Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Dynamics of the Greek ‘Breakthrough’

The dialogue between philosophy and religion

Bibliographic Data

ID23698486
AuthorsS C Humphreys (0009-0003-5986-9907, corresponding author)
Year2004
Pages51-76
Publication date2004-09-30
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeCHAPTER
VenueThe strangeness of gods (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherOxford University PressOxford (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199269235.003.0003
OpenAlexW2488880238
ISBN9780199269235
LanguageEN
Citations received4
References cited293

This chapter traces the construction in the 6th-5th centuries BCE of the opposition between rationality and irrationality, associated with the development of prose as a medium for the rational logos, which generated changes in conceptions of poetry and of religion. The chapter stresses that the emergence of polemical rationalism did not eliminate religious thought (let alone poetry) from the mainstream of Greek culture. Rather, it produced tendencies to rationalize cult in the public sphere through the introduction of deified personifications such as Peace or Concord, and in unofficial circles by the systematization of astrology and the interpretation of omens. It also stimulated more abstract, ‘philosophical’ conceptions of the divine, and an interest in the psychology of ‘possession’ (love, poetic inspiration, madness, drunkenness). Euripides is valued as a religious thinker, and Lycurgus as a reformer of Athenian ritual.

Art · Astrology · Cult · Epistemology · Irrational number · Irrationality · Literature · Opposition (politics) · Poetry · Politics · Possession (linguistics) · Rationality · Theology · Biblical Studies and Interpretation · Classical Antiquity Studies · Historical, Religious, and Philosophical Studies · Law · Philosophy

  • Alexander and Ashoka compared

    James Flynn•History and Anthropology•2026

  • Frommythostologos

    Open Access•Kenneth W Yu•Modern Intellectual History•2015

  • Sacred space and the city

    Open Access•Michael H Jameson•International Journal of Hindu…•1997

  • The Idea of Negative Platonism

    Open Access•Johann P Arnason•Thesis Eleven•2007

  • Much maligned monsters

    Partha Mitter•Much maligned monsters•1977

  • Natural particulars

    Anthony Grafton, Nancy G Siraisi•Natural particulars•1999

  • La formation des noms en grec ancien

    Pierre Chantraine•La formation des noms en grec…•1968

  • The grand procession of Ptolemy Philadelphus

    E E Rice•The grand procession of Ptolemy…•1983

  • Painting and experience in fifteenth century Italy

    Michael Baxandall•Painting and experience in…•1988

  • Family fortunes

    Catherine Hall, Leonore Davidoff•Family fortunes•1987

  • The Written word

    Gerd Baumann•The Written word•1986

  • On Aristotle and Greek tragedy

    John Jones•On Aristotle and Greek tragedy•1980

  • Orchestra

    Open Access•Anton Bierl, Peter von Möllendorff•Orchestra•1994

  • The Invention of Pornography

    Lynn Hunt•Invention of Pornography, 1500-1800•1993

  • Worshipping Virtues

    Emma Stafford•Worshipping Virtues•2000

  • John Wilkes

    Peter D G Thomas•John Wilkes, a friend to liberty•1996

  • From Myth to Reason?

    Richard Buxton•From myth to reason?•1999

  • Children and Childhood in Classical Athens

    Mark Golden•Children and childhood in…•1990

  • Alexander the Great Part 2

    Open Access•A B Bosworth•The Cambridge Ancient History…•1994

  • Shaftesbury and the Culture of Politeness

    Open Access•Lawrence E Klein•Shaftesbury and the Culture of…•1994

  • Reading Greek Tragedy

    Open Access•Simon Goldhill•Reading Greek Tragedy•1986

  • Greek Nymphs

    J Larson•Greek Nymphs•2001

  • Beyond Translation

    Open Access•Alton Becker, Alton L Becker•Beyond Translation•1995

  • The practice turn in contemporary theory

    Open Access•Alexander Styhre•Scandinavian Journal of Management•2003

  • Johann Georg Hamann

    Open Access•Sven-Aage Jorgensen•Johann Georg Hamann•1976

  • Provincializing Europe

    Dipesh Chakrabarty•Provincializing Europe•2000

  • Primitive Rebels, Studies in Archaic Forms of Social Movement in the 19th and 20th Centuries

    Eric Hobsbawm•Primitive Rebels, Studies in…•2021

  • Die Entstehung des Politischen bei den Griechen.

    Christian Meier•Die Entstehung des Politischen…•1983

  • Continuity and change in Roman religion

    J H W G Liebeschuetz•Continuity and change in Roman…•1979

  • Pictorial dictionary of ancient Athens

    Iōannēs N Traulos•Pictorial dictionary of ancient…•1980

  • Literacy and Orality in Ancient Greece

    Open Access•Rosalind Thomas•Literacy and Orality in Ancient…•1992

  • Oral Tradition and Written Record in Classical Athens

    Open Access•Rosalind Thomas•Oral Tradition and Written Record…•1989

  • The fragments of attic comedy after Meineke, Bergk, and Kock

    J M Edmonds•The fragments of attic comedy…•1959

  • Du nouveau sur les courses aux flambeaux d'après deux inscriptions de Kos

    Philippe Gauthier•Revue des Études Grecques•1995

  • Théologia

    Victor Goldschmidt•Revue des Études Grecques•1950

  • Corpus Paroemiographorum Graecorum

    Open Access•Ernst Ludwig von Leutsch, F G Schneidewin•Corpus Paroemiographorum…•2010

  • Reading Neoplatonism

    Open Access•Sara Rappe•Reading Neoplatonism•2000

  • A Historical Commentary on Thucydides

    Malcolm F Mcgregor, A W Gomme•The American Journal of Philology•1958

  • Classics in Russia 1700-1855

    Marinus A Wes•Classics in Russia 1700-1855•1992

  • Two Doxographical Notes

    Albert Henrichs•Harvard Studies in Classical…•1975

  • The Rosicrucian Enlightenment

    Frances Yates, Frances Amelia Yates•Rosicrucian Enlightenment•2003

  • The Consolation of Philosophy

    P G Walsh•Boethius•1999

  • Female Speech in Menander

    Open Access•David Bain•Antichthon•1984

  • Myth and Philosophy from the Presocratics to Plato

    Open Access•Kathryn A Morgan•Myth and Philosophy from the…•2000

  • Beobachtungen zur Funktion der Analogie im Denken Herders

    Hans Dietrich Irmscher•Deutsche Vierteljahrsschrift für…•1981

  • Knowledge and Language

    Open Access•F R Ankersmit, J J A Mooij•Knowledge and Language•1993

  • Myth, Allegory and Argument in Plato

    Mary Margaret Mccabe•Apeiron•1992

  • Philosophy and its history

    Open Access•Charles Taylor•Philosophy in History•1984

  • The Play of Character in Plato's Dialogues

    Open Access•Ruby Blondell•Play of Character in Plato's…•2002

  • Inventing Assyria

    Frederick N Bohrer•The Art Bulletin•1998

  • The Ephebes of Erechtheis, 333/2 B.C. and their dedication

    Open Access•Olga Palagia, David Lewis•The Annual of the British School…•1989

  • Regional Schools in Hellenistic Sculpture

    Olga Palagia, william coulson•Regional Schools in Hellenistic…•2017

  • The axial age

    Open Access•Shmuel N Eisenstadt•European Journal of Sociology•1982

  • Rethinking Anthropology

    E R Leach•Rethinking Anthropology•2021

  • Anonymity and polarity

    Albert Henrichs•Greek Myth and Religion•2019

  • Hands in Greek Epigraphy - Demetrios of Phaleron

    Steven V Tracy•Boeotia Antiqua IV•1994

  • Heritage and Hellenism

    Erich S Gruen•Heritage and Hellenism•1998

  • Guardians of Language

    Robert A Kaster•Guardians of Language•1988

  • Personal Religion Among the Greeks

    André-Jean Festugière•Personal Religion among the Greeks•1954

  • Money and the Corrosion of Power in Thucydides

    Lisa Kallet•Money and the Corrosion of Power…•2001

  • Reflections of Women in Antiquity

    Helene P Foley, Helene Foley•Reflections of Women in Antiquity•2013

  • Characterization and Individuality in Greek Literature

    C B R Pelling, Christopher Pelling•Characterization and individuality…•2009

  • Vom Ursprung und Ziel der Geschichte

    Karl Jaspers, Kurt Salamun•Vom Ursprung und Ziel der…•2017

  • Outline of a Theory of Practice

    Open Access•Pierre Bourdieu, Richard Nice•On Violence•2007

  • The New Brahmans

    D D Karve, Ellen E Mcdonald•New Brahmans•1963

  • The Power of Money

    Thomas J Figueira, Thomas Figueira•Power of Money•1998

  • Greek Thought, Arabic Culture

    Dimitri Gutas•Greek Thought, Arabic Culture•2012

  • Tradition as Truth and Communication

    Open Access•P Boyer•Tradition as Truth and…•1990

  • Wages, Welfare Costs and Inflation in Classical Athens

    William T Loomis, William Loomis•Wages, welfare costs, and…•1999

  • The Dionysiac mysteries of the Hellenistic and Roman age

    Open Access•Martin Nilsson, Martin P Nilsson•Dionysiac Mysteries of the…•1957

  • Aristophanes

    Open Access•A M Bowie•Aristophanes•1993

  • Confucian China and its Modern Fate

    Joseph R Levenson•Confucian China and its Modern Fate•2013

  • Les Jardins d'Adonis

    Marcel Detienne•Les jardins d'Adonis•1972

  • Die Symbolik des Traumes

    Open Access•Gotthilf Heinrich von Schubert•Die Symbolik des Traumes•2011

  • Collection Paul Canellopoulos (I). Armes et lébès de bronze

    Pierre Amandry•Bulletin de correspondance…•1971

  • Early Greek elegy, symposium and public festival

    Open Access•E L Bowie•The Journal of Hellenic Studies•1986

  • Greek Thought, Arabic Culture

    Dimitri Gutas•Greek Thought, Arabic Culture•1988

  • Fetish, Recognition, Revolution

    Open Access•James T Siegel•Fetish, Recognition, Revolution•1997

  • Radical Enlightenment

    Jonathan I Israel, Jonathan Israel•Radical Enlightenment•2001

  • Demystifying Mentalities

    Open Access•G E R Lloyd, Geoffrey E R Lloyd et al.•Demystifying Mentalities•1990

  • The Shaping of Deduction in Greek Mathematics

    Open Access•Reviel Netz•Shaping of Deduction in Greek…•1999

  • The Pnyx in Models

    Homer A Thompson•Hesperia Supplements•1982

  • The Leasing of Land in Rhamnous

    Michael H Jameson•Hesperia Supplements•1982

  • Epistolary Bodies

    Sarah R Marino, Elizabeth Heckendorn Cook•South Atlantic Review•1997

  • Authenticating Culture in Imperial Japan

    Leslie Pincus•Authenticating Culture in…•1996

  • Painting and the Politics of Culture

    Andrew Hemingway, John Barrell•Eighteenth-Century Studies•1993

  • Les Asklepieis de l'Archipel

    Louis Robert•Revue des Études Grecques•1933

  • Personal Religion among the Greeks

    Francis R Walton•The Classical Weekly•1955

  • Athen und Alexander

    Stanley M Burstein, Wolfgang Will•The American Historical Review•1985

  • Regulations for an Athenian Festival

    Michael B Walbank•Hesperia Supplements•1982

  • La querelle philologique du mythe. Les termes d'un débat en Allemagne et en France au début du siècle dernier

    Open Access•Pierre Judet De La Combe, Pierre Combe•Revue germanique internationale•1995

  • Hellenistic Poetry and Homer

    Giuseppe Giangrande•L antiquité classique•1970

  • Thucididean time-reckoning and Euctemon's seasonal calendar

    W Kendrick Pritchett, B L Van Der Waerden•Bulletin de correspondance…•1961

  • The Greater Demarkhia of Erchia

    Sterling Dow•Bulletin de correspondance…•1965

  • Inscriptions de Delphes

    Georges Daux•Bulletin de correspondance…•1954

  • Notes on the Sacrificial Calendar from Erchia

    Michael H Jameson•Bulletin de correspondance…•1965

  • Inscriptions de Delphes

    Jean Bousquet•Bulletin de correspondance…•1959

  • Notes de lecture

    Georges Daux•Bulletin de correspondance…•1970

  • L'inscription généalogique de Cyrène (SGDI 4859)

    Olivier Masson•Bulletin de correspondance…•1974

  • Delphes et les Aglaurides d'Athènes

    Jean Bousquet•Bulletin de correspondance…•1964

  • Le culte de Pluton dans la religion éleusinienne

    Paul-François Foucart•Bulletin de correspondance…•1883

  • Specimens of Antient Sculpture

    Open Access•Alison Ballantyne, Andrew Ballantyne•Art History•2002

  • Persuasions of the Witch's Craft

    Helen A Berger, T M Luhrmann•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1990

  • From Ausonius' Schooldays? A Schoolbook and its Relatives

    Open Access•A C Dionisotti•The Journal of Roman Studies•1982

Unique citing works4
Citations per year0,14
Citation span1997 - 2026 (30)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 4

Tools

Open DOILibgen
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae