Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The lexicalist hypothesis

Both wrong and superfluous

Bibliographic Data

ID2986271
AuthorsBenjamin Bruening (0000-0002-9277-4235, corresponding author)
Year2018
Volume94
Issue1
Pages1-42
Publication date2018-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueLanguage (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0097-8507 • E-ISSN: 1535-0665
PublisherProject MUSE (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1353/lan.2018.0000
OpenAlexW2792098209
LanguageEN
Citations received35
References cited60

The lexicalist hypothesis, which says that the component of grammar that produces words is distinct and strictly separate from the component that produces phrases, is both wrong and superfluous. It is wrong because (i) there are numerous instances where phrasal syntax feeds word formation; (ii) there are cases where phrasal syntax can access subword parts; and (iii) claims that word formation and phrasal syntax obey different principles are not correct. The lexicalist hypothesis is superfluous because where there are facts that it is supposed to account for, those facts have independent explanations. The model of grammar that we are led to is then the most parsimonious one: there is only one combinatorial component of grammar that puts together both words and phrases

Component (thermodynamics) · Emergent grammar · Grammar · Linguistics · Natural language processing · Phrase structure rules · Relational grammar · Syntax · Word (group theory) · Word grammar · Computer Science · Language, Metaphor, and Cognition · Natural Language Processing Techniques · Philosophy · Syntax, Semantics, Linguistic Variation

  • Korean KE compounds as novel evidence for phrase-to-word compounding in the Syntax

    Open Access•Moonhyun Sung•Proceedings of the Linguistic…•2020

  • Toward an individual-difference perspective on phonologization

    Open Access•Alan C L Yu•Glossa a journal of general…•2021

  • The Tale of Two Lexicons

    Terje Lohndal, Michael T Putnam•Heritage Language Journal•2021

  • Brief response to Müller

    Open Access•Benjamin Bruening•Language•2018

  • Analogy in inflectional change

    Open Access•Eugen Hill•Language•2020

  • The end of lexicalism as we know it

    Open Access•Stefan Müller•Language•2018

  • A Collostructional and Constructional Approach to the Transitive out of - ing Construction

    Jungsoo Kim, Rok Sim•English Studies•2023

  • Morphological structure can escape reduction effects from mass admixture of second language speakers

    Open Access•Manuel Widmer, Mathias Jenny et al.•Studies in Language•2020

  • Mari and Udmurt do not require postsyntactic operations (A reply to Georgieva et al. 2021 and Guseva and Weisser 2018)

    Open Access•Benjamin Bruening•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2026

  • Against semantic features

    Open Access•Phoevos Panagiotidis•Glossa a journal of general…•2024

  • Dispositional middle constructions with accusative objects in Slovenian

    Open Access•Jakob Lenardič•Glossa a journal of general…•2024

  • Renumerating wh- compound questions in Japanese at the syntax-morphology interface

    Open Access•Yosuke Sato, Hisako Ikawa•Glossa a journal of general…•2025

  • Deriving and processing experiencer subject causatives

    Open Access•Daiki Asami•Glossa a journal of general…•2024

  • Going ✈️ lexicon? The linguistic status of pro-text emojis

    Open Access•John David Storment•Glossa a journal of general…•2024

  • Multifunctionality and syncretism in non-finite forms

    Ksenia Shagal, Pavel Rudnev et al.•Folia Linguistica•2022

  • Moving Past Slot-Fillers

    Open Access•Remi van Trijp•Zeitschrift für Anglistik und…•2025

  • Heads and layers in agglutination

    Open Access•Takashi Nakajima•Open Linguistics•2021

  • Analysis and falsifiability in practice

    Adam J R Tallman•Theoretical Linguistics•2021

  • It’s time for a complete theory of partial predictability in language

    Louise Mcnally, Olivier Bonami et al.•Theoretical Linguistics•2024

  • A split morphosyntactic analysis of diminutives in two Arabic varieties

    Open Access•Abdulazeez Jaradat, Linda Alkhawaja•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2024

  • The structure of inflected Urdu nominals

    Open Access•Faiza Ghulam Nabi, Baber Sultan Ali Khan et al.•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2025

  • Is This Verb a Word? A philological Study of the Distribution of Phonological and Morphological Domains in the Middle Welsh Verb

    Open Access•Stefan Dedio•Transactions of the Philological…•2023

  • Moving away from lexicalism in psycho- and neuro-linguistics

    Open Access•Alexandra Bunting Krauska, Alexandra Krauska et al.•Frontiers in Language Sciences•2023

  • The Syntax-Morphology Interface in Ancient Greek

    Nadav Asraf•Mnemosyne•2022

  • Deverbal nominals possess no internal VP structure

    Open Access•Arayik Hayriyan•Lingua•2020

  • No escape from syntax

    Open Access•Soo‐hwan Lee, Soo-Hwan Lee•Journal of Linguistics•2026

  • On the syntactic autonomy of theme vowels

    Open Access•Erik Zyman•Journal of Linguistics•2026

  • Radical tmesis is Internal Merge

    Open Access•Erik Zyman•Probus•2025

  • Revisiting Passive Participles

    Maša Bešlin•Linguistic Inquiry•2023

  • Comprehension and production of Kinyarwanda verbs in the Discriminative Lexicon

    Open Access•Ruben Van De Vijver, Emmanuel Uwambayinema et al.•Linguistics•2024

  • VP-Nominalization and the Final-over-Final Condition

    Johannes Hein, Andrew Murphy•Linguistic Inquiry•2022

  • The word as a unit of internal predictability

    Open Access•John Mansfield•Linguistics•2021

  • Construindo adjetivos disposicionais

    Open Access•Bruna Elisa Da Costa Moreira•Cadernos de Linguística e Teoria…•2021

  • The morph as a minimal linguistic form

    Open Access•Martin Haspelmath•Morphology•2020

  • A simpler analysis of English negation (and the Bulgarian definite marker)

    Open Access•Benjamin Bruening•Linguistic Variation•2025

  • Chomsky’s Remarks and the Transformationalist Hypothesis

    Open Access•Thomas Roeper, Tom Roeper•Handbook of Word-Formation…•2005

  • Word Meaning and Montague Grammar

    Open Access•David R Dowty•Word Meaning and Montague Grammar•1979

  • Focus in Generative Grammar

    Michael Rochemont, Michael S Rochemont•Focus in generative grammar•1986

  • The indeterminacy of word segmentation and the nature of morphology and syntax

    Martin Haspelmath•Folia Linguistica•2011

  • Severing the External Argument from its Verb

    Angelika Kratzer•Phrase Structure and the Lexicon•1996

  • The Oxford Handbook of Linguistic Interfaces

    Charles Reis, Gillian Ramchand et al.•The Oxford handbook of linguistic…•2007

  • The architecture of the language faculty

    Ray Jackendoff•The architecture of the language…•1997

  • Semantic Interpretation In Generative Grammar

    Ray S Jackendoff•Semantic Interpretation In…•1974

  • The View from building 20

    Kenneth L Hale, Samuel Jay Keyser•The View from building 20•1993

  • The languages of Japan

    Shibatani Masayoshi•The languages of Japan•1990

  • Verb-Particle Explorations

    Nicole Dehé, Ray Jackendoff et al.•Verb-Particle Explorations•2002

  • Particles

    Marcel Den Dikken•Particles•1995

  • Functional Structure in Nominals

    Artemis Alexiadou•Functional Structure in Nominals•2001

  • Lexical approaches to argument structure

    Stefan Müller, Stephen Wechsler•Theoretical Linguistics•2014

  • Focus on the prefix

    Open Access•Ann Wennerstrom•Phonology•1993

  • Affected Experiencers

    Open Access•Solveig Bosse, Benjamin Bruening et al.•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2012

  • Explaining the structure of case paradigms by the mechanisms of Nanosyntax

    Open Access•Pavel Caha•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2013

  • Word formation is syntactic

    Open Access•Benjamin Bruening•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2014

  • The syntax-semantics interface of ‘respective’ predication

    Open Access•Yusuke Kubota, Robert Levine et al.•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2016

  • The lexical integrity principle

    Open Access•Joan Bresnan, Sam A Mchombo et al.•Natural Language and Linguistic…•1995

  • Theta theory and the syntax of applicatives in Chichewa

    Open Access•Mark C Baker, Mark Baker•Natural Language and Linguistic…•1988

  • Bare coordination

    Open Access•Bert Le Bruyn, Henriette De Swart•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2014

  • The VP within Process Nominals

    Open Access•Jingqi Fu, Thomas Roeper et al.•Natural Language and Linguistic…•2001

  • The Representation of (In)Definiteness

    Jack Hoeksema, Eric J Reuland et al.•Language•1989

  • On the Grammar and Semantics of Sentence Accents

    Julia Hirschberg, Gregory Ward et al.•Language•1986

  • The Mental Representation of Grammatical Relations

    Mark Baltin, Joan Bresnan•Language•1985

  • Explaining Language Universals

    William Croft, John A Hawkins•Language•1991

  • The Scope of Lexical Rules

    Thomas Wasow, Michael Moortgat et al.•Language•1983

  • Discussion Note

    Open Access•Stefan Müller•Language•2006

  • The Oxford Handbook of Japanese Linguistics

    衛 斎藤, Shigeru Miyagawa•The Oxford handbook of Japanese…•2008

  • Handbook of Word-Formation

    Open Access•Pavol Štekauer, Rochelle Lieber•Handbook of Word-Formation…•2005

  • Split Scope of Negative Indefinites

    Open Access•Doris Penka•Language and Linguistics Compass•2012

  • Turkish suspended affixation

    Open Access•Barış Kabak, Bariş Kabak•Linguistics•2007

  • Prefixing and suffixing universals in relation to basic word order

    Open Access•John A Hawkins, Gary Gilligan•Lingua•1988

  • Phrasal morphology in Yoruba

    Open Access•Douglas Pulleyblank, Akinbiyi Akinlabi•Lingua•1988

  • Focus Below the Word Level

    Open Access•Ron Artstein•Natural Language Semantics•2004

  • How marginal are phrasal compounds? Generalized insertion, expressivity, and I/Q-interaction

    Open Access•Jörg Meibauer•Morphology•2007

  • A theory of focus interpretation

    Open Access•Mats Rooth•Natural Language Semantics•1992

  • A unified approach to split scope

    Open Access•Klaus Abels, L F Marti et al.•Natural Language Semantics•2010

  • The Lexicon-Syntax Parameter

    Tanya Reinhart, Tal Siloni•Linguistic Inquiry•2005

  • Double Objects Again

    Beck, Sigrid Beck et al.•Linguistic Inquiry•2004

  • Architecture and Blocking

    David Embick, Alec Marantz•Linguistic Inquiry•2008

  • Ditransitive Asymmetries and a Theory of Idiom Formation

    Benjamin Bruening•Linguistic Inquiry•2010

  • ByPhrases in Passives and Nominals

    Open Access•Benjamin Bruening•Syntax•2013

  • Complex phrase structures within morphological words

    Open Access•Yosuke Sato•Lingua•2010

  • Complex predicates and predicate raising

    Open Access•Y Kuroda•Lingua•2003

  • English Verb-Preposition Constructions

    Open Access•Patrick Farrell•Language•2005

  • Unifying everything

    Open Access•Stefan Müller•Language•2013

  • Revisiting Anaphoric Islands

    Open Access•Alice C Harris•Language•2006

  • English filler-gap constructions

    Open Access•Ivan A Sag•Language•2010

  • On the disunity of right-node raising phenomena

    Open Access•Rui P Chaves•Language•2014

  • Mixed Categories

    Mark C Baker, Mark Baker et al.•Language•1990

  • Noun Incorporation in Greenlandic

    Jerrold M Sadock•Language•1980

  • Bracketing Paradoxes and the English Lexicon

    Andrew Spencer•Language•1988

  • Word Formation in a Modular Theory of Grammar

    Masayoshi Shibatani, Taro Kageyama et al.•Language•1988

  • Autolexical Syntax

    Mark C Baker, Mark Baker et al.•Language•1997

  • A Pragmatic Analysis of So-Called Anaphoric Islands

    Gregory Ward, Richard Sproat et al.•Language•1991

  • Quotations as Demonstrations

    Herbert H Clark, Richard J Gerrig•Language•1990

  • Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation

    Donald Davidson, Donald Herbert Davidson•Inquiries into truth and…•2001

  • On the Definition of X0 and XP

    Open Access•Andrew Carnie•Syntax•2000

Unique citing works35
Citations per year4,38
Citation span2018 - 2026 (9)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 29

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae