Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Archetypal Actions of Ritual

A Theory of Ritual Illustrated by the Jain Rite of Worship

Bibliographic Data

ID2579445
AuthorsJohn R Bowen
Year1997
Volume3
Issue3
Pages631
Publication date1997-09-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeREVIEW
Review ofThe archetypal actions of ritual: A theory of ritual illustrated by the Jain rite of worship, Caroline Humphrey, 1994
VenueJournal of the Royal Anthropological Institute (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1359-0987 • E-ISSN: 1467-9655
PublisherJSTOR (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.2307/3034804
OpenAlexW2058536786
LanguageEN

Religious rituals can provoke a deeply ambigious reaction in those who practise them. What happens in religious traditions when the nature of the ritual is questioned, but the practice of performing rituals is not itself abandoned? This book draws on the authors' observations of such reactions among Jains in western India, and asks why they can tell us about ritual as a universal mode of human action. Most anthropologists have assumed that ritual is a special kind of happening, which requires a special kind of interpretation. The authors argue that 'ritual' is a quality which can in principle apply to any kind of action. The question they try to answer is: what is distinctive about actions which are ritualized? They reject the common view that ritual carries intrinsic meaning, and explore the apparent paradox that ritualization, which makes action in an important sense non-intentional, is itself the result of an intentional act - the adoption by the actor of what the authors call the 'ritual commitment

Rite · Sociology · Theology · Worship · History · Indian and Buddhist Studies · Philosophy · Religion and Society Interactions

  • Islamic Studies in the Twenty-First Century

    Open Access•Léon Buskens, Annemarie van Sandwijk•Islamic Studies in the…•2017

  • Ritual increases children’s affiliation with in-group members

    Open Access•Nicole J Wen, Patricia A Herrmann et al.•Evolution and Human Behavior•2016

  • Les formes élémentaires d’agir performatif. Un essai de typologie sociologique

    Open Access•Werner Binder, Sophie Schinko et al.•Cahiers de recherche sociologique•2013

  • Religion in Mind

    Jesper Sørensen•Numen•2005

  • The Coexistence Problem in Psychology, Anthropology, and Evolutionary Theory

    H Whitehouse•Human Development•2011

  • Ritual and the Subjunctive

    Adam Seligman, Adam B Seligman et al.•Ritual and Its Consequences•2008

  • Ambiguity, Ambivalence, and Boundaries

    Adam Seligman, Adam B Seligman et al.•Ritual and Its Consequences•2008

  • Preface

    Open Access•François Berthomé, Julien Bonhomme et al.•Hau Journal of Ethnographic Theory•2012

  • Pleasing to behold

    Kenneth Mullen•Mental Health Religion & Culture•2001

  • Dying for the group

    Open Access•H Whitehouse•Behavioral and Brain Sciences•2018

  • A Sociological History of Christian Worship

    Open Access•Martin D Stringer•Sociological History of Christian…•2005

  • Studies in Jaina History and Culture

    Open Access•Peter Flugel•Stud Jaina Hist and Cult Disp and…•2006

  • About servants and flagellants

    Open Access•Maik Patzelt•Lived Religion in the Ancient…•2020

  • Trading justice for peace? Reframing reconciliation in TRC processes in South Africa, Canada and Nordic countries

    Open Access•Eugene Baron, Stanley Henkeman et al.•Trading justice for peace?…•2021

  • Le chant des serpents

    Open Access•Christine Guillebaud•Le chant des serpents•2008

  • Meditation in Modern Buddhism

    Open Access•James Wyatt Cook, Joanna Cook•Meditation in Modern Buddhism•2010

  • The Social Functions of Group Rituals

    Open Access•Rachel E Watson-Jones, Rachel E Watson‐Jones et al.•Current Directions in Psychological…•2016

  • Imitation and Innovation

    Open Access•Cristine H Legare, Mark Nielsen•Trends in Cognitive Sciences•2015

  • The Psychology of Rituals

    Open Access•Nicholas Hobson, Nicholas M Hobson et al.•Personality and Social Psychology…•2018

  • Lived Islam

    Open Access•A Kevin Reinhart, Andreas Reinhart•Lived Islam•2020

  • Menstrual Slaps and First Blood Celebrations

    M Houseman•Learning Religion•2022

  • Response

    Open Access•M Strathern•Hau Journal of Ethnographic Theory•2012

  • Behind Heathendom

    Open Access•Anders Andrén•Scottish Archaeological Journal•2005

  • On Polytropy

    Open Access•Michael Carrithers•Modern Asian Studies•2000

  • Hesukristo superstar

    Open Access•J Bautista•The Australian Journal of…•2017

  • Objects, Bodies and Gods

    Arnaud Halloy•Making Spirits•2013

  • About Buddhist Burma

    Open Access•Bénédicte Brac De La Perriére•The Appropriation of Religion in…•2017

  • Sacrifice and Ritualization

    Caroline Humphrey, James Laidlaw•Archaeology of Ritual•2007

  • Historical origins of a ‘caste society’

    Open Access•Susan Bayly•Caste, society and politics in…•1999

  • The Ritual Animal

    H Whitehouse, Oxford Editor•Ritual Animal•2021

  • Legitimacy and Law in the Roman World

    Open Access•Elizabeth A Meyer•Legitimacy and Law in the Roman…•2004

  • Liminal meanings

    Open Access•J Mcintosh•Language & Communication•2005

  • Religions de l'Afrique noire (ethnologie)

    Open Access•M Houseman•Annuaire - Ecole pratique des…•2019

  • Prestation Economy’

    Open Access•Adriene Baron Tacla•Revista do Museu de Arqueologia e…•2008

  • Houses in Lesu

    Göran Aijmer•Journal of Anthropological Research•2007

  • Jainism and society

    Open Access•Peter Flugel•Bulletin of the School of…•2006

  • Heroism, Spiritual Development, and Triadic Bonds in Jain and Christian Mendicancy and Almsgiving

    Stephen R Munzer•Numen•2001

  • Ritual and Self-Cultivation in the Daoist Practice of “Oblatory Refinement”

    Joshua Capitanio•Numen•2019

  • The (Ancient Greek) Subject Supposed to Believe

    Esther Eidinow•Numen•2019

  • Handshaking promotes deal-making by signaling cooperative intent

    Jonathan Schroeder, Juliana Schroeder et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•2019

  • Pleasing to behold

    Kenneth Mullen•Mental Health Religion & Culture•2001

  • Ritual healing and mental health in India

    Open Access•William S Sax, William Sax•Transcultural Psychiatry•2014

  • Cognitive Science in the Study of Early Christianity

    Open Access•Risto Uro•New Testament Studies•2017

  • Religious History of the Gaṇḍī Beam

    Ekaterina Sobkovyak•Asiatische Studien – Études…•2015

  • Tying the Hand

    Junko Iida•Asiatische Studien – Études…•2017

  • The Four Great Temples

    Donald F Mccallum•Four Great Temples•2008

  • Ritual Disintermediations

    Swayam Bagaria•Material Religion•2021

  • Religious reflexivity and transmissive frequency

    Open Access•H Whitehouse•Social Anthropology•2007

  • Studying Thy Neighbor

    Open Access•Michael Bourdillon, Michael F C Bourdillon•Anthropology & Humanism•1997

  • Religious reflexivity and transmissive frequency

    Open Access•H Whitehouse•Social Anthropology•2002

  • The Dangers of Excess

    Open Access•Rebecca Empson•Social Analysis•2012

  • Tree Totems and the Tamarind People

    Open Access•G Forth•Oceania•2009

  • On Making Fathers in Lesu

    Open Access•Göran Aijmer•Oceania•2007

  • Taking Play Seriously

    Open Access•Peter G Stromberg, Peter Stromberg et al.•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•2007

  • Action Rituelle ou Réaction Politique ? L'invention des processions du nationalisme hindou dans les années 1980 en Inde

    Open Access•Jackie Assayag•Annales Histoire Sciences Sociales•1997

  • Spontaneous processing of functional and non-functional action sequences

    Kristoffer L Nielbo, Jesper Sørensen•Religion Brain & Behavior•2011

  • Materiality of Religion

    Open Access•Tõnno Jonuks, Ester Oras et al.•Folklore Electronic Journal of…•2013

  • Sacrifice or Offering

    Open Access•Ester Oras•Folklore Electronic Journal of…•2013

  • The Symbological Project

    Open Access•G÷ran Aijmer•Cultural Dynamics•2001

  • The New Normal and Covid-19 in Serbia from February to May 2020

    Open Access•Bojan Žikić, Mladen Stajić et al.•Etnoantropološki problemi /…•2020

  • The Anthropology of Ontology Meets the Writing Culture Debate

    Open Access•Rane Willerslev•Social Analysis•2016

  • Experiencing a Ritual Space – Results of Phosphate Analyses from Four Sámi Offering Places

    Tiina Äikäs, Siiri Tolonen•Norwegian Archaeological Review•2016

  • Animating rituals at Sámi sacred sites in northern Finland

    Open Access•Anna‐kaisa Salmi, Anna-Kaisa Salmi et al.•Journal of Social Archaeology•2011

  • The question of ritual

    Open Access•Jesper Sørensen•Scripta Instituti Donneriani…•2003

  • Performed Weeping

    T Gamliel•TDR/The Drama Review•2010

  • DEN Magiske Illusion? En kognitiv tilgang til magiske ritualer

    Jesper Sørensen•Tidsskriftet Antropologi•2000

  • Ideernes Epidemiologi Og Kulturens Immunologi

    Jesper Sørensen•Tidsskriftet Antropologi•2006

  • Teyyam

    Marcus Banks•Visual Anthropology•2003

  • Visible Knowledge

    Ulrich Demmer•Visual Anthropology•2004

  • Introduction

    Paul Hockings•Visual Anthropology•2000

  • Pilgrimage, Tourism and Leisure

    Open Access•Vinay Kumar Srivastava•Journal of the Anthropological…•2019

  • The “body of ritual” transformed

    Open Access•Chen Jin•The Journal of Chinese Sociology•2018

  • The relationship between words and being in the world for students of Qur’anic recitation in Brussels

    Open Access•Mieke Groeninck•Contemporary Islam•2016

  • Not Just Dead Meat

    Claire White, Maya Marin et al.•Journal of Cognition and Culture•2017

  • Transmissive Frequency, Ritual, and Exegesis

    H Whitehouse•Journal of Cognition and Culture•2001

  • The Aztec Gods in Blended-Space

    D Dehouve•Journal of Cognition and Culture•2019

  • Are Motor Collective Rituals as Rigid as They Seem? A Test Case of a Zulu Wedding Dance

    Hila Keren, Michal Fux et al.•Journal of Cognition and Culture•2013

  • Infelicitous inter-ritual hospitality

    Open Access•Marianne Moyaert•Culture and Religion•2017

  • Jewish Redemption by Way of the Buddha

    A Vallely•Jewish Culture and History•2006

  • Ethnographic Studies in Christian Ritual

    Ronald L Grimes•Journal of Contemporary Religion•2016

  • Tangible Traces 0f Devotion

    Open Access•A Kjellström•Current Swedish Archaeology•2021

  • Cultivating Corpses

    Open Access•Anders Kaliff, Terje Oestigaard•Current Swedish Archaeology•2021

  • Vedic and devotional waters

    Open Access•Fiona M Smith•International Journal of Hindu…•2004

  • Religion, politics, and ritual. Remarks on Geertz and Bloch

    Open Access•D N Gellner•Social Anthropology•2007

  • Performance, Belonging and Identity

    Marta Domínguez Díaz•Religion State & Society•2011

  • The ‘Bear Ceremonial’ and Bear Rituals among the Khanty and the Sami

    Open Access•Hakan Rydving•Temenos - Nordic Journal for the…•2010

  • A Western Folk Category in Mind

    Open Access•Hakan Rydving•Temenos - Nordic Journal for the…•2008

  • Nirodha and the Nirodhalaksana of VallabhĀcĀrya

    Open Access•Fiona M Smith, Frederick M Smith•Journal of Indian Philosophy•1998

  • Textual Authority in Ritual Procedure

    Open Access•Paul Dundas•Journal of Indian Philosophy•2011

  • The Conflict over Cicero's House

    Anders Lisdorf•Numen•2005

  • The Ritualization of Strategy Workshops

    Open Access•Gerry Johnson, Shameen Prashantham et al.•Organization Studies•2010

  • Assessing and Adapting Rituals That Reproduce a Collectivity

    Open Access•Nicolas Sihlé•Religion and Society•2018

  • The Citizen Amendment Act of 2019 and its lack of impact on Shvetambara Jains in Mumbai

    Andrea Luithle-Hardenberg•Nidān•2020

  • Risking a Miracle

    Marc Roscoe Loustau•Journal of Contemporary Religion•2016

  • The Last Groups Standing

    Open Access•Maxime Lamoureux-St-Hilaire, Scott Macrae et al.•Latin American Antiquity•2015

  • Ritualizing a Nonroyal Building Termination at the Classic Maya Capital of Tamarindito, Guatemala

    Open Access•M Eberl, Sven Gronemeyer et al.•Latin American Antiquity•2019

  • Metaphoric veiled image-schema of kinship organization in ceremonial space

    Open Access•T D Dillehay•Journal of Anthropological…•2024

  • Rites in the dark? An evaluation of the current evidence for ritual areas at Magdalenian cave sites

    Pablo Arias Cabal, Pablo Arias•World Archaeology•2009

  • Understanding Possession in Jainism

    Open Access•Knut Aukland•Modern Asian Studies•2013

  • Symbol, idol and mūrti

    Gregory Price Grieve•Renaissance and Modern Studies•2003

Citation velocityhistorical
Highly citedNo

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae