Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

I'm in Control

Compensatory Manhood in a Therapeutic Community

Bibliographic Data

ID2367502
AuthorsMatthew B Ezzell (James Madison University), Matthew Ezzell (0000-0002-4021-392X, James Madison University, corresponding author)
Year2012
Volume26
Issue2
Pages190-215
Publication date2012-04-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueGender & Society (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0891-2432 • E-ISSN: 1552-3977
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/0891243211434611
OpenAlexW2166460093
LanguageEN
Citations received55
References cited65

Based on participant observation and in-depth interviews, this article analyzes the ways that male residents in a drug treatment program signified a masculine self through compensatory manhood acts. I analyze four strategies of identity work that men used during group accountability sessions called 'games': (1) signifying masculinity through aggression; (2) subordinating women and nonconventional men; (3) calling others to account as men; and (4) 'keeping your head': managing emotions to (re)assert control. This article adds to our understanding of the ways that compensatory manhood acts are structured locally through interaction, highlighting ways that men's interactions may be self-defeating and also reproduce inequality by reinforcing dominant ideologies of misogyny and homophobia. In addition, it speaks to the ways that masculine subjectivity is constructed against and through dominant narratives of addiction and treatment

Addiction · Aesthetics · Aggression · Epistemology · Ideology · Masculinity · Narrative · Political science · Politics · Sociology · Subjectivity · Gender Diversity and Inequality · Gender Roles and Identity Studies · Gender Studies · Gender, Feminism, and Media · Psychology · Social Psychology

  • From compensation to capitulation

    Open Access•Jessica Pfaffendorf, T D Hill et al.•Social Problems•2026

  • Heteronational Matrix

    Open Access•Caner Hazar•Nationalities Papers•2026

  • Guy Talk, Precarious Masculinity, and Men’s Sexual Health

    Open Access•Trenton M Haltom, Meredith G F Worthen•American Journal of Men s Health•2026

  • “‘I’m a Married Man. No, I’m Not. I’m a Married Fat Man’

    Open Access•Elyse Neumann•Men and Masculinities•2025

  • ‘Observe and Absorb’

    Open Access•Ian Blackwell, Jason Preston•Men and Masculinities•2026

  • Bitchifying Hillary

    Open Access•Kristen Erichsen, Douglas Schrock et al.•Social Currents•2020

  • Involuntary Celibacy (Incel) Identity

    Open Access•Marco De Vettor, Gabriele Lo Buglio et al.•Societies•2025

  • Assessing online misogyny

    Open Access•Mairead Moloney, Tony P Love•Sociology Compass•2018

  • Emotional Subcultures

    Open Access•Kenneth H Kolb•Sociology Compass•2014

  • Hatespeech or Tatespeech? Andrew Tate and the rise of the radical misogynist

    Open Access•Tony P Love, Ena Prskalo et al.•New Media & Society•2025

  • Critical Masculinity Studies and Research on Violence Against Women

    Open Access•Edward W Morris, Kathleen Ratajczak•Violence Against Women•2019

  • Migration, marginalization and metropolitaneity

    Wai-Man Tang•Gender Place & Culture•2017

  • A psychoactive paradox of masculinities

    Clay Darcy•Gender Place & Culture•2019

  • Women’s Ideals for Masculinity Across Social Contexts

    Open Access•Michael Quayle, Graham Lindegger et al.•Sex Roles•2017

  • Making the invisible visible

    Open Access•Clay Darcy•Irish Journal of Sociology•2018

  • Four Distinct Cultures of Oilfield Masculinity, but Absent Hegemonic Masculinity

    Open Access•N N Adams•Journal of Contemporary Ethnography•2022

  • The use of gender in the interpretation of BDSM

    Open Access•Brandy L Simula, J E Sumerau et al.•Sexualities•2019

  • Man Up, Man Down

    Open Access•J E Yavorsky, Philip N Cohen et al.•Sociological Quarterly•2016

  • ‘She doesn’t think that happens’

    Open Access•Joni L Meenagh•Sexualities•2021

  • Gendering Identity Talk

    Bertan Buyukozturk•Sociological Focus•2022

  • Men never cry”

    J E Sumerau, R T Cragun et al.•Sociological Focus•2017

  • The Civil Rights Movement of Our Time”

    Open Access•André Vaughn Ivey, Douglas P Schrock et al.•Symbolic Interaction•2025

  • Narrative Manhood Acts

    Open Access•Douglas Schrock, Janice Mccabe et al.•Symbolic Interaction•2018

  • Emotions and Medical Decision-Making

    Open Access•Amanda M Gengler•Social Psychology Quarterly•2020

  • When feeling under threat

    Open Access•Justina Berškytė, Adelina Valoschi et al.•Synthese•2025

  • No more of this macho bullshit’

    Open Access•Robert Wilton, Geoffrey Deverteuil et al.•Transactions of the Institute of…•2013

  • Created by god and wired to porn

    Open Access•K Burke, Trenton M Haltom•Gender & Society•2020

  • Understanding masculine identity among anti-war veterans

    Anjel Stough-Hunter, Anjel Stough‐hunter et al.•NORMA•2015

  • The Sociology of Gaslighting

    Open Access•Paige L Sweet•American Sociological Review•2019

  • Marginal men, respectable masculinity and access to HIV services through intimate relationships with female sex workers in Kampala, Uganda

    Open Access•Martin Mbonye, Godfrey Siu et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2022

  • Contesting 'sex' and 'gender' difference in emotions through music use in the UK

    Sam De Boise•Journal of Gender Studies•2016

  • Men and the Drug Buzz

    Open Access•Clay Darcy•Sociological Research Online•2020

  • The Strength to Diet

    Open Access•Warren Jensen•Men and Masculinities•2023

  • Fighting for Masculine Hegemony

    Open Access•Jillian Sunderland•Men and Masculinities•2023

  • Masculine Maneuvers

    Open Access•Trenton M Haltom•Men and Masculinities•2022

  • Trans Manhood

    Open Access•Baker A Rogers•Men and Masculinities•2022

  • Valorizing Trump's Masculine Self

    Open Access•Pierce Dignam, Douglas Schrock et al.•Men and Masculinities•2021

  • The Unsung Heroes of Ireland

    Open Access•David Ralph•Men and Masculinities•2020

  • TheFappening

    Open Access•Mairead Eastin Moloney, Mairead Moloney et al.•Men and Masculinities•2018

  • Losing Manhood Like a Man

    Open Access•R T Cragun, J E Sumerau•Men and Masculinities•2017

  • The Limited Construction of an Egalitarian Masculinity

    Open Access•Ellen Lamont•Men and Masculinities•2015

  • Compromising Positions

    Open Access•Beth A Eck•Men and Masculinities•2014

  • Weaponized Subordination

    Open Access•Marjorie Halpin•Gender & Society•2022

  • From the Guest Editors

    Open Access•Nancy A Naples, Laura Mauldin et al.•Gender & Society•2019

  • (Re)Fashioning Masculinity

    Open Access•Ben Barry•Gender & Society•2018

  • Sensitive Cowboys

    Open Access•Jessica Pfaffendorf•Gender & Society•2017

  • Male Dominance under Threat

    Open Access•E Hertzog, A Lev•Journal of Contemporary Ethnography•2019

  • Methodological Impression Management in Ethnographic Research

    Open Access•Amanda M Gengler, Matthew B Ezzell et al.•Journal of Contemporary Ethnography•2018

  • Diversifying Feminist Ethnographers' Dilemmas and Solutions

    Open Access•Douglas Schrock, Amanda Koontz Anthony•Journal of Contemporary Ethnography•2013

  • Whose Feminism? Whose Dilemma

    Open Access•Nancy A Naples•Journal of Contemporary Ethnography•2013

  • Desire, Rights, Entitlements

    Poulami Roychowdhury•Signs: Journal of Women in…•2016

  • Brotherhood and sexism as manhood acts for trans men in the Southeastern United States

    Megan Y Phillips, Baker A Rogers•Sociological Spectrum•2021

  • Gender Differences in Reactions to Mental Illness Labeling

    Chivon H Fitch, Jessica L Burke et al.•Deviant Behavior•2019

  • Music and the Social Construction of Self

    Open Access•J E Sumerau, Lain A B Mathers•Symbolic Interaction•2025

  • Undermining the Moral Obligations of Manhood Acts

    Open Access•Chris M Vidmar•Symbolic Interaction•2024

  • Code of the street

    Elijah Anderson•Code of the street•1999

  • The gender knot

    Allan G Johnson•The gender knot•1997

  • Deep Down in the Jungle

    Roger D Abrahams•Deep Down in the Jungle•1970

  • Cool pose

    Richard Majors•Cool pose•1992

  • Paradoxes of gender

    Judith Lorber•Paradoxes of gender•1994

  • The Therapeutic Community

    George De Leon, Frank M Tims et al.•Therapeutic Community•2000

  • A systematic review of drug court effects on recidivism

    Open Access•David B Wilson, Ojmarrh Mitchell et al.•Journal of Experimental Criminology•2007

  • Learning to Labor

    Paul E Willis, Paul Willis•Learning to Labour•2017

  • Managing the Shopfloor

    David L Collinson, David Collinson•Managing the Shopfloor•1992

  • "Playing the Dozens"

    Harry G Lefever•Phylon (1960•1981

  • Fast Food, Fast Talk

    Robin Leidner•Fast Food, Fast Talk•1994

  • Be Not Deceived

    M Wolkomir•Be Not Deceived•2019

  • Emotions and Fieldwork

    Sherryl Kleinman, Martha Copp•Emotions and fieldwork•1993

  • In Search of Respect

    Open Access•P Bourgois, Philippe I Bourgois•In Search of Respect•2002

  • The Managed Heart

    Arlie Russell Hochschild•Managed Heart•2003

  • The Dozens

    Open Access•Amuzie Chimezie•Journal of Black Studies•1976

  • Naming Men as Men

    Open Access•David Collinson, J Hearn•Gender Work and Organization•1994

  • Women in Prison

    Stephanie S Covington•Women & Therapy•1998

  • Proving Manhood

    Øystein Gullvåg Holter, Oystein G Holter et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1998

  • Sociological Analysis

    Arun Sahay•Sociological Analysis•2023

  • Emotional Capital and Professional Socialization

    Spencer E Cahill•Social Psychology Quarterly•1999

  • Mass Imprisonment

    David Garland•Mass Imprisonment•2001

  • Ribbin', Jivin', and Playin' the Dozens, The Unrecognized Dilemma of Inner City Schools

    Carol Camp Yeakey, Herbert L Foster•The Journal of Negro Education•1976

  • Playing the Dozens

    Roger D Abrahams•Journal of American Folklore•1962

  • Mind, Self, and Society

    George Herbert Mead, Charles W Morris•Mind, self, and society•1967

  • Asylums

    Erving Goffman, David Dutton et al.•Asylums•2017

  • Dude, You're a Fag

    C J Pascoe•Dude, You're a Fag•2020

  • Generic Processes in the Reproduction of Inequality

    Michael Schwalbe, Sandra Godwin et al.•Social Forces•2000

  • Structural Dissensus in the Therapeutic Community

    Edmund G Doherty, Joseph Harry•Journal of Health and Social…•1976

  • Gay and Greek

    King-To Yeung, Mindy Stombler•Social Problems•2000

  • The Inexpressive Male

    Jack W Sattel•Social Problems•1976

  • Managing the Emotions of Others

    Open Access•P A Thoits•Symbolic Interaction•1996

  • Masculinity in the Workplace

    Open Access•Hernan Ramirez, Hernán Cardona Ramírez•Men and Masculinities•2011

  • Peacekeepers, Masculinities, and Sexual Exploitation

    Open Access•Paul Higate•Men and Masculinities•2007

  • Hey Brother, How's Your Health

    Open Access•Michael Royster, Michael O Royster et al.•Men and Masculinities•2006

  • Teaching about Being an Oppressor

    Open Access•Steven P Schacht•Men and Masculinities•2001

  • Lives at the Center of the Periphery, Lives at the Periphery of the Center

    Open Access•Anthony S Chen•Gender & Society•1999

  • Misogyny on and Off the 'Pitch

    Open Access•Steven P Schacht•Gender & Society•1996

  • Class-Based Masculinities

    Open Access•Karen D Pyke, Karen Pyke•Gender & Society•1996

  • Doing Gender

    Open Access•Candace West, Don H Zimmerman•Gender & Society•1987

  • Getting Gut-Level

    Open Access•Allison Mckim•Gender & Society•2008

  • Negotiating Hegemonic Masculinity in a Batterer Intervention Program

    Open Access•Douglas P Schrock, Douglas Schrock et al.•Gender & Society•2007

  • Hegemonic Masculinity

    Open Access•R Connell, R W Connell et al.•Gender & Society•2005

  • Beards, Breasts, and Bodies

    Open Access•R Dozier•Gender & Society•2005

  • Gang-Related Gun Violence

    Open Access•Paul B Stretesky, Mark R Pogrebin•Journal of Contemporary Ethnography•2007

  • Embodied Surveillance And The Gendering Of Punishment

    Open Access•Jill A Mccorkel, Jill Mccorkel•Journal of Contemporary Ethnography•2003

  • Men, Masculinity, and Manhood Acts

    Douglas Schrock, Michael Schwalbe•Annual Review of Sociology•2009

  • The dramatisation of emotions in practice and theory

    Open Access•Juniper Wiley•Sociology of Health & Illness•1990

  • Conditions of Successful Degradation Ceremonies

    Harold Garfinkel•American Journal of Sociology•1956

  • The arrangement between the sexes

    Open Access•Erving Goffman•Theory and Society•1977

Unique citing works55
Citations per year4,23
Citation span2013 - 2026 (14)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 55

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae