Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Governing Climate Change Transnationally

Assessing the Evidence from a Database of Sixty Initiatives

Bibliographic Data

ID23337296
AuthorsHarriet Bulkeley (0000-0001-9912-5687, Durham University, corresponding author), Liliana B Andonova (0000-0002-4771-7936, Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies, corresponding author), Liliana Andonova (The Graduate University, Rue de Lausanne 132, 1201 Geneva, Switzerland), Karin Bäckstrand (0000-0002-8608-8888, Lund University, corresponding author), Michele Betsill (Colorado State University), Michele M Betsill (0000-0001-7090-904X, Colorado State University, corresponding author), Daniel Compagnon (0000-0001-5815-0384, Sciences Po Bordeaux, 11 Allée ausone, Domaine Universitaire, 33607 PESSAC Cedex, France, corresponding author), Rosaleen Duffy (School of Social Sciences, Arthur Lewis Building 4.026, The University of Manchester, Manchester M13 9PL, England), Rosaleen V Duffy (0000-0002-6779-7240, University of Manchester, corresponding author), Ans Kolk (0000-0001-5345-2965, Strategy and Marketing, University of Amsterdam Business School, Plantage Muidergracht 12, 1018 TV Amsterdam, The Netherlands, corresponding author), Matthew Hoffmann (0000-0002-9325-4186, University of Toronto, corresponding author), Dena Levy (0000-0001-9285-9610, University of Massachusetts Boston, corresponding author), David Levy (0000-0002-4044-8438, Department of Management and Marketing, University of Massachusetts, Boston, 100 Morrissey Boulevard, Boston, MA 02125-3393, USA), Peter Newell (0000-0002-5371-7668, Tyndall Centre, School of Environmental Sciences, University of East Anglia, Norwich NR4 7TJ, England, corresponding author), Tori Milledge (corresponding author), Marisa Paterson (0000-0002-0007-2229, University of Ottawa, corresponding author), Matthew Paterson (University of Ottawa), Philipp Pattberg (0000-0003-1136-7791, Department of Political Science, VU University Amsterdam, De Boelenaan 1081, 1081 HV Amsterdam, The Netherlands, corresponding author), Stacy D Vandeveer (0000-0001-5941-8020, University of New Hampshire, corresponding author), Stacy VanDeveer (University of New Hampshire)
Year2012
Volume30
Issue4
Pages591-612
Publication date2012-08-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEnvironment and Planning C Government and Policy (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0263-774X • E-ISSN: 1472-3425
PublisherSAGE Publications (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1068/c11126
OpenAlexW2145162648
LanguageEN
Citations received110
References cited40

With this paper we present an analysis of sixty transnational governance initiatives and assess the implications for our understanding of the roles of public and private actors, the legitimacy of governance ‘beyond’ the state, and the North–South dimensions of governing climate change. In the first part of the paper we examine the notion of transnational governance and its applicability in the climate change arena, reflecting on the history and emergence of transnational governance initiatives in this issue area and key areas of debate. In the second part of the paper we present the findings from the database and its analysis. Focusing on three core issues, the roles of public and private actors in governing transnationally, the functions that such initiatives perform, and the ways in which accountability for governing global environmental issues might be achieved, we suggest that significant distinctions are emerging in the universe of transnational climate governance which may have considerable implications for the governing of global environmental issues. In conclusion, we reflect on these findings and the subsequent consequences for the governance of climate change.

Business · Climate change · Database · Political science · Climate Change Policy and Economics · Computer Science · Geology · International Development and Aid · Sustainability and Climate Change Governance

  • Navigating Regional Environmental Governance

    Jörg Balsiger, Stacy D Vandeveer•Global Environmental Politics•2012

  • Conclusion

    John S Dryzek, Jeffrey Pickering et al.•Politics of the Anthropocene•2018

  • Democratic Anthropocene

    John S Dryzek, Jeffrey Pickering et al.•Politics of the Anthropocene•2018

  • Governance in the Holocene

    John S Dryzek, Jeffrey Pickering et al.•Politics of the Anthropocene•2018

  • Sustainability

    John S Dryzek, Jeffrey Pickering et al.•Politics of the Anthropocene•2018

  • Governance in the Anthropocene

    John S Dryzek, Jeffrey Pickering et al.•Politics of the Anthropocene•2018

  • Who will form the Anthropocene?

    John S Dryzek, Jeffrey Pickering et al.•Politics of the Anthropocene•2018

  • Anthropocene

    John S Dryzek, Jeffrey Pickering et al.•Politics of the Anthropocene•2018

  • Planetary justice

    John S Dryzek, Jeffrey Pickering et al.•Politics of the Anthropocene•2018

  • The platform governance triangle

    Open Access•Robert Gorwa•Internet Policy Review•2019

  • Environmental Governance

    Open Access•David Benson, Andrew J Jordan et al.•International Encyclopedia of…•2017

  • Transnational Climate Change Governance

    Open Access•Harriet Bulkeley, Liliana B Andonova et al.•Transnational Climate Change…•2014

  • Governing Climate Change

    Open Access•Andrew J Jordan, Andrew Jordan et al.•Governing Climate Change•2018

  • Orchestration and transnational climate governance

    Open Access•Thomas Hale, Charles Rogers et al.•The Review of International…•2014

  • Multiactor Governance and the Environment

    Open Access•Peter Newell, Philipp Pattberg et al.•Annual Review of Environment and…•2012

  • The Politics of Sustainability and Development

    Open Access•I Scoones•Annual Review of Environment and…•2016

  • The Transnational Regime Complex for Climate Change

    Open Access•Kenneth W Abbott•Environment and Planning C…•2012

  • Inclusive approaches to urban climate adaptation planning and implementation in the Global South

    Elaine Chu, Eric Chu et al.•Climate Policy•2016

  • Drivers of national climate policy

    Erick Lachapelle, Marisa Paterson et al.•Climate Policy•2013

  • Greening the cloud

    Open Access•Jerry Patchell, Roger Hayter•Cambridge Journal of Regions…•2021

  • The Reconfiguration of Authority in Global Climate Governance

    Thomas Hickmann•International Studies Review•2017

  • After Covid-19

    Open Access•Benjamin Klasche•Social Sciences & Humanities Open•2021

  • Determining the credibility of commitments in international climate policy

    Open Access•David G Victor, Marcel Lumkowsky et al.•Nature Climate Change•2022

  • Treaty Preambles and The Environmental Justice Gap

    Open Access•Matthew Scobie•Global Policy•2021

  • Rethinking polycentricity

    Open Access•Cille Kaiser•International Environmental…•2022

  • Covenant of mayors signatories leading the way towards 1.5 degree global warming pathway

    Open Access•Albana Kona, Paolo Bertoldi et al.•Sustainable Cities and Society•2018

  • Can national policy blockages accelerate the development of polycentric governance? Evidence from climate change policy in the United Kingdom

    Open Access•Ross Gillard, Andrew Gouldson et al.•Global Environmental Change•2017

  • Not so polycentric

    Open Access•Benjamin Leffel, Ben Derudder et al.•Cities•2023

  • Fostering transparency? Analysing information disclosure in transnational regulatory climate initiatives

    Open Access•Laura Iozzelli•Earth System Governance•2023

  • Where do novelties come from? A social network analysis of Transnational Municipal Networks in global climate governance

    Open Access•Marielle Papin•Earth System Governance•2020

  • Governance through goals in action

    Open Access•Cornelia Fast, Oscar Widerberg•Earth System Governance•2025

  • Framing science-based targets

    Open Access•Sasha Quahe, Cornell et al.•Earth System Governance•2023

  • A Momentum for Change? Systemic effects and catalytic impacts of transnational climate action

    Open Access•Sander Chan, Friederike Eichhorn et al.•Earth System Governance•2021

  • Hardwired towards transformation? Assessing global climate governance for power sector decarbonization

    Open Access•Lukas Hermwille•Earth System Governance•2020

  • A portrait of the different configurations between digitally-enabled innovations and climate governance

    Open Access•Pierre Chuard, Jennifer Garard et al.•Earth System Governance•2022

  • Beyond experiments

    Open Access•Frans Sengers, Bruno Turnheim et al.•Environment and Planning C…•2020

  • Climate governance entrepreneurship

    Open Access•Elin Lerum Boasson, Dave Huitema•Environment and Planning C…•2017

  • Subnational governance for the low carbon energy transition

    Open Access•Thomas Muinzer, Geraint Ellis•Environment and Planning C…•2017

  • Stability and climate policy? Harnessing insights on path dependence, policy feedback, and transition pathways

    Open Access•Daniel Rosenbloom, James Meadowcroft et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2018

  • Governance of Fragmented Compliance and Voluntary Carbon Markets Under the Paris Agreement

    Open Access•Hanna-Mari Ahonen, Juliana Kessler et al.•Politics and Governance•2022

  • Crisis Capitalism and Climate Finance

    Open Access•J Long•Politics and Governance•2021

  • Transformations to sustainability

    Open Access•I Scoones, Andy Stirling et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2020

  • Towards a global comprehensive and transparent framework for cities and local governments enabling an effective contribution to the Paris climate agreement

    Open Access•Paolo Bertoldi, Albana Kona et al.•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2018

  • Revisiting International Political Leadership

    Open Access•Christin Heinz‐Fischer, Elin Lerum Boasson•Global Policy•2026

  • Collective climate action and networked climate governance

    Open Access•J Tosun, Jonas J Schoenefeld•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2016

  • Promises and risks of nonstate action in climate and sustainability governance

    Open Access•Sander Chan, Idil Boran et al.•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2019

  • Steering global energy governance

    Open Access•Christian Downie•Regulation & Governance•2020

  • Assessing transformative and synergistic capacity in cooperative climate initiatives

    Open Access•Matilda Miljand, Maximilian S T Wanner•International Environmental…•2026

  • Years of global climate change governance research

    Open Access•Philipp Pattberg, Cille Kaiser et al.•International Environmental…•2022

  • Governing lofty goals

    Open Access•Cornelia Fast•International Environmental…•2026

  • Make it or break it

    Open Access•Maximilian S T Wanner-Freyland, Matilda Miljand•International Environmental…•2026

  • Cities to the rescue? Assessing the performance of transnational municipal networks in global climate governance

    Open Access•Jennifer S Bansard, Philipp Pattberg et al.•International Environmental…•2016

  • The roles of non-state actors in climate change governance

    Open Access•Naghmeh Nasiritousi, Mattias Hjerpe et al.•International Environmental…•2014

  • Global climate governance

    Open Access•Nataliya Stranadko•International Environmental…•2022

  • Transnational municipal networks

    Open Access•Marielle Papin•International Environmental…•2019

  • All Hands on Deck”

    Thomas Hale•Global Environmental Politics•2016

  • Transnational Governing at the Climate–Biodiversity Frontier

    Anouk Fransen, Harriet Bulkeley•Global Environmental Politics•2023

  • Governance by Diffusion

    Lukas Hakelberg•Global Environmental Politics•2014

  • Order out of Chaos

    Jessica Green•Global Environmental Politics•2013

  • Steering and Influence in Transnational Climate Governance

    Joshua B Horton, Barbara Koremenos•Global Environmental Politics•2020

  • Transnational Private Environmental Rule Makers as Interest Organizations

    Stefan Rencken, Kristen Pue et al.•Global Environmental Politics•2022

  • Environmental Mobilities

    Open Access•Ingrid Boas, Sanneke Kloppenburg et al.•Global Environmental Politics•2018

  • The potential of international cooperative initiatives to address key challenges of protected areas

    Open Access•Katarzyna Negacz, Matilda Petersson et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2022

  • Who should do what in environmental management? Twelve principles for allocating responsibilities

    Open Access•Erik Mostert•Environmental Science & Policy•2014

  • International Public Administrations on Twitter

    Alexandra Goritz, Johannes Schuster et al.•Journal of Comparative Policy…•2020

  • From Kyoto to Paris and Beyond

    Open Access•Saurabh Thakur•India Quarterly A Journal of…•2021

  • Transnational city networks, global political economy, and climate governance

    José Manuel Leal, Marisa Paterson•Review of International Political…•2023

  • Overlap and fragmentation in the global governance complex of sustainable finance

    Stefan Rencken, Christian Elliott•Review of International Political…•2025

  • A very human business’—Transnational networking initiatives and domestic climate action

    Open Access•Richard Perkins, Michal Nachmany•Global Environmental Change•2019

  • Climate governance through partnerships

    Open Access•Linda Westman, Vanesa Castán Broto•Global Environmental Change•2018

  • Transnational adaptation governance

    Open Access•Adis Dzebo, Johannes Stripple•Global Environmental Change•2015

  • Scaling up zero-deforestation initiatives through public-private partnerships

    Open Access•Paul R Furumo, Eric F Lambin•Global Environmental Change•2020

  • Advancing urban adaptation where it counts

    Open Access•Samuel Geldin•Environment and Urbanization•2018

  • Explaining policy teaching versus learning in environmental transnational municipal networks

    Benjamin Leffel, D J Gordon et al.•Journal of Urban Affairs•2025

  • How do transnational municipal networks affect climate policymaking? A qualitative study in Turkey

    G Duygu Butun Bayindir•Journal of Urban Affairs•2020

  • A matter of information – The influence of international bureaucracies in global climate governance networks

    Open Access•Alexandra Goritz, Helge Jörgens et al.•Social Networks•2022

  • Transnational networks for the ‘greening’ of ports

    Open Access•Eric Tamatey Lawer•GeoJournal•2019

  • Unraveling the Notion of “Fair Carbon”

    Open Access•Rebecca J Howard, Anne Tallontire et al.•World Development•2015

  • Urban Governance and the Politics of Climate change

    Open Access•Vanesa Castán Broto•World Development•2017

  • Transnational Climate Governance Initiatives

    Katharina Michaelowa, Axel Michaelowa•International Interactions•2016

  • Mapping the Participation of Asean Actors in International Climate Initiatives

    Open Access•Ida Dokk Smith, Gavkharkhon Mamadzhanova et al.•Asia & the Pacific Policy Studies•2025

  • Beyond Technical Fixes

    Open Access•Andrea J Nightingale, Shelly Eriksen et al.•Climate and Development•2019

  • Two degrees and the SDGs

    Open Access•Johanna Coenen, Lisa-Maria Glass et al.•Sustainability Science•2021

  • Policy experimentation

    Open Access•Dave Huitema, Andrew J Jordan et al.•Policy Sciences•2018

  • The expanding field of cooperative initiatives for decarbonization

    Open Access•Oscar Widerberg, Johannes Stripple•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2016

  • Deliberation as a catalyst for reflexive environmental governance

    Open Access•John S Dryzek, Jeffrey Pickering et al.•Ecological Economics•2017

  • A framework for governance of public green spaces in cities

    Andrew MacKenzie, Leonie J Pearson et al.•Landscape Research•2019

  • Interconnected bureaucracies? Comparing online and offline networks during global climate negotiations

    Open Access•Alexandra Goritz, Helge Jörgens et al.•International Review of…•2021

  • Governance experiments in climate action

    Open Access•Kaisa Matscho, Kaisa Matschoss et al.•Environmental Politics•2018

  • Correlates of rigorous and credible transnational governance

    Open Access•Hamish Van Der Ven•Regulation & Governance•2015

  • Public orchestration, social networks, and transnational environmental governance

    Open Access•L F Henriksen, Stefano Pontes•Regulation & Governance•2018

  • Organizational Ecology and Institutional Change in Global Governance

    Open Access•Kenneth W Abbott, Jessica F Green et al.•International Organization•2016

  • Boomerangs to Partnerships? Explaining State Participation in Transnational Partnerships for Sustainability

    Open Access•Liliana B Andonova•Comparative Political Studies•2014

  • The Federated Entities in Environmental Treaties (Feet) Dataset

    Open Access•Jean-Frédéric Morin, Véronique Fournier et al.•Canadian Journal of Political…•2022

  • Engaging with multi-system interactions in sustainability transitions

    Open Access•Daniel Rosenbloom•Environmental Innovation and…•2020

  • Revisiting multi-level governance theory

    Open Access•Linda Katrin Westman, Linda Westman et al.•Political Geography•2019

  • Analyzing Geographic Bias of Newspaper Articles Reporting Global Climate Disasters

    Open Access•Inhye Kong, Ross S Purves•Annals of the American…•2025

  • Constructing climate capitalism

    Open Access•Jean Philippe Sapinski•Global Networks•2016

  • Voluntary instruments for ambitious objectives? The experience of the EU Covenant of Mayors

    Ekaterina Domorenok•Environmental Politics•2019

  • Assessing the impact of the securitization narrative on climate change adaptation in Nigeria

    Open Access•Chinwe Philomina Oramah, Odd Einar Olsen et al.•Environmental Politics•2022

  • Climate for Change

    Open Access•Peter Newell•Climate for Change•2000

  • Transnational Climate Change Governance

    Open Access•Harriet Bulkeley, Liliana B Andonova et al.•Transnational Climate Change…•2014

  • Governing Climate Change

    Harriet Bulkeley, Peter Newell•Governing climate change•2010

  • Climate Governance at the Crossroads

    Matthew J Hoffmann, Matthew Hoffmann•Climate governance at the…•2011

  • Who Governs the Globe?

    Open Access•Deborah D Avant, Martha Finnemore et al.•Who Governs the Globe?•2010

  • The Emergence of Private Authority in Global Governance

    Open Access•Rodney Bruce Hall, Thomas J Biersteker•The emergence of private…•2002

  • Paths to a Green World

    Jennifer Clapp, Peter Dauvergne•Paths to a Green World•2005

  • Climate Capitalism

    Open Access•Peter Newell, Marisa Paterson et al.•Climate Capitalism•2010

  • The Governance of Sustainable Development

    Open Access•Andrew J Jordan, Andrew Jordan•Environment and Planning C…•2008

  • The Transnational Regime Complex for Climate Change

    Open Access•Kenneth W Abbott•Environment and Planning C…•2012

  • Global Environmental Governance

    Open Access•Felix Biermann, Frank Biermann et al.•Annual Review of Environment and…•2008

  • Quasi-States

    Open Access•Robert H Jackson•Quasi-States•1991

  • Bringing transnational relations back in

    Open Access•Thomas Risse, Thomas Risse-Kappen•Bringing Transnational Relations…•1995

  • Activists beyond Borders

    Margaret E Keck, Kathryn Sikkink•Activists beyond borders•2014

  • Business–NGO Collaboration in a Conflict Setting

    Open Access•Ans Kolk, Francois Lenfant•Business & Society•2012

  • Transnational Relations and World Politics

    Robert O Keohane, Jr Joseph S Nye•Transnational Relations and World…•1972

  • Beyond the public and private divide

    Open Access•Philipp Pattberg, Johannes Stripple•International Environmental…•2008

  • Private Environmental Governance and International Relations

    Robert Falkner•Global Environmental Politics•2003

  • Transnational Climate Governance

    Liliana B Andonova, Michele M Betsill et al.•Global Environmental Politics•2009

  • Transparency in Nonstate Certification

    Graeme Auld, Lars H Gulbrandsen•Global Environmental Politics•2010

  • Accountability of Networked Climate Governance

    Karin Bäckstrand•Global Environmental Politics•2008

  • Public-Private Partnerships for the Earth

    Liliana B Andonova•Global Environmental Politics•2010

  • Global Governance as a Perspective on World Politics

    Klaus Dingwerth, Philipp Pattberg•Global Governance A Review of…•2006

  • Intersectoral partnerships for a sustainable coffee chain

    Open Access•Verena Bitzer, Mara Francken et al.•Global Environmental Change•2008

  • Partnerships in forest governance

    Open Access•I J Visseren-Hamakers, Pieter Glasbergen•Global Environmental Change•2007

  • Private Governance and the South

    Philipp Pattberg•Third World Quarterly•2006

  • The Regime Complex for Climate Change

    Open Access•Robert O Keohane, David G Victor•Perspectives on Politics•2011

  • Multisectoral Networks in Global Governance

    Open Access•Thorsten Benner, Wolfgang H Reinicke et al.•Government and Opposition•2004

  • The Institutionalization of Private Governance

    Open Access•Philipp Pattberg•Governance•2005

  • Climate Governance Beyond the State

    C Jager, Sverker C Jager et al.•Global Governance A Review of…•2003

  • North-South Parity in Global Governance

    Klaus Dingwerth•Global Governance A Review of…•2008

  • Reconstituting the Global Public Domain - Issues, Actors, and Practices

    Open Access•John Gerard Ruggie•European Journal of International…•2004

  • My Space

    Open Access•Marisa Paterson, Matthew Paterson et al.•Environment and Planning D…•2010

  • Non-governmental organisations and governance states

    Rosaleen Duffy, Rosaleen V Duffy•Environmental Politics•2006

  • Accumulation by Decarbonization and the Governance of Carbon Offsets

    Open Access•Adam Bumpus, Adam G Bumpus et al.•Economic Geography•2008

Unique citing works110
Citations per year7,86
Citation span2012 - 2026 (15)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 109

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae