appraising empirical applications of Structuration Theory in management and organization studies

    Frank Den Hond, F K Boersma et al.•Journal of Political Power•2012

  • The impact of top management team power centralization on firm performance under varying industry conditions

    Dapeng Liang, Hengyi Shen et al.•Cross Cultural & Strategic…•2025

  • Real Virtuality

    Open Access•Emil A Røyrvik, Marianne Brodersen•Culture Unbound Journal of…•2013

  • Intersecting Gender, Race, and Class in the Labor of Beauty

    Open Access•Sepideh Borzoo•Sociology Compass•2025

  • Cages in Tandem

    Open Access•Dan Kärreman, Mats Alvesson•Organization•2004

  • Strategic (dis)obedience

    Open Access•Salvador Barragan, Murat Şakir Eroğul et al.•Gender Work and Organization•2018

  • A subtle governance

    Open Access•Rod Sheaff, Anne Rogers et al.•Sociology of Health & Illness•2003

  • Modernisation as a professionalising strategy

    Open Access•John Green, Judith Green et al.•Sociology of Health & Illness•2011

  • Dynamics between doctors and managers in the Italian National Health Care System

    Open Access•Giovanna Vicarelli, Giovanna M Vicarelli et al.•Sociology of Health & Illness•2017

  • Managerialism in the Australian public health sector

    Open Access•John Germov•Sociology of Health & Illness•2005

  • Professional autonomy and surveillance

    Open Access•Mark Exworthy, Jonathan Gabe et al.•Sociology of Health & Illness•2019

  • Soft governance, restratification and the 2004 general medical services contract

    Open Access•Suzanne Grant, Adele Ring et al.•Sociology of Health & Illness•2015

  • Soft authority

    Open Access•Paul Crawford, Brian Brown•Sociology of Health & Illness•2008

  • Managerialism and the Military

    Open Access•Sofia K Ledberg, Shirin Ahlbäck Öberg et al.•Armed Forces & Society•2022

  • Modalities of power

    Open Access•Syb Kuijper, Martijn Felder et al.•Journal of Political Power•2026

  • The Construction of Risk Management Credibility Within Corporate Boardrooms

    Yves Gendron, Marion Brivot et al.•European Accounting Review•2016

  • Competition as a catalyst for collaboration

    Open Access•Anna Kosmützky•Higher Education•2026

  • Gender, the Labor Process and Dignity at Work

    M Crowley, Michael F Crowley•Social Forces•2013

  • New Public Management in Public Sector Organizations

    Open Access•Thomas Diefenbach•Public Administration•2009

  • Power, Rationality and Legitimacy in Public Organizations

    Open Access•Ray Gordon, Martin Kornberger et al.•Public Administration•2009

  • Strategic Bureaucracy

    Open Access•Peter Woelert, Bjørn Stensaker et al.•Minerva•2024

  • An Innovative strategy to re-build trust in educational governance systems after 40 years of English destabilising rapid reforms

    Аlison Taysum•Journal of Educational…•2019

  • Power as an enabling force

    Open Access•Steven van Baarle, Annelies Bobelyn et al.•Human Relations•2022

  • The impact of management on medical professionalism

    Open Access•Dino Numerato, Domenico Salvatore et al.•Sociology of Health & Illness•2012

  • Doing the right thing? HRM and the angry knowledge worker

    Open Access•Jean Cushen, Paul Thompson•New Technology Work and Employment•2012

  • Rhetorics of regulation in education after the global economic crisis

    David Hartley•Journal of Education Policy•2010

  • Media Between Power and Empowerment

    Leopoldina Fortunati•The Information Society•2014

  • The State and Democracy After New Public Management

    D D Navarra, Tony Cornford•The Information Society•2012

  • Governmentality by Network in English Primary Healthcare

    Open Access•Rod Sheaff, Martin Marshall et al.•Social Policy and Administration•2004

  • On guilt and the depoliticization of downsizing practices

    Open Access•Nikolaos Karfakis, George Kokkinidis•International Journal of…•2019

  • Power dynamics in organizational change

    Open Access•Emmanuel Mastio, Ken Dovey•International Journal of…•2019

  • The shock of the new? Democratic narratives and political agency

    Stephen Driver, Alexander Hensby et al.•Policy Studies•2012

  • Who Participates in Public Participation? The Exclusionary Effects of Inclusionary Efforts

    Open Access•Ludo Glimmerveen, Sierk Ybema et al.•Administration & Society•2022

  • Der Fussballverein zwischen e.V. und Kapitalgesellschaft

    Open Access•Uwe Wilkesmann, Doris Blutner et al.•KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für…•2002

  • Hacking work

    Open Access•Peter Bloom, Martyna Śliwa•Human Relations•2022

  • The indeterminacy of ‘temporariness’

    Open Access•Jonathan Morris, Catherine Farrell et al.•Human Relations•2016

  • Relationship building in small firms

    Open Access•Elizabeth Chell, Paul Tracey•Human Relations•2005

  • Ethics, alterity and the rationality of leadership justice

    Open Access•Carl Rhodes•Human Relations•2012

  • The iron cage revisited institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields

    P Dimaggio, Paul J Dimaggio et al.•Economics meets sociology in…•2004

  • Economy and Society

    Claus Wittich, Guenther Roth et al.•Economy and Society•2013

  • Patterns of Industrial Bureaucracy

    Alvin W Gouldner•Patterns of Industrial Bureaucracy•1954

  • Complex organizations

    Charles Perrow•Complex organizations•1986

  • L'action contrainte

    David Courpasson•L' Action contrainte•2000

  • Too Much, Too Little and Too Often

    Open Access•Vincent Fournier, Valérie Fournier et al.•Organization•1999

  • The Sage Handbook of Organization Studies

    Stewart Clegg, C Hardy et al.•The SAGE Handbook of Organization…•2006

  • Frameworks of Power

    Stewart Clegg•Frameworks of power•1989

  • Consumption and Identity at Work

    Paul Du Gay•Consumption and identity at work•1996

  • The Iron Cage Revisited

    P Dimaggio, Paul J Dimaggio et al.•American Sociological Review•1983

Unique citing works128
Citations per year5,12
Citation span2001 - 2026 (26)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 119

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae