Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Estimating Tillage Effects on Artifact Distributions

Bibliographic Data

ID2575782
AuthorsGeorge H Odell (University of Tulsa, corresponding author), Frank L Cowan (Buffalo State University), Frank Cowan
Year1987
Volume52
Issue3
Pages456-484
Publication date1987-07-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Antiquity (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0002-7316 • E-ISSN: 2325-5064
PublisherCambridge University Press (CUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.2307/281594
OpenAlexW2329883339
LanguageEN
Citations received68
References cited26

Although behavioralists who deal with plow zone sites have a need to discriminate between cultural and non-cultural effects on artifact distributions, relatively little is known about the influences of agricultural equipment. A series of experiments was conducted to answer questions concerning the parameters of recovery, lateral artifact displacement, spatial patterning, duration of tillage, and the effects of tillage patterning. Results indicate an average recovery rate of 5-6 percent; support for the 'size effect'; relatively constant recovery of small and large pieces; dominant displacement in the direction of plowing; lack of relationship between displacement and artifact size; basically random distribution of objects; and possible spurious clustering, depending upon the analytical methods employed

Agronomy · Archaeology · Artifact (error) · Cluster analysis · Displacement (psychology) · Econometrics · Geography · Plough · Spurious relationship · Statistics · Tillage · Artificial Intelligence · Computer Science · Environmental Science · Mathematics · Pleistocene-Era Hominins and Archaeology · Primate Behavior and Ecology · Psychology · Soil Science · Wildlife Ecology and Conservation

  • The Wadi Faynan Fourth and Third Millennia Project, 1997

    Katherine Wright, Mohammed Najjar et al.•Levant•1998

  • Revisiting Tell Begum

    Open Access•Olivier Nieuwenhuyse, Takahiro Odaka et al.•Iraq•2016

  • Comment on Estimating Tillage Effects on Artifact Distributions

    Open Access•Ronald M Yorston•American Antiquity•1990

  • Integrating surface and subsurface reconnaissance data in the study of stratigraphically complex sites

    Open Access•Haskel J Greenfield•Geoarchaeology•2000

  • Nye åkre og gamle funn Metodiske betraktninger om undersundersøøkelser av skelser av søørrøøstnorske steinalderbostnorske steinalderbo--plasser i dyrket mark

    Open Access•Alex Mjærum•Primitive Tider•2021

  • “My problems aren't severe enough to seek help”

    Open Access•Amy Dana Ménard, Kyle Gary Harvey et al.•Health Policy•2022

  • The Advantages and Limitations of Coring Survey

    Open Access•Ivo van der Graaff, Robert Vander Poppen et al.•Theoretical Roman Archaeology…•2010

  • Reassessing Surface Artefact Scatters. The Integration of Artefact‐Accurate Fieldwalking with Geophysical Data at Medieval Harbour Sites Near Bruges (Belgium)

    Open Access•Jan Trachet, Samuël Delefortrie et al.•Archaeological Prospection•2017

  • Geochemical and geophysical prospecting at three multicomponent sites in the Southwestern Lake Erie Basin

    Open Access•K C Nolan, Brian G Redmond•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2015

  • Sampling to redundancy in an applied zooarchaeology

    Open Access•Joseph Mitchell, Evan Peacock et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2016

  • Sentinel-2 imagery analyses for archaeological site detection

    Open Access•Marta Estanqueiro, Aleksandar Šalamon et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2023

  • Assessing the Utility of Plowed Field Surface Deposits in Pilot Research

    Open Access•Scott Palumbo•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2015

  • Collaborating with Farmers to Recover Indigenous Archaic Period History from Private Lithic Collections in Virginia's Rappahannock River Valley

    Open Access•Gail W Wertz•Advances in Archaeological Practice•2022

  • Interpreting West Ashcom

    Open Access•Liza Gijanto•International Journal of…•2020

  • A Multidisciplinary Approach to Medieval and Early Modern Land Use

    Open Access•K Patrick Fazioli•Archaeological Prospection•2014

  • The Social Life of Palimpsests

    Open Access•M Kolhatkar•Journal of Archaeological Method…•2023

  • Understanding the stratigraphic context of the maya postclassic in belize

    Open Access•M A Masson•Geoarchaeology•1995

  • Análisis geoarqueológico y espacial de un yacimiento musteriense al aire libre

    Open Access•Jesús Fernández Fernández, David Álvarez-Alonso•Lucentum•2014

  • Site maintenance practices and settlement social organization in Iron Age Karnataka, India

    Open Access•Peter G Johansen, Peter Johansen•Journal of Anthropological…•2010

  • Report on the 1997 field season of the Bayswater Archaeological Research Project, NSW Hunter Valley

    Katrina MacDonald, Malcolm Ridges et al.•Australian Archaeology•1998

  • Neutron activation analysis of obsidian from two Neolithic sites in Italy

    Open Access•A J Ammerman, A Cesana et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•1990

  • Simulation of artefact movement due to cultivation

    Open Access•R M Yorston, Vincent Gaffney et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•1990

  • Phosphates, plowzones, and plazas

    Open Access•Christopher I Roos, K C Nolan•Journal of Archaeological Science•2011

  • Stone pipe-making tools in ancient North America

    Open Access•P B MacLaren Law de Lauriston, George H Odell et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science•2015

  • A geoarchaeological approach to using surface sites for paleoenvironmental reconstructions

    Open Access•J L Ripley•Geoarchaeology•1998

  • Comprendiendo los campamentos pequeños de cazadores-recolectores mediante el análisis funcional y espacial. Tres casos de estudio del Mesolítico de Polonia

    Open Access•Tomasz Boroń, Małgorzata Winiarska-Kabacińska•Trabajos de Prehistoria•2021

  • Dynamic landscapes, artifact taphonomy, and landuse modeling in the western Mediterranean

    Open Access•C Michael Barton, Joan Bernabeu Aubán et al.•Geoarchaeology•2002

  • The memory of the landscape

    Open Access•Sabrina Leonardt, Vivian Scheinsohn et al.•Quaternary International•2016

  • Exploring Colonization and Ethnogenesis through an Analysis of the Flaked Glass Tools of the Lower Columbia Chinookans and Fur Traders

    Stephanie Simmons•2000

  • D geometric morphometric analysis casts doubt on the validity of large tanged points as cultural markers in the European Final Palaeolithic

    Open Access•Kamil Serwatka, F Riede•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2016

  • Towards an artefact's-eye view

    Open Access•Philip Riris•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2017

  • A Plantation Transplanted

    James A Delle, Kristen R Fellows•Northeast Historical Archaeology•2012

  • Evaluating the effect of plowing on the archaeological record

    Open Access•Fernando Diez-Martín•Quaternary International•2009

  • Patterning in a large sample of retouched unifacial tools

    Open Access•W Engelbrecht, Andrew P Bradbury et al.•Journal of Archaeological Science…•2021

  • Skill in Stone Knapping

    Open Access•M Kolhatkar•Journal of Archaeological Method…•2021

  • Taking out the Trash

    Open Access•Åsa M Larsson•Current Swedish Archaeology•2021

  • Redistribution of archaeological assemblages in plowzones

    Open Access•Marta Navazo, Carlos Díez et al.•Geoarchaeology•2008

  • Surface and Subsurface Patterns of Archaeological Materials at Fort Fillmore, New Mexico

    Open Access•Edward Staski•North American Archaeologist•1990

  • Shadow of Doubt or Doubtful Shadows

    Open Access•David P Staley•North American Archaeologist•2006

  • Shifting Patterns of Settlement in the Highlands of Central Jordan during the Early Bronze Age

    Timothy P Harrison•Bulletin of the American Schools…•1997

  • A method for finding stratified sites

    Petr Škrdla, Ladislav Nejman et al.•Journal of Field Archaeology•2016

  • Assembly and Collection – Lithic Complexes in the Cambridgeshire Fenlands

    Open Access•Mark Edmonds, Chris Evans et al.•Proceedings of the Prehistoric…•1999

  • Estudio De Alteraciones Provocadas Por Laboreo Agrícola Sobre Conjuntos Cerámicos en Agua Amarga (Tupungato, Mendoza, Argentina)

    Open Access•M J Ots•Chungara•2008

  • Artifact Size and Lateral Displacement under Tillage

    Open Access•Robert C Dunnell•American Antiquity•1990

  • Site Formation Processes and the Origin of Artifacts in Plow-Zone Proveniences

    Open Access•Jeff Leach, Jeff D Leach•North American Archaeologist•1999

  • Exploring Surface Collected Data with Spatial Analysis Methods

    Open Access•Andrew P Bradbury, Jason Anderson et al.•North American Archaeologist•2008

  • George H. Odell's Contributions to Lithic Quarry and Raw Material Procurement Research

    Open Access•Anne S Dowd•North American Archaeologist•2013

  • A Quantitative Analysis of Skill and Efficiency

    K C Nolan, Mark F Seeman et al.•Midcontinental Journal of…•2007

  • The Firebreak Plow and Subsurface Site Discovery

    James D Bloemker, Carey B Oakley•Journal of Field Archaeology•1999

  • A Multi-Method Approach to Reconstructing Occupational History and Activity Areas

    Tatsuya Murakami, Shigeru Kabata et al.•Journal of Field Archaeology•2018

  • Visibility and Site Recovery in the Cecina Valley Survey, Italy

    Nicola Terrenato, A J Ammerman•Journal of Field Archaeology•1996

  • Reliability of Archaeological Records on Cultivated Surfaces

    Michael Shott, Michael J Shott•Journal of Field Archaeology•1995

  • Artifact Size and Plowzone Processes

    Robert C Dunnell, Jan F Simek•Journal of Field Archaeology•1995

  • Scratching the Surface

    Open Access•Tesse D Stek, Jitte Waagen•Journal of Field Archaeology•2022

  • Putting the Spotlight on Small Metal Age Pottery Scatters in Northern Calabria (Italy)

    Open Access•Wieke De Neef, Kayt Armstrong et al.•Journal of Field Archaeology•2017

  • The Classical Farmstead Revisited. Activity Differentiation based on a Ceramic Use-Typology

    Open Access•Kristina Winther-Jacobsen•The Annual of the British School…•2010

  • Fragmentation Resistant Measures of Chipped Stone Abundance and Size

    Matthew Douglass, Luann Wandsnider•Plains Anthropologist•2012

  • More on Estimating Tillage Effects

    Open Access•Frank L Cowan, George H Odell•American Antiquity•1990

  • The Final Palaeolithic Hunter-Gatherer Colonisation of Lithuania in Light of Recent Palaeoenvironmental Research

    Open Access•Livija Ivanovaitė, F Riede•Open Quaternary•2018

  • The political economy of late Neolithic and early Bronze age society

    Timothy Earle, Jens‐henrik Bech et al.•Norwegian Archaeological Review•1998

  • Aspects of Structure in an Epipaleolithic Occupation Site in West Central Jordan

    Open Access•Nancy R Coinman, Geoffrey A Clark et al.•Archeological Papers of the…•1989

  • Contextualizing the Upper Paleolithic of the Armenian Highlands

    Open Access•Tanner Z Kovach, Artur Petrosyan et al.•Journal of Human Evolution•2025

  • Testing the damage caused by a golden eagle (Aquila chrysaetos) on a primate skull

    Open Access•A Rufà, Goizane Alonso et al.•International Journal of…•2020

  • Formation Processes of Large Earthen Residential Mounds in La Mixtequilla, Veracruz, Mexico

    Open Access•Barbara Ann Hall•Latin American Antiquity•1994

  • Ploughzone sampling in Denmark

    Open Access•Jill M Steinberg, John M Steinberg•Antiquity•1996

  • Understanding early medieval pottery distributions

    Open Access•J Schofield, A J Schofield•Antiquity•1989

  • Land-Use Dynamics and Socioeconomic Change

    Open Access•C Michael Barton, Joan Bernabeu Aubán et al.•American Antiquity•1999

  • Measuring Time, Population, and Residential Mobility from the Surface at San Marcos Pueblo, North Central New Mexico

    Open Access•Ann F Ramenofsky, Fraser D Neiman et al.•American Antiquity•2009

  • Spatial analysis in archaeology

    Ian Hodder•Spatial analysis in archaeology•1976

  • A history of American archaeology

    Gordon Randolph Willey•A history of American archaeology•1974

  • Distance to Nearest Neighbor as a Measure of Spatial Relationships in Populations

    Open Access•P J Clark, Francis C Evans•Ecology•1954

  • The Nature of Organization of Intrasite Archaeological Records and Spatial Analytic Approaches to Their Investigation

    Open Access•Catherine Carr, Christopher Carr•Advances in archaeological method…•1984

  • Plow Zones and Predictability

    Open Access•Curtiss Hoffman•North American Archaeologist•1983

  • Plow-Zone Experiments in Calabria, Italy

    A J Ammerman•Journal of Field Archaeology•1985

  • The Harvey Lecture Series. The Significance of Variability among Lithic Artifacts

    Jean-Philippe Rigaud, Jean‐Philippe Rigaud•Journal of Anthropological Research•1978

  • Microdebitage analysis

    Open Access•Knut R Fladmark•Journal of Archaeological Science•1982

  • Temporal Land-Use Pattern Analysis With the Use of Nearest Neighbor and Quadrat Methods 1

    Arthur Getis•Annals of the Association of…•1964

  • The Size Effect

    Open Access•Charles M Baker•American Antiquity•1978

  • L'habitation magdalénienne n° 1 de Pincevent près Monterau (Seine-et-Marne)

    Open Access•André Leroi‐gourhan, André Leroi-Gourhan et al.•Gallia préhistoire•1966

  • Estimating original assemblage content to adjust for post-depositional vertical artifact movement

    Ralph M Rowlett, M C Robbins•World Archaeology•1982

  • Shaw's Creek Shelter

    Open Access•Eugene D Stockton•Mankind•2010

  • Statistical Tests of Spatial Association in the Locations of Tool Types

    Open Access•Michael F Dacey•American Antiquity•1973

  • Nearest Neighbor Analysis of Pueblo I-III Settlement Patterns along the Rio Puerco of the East, New Mexico

    Open Access•D K Washburn•American Antiquity•1974

  • The Nearest-Neighbor Statistic

    Open Access•David Pinder, Izumi Shimada et al.•American Antiquity•1979

  • Lateral Displacement of Artifacts Due to Plowing

    Open Access•Donna C Roper•American Antiquity•1976

  • Replicated Collection of Site Surfaces

    Open Access•A J Ammerman, Marcus W Feldman•American Antiquity•1978

  • Dimensional Analysis of Behavior and Site Structure

    Open Access•Lewis R Binford•American Antiquity•1978

  • Spatial Analysis of Occupation Floors II

    Open Access•Robert Whallon•American Antiquity•1974

  • Systematic, Intensive Surface Collection

    Open Access•Charles L Redman, Patty Jo Watson•American Antiquity•1970

Unique citing works68
Citations per year1,84
Citation span1989 - 2025 (37)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 66

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae