Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Bringing the Social Back in

A Critique of the Biomedicalization of Dementia

Bibliographic Data

ID23327147
AuthorsKyle A Lyman (0000-0002-3309-7211, University of Southern California, corresponding author)
Year1989
Volume29
Issue5
Pages597-605
Publication date1989-10-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueThe Gerontologist (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0016-9013 • E-ISSN: 1758-5341
PublisherOxford University Press (OUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1093/geront/29.5.597
PMID2689293
OpenAlexW2093969649
LanguageEN
Citations received84

This paper presents the argument that social gerontologists have adopted a biomedical model of senile dementia, neglecting social factors involved in the definition and interpretation of brain disease and in the experience of dementing illness. This biomedical model is critiqued, including the definition of pathology, the attribution of behavioral changes to disease stages, and the legitimation of medical control over persons with dementing illnesses.

Argument (complex analysis) · Attribution · Dementia · Disease · Interpretation (philosophy) · Legitimation · Linguistics · Pathology · Political science · Psychiatry · Senile dementia · Medicine · Mental Health and Psychiatry · Philosophy · Psychology · Social Psychology · Gerontology

  • Thinking About Dementia

    A Leibing, L Cohen•Thinking About Dementia•2006

  • Critical Dementia Studies

    Open Access•Richard Ward, Linn J Sandberg•Critical Dementia Studies•2023

  • International Perspectives on Aging

    George J Alexander•International Perspectives on Aging•1992

  • Ethnoculturally-profiled care

    Open Access•Eleonor Antelius, Charlotta Plejert•Anthropology & Aging•2023

  • Theorizing Beta Thalassemia Major

    Open Access•Muhammad Abo ul Hassan Rashid, Saif–ur-Rehman Saif Abbasi et al.•International and Multidisciplinary…•2020

  • Vol. 9, Num. 1 - Full Issue

    Open Access•Tinka Tabea Schubert•International and Multidisciplinary…•2020

  • Dementia, disability rights and disablism

    Carol Thomas, Christine Milligan•Disability & Society•2017

  • Informal Caregiving to Aging Family Members

    Alexis J Walker, Clara C Pratt et al.•Family Relations•1995

  • Our Own Little Language

    A Vittoria, Anne K Vittoria•Symbolic Interaction•1999

  • Beyond V40.31

    Open Access•Olga Solomon, Mary C Lawlor et al.•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•2018

  • Senility And Irony's Age

    Open Access•L Cohen•Social Analysis•2003

  • Like He's a Kid

    Aaron T Seaman•Medical Anthropology•2020

  • Ethnographic reflections on selfhood, embodiment and Alzheimer's disease

    Open Access•Pia Kontos, Pia C Kontos•Ageing and Society•2004

  • The social and political context of formal dementia care provision

    Open Access•Amy Innes, Anthea Innes•Ageing and Society•2002

  • Researching dementia

    Open Access•John Bond, Lynne Corner•Ageing and Society•2001

  • Concluding narratives of a career with dementia

    Open Access•Gillian Mccolgan, James Valentine et al.•Ageing and Society•2000

  • Teaching Health Care and Aging

    Dale J Jaffe•Teaching Sociology•1990

  • Language Socialization Among Persons with Dementia and Their Caregivers

    Open Access•Pamela A Saunders, Pâmela Saunders•Language Socialization•2017

  • Embodied selfhood in Alzheimer's disease

    Open Access•Pia Kontos, Pia C Kontos•Dementia•2005

  • Dementia, Treatment Decisions, and the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons With Disabilities. A New Framework for Old Problems

    Open Access•Kevin De Sabbata•Frontiers in Psychiatry•2020

  • Dementia and Dementia Care

    Open Access•Phyllis Braudy Harris•Sociology Compass•2010

  • Battling the “Invincible Predator”

    Open Access•Linda Simon•The Journal of American Culture•2014

  • What Does it Mean to Listen to People with Dementia

    David Reid, Tony Ryan et al.•Disability & Society•2001

  • The medicalization of dementia

    Open Access•John Bond•Journal of Aging Studies•1992

  • Transgressions and sickness in old age

    Open Access•Elizabeth J Herskovits, Linda S Mitteness•Journal of Aging Studies•1994

  • A paradox of medicalization

    Open Access•Baila Miller, Michael Glasser et al.•Journal of Aging Studies•1992

  • Multi-species dementia studies

    Open Access•Nicholas Jenkins, Richard Gorman et al.•Journal of Aging Studies•2021

  • Forced continuity

    Open Access•Tobias Haeusermann•Journal of Aging Studies•2019

  • Managing disability and enjoying life

    Open Access•Renée L Beard, Jenny Knauss et al.•Journal of Aging Studies•2009

  • Toward a political model of dementia

    Open Access•Susan M Behuniak•Journal of Aging Studies•2010

  • The controversial promises of cholinesterase inhibitors for Alzheimer's disease and related dementias

    Open Access•Ashley A Berard, André Smith et al.•Journal of Aging Studies•2011

  • Interpreting the “hidden program” of a place

    Open Access•Keith Diaz Moore•Journal of Aging Studies•2004

  • A man's gotta do what a man's gotta do

    Open Access•Tapio Kirsi, Antti Hervonen et al.•Journal of Aging Studies•2000

  • From ‘not a big deal’ to ‘hellish’

    Open Access•Wendy Hulko•Journal of Aging Studies•2009

  • Living and loving with dementia

    Open Access•Jeanne Hayes, Craig Boylstein et al.•Journal of Aging Studies•2008

  • Painting as a form of Material Thinking

    Open Access•Megan Wyatt, Paula Boddington•Journal of Aging Studies•2025

  • Alzheimer's disease and senile dementia, 1885–1920

    Open Access•Martha Holstein•Journal of Aging Studies•1997

  • Experiencing Leisure on a Cognitive Support Unit

    Anne‐Marie Sullivan, Anne-Marie Sullivan et al.•Loisir et Société / Society and…•2002

  • Death in Advance? A critique of the “Zombification” of people with dementia

    Open Access•Mark Schweda, Karin R Jongsma et al.•History & Philosophy of the Life…•2022

  • Social Care Interface in Early-Stage Dementia

    Open Access•Normand Carpentier, Marie-Pascal Pomey et al.•Journal of Aging and Health•2008

  • The painterly hand

    Open Access•Pia Kontos, Pia C Kontos•Journal of Aging Studies•2003

  • Dementia and migration

    Open Access•Anders Næ, Anders Næss et al.•Ageing and Society•2014

  • The living dead? The construction of people with Alzheimer's disease as zombies

    Open Access•Susan M Behuniak•Ageing and Society•2010

  • Dichotomising dementia

    Open Access•Patricia Mcparland, Fiona Kelly et al.•Sociology of Health & Illness•2017

  • Making the best you can of it

    Open Access•Hazel Macrae•Sociology of Health & Illness•2008

  • Critical condition

    Ryan Prout•Journal of Iberian & Latin…•2012

  • Where Person-Centered Care Falls Short

    Open Access•Menal Ahmad, Anne-Mei The•Social Sciences•2026

  • The Evolving Classification of Dementia

    Open Access•Daniel R George, P J Whitehouse et al.•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•2011

  • Understanding the Diabetic Body-Self

    Open Access•J K Montez, Tracy X Karner•Qualitative Health Research•2005

  • Constructing Alzheimer's

    Open Access•W Ladson Hinton, Sue Levkoff et al.•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•1999

  • The Experience of Dementia in China

    Open Access•Charlotte Ikels•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•1998

  • Demenzfreundliche Kommunen in Deutschland und England – ein Blick auf mögliche Perspektiven

    Hermann Brandenburg, Matthias Brünett•Sozialer Fortschritt•2014

  • A Disembodied Dementia

    Open Access•Sarah B Kovan, Derek R Soled•Journal of Medical Humanities•2023

  • Cross-Cultural Research on Alzheimer's Disease

    Open Access•Ashley A Berard, André Smith•Transcultural Psychiatric…•1996

  • Perceptions of dementia, caregiving, and help-seeking among recent Vietnamese immigrants

    Open Access•Kathryn L Braun, Jeanette C Takamura et al.•Journal of Cross-Cultural…•1996

  • Sociocultural insights on dementia care-giving in Arab and Muslim communities

    Open Access•Suzanne Hammad, Suhad Daher-Nashif et al.•Ageing and Society•2024

  • In the moment with music

    Open Access•Robyn Dowlen, John Keady et al.•Ageing and Society•2022

  • The Politics of Caregiving

    Open Access•John Bond•Ageing and Society•1992

  • The épreuve of ageing with Alzheimer's disease

    Open Access•Vincent Caradec, Aline Chamahian•Ageing and Society•2017

  • The Mask of Dementia

    Open Access•Hava Golander, A E Raz•Ageing and Society•1996

  • Being’ and ‘doing’ well in the moment

    Open Access•Meghánn Catherine Ward, Christine Milligan et al.•Area•2024

  • Old Age, Disease, and the Discourse on Risk

    Open Access•Sharon R Kaufman•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•1994

  • Biomedicalization

    Open Access•Adele E Clarke, Laura Mamo et al.•American Sociological Review•2003

  • Deceptive Practices in Managing a Family Member with Alzheimer's Disease

    Open Access•Nancy Sue Blum•Symbolic Interaction•1994

  • Losing Selves

    Open Access•Tracy X Karner, Donna Bobbitt-Zeher et al.•Symbolic Interaction•2005

  • Liberating the wanderers

    Open Access•Johanna M Wigg•Sociology of Health & Illness•2010

  • Making sense of nonsense

    Open Access•Renée L Beard, Tara M Neary•Sociology of Health & Illness•2013

  • Ethnographic Research in Medical Sociology

    Open Access•Kathy Charmaz, Virginia Olesen•Sociological Methods & Research•1997

  • This is your home now

    Open Access•D Reed-Danahay•Qualitative Research•2001

  • Alzheimer's Disease Specialty Care Units and the Loss of Self

    Open Access•Date J Jaffe•Illness Crisis & Loss•1992

  • Processos De (Des)legitimação Linguístico-Cognitiva

    Open Access•Edwiges Maria Morato•Cadernos CEDES•2018

  • Developing a critical trans gerontology

    Open Access•Michael Toze•British Journal of Sociology•2019

  • Expressions of Personhood in Alzheimer's Disease

    Open Access•Pia Kontos, Pia C Kontos et al.•Qualitative Health Research•2007

  • Always One Step Behind

    Open Access•Tapio Kirsi, Antti Hervonen et al.•Health An Interdisciplinary…•2004

  • The process of self-report of impairment in clinical research

    Open Access•Mark Luborsky, Mark R Luborsky•Social Science & Medicine•1995

  • Responding to Symptoms of Alzheimer's Disease

    Open Access•Jeanne Hayes, Mary K Zimmerman et al.•Qualitative Health Research•2010

  • Transitions in cognitive status among the aged in Japan

    Open Access•Jersey Liang, Elaine Borawski-Clark et al.•Social Science & Medicine•1996

  • "The consequence of "doing nothing

    Open Access•Aaron T Seaman•Social Science & Medicine•2018

  • Repelling neoliberal world-making? How the ageing-dementia relation is reassembling the social

    Open Access•Joanna Latimer•The Sociological Review•2018

  • The neuropsychiatric biopolitics of dementia and its ethnicity problem

    Open Access•James Rupert Fletcher, Maria Zubair et al.•The Sociological Review•2022

  • Toward an Anthropology of Senility

    Open Access•L Cohen•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•1995

  • Struggling over Subjectivity

    Open Access•Elizabeth Herskovits, Elizabeth J Herskovits•Medical Anthropology Quarterly•1995

  • Does Digital Gaming Enable Healthy Aging for Community-Dwelling People With Dementia

    Open Access•Clare Cutler, Benjamin Hicks et al.•Games and Culture•2016

  • Towards a Code of Practice for Effective Communication With People With Dementing Illnesses

    Open Access•Tony Young, Christopher Manthorp•Journal of Language and Social…•2009

Unique citing works84
Citations per year2,33
Citation span1990 - 2026 (37)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 67

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae