Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Problems of projection

Extensions

Bibliographic Data

ID23322883
AuthorsNoam Chomsky (0000-0002-3632-2461, corresponding author)
Year2015
Pages3-16
Publication date2015-08-27
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeCHAPTER
VenueStructures, strategies and beyond (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherJohn Benjamins Publishing Company (PUBLISHER • NL)
DOI10.1075/la.223.01cho
OpenAlexW4238616143
ISBN9789027257062
LanguageEN
Citations received76
References cited20

I presuppose here Chomsky (2013), including separation of projection (labeling) from the principles of construction of expressions. Assume further that for interpretation, syntactic objects must be labeled. It follows that Internal Merge is successive-cyclic leading to a criterial position, and is forced to ensure labeling. A further question is what Rizzi calls “the halting problem.” A simple solution is outlined. Special properties of subjects of CP are discussed: the Extended Projection Principle (EPP) and the Empty Category Principle (ECP). These can be unified under the labeling theory assumed, and the analysis is extended to the second phase v*P, where the object that is raised is in a structural position analogous to subjects of CP. Other outstanding questions also fall into place.

Algorithm · Calculus (dental) · Epistemology · Information retrieval · Interpretation (philosophy) · Merge (version control) · Object (grammar) · Position (finance) · Programming language · Projection (relational algebra) · Simple (philosophy) · Artificial Intelligence · Computer Science · Historical Linguistics and Language Studies · Mathematics · Natural Language Processing Techniques · Philosophy · Syntax, Semantics, Linguistic Variation

  • DP, NP, or neither? Contours of an unresolved debate

    Open Access•Andreas Blümel, Anke Holler•Glossa a journal of general…•2021

  • EPP, Labeling and Word Order in Arabic

    Open Access•Ameen Alahdal•International Journal of English…•2021

  • Differential object marking in inanimate objects in Spanish

    Open Access•Ricardo Corzo Ramirez, Rafael Camacho•Borealis – An International…•2023

  • The morphosyntax of exhaustive focus

    Open Access•Henry Zamchang Fominyam, Henry Fominyam et al.•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2017

  • Uma perspectiva etiológica sobre a função natural da Faculdade da Linguagem / An etiological perspective on the natural function of the Faculty of Language

    Open Access•Francisco Iokleyton de Araujo Matos•Revista de Estudos da Linguagem•2019

  • Proleptic PPs are arguments

    Erik Zyman•The Linguistic Review•2022

  • Left Periphery of the Clause

    Open Access•Laura Rizzi, Luigi Rizzi et al.•The Wiley Blackwell Companion to…•2017

  • VOS Puzzle

    Open Access•Nicholas Sobin, S Regina Zavala et al.•Borealis – An International…•2021

  • If agreement is pronominal there is no pro-drop

    Open Access•Luis Miguel García López, Luis López•Borealis – An International…•2025

  • Spanish null subjects

    Open Access•Andrés Fábregas•Borealis – An International…•2025

  • On Subject & Negative Positioning in Spanish

    Open Access•Nicholas Sobin, Natalia Mazzaro•Borealis – An International…•2026

  • A new look at an old question

    M Rita Manzini, Anna Roussou•Language Typology and Universals•2025

  • On the Acquisition of French (Null) Subjects and (In)Definiteness

    Laia Arnaus Gil, Johanna Stahnke et al.•Probus•2021

  • Form Copy, Agree and Clitics

    Open Access•Ian Roberts•Probus•2024

  • The structure of wh-exclamatives in Jordanian Arabic and beyond

    Hussein Al-Bataineh•Acta Linguistica Hafniensia•2023

  • Conjoining meanings without losing our heads

    Open Access•John Collins•Mind & Language•2020

  • VP copying interacting with verum focus

    Open Access•Ningxian Li•Folia Linguistica•2026

  • Theoretical A‐grammatism

    Open Access•Claudia Pañeda, Gimena Lorenzo•Studia Linguistica•2025

  • On the Deduction of the EPP from Labeling

    Open Access•Manabu Mizuguchi•Studia Linguistica•2022

  • Bottom Copy Pronunciation in Japanese Passives

    Open Access•Jun Abe•Studia Linguistica•2024

  • Expletive Constructions and Agreement in Labeling Theory

    Open Access•Jason Ginsburg•Studia Linguistica•2026

  • Kind‐Level Predicates of Events Inside Another Predication☆

    Open Access•Niina Ning Zhang•Studia Linguistica•2022

  • Satisfying the composite probe on the Topic head in Mandarin Chinese

    Open Access•Chao-Ting Tim Chou•Studia Linguistica•2025

  • On the Syntax of Vp Dislocation in Mandarin

    Open Access•Wei-Cherng Sam Jheng•Studia Linguistica•2023

  • Deriving Latin Ablative Absolute

    Open Access•Jarosław Jakielaszek•Studia Linguistica•2025

  • Labeling Defective T

    Open Access•Yoshio Sugimoto•Studia Linguistica•2021

  • External Set‐Merge of Heads and Composite Probing

    Open Access•Chao-Ting Tim Chou, Chao‐ting Tim Chou•Studia Linguistica•2020

  • Latin Dominant Participles

    Open Access•Jarosław Jakielaszek•Studia Linguistica•2021

  • Negation in Albanian

    Open Access•Leonardo M Savoia•Roczniki Humanistyczne•2025

  • A refinement of the analysis of the resultative V -de construction in Mandarin Chinese

    Yehao Hu, Gong Cheng•Linguistics Vanguard•2024

  • Acceleration and delay in bilingual, trilingual and multilingual German-Romance children

    Open Access•Laia Arnaus Gil, Natascha Müller•Linguistic Approaches to…•2020

  • Raising out of Finite Clauses (Hyperraising)

    Open Access•Erik Zyman•Annual Review of Linguistics•2022

  • Successive Cyclicity and the Syntax of Long-Distance Dependencies

    Coppe Van Urk•Annual Review of Linguistics•2019

  • Clause size, cross-clausal dependencies, and the left periphery

    Open Access•Peter Grishin•The Canadian Journal of…•2026

  • On finiteness and modal mismatches under clausal ellipsis in Japanese

    Open Access•Kensuke Takita•Journal of East Asian Linguistics•2025

  • Evolutionary monkey oscillomics

    Elliot Murphy•Theoretical Linguistics•2016

  • Are uninterpretable features vulnerable

    Elly Van Gelderen•Theoretical Linguistics•2019

  • On Minimal Yield and Form Copy

    Mamoru Saito•The Linguistic Review•2024

  • A multi-dimensional derivation model under the free-Merge system

    Open Access•Victor Junnan Pan, Yuqiao Du•The Linguistic Review•2024

  • Projection without agreement

    Ángel J Gallego•The Linguistic Review•2018

  • The third way

    Adrian Stegovec•The Linguistic Review•2024

  • Large-scale pied-piping in the labeling theory and conditions on weak heads

    Hiromune Oda•The Linguistic Review•2024

  • A categorisation solution to the incompleteness puzzle in Mandarin

    Chen Wang, Wang Chen•The Linguistic Review•2024

  • Labeling by type

    Alain Rouveret•The Linguistic Review•2024

  • Negative concord by phase

    M Rita Manzini, Diego Pescarini•The Linguistic Review•2024

  • Quotation as a challenge for feature-driven phases

    Jan Wiślicki•The Linguistic Review•2018

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Victor Junnan Pan, Mamoru Saito et al.•The Linguistic Review•2024

  • A phase-based account of agreement asymmetry in Arabic

    Open Access•Ameen Alahdal, Jeroen Van De Weijer•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2021

  • A distinctness approach to clitic combinations in Romance

    María Pilar Colomina, María Colomina•Studies in Hispanic and Lusophone…•2020

  • A phase-theoretic approach to cliticization in Romance

    Ángel J Gallego•Studies in Hispanic and Lusophone…•2016

  • Animacy in the Brazilian Portuguese null object

    Ricardo Corzo Ramirez•Studies in Hispanic and Lusophone…•2025

  • Scrambling in the nominal domain

    Open Access•Qiushi Chen•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2026

  • On the syntactic autonomy of theme vowels

    Open Access•Erik Zyman•Journal of Linguistics•2026

  • Phonological Features

    Open Access•Qilin Tian•SAGE Open•2024

  • A syntactic account of auxiliary selection in French

    Open Access•Marc Olivier•Probus•2025

  • French clausal ellipsis

    Open Access•J-Marc Authier, J ­Marc Authier•Probus•2025

  • Restructuring and focus in Japanese

    Mina Sugimura, Yoichi Miyamoto•Journal of Japanese Linguistics•2025

  • Taking case out of the Person-Case Constraint

    Open Access•Adrian Stegovec•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2020

  • Predicate fronting in Yiddish and conditions on multiple copy Spell-Out

    Open Access•Isaac L Bleaman•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2022

  • Light heads and predicate formation

    Open Access•Jan Wiślicki•Linguistics•2021

  • Pragmatic competence, autistic language use and the basic properties of human language

    Open Access•Tiaoyuan Mao•Journal for the Theory of Social…•2023

  • The Setting of the Null Subject Parameters across (Non-)Null-Subject Languages

    Open Access•Karina Gomes Bertolino, Karina Bertolino•Languages•2024

  • Remark on theEPPin Labeling Theory

    Open Access•Ángel J Gallego•Syntax•2017

  • ɸ-Features at the Syntax-Semantics Interface

    Ivona Kučerová•Linguistic Inquiry•2018

  • Labeling without Weak Heads

    Open Access•Norimasa Hayashi•Syntax•2020

  • Labeling nominal phrases in Mandarin Chinese

    Open Access•Xiangyu Li, Victor Junnan Pan•Linguistic Variation•2025

  • Revisiting diachronic change in the nominal domain from Latin to modern Romance

    Open Access•Andreas Blümel•Linguistic Variation•2025

  • Simplifications and extensions of the Miracle Creed

    Open Access•Hisatsugu Kitahara, T Daniel Seely•Linguistic Variation•2025

  • On (partially) quirky subjects, numeral subjects, and subject-oriented anaphor binding

    Open Access•Zeljko Boskovic•Linguistic Variation•2025

  • Revisiting the freezing principle

    Open Access•Nobu Goto, Toru Ishii•Linguistic Variation•2025

  • On Movement out of Moved Elements, Labels, and Phases

    Zeljko Boskovic•Linguistic Inquiry•2018

  • Just pair-merge

    Open Access•Ken Safir•Syntax•2024

  • A Restriction on Recursion

    Open Access•Marcel Den Dikken, Éva Dékány•Syntax•2018

  • Parenthetical niching

    Open Access•Andrew Mcinnerney•Syntax•2022

  • Reconsidering the Optionality of Raising in Japanese Exceptional-Case-Marking Constructions

    Open Access•Megumi Takahashi•Syntax•2021

  • Directing Syntactic Traffic

    Open Access•Nicholas Sobin•Syntax•2020

  • Structuring Sense Volume I

    Hagit Borer•In name only•2005

  • Structuring Sense

    Hagit Borer•Structuring Sense Vol. III•2013

  • Issues in Italian Syntax

    Laura Rizzi, Luigi Rizzi•Issues in Italian Syntax•1982

  • The variable status of comp-trace phenomena

    Open Access•Nicholas Sobin•Natural Language and Linguistic…•1987

  • The Comp-trace effect, the adverb effect and minimal CP

    Open Access•Nicholas Sobin•Journal of Linguistics•2002

  • The mystery of language evolution

    Open Access•Marc D Hauser, Charles Yang et al.•Frontiers in Psychology•2014

  • Problems of projection

    Open Access•Noam Chomsky•Lingua•2013

  • Architecture and Blocking

    David Embick, Alec Marantz•Linguistic Inquiry•2008

Unique citing works76
Citations per year7,6
Citation span2016 - 2026 (11)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 71

Tools

Open DOILibgen
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae