Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Constitutional Design

Proposals Versus Processes

Bibliographic Data

ID23364772
AuthorsDonald L Horowitz (corresponding author)
Year2002
Pages15-36
Publication date2002-03-14
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeCHAPTER
VenueThe architecture of democracy (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherOxford University PressOxford (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1093/0199246467.003.0002
OpenAlexW1476075615
ISBN9780199246465
LanguageEN
Citations received86
References cited193

The essence of democracy is that it is indigenous, and the practice over importing a model of democratic governance from outside virtually assures its non‐democratic character, unless a very circumspect approach is adopted. Nor is there a clear theoretical consensus within the developed countries themselves. This chapter sets out the author's basic objections to the theory of consociationalism, and his reasons for preferring an incentives‐based approach to encouraging accommodative behaviour over power‐sharing.

Character (mathematics) · Corporate governance · Democracy · Economics · Incentive · Indigenous · Law and economics · Management · Microeconomics · Physics · Political science · Power (physics) · Sociology · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Judicial and Constitutional Studies · Law · Mathematics · Political Conflict and Governance · Public Administration

  • The Politics of Electoral Reform

    Open Access•Alan Renwick•Politics of Electoral Reform•2010

  • What Politicians Can Teach Academics

    Open Access•Paul Dixon•Consociationalism and Power-Sharing…•2018

  • When do ethnic majorities share power? The politics of de-majoritarian constitutional reforms in Pakistan and Sri Lanka

    Salman Rafi Sheikh•Territory Politics Governance•2025

  • How can civil society support reconciliations and civil engagement in Somalia

    Open Access•Farhia A Abdi, Kon K Madut•HUMAN GEOGRAPHIES – Journal of…•2019

  • Spatiality of ethnic identity and construction of sociopolitical interaction in South Sudan

    Open Access•Kon K Madut•HUMAN GEOGRAPHIES – Journal of…•2017

  • Complex Power-sharing and the Centrality of Territorial Self-governance in Contemporary Conflict Settlements

    Stefan Wolff•Ethnopolitics•2009

  • State Building and Transitional Politics in Iraq

    Open Access•Katia Papagianni•International Studies Perspectives•2007

  • A Bottom-up Approach to Peacebuilding

    Open Access•Brian R Urlacher, Brian Urlacher•International Studies Review•2008

  • Ethnic Power Sharing

    Open Access•Donald L Horowitz•Journal of democracy•2014

  • Are civil liberties contagious? Analysis of determinants of de facto civil rights protection in post-socialist countries

    Open Access•Anna Lewczuk•Constitutional Political Economy•2020

  • The Predicament of Ethnic Federal System

    Open Access•Yohannes Getahun•African Journal of Political…•2024

  • State-building and local resistance in Kosovo

    Open Access•Jelena Lončar•Communist and Post-Communist…•2016

  • Addressing Ethnic Divisions in Post-Conflict Institution-Building

    Open Access•Sven Gunnar Simonsen•Security Dialogue•2005

  • Governing ‘Ethnicised’ Public Sphere

    Open Access•Nkwachukwu Orji•Africa Development•2011

  • Crafting Political Institutions in Africa

    Alexander Stroh•Verfassung in Recht und Übersee•2007

  • Who controls the wealth? Electoral system design and ethnic war in resource-rich countries

    Open Access•Natascha S Neudorfer, Ulrike G Theuerkauf•Electoral Studies•2014

  • Consociational Democracy and Political Engineering in Postwar Kosovo

    Open Access•Adem Beha•Nationalities Papers•2019

  • The alternative vote and interethnic moderation

    Open Access•Donald L Horowitz•Public Choice•2004

  • The merits of Neo-Downsian modeling of the alternative vote

    Open Access•Jon Fraenkel, B Grofman•Public Choice•2007

  • Can Institutions Build Unity in Multiethnic States

    Open Access•Zachary Elkins, Josh Sides et al.•American Political Science Review•2007

  • Territory, Democracy and Justice

    Open Access•Scott L Greer•Territory, Democracy and Justice•2006

  • The Peacebuilding Puzzle

    Open Access•Naazneen H Barma, Naazneen Barma•The Peacebuilding Puzzle•2016

  • Federalism and Regionalism in Western Europe

    Open Access•Wilfried Swenden•Federalism and Regionalism in…•2006

  • Mobilization and Conflict in Multiethnic States

    Manuel Vogt•Mobilization and Conflict in…•2019

  • Restructuring the State

    Simon Toubeau•Publius The Journal of Federalism•2017

  • Democratic Design

    Michael Saward•Democratic Design•2021

  • In search of inter-ethnic balance

    Петр Панов, Petr Panov•European Politics and Society•2016

  • Las elecciones legislativas de Irlanda del Norte 2022. ¿Una victoria histórica del nacionalismo

    Open Access•Daniel Casal•Ciencia Política•2025

  • The “Communal College

    Open Access•Ivan Pepić•Swiss Political Science Review•2026

  • Explosive by nature, escalation by design

    Maxime Vandenberghe, Nicolas Bouteca•Regional & Federal Studies•2026

  • Political Transitions after Peace Agreements

    Katia Papagianni•Journal of Intervention and…•2009

  • Territorial Distribution Requirements Without Centripetal Pitfalls

    Open Access•Ivan Pepić•Ethnopolitics•2023

  • Power-Sharing and the Paradox of Federalism

    Open Access•Maxime Vandenberghe•Ethnopolitics•2022

  • Presidentialism and the Risk of Ethnic Violence

    Ulrike G Theuerkauf•Ethnopolitics•2012

  • After Dayton, Dayton? The evolution of an unpopular peace

    Florian Bieber•Ethnopolitics•2006

  • The Politics of Association

    Alexandre W Raffoul•Ethnopolitics•2018

  • Does the Process of Constitution-Making Matter

    T Ginsburg, Zachary Elkins et al.•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2009

  • Managing ethno-national conflict

    Stefan Wolff•Commonwealth and Comparative…•2011

  • Ethiopia's Experiment in Accommodating Diversity

    Assefa Fiseha•Regional & Federal Studies•2012

  • The One-Dimensionality of the Institutional Incentives Approach to Ethnic Violence

    Ulrike G Theuerkauf•Studies in Conflict and Terrorism•2010

  • Ethnic Mobilization, Armaments, and South Sudan’s Quest for Sustainable Peace

    Open Access•Kon K Madut•Peace Review•2020

  • Militarism and Political Conformism in Sudan and South Sudan

    Open Access•Kon K Madut•Peace Review•2020

  • Ironies of Consociation

    Aaron Vlasak•Society & Natural Resources•2018

  • The Quest for a Quebec Constitution

    Nelson Wiseman•The American Review of Canadian…•2010

  • Probing PR

    Open Access•Nils-Christian Bormann, Simon Hug•Research & Politics•2025

  • Michael Kerr

    Robin Wilson•Democracy and Security•2007

  • The 'Sociological Laws' of Maurice Duverger

    Open Access•Miroslav Novák•Czech Sociological Review•2015

  • Kosovo

    Open Access•Andrei Semenov, Andrej Semenov•International Studies•2020

  • A Evolução dos Modelos Democrátcos de Arend Lijphart

    Open Access•Renata Albuquerque De Moraes, Renato Almeida De Moraes et al.•Cuadernos de Educación y Desarrollo•2025

  • An exploratory study of constitutional design in three island states

    Eliezer S Poupko•Journal of Contemporary African…•2017

  • A three-legged race

    Open Access•Maxime Vandenberghe•Acta Politica•2025

  • Survival of the Fittest(?)

    Chien-Chih Lin•The American Journal of…•2014

  • Nation Building. A Long-Term Perspective and Global Analysis

    Andreas Wimmer•European Sociological Review•2015

  • The Normative Agency of Regional Organizations and Non‐governmental Organizations in International Peace Mediation

    Open Access•Jamie Pring, Julia Palmiano Federer•Swiss Political Science Review•2020

  • Conflict Resolution between Power Sharing and Power Dividing, or Beyond

    Open Access•Stefan Wolff•Political Studies Review•2007

  • Legislative Behaviour in the Northern Ireland Assembly, 2007–11

    Open Access•Richard S Conley, Richard Conley et al.•Political Studies•2013

  • Do electoral coalitions facilitate democratic consolidation in Africa

    Open Access•Donald Resnick, Danielle Resnick•Party Politics•2013

  • The choice of candidate-centered electoral systems in new democracies

    Open Access•Jae Hyeok Shin•Party Politics•2017

  • Power‐sharing coalitions in the Basque Country (1987–1998)

    Open Access•Asier Blas•Nations and Nationalism•2018

  • Constitutional choices

    Open Access•Jai Kwan Jung, Christopher J Deering•International Political Science…•2015

  • The stability of basic income

    Open Access•Jurgen De Wispelaere, Leticia Morales•Journal of Public Policy•2016

  • Language, Religion, and Ethnic Civil War

    Open Access•Nils-Christian Bormann, Lars-Erik Cederman et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2017

  • The Ethnic Implications of Preferential Voting

    Open Access•J Coakley, Jon Fraenkel•Government and Opposition•2017

  • Deliberative inclusion of minorities

    Open Access•Seraina Pedrini, André Bächtiger et al.•European Political Science Review•2013

  • Ethnic polarization and the limits of democratic practice

    Brian Shoup, Brian D Shoup•Democratization•2018

  • Consociational settlements in deeply divided societies

    Allison Mcculloch•Democratization•2014

  • Consistency in constitutional design and its effect on democracy

    Anna Fruhstorfer•Democratization•2019

  • Who negotiates for a nation? Catalan mobilization and nationhood before the Spanish democratic transition, 1970–1975

    Scott L Greer•Democratization•2016

  • Does the Alternative Vote Foster Moderation in Ethnically Divided Societies

    Open Access•Jon Fraenkel, B Grofman•Comparative Political Studies•2006

  • The Myth of Consociationalism? Conflict Reduction in Divided Societies

    Open Access•Joel Selway, Kharis Templeman•Comparative Political Studies•2012

  • Strategy Takes a Holiday

    Open Access•Donald L Horowitz•Comparative Political Studies•2006

  • Survival of the Fittest

    Open Access•Liam Anderson, Cristina Maria Maués Da Costa et al.•Swiss Political Science Review•2016

  • Pacification through decentralization

    Open Access•Maxime Vandenberghe•Swiss Political Science Review•2023

  • Centripetalism in Consociational Democracy

    Open Access•Laurent De Briey, Aurian De Briey•Swiss Political Science Review•2024

  • The Political Consequences of the Electoral System in Northern Ireland

    J Coakley•Irish Political Studies•2009

  • Intuitively neoliberal? Towards a critical understanding of resilience governance

    Open Access•Jessica Schmidt•European Journal of International…•2015

  • Understanding Hybrid Democracy in Cambodia

    Open Access•Mikael Baaz, M Lilja•Asian Politics & Policy•2014

  • War

    Andreas Wimmer•Annual Review of Sociology•2014

  • Bringing politics back in

    Paul Dixon•Small Wars and Insurgencies•2021

  • Consociationalism under examination

    Open Access•Hakan Kolçak•Digest of Middle East Studies•2020

  • The Problematic Relation between Direct Democracy and Accountability in Latin America

    Open Access•Anita Breuer•Bulletin of Latin American Research•2008

  • Is the Rule of Law an Antidote for Religious Tension? The Promise and Peril of Judicializing Religious Freedom

    Open Access•Benjamin Schonthal, Tamir Moustafa et al.•American Behavioral Scientist•2016

  • Good Fences Make Good Neighbours? A Comparison of Conflict-Regulation Strategies in Postwar Bosnia

    Open Access•Nina Caspersen•Journal of Peace Research•2004

  • Why did governance and institutional establishments fail in Sudan and South Sudan

    Kon K Madut•The Journal of North African…•2023

  • Including chiefs, maintaining peace? Examining the effects of state-traditional governance interaction on civil peace in sub-Saharan Africa

    Open Access•Katariina Mustasilta•Journal of Peace Research•2019

  • Electoral rules of the authoritarian game

    Alexander Stroh•Journal of Eastern African Studies•2010

  • Competing equalities

    Marc Galanter•Competing equalities•1991

  • Constitutions of the countries of the world

    Albert P Blaustein, Gisbert H Flanz•Constitutions of the countries of…•1971

  • Buddhism betrayed?

    Stanley Jeyaraja Tambiah•Buddhism betrayed?•1992

  • An Introduction to Nigerian Government and Politics

    Billy J Dudley•An Introduction to Nigerian…•1983

  • Language, Religion and Politics in North India

    Paul R Brass•Language, Religion and Politics…•2005

  • The theory of political coalitions.

    William H Riker•The theory of political coalitions.•1962

  • Minorities at risk

    Ted Robert Gurr•Minorities at risk•1993

  • The Politics of Democratic Consolidation

    Robert Gunther, Hans-Jurgen Puhle et al.•The politics of democratic…•1995

  • Institutional Design in Post-Communist Societies

    Open Access•Jon Elster, Claus Offe et al.•Institutional Design in…•1998

  • Presidents and Assemblies

    Open Access•Matthew Soberg Shugart, John Michael Carey•Presidents and Assemblies•1992

  • Considerations on representative government.

    John Stuart Mill•1862

  • Making Votes Count

    Open Access•Gary W Cox•Making Votes Count•1997

  • Electoral Systems and Party Systems

    Arend Lijphart•Electoral systems and party systems•1994

  • Fair Division

    Open Access•Steven J Bram, Steven J Brams et al.•Fair Division•1996

  • World Development Report 1997

    World Bank•The state in a changing world.•1997

  • Presidentialism and Democracy in Latin America

    Open Access•Scott Mainwaring, Matthew Soberg Shugart•Presidentialism and Democracy in…•1997

  • Democracy and Elections

    Richard S Katz•Democracy and elections•1997

  • The decline of constitutional democracy in Indonesia

    Herbert Feith•The decline of constitutional…•2007

  • Building democratic institutions

    Scott Mainwaring, Timothy Scully•Building democratic institutions•1995

  • Power sharing and international mediation in ethnic conflicts

    Timothy D Sisk•Power sharing and international…•1996

  • The third wave

    Samuel P Huntington•The third wave•1991

  • Political man

    Seymour Martin Lipset•Political man•1983

  • Agendas, alternatives, and public policies

    John W Kingdon•Agendas, alternatives, and public…•1995

  • Democracy and the Market

    Open Access•Adam Przeworski•Democracy and the Market•1991

  • Democracy in Plural Societies

    Arend Lijphart•Democracy in Plural Societies•1980

  • Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance

    Open Access•Douglass C North•Institutions, Institutional…•1990

  • Division and Cohesion in Democracy

    Harry Eckstein•Division and Cohesion in Democracy•2015

  • Perception and Misperception in International Politics

    Robert Jervis•Perception and Misperception in…•2017

  • Perspectives on Public Choice

    Open Access•Dennis C Mueller•Perspectives on Public Choice•1996

  • Identity, Interest and Action

    Open Access•Erik Ringmar•Identity, Interest and Action•1996

  • Critical Elections

    Geoffrey Evans, Pippa Norris•Critical Elections•1999

  • Autonomy, Sovereignty, and Self-Determination

    Hurst Hannum•Autonomy, Sovereignty, and…•1996

  • Autonomy

    Markku Suksi•Autonomy•1998

  • Nations and Nationalism

    Howard Wollman, Philip J Spencer et al.•Nations and Nationalism•2019

  • The Princes of India in the Endgame of Empire, 1917–1947

    Open Access•Ian Copland•Princes of India in the Endgame…•1997

  • Managing Political Change in Singapore

    Lam Peng Er, Kevin Tan•Managing Political Change in…•2013

  • The Untouchables

    Open Access•Oliver Mendelsohn, Marika Vicziany•Untouchables•1998

  • Explaining the Increase in Inequality during the Transition

    Branko Milanovic•World Bank policy research…•1998

  • Electoral Systems and Democratization in Southern Africa

    Andrew Reynolds, Andrew N Reynolds•Electoral systems and democratizati…•1999

  • Electoral Systems and Conflict in Divided Societies

    Ben Reilly, National Research Council•Electoral systems and conflict in…•1999

  • Strange Multiplicity

    Open Access•James Tully•Strange Multiplicity•1995

  • A Democratic South Africa

    Donald L Horowitz•Democratic South Africa?•1991

  • Post-Communist Party Systems

    Open Access•Herbert Kitschelt, Zdenka Mansfeldová et al.•Post-Communist Party Systems•1999

  • Party Fragmentation and Presidential Elections in Post-Communist Democracies

    Open Access•Михаил Филиппов, Mikhail G Filippov et al.•Constitutional Political Economy•1999

  • The Alternative Vote System In Fiji

    Jon Fraenkel•Commonwealth and Comparative…•2001

  • Presidents vs. Parliaments

    Open Access•Juan J Linz•Journal of democracy•1990

  • The politics of state building

    Roman Solchanyk•Europe Asia Studies•1994

  • Preferential voting and political engineering

    Benjamin Reilly, Ben Reilly•The Journal of Commonwealth &…•1997

  • A Review

    Vladimir Shlapentokh•Public Opinion Quarterly•1994

  • Towards a united future

    Brij V Lal•Journal of Pacific History•1997

  • Minority government and majority rule

    Steven M Delue•History of European Ideas•1991

  • Electoral systems change in Estonia, 1989–1993

    B Grofman, Evald Mikkel et al.•Journal of Baltic Studies•1999

  • The Framing of the Constitution of the United States

    Evarts B Greene, Max Farrand•The Mississippi Valley Historical…•1914

  • The Military in African Politics

    Melvin E Page, John W Harbeson•African Economic History•1988

  • Key Variables In Social Investigation

    Therese L Baker, Robert G Burgess et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1987

  • Kashmir

    S Bose, Subash Chandra Bose•Survival•1999

  • The security dilemma and ethnic conflict

    Barry R Posen•Survival•1993

  • Classifying political regimes

    Open Access•Mike Alvarez, José Antônio Cheibub et al.•Studies in Comparative…•1996

  • The Protection of Human Rights under the Belfast Agreement

    Open Access•Brian O’leary, Brendan O’leary•The Political Quarterly•2001

  • Is there a third-world policy process

    Open Access•Donald L Horowitz•Policy Sciences•1989

  • Conflict resolution in Africa

    Peter Vales, Peter Vale•International Affairs•1992

  • The Story of the Integration of the Indian States

    L F Rushbrook-Williams•International Affairs•1957

  • The New Commonwealth and its Constitutions

    J E S Fawcett•International Affairs•1964

  • Political Parties

    Brian Chapman•International Affairs•1955

  • The global resurgence of democracy

    Tony Evans•International Affairs•1994

  • Hopes and Shadows

    Robert Legvold, J F Brown•Foreign Affairs•1995

  • Conflict and Resolution

    Open Access•I William Zartman•The Annals of the American…•1991

  • Political opposition and inter‐governmental relations in the second Nigerian republic

    Rotimi T Suberu•The Journal of Commonwealth &…•1990

  • Transition without End

    John Flint, L Diamond et al.•International Journal Canada s…•1998

  • Mercenaries, Pirates, and Sovereigns

    Janice E Thomson•Mercenaries, Pirates, and…•1996

  • Suharto's Armed Forces

    Salim Said•Asian Survey•1998

  • Northern Irish Voters and the British–Irish Agreement

    Open Access•G Evans, Geoffrey M Evans et al.•The Political Quarterly•2000

  • Cross-Border Cooperation in the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland

    Open Access•Etain Tannam•Cross-Border Cooperation in the…•1999

  • Consociationalism and the Northern Ireland peace process

    P Dixon•Nationalism and Ethnic Politics•1997

  • Incentives and behaviour in the ethnic politics of Sri Lanka and Malaysia

    Donald L Horiwitz•Third World Quarterly•1989

  • Women's legislative participation in western Europe

    P Norris•West European Politics•1985

  • The Effect of Legal Thresholds on the Revival of Former Communist Parties in East-Central Europe

    Bryon Moraski, Gerhard Loewenberg•The Journal of Politics•1999

  • The Formation of Party Systems in East Central Europe

    Open Access•Herbert Kitschelt•Politics & Society•1992

  • Transitional Electoral Systems in Post-Communist Eastern Europe

    Open Access•John Ishiyama, John T Ishiyama•Political Science Quarterly•1997

  • Electoral Systems and Democracy in Central Europe, 1990-1994

    Open Access•János Simon•International Political Science…•1997

  • Distinctiveness of regional voting

    Open Access•Derek J Hearl, Ian Budge et al.•Electoral Studies•1996

  • A Comparative Perspective on the Leninist Legacy in Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Barbara Geddes•Comparative Political Studies•1995

  • Comparing electoral systems

    Duncan Watts•Representation•1998

  • The international Idea handbook of electoral system design

    Paul Wilder•Representation•1999

  • Debate

    Open Access•Andrew Reynolds•Journal of democracy•1995

  • Federalism and Democracy

    Open Access•Alfred Stepan, Alfred C Stepan•Journal of democracy•1999

  • Imagined communities

    Benedict Anderson•Imagined communities•1991

  • Ethnic groups in conflict

    Donald L Horowitz•Ethnic groups in conflict•2000

  • Electoral Systems and the Number of Parties in Postcommunist States

    Open Access•Robert G Moser•World Politics•1999

  • Constitutional Frameworks and Democratic Consolidation

    Open Access•Alfred Stepan, Cindy Skach•World Politics•1993

  • Lijphart, Lakatos, and Consociationalism

    Open Access•I S Lustick•World Politics•1997

  • Winners Take All

    Open Access•Joel S Hellman•World Politics•1998

  • The disorderly universe of consociational democracy

    Sue M Halpern•West European Politics•1986

  • Intransigence and flexibility on the way to two forums

    Geoffrey Evans, Brendan O''Leary et al.•Representation•1997

  • Three levels of elections in Israel

    Reuven Y Hazan•Representation•1997

  • Electoral reform in Ukraine

    Sarah Birch•Representation•1998

  • The implications for political accommodation in northern Ireland of reforming the electoral system for the Westminster parliament1

    Brendan O''Leary, Brian O’leary et al.•Representation•1998

  • The Romanian elections of November 19961

    Dennis Deletant, Peter Siani‐davie et al.•Representation•1998

  • Electoral systems and their political effects in Africa

    Shaheen Mozaffar•Representation•1997

  • Australia's experience with the alternative vote

    Clive Bean•Representation•1997

Unique citing works86
Citations per year3,91
Citation span2004 - 2026 (23)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 66

Tools

Open DOILibgen
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae