Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Rethinking Political Myth

The Clash of Civilizations as a Self-Fulfilling Prophecy

Bibliographic Data

ID2397728
AuthorsChiara Bottici (UNIVERSITY OF FLORENCE AND EUROPEAN UNIVERSITY INSTITUTE, FLORENCE, ITALY), Benoît Challand (0000-0003-1510-5430, UNIVERSITY OF FLORENCE AND EUROPEAN UNIVERSITY INSTITUTE, FLORENCE, ITALY)
Year2006
Volume9
Issue3
Pages315-336
Publication date2006-08-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEuropean Journal of Social Theory (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1368-4310 • E-ISSN: 1461-7137
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/1368431006065715
OpenAlexW2016345961
LanguageEN
Citations received60
References cited22

This article argues for the need to recover the concept of political myth in order to understand the crucial phenomena of our epoch. By drawing on Blumenberg's philosophical reflections on myth, it proposes to understand political myth as the continual process of work on a common narrative by which the members of a social group can provide significance to their political conditions and experience. In order to show how this understanding of political myth can throw light on important aspects of contemporary politics, the article analyses the work on one of the most conspicuous political myths of our time: the clash of civilizations. By reconstructing the mechanisms through which this myth works, the article shows how a paradigm that has been strongly criticized as too simplistic and scientifically inadequate could have turned into a successful political myth, i.e. into a self-fulfilling prophecy

Epistemology · Mythology · Narrative · Order (exchange · Political science · Politics · Social science · Sociology · Hannah Arendt's Political Philosophy · Humanities and Social Sciences · Populism, Right-Wing Movements · Law · Philosophy

  • A Philosophy of Political Myth

    Open Access•Chiara Bottici•A Philosophy of Political Myth•2007

  • What kind of ‘world order’? An artificial neural networks approach to intensive data mining

    Open Access•Massimo Buscema, Guido Ferilli et al.•Technological Forecasting and…•2017

  • Monumental mythologies in the Baghdadi relief murals of Mohammed Ghani Hikmat

    Tiffany Floyd•Journal of Contemporary Iraq &…•2025

  • Relationship between Islam and the West

    Open Access•Edi Kurniawan•Journal of Islamic Civilization•2023

  • A Semiotic Analysis on the Myths in the Election Campaign of Female Politicians

    Open Access•Pune KARIMI, Raci Taşcıoğlu•İran Çalışmaları Dergisi•2023

  • Civilizational Perspectives of the Belt and Road Initiative

    B He•China and the World•2021

  • The Global Regulation of “Fake News” in the Time of Oxymora

    Open Access•Rostam J Neuwirth•International Journal for the…•2022

  • Worldviews and Conflict Analysis

    Open Access•Mona Kanwal Sheikh•Negotiation Journal•2022

  • Mythologizing war

    Michal Mochtak•Journal of Southeast European and…•2020

  • Myth in International Politics

    Open Access•Berit Bliesemann De Guevara•Myth and Narrative in International…•2016

  • A Philosophy of Political Myth

    Chiara Bottici•A Philosophy of Political Myth•2007

  • Invoking Churchill

    Open Access•Thomas Eason, Artur Nadiiev•The British Journal of Politics…•2026

  • Spiritual Values, Religious Practices, and Democratic Attitudes

    Open Access•Myunghee Kim, Myung-Hee Kim•Politics and Religion•2008

  • Representing Islam and Muslims in New Zealand Newspapers

    Shah Nister Kabir, Michael Bourk•Institute of Muslim Minority…•2012

  • Between history and literature

    Open Access•Juan Osorio, Juan David Osorio•Historia Crítica•2024

  • Technology assessment as a myth buster

    Open Access•Helge Torgersen, Daniela Fuchs•Journal of Responsible Innovation•2017

  • Intermarium in the current Polish foreign policy debate

    Open Access•Alicja McGarrigle•Journal of Contemporary Central…•2025

  • The Mediterranean, between unity and fault line

    Federica Bicchi•Global Affairs•2018

  • Political Discussion on Social Media and the Public Sphere

    Open Access•Sarah Brenne•Sociology and Anthropology•2016

  • Beyond staged retreat behind virtual ‘gender paradigm’ barricades

    Steve Moxon•Journal of Aggression Conflict…•2011

  • Examining the Danish cartoon affair

    Open Access•Shawn Powers•Media War & Conflict•2008

  • We are all children of the commonwealth’

    Open Access•Mark Ølholm Eaton•British Politics•2019

  • Introducing Myth to Foreign Policy Analysis

    Open Access•Thomas Eason•Foreign Policy Analysis•2023

  • Does Tanzania's Development Trajectory Borrow from the China Model

    Open Access•Abel Kinyondo•Politics & Policy•2020

  • Political Myth as Strategic Communication

    Lingzi Zhong, Juyan Zhang•International Journal of…•2016

  • Myth of the near future? Assessing the European Green Deal’s potential to become a political myth for the European Union

    Open Access•Jeremy Moulton•Journal of Contemporary European…•2023

  • Philosophies of Political Myth, a Comparative Look Backwards

    Open Access•Chiara Bottici•European Journal of Political…•2009

  • Realist-normative power Europe? Explaining EU policies toward Lebanon from an IR perspective

    Open Access•Chiara Ruffa•Comparative European Politics•2011

  • Intellectual spring cleaning

    Aaron P Jackson, Ben Zweibelson et al.•Defence Studies•2018

  • Türkiye within the European security community as an ontological security community model

    Open Access•Sezgi ERDOĞAN•Turkish Studies•2026

  • The Violence of Poverty

    Chris Shannahan•Political Theology•2018

  • Framing and praising Allah on YouTube

    Open Access•Lela Mosemghvdlishvili, Jeroen Jansz•New Media & Society•2012

  • Générations politiques et générations universitaires dans les Territoires palestiniens

    Vincent Romani•Revue internationale de politique…•2009

  • Explaining the resilience of free trade

    Open Access•Gabriel Siles-Brügge•Review of International Political…•2013

  • Storytelling for sustainable development in rural communities

    Open Access•Brennan Lowery, John Dagevos et al.•Sustainable Development•2020

  • From Hammer and Sickle to Star and Crescent

    Benoît Challand•Religion State & Society•2009

  • The politics of imagination and the public role of religion

    Open Access•Chiara Bottici•Philosophy & Social Criticism•2009

  • Constructing the Collective Trauma of “The Hard 1990s” as a Disregarded Tool of Legitimation for Putin’s Authority

    Open Access•Olga Malinova•Nationalities Papers•2022

  • White Supremacy, Racism, and War

    Josh Berkenpas•Soundings An Interdisciplinary…•2022

  • From Green Revolution to Green Evolution

    Open Access•Roger A Pielke, Björn-Ola Linnér•Minerva•2019

  • Solving for X?’ Towards a problem-finding framework to ground long-term governance strategies for artificial intelligence

    Open Access•Hin-Yan Liu, Matthijs M Maas•Futures•2021

  • The emperor, the lion and the peacock

    Open Access•Asebe Regassa, Rony Emmenegger•Environment and Planning C…•2023

  • Past and Future in the Construction of Communal Identity

    Open Access•Christoffer Kølvraa•Scandinavian Studies in Language•2015

  • European security and the accession of Turkey

    Open Access•Senem Aydın-Düzgit•Cooperation and Conflict•2013

  • Political Myth and the Sacred Center of Human Rights

    Open Access•Jenna Reinbold•Human Rights Review•2010

  • History in the Service of Politics

    Open Access•Steve Kirkwood•Political Psychology•2019

  • Where does religion meet democracy? A comparative analysis of attitudes in Europe

    Open Access•Natalia Vlas, Gherghina et al.•International Political Science…•2012

  • European Fantasies

    Open Access•Christoffer Kølvraa•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2016

  • Explaining Policy Conflict across Institutional Venues

    Open Access•Annabelle Littoz‐monnet•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2012

  • The Myth of a Green Europe

    Open Access•Andrea Lenschow, Carina Sprungk•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2010

  • Political Myth, Mythology and the European Union

    Open Access•Vincent Della Sala•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2010

  • Violence and Political Myth

    Open Access•Xander Kirke•International Political Sociology•2015

  • Creative self-destruction

    C Wright, Daniel Nyberg•Environmental Politics•2014

  • Legitimizing the “War on Terror”

    Open Access•Joanne Esch•Political Psychology•2010

  • From states to polities

    Open Access•Jessica Shadian, Jessica M Shadian•European Journal of International…•2010

  • Unsettling sovereignty

    Open Access•Rony Emmenegger•Political Geography•2021

  • Armadillo and the Viking spirit

    Kristian Frisk•Critical Military Studies•2019

  • From Ethnic Nationalisms to Clashing Civilizations

    Open Access•Joel Busher•Religion Compass•2012

  • "Por um "arquivo vivo

    Open Access•Filipa Coimbra•Midas•2023

  • Habermas on Religion and Democracy

    Camil Ungureanu, Paolo Monti•The European Legacy•2017

  • Work on myth

    Hans Blumenberg•Work on myth•1985

  • Political Myth

    Open Access•Henry Tudor•Political Myth•1972

  • Slaves on Horses

    Open Access•Patricia Crone•Slaves on Horses•1980

  • Constructing the political spectacle

    Murray J Edelman•Constructing the political…•1988

  • What Went Wrong?

    Bernard Lewis, Bernard Lewıs•What went wrong?•2002

  • America and Political Islam

    Open Access•Fawaz A Gerges•America and Political Islam•1999

  • The Coming Anarchy

    Robert D Kaplan•Globalization and the Challenges…•2000

  • The Invention Of Tradition

    Eric Hobsbawm, Terence O Ranger•Invention of Tradition•2012

  • Myth, Ritual, and Political Control

    Open Access•W L Bennett•Journal of Communication•1980

  • The Symbolic Construction of Community

    Anthony P Cohen•Symbolic Construction of Community•1985

  • Public Religions in the Modern World

    José Casanova•Public Religions in the Modern…•1994

  • The US media, Huntington and September 11

    Ervand Abrahamian•Third World Quarterly•2003

  • Neo-Orientalism and the new barbarism thesis

    Dag Tuastad•Third World Quarterly•2003

  • Europe Against Islam

    Open Access•Talal Asad•The Muslim World•1997

  • Myths and Memories of the N1ation

    Anthony D Smith•Myths and memories of the nation•1999

  • Terror, Islam, and Democracy

    Open Access•Ladan Boroumand, Roya Boroumand•Journal of democracy•2002

  • The New Orientalism and the Democracy Debate

    Yahya Sadowski•Middle East Report•1993

  • Islam, Political Change and Globalization

    Open Access•Saïd Amir Arjomand•Thesis Eleven•2004

  • Somebody Else's Civil War

    Michael Scott Doran, Michael Doran•Foreign Affairs•2002

  • The Rise of Illiberal Democracy

    Fareed Zakaria•Foreign Affairs•1997

Unique citing works60
Citations per year3,16
Citation span2007 - 2026 (20)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 60

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae