Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

An Initial Assessment of the Consequences of MMP in New Zealand

Bibliographic Data

ID23746321
AuthorsFiona Barker (0000-0002-7856-2922), Jonathan Boston, Stephen Levine, Elizabeth Mcleay, Nigel S Roberts
Year2003
Pages297-322
Publication date2003-02-06
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeCHAPTER
VenueMixed-Member Electoral Systems (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherOxford University PressOxford (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1093/019925768x.003.0015
OpenAlexW2483888855
ISBN9780199257683
LanguageEN
Citations received8
References cited196

The purpose is to provide an initial assessment of the impact of the introduction of the mixed‐member proportional (MMP) electoral system on the New Zealand political system, especially with regard to the normative criteria established by the New Zealand Royal Commission on the Electoral System. However, since the normative nature of these criteria may limit the breadth of any analysis (they are not necessarily comprehensive and unambiguous, nor do they provide a watertight framework for evaluation), this particular discussion of the impact of MMP on the New Zealand political system is left until the last section. The bulk of the chapter instead employs the findings of political scientists on the relationships between electoral systems, political behavior, and political institutions. These are presented in 10 sections: Anticipating the New Electoral System; The Election and Government Formation; The Political Parties and the Party System; Political Recruitment and Careers; Voting Behavior; Parliament; Government Transition and Durability; Government and the Policy Process; The Future of the New Electoral System; and Winners and Losers. The authors make the point that (as in Germany) personalized geographic representation has continued even as the overall system has been made more proportional.

Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Environmental Science · Populism, Right-Wing Movements · Social Policy and Reform Studies

  • Electoral Systems and Substantive Representation of Women

    Manon Tremblay•Commonwealth and Comparative…•2007

  • Natural because it had become just that.’ Path dependence in pre-electoral pacts and government formation

    Tim Bale, Jonathan Boston et al.•Australian Journal of Political…•2005

  • Challenging the Odds

    Open Access•Zsófia Papp•East European Politics and…•2017

  • Voice and trust in parliamentary representation

    Open Access•Kris Dunn•Electoral Studies•2012

  • Incentives in Mixed-Member Electoral Systems

    Open Access•Brian F Crisp•Comparative Political Studies•2007

  • An Exploration of the Use of Facebook by Legislators in Taiwan

    Kah-Yew Lim•Issues & Studies•2018

  • The political consequences of changes in district magnitude

    Open Access•Philipp Harfst•Acta Politica•2017

  • Does Electoral System Reform Work? Electoral System Lessons from Reforms of the 1990s

    Ethan Scheiner•Annual Review of Political Science•2008

  • New trends in Canadian federalism

    François Rocher, Miriam Catherine Smith•New trends in Canadian federalism•2003

  • Southern politics in State and Nation

    V O Key•Southern politics in State and…•1949

  • Constitutional odyssey

    Peter H Russell•Constitutional odyssey•1993

  • Federalism and the role of the state

    Herman Bakvis•Federalism and the role of the…•1987

  • Democracy, Italian style

    Joseph Lapalombara•Democracy, Italian style•1987

  • New Zealand

    George Augustus Selwyn•New Zealand•2011

  • The Personal Vote

    Bruce E Cain, Bruce Cain et al.•Personal Vote•1987

  • The Efficient Secret

    Open Access•Gary W Cox•Efficient Secret•1987

  • Presidents and Assemblies

    Open Access•Matthew Soberg Shugart, John Michael Carey•Presidents and Assemblies•1992

  • Parties and Leaders in the Postreform House

    David W Rohde•Parties and leaders in the…•1991

  • Term Limits and Legislative Representation

    Open Access•John Michael Carey•Term Limits and Legislative…•1996

  • Making and Breaking Governments

    Open Access•Michael Laver, Kenneth A Shepsle•Making and Breaking Governments•1996

  • Making Votes Count

    Open Access•Gary W Cox•Making Votes Count•1997

  • Electoral Systems and Party Systems

    Arend Lijphart•Electoral systems and party systems•1994

  • Why Parties?

    John H Aldrich•Why Parties?•1995

  • Presidentialism and Democracy in Latin America

    Open Access•Scott Mainwaring, Matthew Soberg Shugart•Presidentialism and Democracy in…•1997

  • Democracy and Elections

    Richard S Katz•Democracy and elections•1997

  • Political parties and political development

    Joseph Lapalombara, Myron Weiner•Political parties and political…•1969

  • Agendas, alternatives, and public policies

    John W Kingdon•Agendas, alternatives, and public…•1995

  • Political Equality and Election Systems

    Jonathan W Still•Ethics•1981

  • Politics after Hitler

    Open Access•D Rogers, Daniel E Rogers•Politics after Hitler•1995

  • Obstacles to Electoral Reform in Canada

    Henry Milner•The American Review of Canadian…•1994

  • Trends in Israeli Democracy

    Yochanan Peres, Ephraim Yuchtman Yaar•Trends in Israeli Democracy•1992

  • Israeli Democracy Under Stress

    Myron J Aronoff, Vernon Bogdanor et al.•Israeli Democracy Under Stress•1993

  • How the Conservatives Rule Japan

    Nathaniel Bowman Thayer•How the Conservatives Rule Japan•2015

  • Political reform in Japan

    Steven R Reed, S Reed•Social Science Japan Journal•1999

  • Institutional Design, Uncertainty, and Path Dependency during Transitions

    Open Access•Michael Mcfaul•Constitutional Political Economy•1999

  • Mixed Electoral Systems in Britain and the Jenkins Commission on Electoral Reform

    Open Access•Patrick Dunleavy, Helen Z Margetts•The British Journal of Politics…•1999

  • British Voters and Their Criteria for Evaluating Electoral Systems

    Open Access•David M Farrell, Michael Gallagher•The British Journal of Politics…•1999

  • Sex, money and politics

    David M Farrell, I Mcallister et al.•Journal of Elections Public…•1998

  • Hungary's Road to Systemic Change

    Open Access•Andras Bozoki•East European Politics and…•1993

  • How Ottawa Spends

    R W Crowley, Susan D Phillips•Canadian Public Policy•1994

  • The Impact of Electoral Reform on the Public Service

    Open Access•Jonathan Boston, Stephen Levine et al.•Australian Journal of Public…•1998

  • Electoral law, electoral behaviour and electoral outcomes

    Clive Bean•The Journal of Commonwealth &…•1986

  • Italy

    Open Access•Luciano Bardi•European Journal of Political…•1992

  • The demise of the last westminster system? Comments on the report of New Zealand's Royal Commission on the Electoral System

    Open Access•Arend Lijphart•Electoral Studies•1987

  • Minority government and majority rule

    Steven M Delue•History of European Ideas•1991

  • Congress, The Electoral Connection

    Michael J Ross, David R Mayhew•The Western Political Quarterly•1975

  • The Formation of Political Parties and the First National Elections in Russia

    Thomas Fallows, Terence Emmons•The Russian Review•1984

  • Democracy and Elections

    Open Access•Mark P Jones•Political Science Quarterly•1999

  • How Many Parties will New Zealand have under MMP

    Open Access•Jack H Nagel•Political Science•1994

  • Women and the Problem of Parliamentary Representation

    Open Access•Elizabeth Mcleay•Political Science•1993

  • Programmatic Intransigence and the Limits of the Modern Campaign

    Open Access•David Denemark•Political Science•1994

  • Party Identification and Voting Behaviour in New Zealand

    Open Access•James W Lamare•Political Science•1984

  • The Political Consequences of Labour’s New Right Agenda

    Open Access•David Denemark•Political Science•1990

  • Social Structure and Political Attitudes

    Open Access•Jack Vowles•Political Science•1987

  • Voter Turnout in New Zealand General Elections, 1928-1988

    Open Access•Jack H Nagel•Political Science•1988

  • Parties, Policies, and Personalities

    Open Access•Stephen Levine, Nigel S Roberts•Political Science•1987

  • Second-Class MPs’? New Zealand’s Adaptation to Mixed-Member Parliamentary Representation

    Open Access•Leigh J Ward•Political Science•1998

  • Thatcherism and Rogernomics

    Open Access•Jonathan Boston•Political Science•1987

  • Waiting for Change

    Open Access•Stuart Weir•The Political Quarterly•1992

  • Japan's Political Marketplace

    E B Keehn, J Mark Ramseyer et al.•Monumenta Nipponica•1994

  • Critical Elections and Congressional Policy Making

    James T Currie, D Brady et al.•Journal of American History•1989

  • German Electoral Politics

    John S Conway, Uwe Kitzinger et al.•International Journal Canada s…•1960

  • Return to diversity

    Gabriel Partos•International Affairs•1990

  • Italy—Republic Without Government

    Muriel Grindrod•International Affairs•1974

  • Political Parties

    Brian Chapman•International Affairs•1955

  • Reflections on reforming the Canadian electoral system

    Open Access•John C Courtney•Canadian Public Administration•1980

  • Social Democracy and Contextual Unemployment

    David Denemark•Australian Geographer•1999

  • Ghost-Hunting

    James J Foster, James J S Foster•Asian Survey•1982

  • Japan's LDP Considers Electoral Reform

    Eugene L Wolfe, Eugene L Wolfe Eugene L Wolfe•Asian Survey•1992

  • The Voters Decide

    Open Access•Michael Marsh•European Journal of Political…•1985

  • The Dynamics of European Party Systems

    Open Access•Mogens N Pedersen•European Journal of Political…•1979

  • Independents and Party Formation

    Robert G Moser•Comparative Politics•1999

  • Counting the Number of Parties

    Open Access•Juan Molinar•American Political Science Review•1991

  • Belgian paradoxes

    John Fitzmaurice•West European Politics•1992

  • MMP — Has it delivered, should it continue?1

    Rod Donald•Representation•1998

  • Comparing electoral systems

    Duncan Watts•Representation•1998

  • Making votes count

    Michael Meadowcroft•Representation•1998

  • The international Idea handbook of electoral system design

    Paul Wilder•Representation•1999

  • Gubernatorial Elections in Russia, 1996-1997

    Steven L Solnick•Post-Soviet Affairs•1998

  • Instability and Fragmentation

    Open Access•Peter Reddaway•Journal of democracy•1994

  • Voter Responses to Electoral Complexity

    Open Access•Kathleen Bawn•British Journal of Political…•1999

  • Electoral Systems and the Number of Parties in Postcommunist States

    Open Access•Robert G Moser•World Politics•1999

  • Mobilization, Social Networks, and Turnout

    Open Access•Gary W Cox, Frances Mccall Rosenbluth et al.•World Politics•1998

  • Congruence between Citizens and Policymakers in Two Visions of Liberal Democracy

    Open Access•John D Huber, G Bingham Powell•World Politics•1994

  • Electoral transition’ and party system change in Italy

    Roberto D’alimonte, Roberto D''Alimonte et al.•West European Politics•1997

  • Electoral Institutions and Party Cohesion in the Russian Duma

    Moshe Haspel, Thomas F Remington et al.•The Journal of Politics•1998

  • Electoral Rules, Constituency Pressures, and Pork Barrel

    Barry Ames•The Journal of Politics•1995

  • Consensus and Consensus Democracy

    Open Access•Arend Lijphart•Scandinavian Political Studies•1998

  • Enthusiasm and entropy

    Jonathan Boston, Stephen Levine et al.•Representation•1998

  • The last Westminster electoral system? Canada, not Britain

    Open Access•Donley T Studlar•Representation•1998

  • The‐Devil‐you‐know factor

    Peter Kellner•Representation•1992

  • Choosing an electoral system for elections to conflict‐resolution negotiations

    Richard Sinnott, Richard O Sinnott•Representation•1997

  • The implications for political accommodation in northern Ireland of reforming the electoral system for the Westminster parliament1

    Brendan O''Leary, Brian O’leary et al.•Representation•1998

  • Reform of New Zealand's voting system, 1985–1996

    Malcolm Mackerras•Representation•1994

  • Why did New Zealand adopt German‐style proportional representation

    Jonathan Boston, Stephen Levine et al.•Representation•1996

  • Making votes count’ ‐ a critique

    Crispin Allard•Representation•1998

  • December 1993 as a Replication of Late-Soviet Electoral Practices

    Michael A Urban, Michael Urban•Post-Soviet Affairs•1994

  • Russia's Party System

    Peter C Ordeshook•Post-Soviet Affairs•1996

  • The Roots of Polarization

    George W Breslauer•Post-Soviet Affairs•1993

  • Party Strategy and Voter Organization under Cumulative Voting in Victorian England

    Open Access•Shaun Bowler, Todd Donovan et al.•Political Studies•1999

  • The Electoral Foundations of Japan's Banking Regulation

    Open Access•Frances Mccall Rosenbluth, Frances Rosenbluth et al.•Policy Studies Journal•2001

  • Mobilizing Demobilized Voters in Post-Communist Societies

    Open Access•Richard Rose•Party Politics•1995

  • Does Center Equal Middle

    Open Access•Reuven Y Hazan•Party Politics•1996

  • Providing Clear Cues

    Open Access•Steven R Reed•Party Politics•1997

  • Crisis of Parties and Change of Party System in Italy

    Open Access•Leonardo Morlino•Party Politics•1996

  • The Politics of Electoral Reform in Great Britain and the United States

    Lowrence D Longley•Parliamentary Affairs•1988

  • As a Matter of Factions

    Open Access•Mathew D Mccubbins, Michael F Thies et al.•Legislative Studies Quarterly•1997

  • The Development of Parliamentary Parties in Russia

    Open Access•Thomas F Remington, Stephanie S Smith et al.•Legislative Studies Quarterly•1995

Unique citing works8
Citations per year0,38
Citation span2005 - 2018 (14)
Citation velocityhistorical
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 3

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae