Psychiatric Diagnosis as Reified Measurement
Bibliographic Data
| ID | 2545481 |
|---|---|
| Authors | John Mirowsky (corresponding author), Catherine E Ro (0000-0002-0644-5268), CATHERINE E ROSS |
| Year | 1989 |
| Volume | 30 |
| Issue | 1 |
| Pages | 11 |
| Publication date | 1989-03-01 |
| Peer Reviewed | Yes |
| Open Access | No |
| Type | ARTICLE |
| Venue | Journal of Health and Social Behavior (JOURNAL) |
| Journal identifiers | ISSN: 0022-1465 • E-ISSN: 2150-6000 |
| Publisher | SAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER) |
| DOI | 10.2307/2136907 |
| PMID | 2723377 |
| OpenAlex | W2018156214 |
| Language | EN |
| Citations received | 72 |
| References cited | 7 |
Throughout the 1980s, psychiatry has promoted diagnosis--with its language of categories--as the preeminent measure of psychological problems. In clinical psychiatry, the decade opened with the publication of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-III (DSM-III). In psychiatric epidemiology, the decade saw the development of the Diagnostic Interview Schedule (DIS) and its use in the large-scale Epidemiologic Catchment Area (ECA) surveys. Proponents of the diagnostic approach herald the DIS as a breakthrough. We argue, on the contrary, that diagnosis as a form of measurement hinders understanding. If the ECA studies provide new insight into the patterns and causes of psychological problems, they will do so despite the use of diagnostic measurement. We present here a critical analysis of the inherent weaknesses of diagnosis as a form of measurement, particularly as a means of representing psychological problems. First, we describe the weaknesses: diagnosis treats attributes as entities; it reduces the signal but not the noise; and it collapses the structural relationships. Second, we offer an interpretation of why psychiatry promotes a form of measurement poorly suited to its subject: the linguistic legacy of nineteenth-century biology and epidemiology; the social construction of the need for mental health services; and the enclosure of a scientific and professional domain. Third, we conclude that diagnostic measurement impedes understanding. We recommend eliminating diagnosis from research on the nature, causes, and consequences of mental, emotional, and behavioral problems
Interpretation (philosophy) · Mental health · Pathology · Psychiatry · Strengths and weaknesses · Subject (documents) · Computer Science · Epidemiology · Medicine · Mental Health and Psychiatry · Mental Health Research Topics · Mental Health Treatment and Access · Psychology · Social Psychology
The Absurdalities of Mental Illness – A Narrative Inquiry into Psychiatric Diagnosis
Medical Sociology and the Study of Severe Mental Illness
Mental Health, Social Mirror
Psychische Behinderung
Labeling and Stigma
Psychosocial Resources and the Stress Process
Month Prevalence of DSM-III-R Psychiatric Disorders Among Mexican Americans
Water and mental health
The Stress Process Revisited
ADHD and reification
Mental Health of Chinese Online Networkers under Covid-19
Mental health inequality between urban and rural youth under Covid-19 from survey data from China
Lesbian Health
Cross-Cultural Issues in Illness and Wellness
Gender and Mental Health
The Role of Sociology in the Study of Mental Health … and the Role of Mental Health in the Study of Sociology
Naming and Framing
Beyond Symptoms
Gender Differences in the Determinants of Distress, Alcohol Misuse, and Related Psychiatric Disorders
Perceived Need for Mental Health Care
The Proximity of Common Unhappiness and Misery
Nosological Reflections
Making Kraepelin history
Social network factors as mediators of mental health and psychological distress
Nature, Nurture, Neither, Nor
Aging, Mental Health, and Well‐Being
Psychiatric diagnosis under conditions of uncertainty
Should We Talk about the Pain? Personalizing Sociology in the Medical Sociology Classroom
The Sociological Study of Stress
Diagnostic line-drawing, professional boundaries, and the rhetoric of scientific justification
Discursive style and psychological practice
Social Structure, Stress, and Mental Health
Depression and Alcohol Dependence among Poor Women
The Impact of Childhood Abuse and Neglect on Adult Mental Health
Socioeconomic Status and Depressive Syndrome
Measurement for a Human Science
Collective Adaptive Responses Through Coping and Sensemaking Under Stress
Aging and the Elapse of Time
A Healthy state of tension
The History and Future of the Sociology of Therapy
Personal Resources and the Social Distribution of Depression
Race, gender, and the response to stress
The biomedicalization of psychiatry
Framing disease
The mental health of women 6 months after they give birth to an unwanted baby
Psychiatrists as social engineers
Stigma, Social Structure, and the Biomedical Framework
Socioeconomic pathways to depressive symptoms in adulthood
DSM-IV and dangerous and severe personality disorder-an essay
Depression, parenthood, and age at first birth
Resistance to the biomedicalization of mental illness through peer support
Multigenerational Coresidence and Psychological Distress during Adolescence and Young Adulthood
The twain meet
Distinguishing distress from disorder as psychological outcomes of stressful social arrangements
Medicalizing melancholia
A Social Diagnosis of Digitally Mediated Covid-19 Trauma
Everybody's Got a Little Mental Illness
The Myth of the Migrant Homeless
Doing Abstraction
Social Context, Biology, and the Definition of Disorder
Taking Time Seriously
Introducing John Mirowsky
The Public Stigma of Mental Illness
The Labeling Paradox
Social Contingencies in Mental Health
Region, Religious Commitment, and Life Satisfaction Among Black Americans
Extending Fundamental Cause Theory to Holistic Health
The emergence and implications of a mental health ethos in juvenile justice
Low Socioeconomic Status and Mental Disorders
Swell Foundations
Roles, race and subjective well-being
Psychiatric Expansionism and Social Control
National Institute of Mental Health Diagnostic Interview Schedule
A Comparison of Clinical and Diagnostic Interview Schedule Diagnoses
Six-Month Prevalence of Psychiatric Disorders in Three Communities
DSM-III and the politics–science dichotomy syndrome
Advances in psychiatric epidemiology
Assessing Reliability and Stability in Panel Models
| Unique citing works | 72 |
|---|---|
| Citations per year | 1,95 |
| Citation span | 1989 - 2025 (37) |
| Citation velocity | recent |
| Highly cited | No |
| Citation types | Neutral: 70 |