Does Simulation-Based Medical Education With Deliberate Practice Yield Better Results Than Traditional Clinical Education? A Meta-Analytic Comparative Review of the Evidence
Bibliographic Data
| ID | 23344141 |
|---|---|
| Authors | William C Mcgaghie (0000-0003-1672-0398, Northwestern University, corresponding author), S Barry Issenberg (0000-0002-2524-4736, Northwestern University), Elaine R Cohen, Elaine Cohen (0000-0003-2379-6112, Northwestern University), Jeffrey H Barsuk (0000-0001-6584-9943, Northwestern University), Diane B Wayne (0000-0001-6468-0744, Northwestern University) |
| Year | 2011 |
| Volume | 86 |
| Issue | 6 |
| Pages | 706-711 |
| Publication date | 2011-06-01 |
| Peer Reviewed | Yes |
| Open Access | No |
| Type | ARTICLE |
| Venue | Academic Medicine (JOURNAL) |
| Journal identifiers | ISSN: 1040-2446 • E-ISSN: 1938-808X |
| Publisher | Oxford University Press (OUP) (PUBLISHER) |
| DOI | 10.1097/acm.0b013e318217e119 |
| PMID | 21512370 |
| PMCID | PMC3102783 |
| OpenAlex | W1969241382 |
| Language | EN |
| Citations received | 63 |
| References cited | 36 |
PURPOSE: This article presents a comparison of the effectiveness of traditional clinical education toward skill acquisition goals versus simulation-based medical education (SBME) with deliberate practice (DP). METHOD: This is a quantitative meta-analysis that spans 20 years, 1990 to 2010. A search strategy involving three literature databases, 12 search terms, and four inclusion criteria was used. Four authors independently retrieved and reviewed articles. Main outcome measures were extracted to calculate effect sizes. RESULTS: Of 3,742 articles identified, 14 met inclusion criteria. The overall effect size for the 14 studies evaluating the comparative effectiveness of SBME compared with traditional clinical medical education was 0.71 (95% confidence interval, 0.65-0.76; P < .001). CONCLUSIONS: Although the number of reports analyzed in this meta-analysis is small, these results show that SBME with DP is superior to traditional clinical medical education in achieving specific clinical skill acquisition goals. SBME is a complex educational intervention that should be introduced thoughtfully and evaluated rigorously at training sites. Further research on incorporating SBME with DP into medical education is needed to amplify its power, utility, and cost-effectiveness.
Alternative medicine · Clinical Practice · Clinical trial · Confidence interval · Evidence-based medicine · Family medicine · Inclusion (mineral) · Intervention (counseling) · Medical education · MEDLINE · Meta-analysis · Pathology · Psychiatry · Scientific evidence · Statistics · Innovations in Medical Education · Internal Medicine · Medicine · Psychology · Simulation-Based Education in Healthcare · Social Psychology · Surgical Simulation and Training
Aprendizaje basado en simulación con realidad virtual
Novel Neonatal Simulator Provides High-Fidelity Ventilation Training Comparable to Real-Life Newborn Ventilation
The use of virtual patient simulations in psychology
Using wise interventions to motivate deliberate practice
Technology-Enhanced Simulation for Health Professions Education
Communicative Figurations
Global Surgery 2030
The impact of simulation-based training in medical education
Simulation in healthcare education
Promoting Excellence and Reflective Learning in Simulation (PEARLS)
CPR training as a gender and rights-based healthcare issue
Implementation and Evaluation of a Virtual Reality Simulation
The Effects of a Digital Game Simulator versus a Traditional Intervention on Paramedics’ Neonatal Resuscitation Performance
Psychological State and Exam Performance among Paramedics’ Students in Geneva during the Covid-19 Pandemic
Simulation as a Training Method for Electricity Workers’ Safety
A Randomized Controlled Simulation Trial of a Neonatal Resuscitation Digital Game Simulator for Labour and Delivery Room Staff
Blending simulation and e-learning in medical education to enhance professional competence and skills acquisition
Construction and implementation of an AI-enhanced progressive training model for clinical competency development in obstetrics and gynecology residents
Development and validation of a Novel 3D-printed mold-based silicone model for laparoscopic duodenal stump reinforcement suture simulation training
Preliminary exploration and evaluation of video-based feedback for orthokeratology lens fitting
Overcoming Challenges to Teamwork in Healthcare
Formal tobacco-control training and thirdhand smoke counseling practices among pediatric nurses in China
Evaluation of a Novel Simulation Curriculum With the Segmented Model in Pediatric Cardiovascular Education
Disease burden, influencing factors and trend-based surveillance of needlestick injuries among healthcare workers
Evaluation of teaching effect of first-aid comprehensive simulation-based education in clinical medical students
Using Technology-Supported Approaches for the Development of Technical Skills Outside of the Classroom
Interaction principles for digital puppeteering to promote teacher learning
An online field experience using mixed reality virtual simulation
Beyond Individual Diagnosis
Development and Application of an Objective Structured Clinical Examination for Practicing Integrated Behavioral Health Skills
Promoting Readiness for Residency
Communicating Diagnostic Uncertainty at Emergency Department Discharge
Fostering Adaptive Expertise Through Simulation
Competency-Based Medical Education
Simulating for Quality
‘Dancing with emotions’
Implementing, embedding and sustaining simulation‐based education
Stereoscopic three‐dimensional visualisation technology in anatomy learning
Observational learning in simulation-based social work education
Communication content during debriefing in simulation-based medical education
Unravelling the differences between observation and active participation in simulation-based education
Using insights from cognitive science for the teaching of clinical skills
Powerful medical education improves health care quality and return on investment
Twelve tips for developing a systematic acute care curriculum for medical students
Effective Teacher Professional Development
The effectiveness of simulation in drug recognition expert training
Simulation in Social Work
A posthuman ecology of simulated human patients
Medical education and human trafficking
Using longitudinal progress test data to determine the effect size of learning in undergraduate medical education – a retrospective, single-center, mixed model analysis of progress testing results
The 2024 French guidelines for scenario design in simulation-based education
Feasibility of scenario-based simulation training versus traditional workshops in continuing medical education
The Effectiveness of Educational Intervention in Improving Primary Health-Care Service Providers’ Knowledge, Identification, and Management of Elder Abuse and Neglect
Learning environment and simulation effectiveness in midwifery education
Mastering Sedation and Associated Respiratory Events through Simulation-Based Training
High-Fidelity Simulation-Based Education
Acting Like It Matters
Meta-analysis and machine learning-augmented mixed effects cohort analysis of improved diets among 5847 medical trainees, providers and patients
Culinary medicine course
Simulation-Based Research
Simulation in Social Work Education
Qualitative Study of Paediatric Advance Care Planning Through Simulation
A disability disclosure simulation as an educational tool
The Cambridge Handbook of Expertise and Expert Performance
Introduction to Meta‐Analysis
Deliberate Practice and the Acquisition and Maintenance of Expert Performance in Medicine and Related Domains
The Influence of Experience and Deliberate Practice on the Development of Superior Expert Performance
Realist review - a new method of systematic review designed for complex policy interventions
A critical review of simulation‐based medical education research
Features and uses of high-fidelity medical simulations that lead to effective learning
Meta-analysis of Observational Studies in Epidemiology A Proposal for Reporting
| Unique citing works | 63 |
|---|---|
| Citations per year | 4,2 |
| Citation span | 2011 - 2026 (16) |
| Citation velocity | current |
| Highly cited | No |
| Citation types | Neutral: 58 |