In the Name of the Father and Other Stories by Julia & Peter Sherwood
Bibliographic Data
| ID | 3141946 |
|---|---|
| Authors | Ali Kinsella (corresponding author) |
| Year | 2018 |
| Volume | 92 |
| Issue | 1 |
| Pages | 78-78 |
| Publication date | 2018-01-01 |
| Open Access | No |
| Type | ARTICLE |
| Venue | World Literature Today (JOURNAL) |
| Journal identifiers | ISSN: 0196-3570 • E-ISSN: 1945-8134 |
| Publisher | Project MUSE (PUBLISHER • US) |
| DOI | 10.1353/wlt.2018.0340 |
| OpenAlex | W4206484765 |
| Language | EN |
author’s own psyche. As a youngster, Vosganian was believed to be a “child old in years” and “destined to be the family historian.” The book reads as a novel narrated both in the first and third person, but sometimes the author breaks form and speaks directly to his reader—a startling effect, to be sure. As a paean to his fellow Armenians who suffered such persecution and slaughter, the story is loaded with a myriad of names of the deceased (all of the characters in this book are real). At times, The Book of Whispers can be a confusing read. Not penned in chronological order, the author swings from one era in history to the next, sometimes on the same page. “For me, the storyteller,” he admits, it is quite “hard to keep to the thread of the story.” Be sure and read esteemed Romanian translator Alistair Blyth’s introduction, a good primer for what is to follow. Readers familiar with Armenian, Romanian, and Turkish history will find this work immensely engrossing; those who are not may well be a bit lost. Vosganian’s ethereal prose is at its best when describing wartime atrocities. It becomes a detached voice—a hypnotic voice—when grisly details are not spared. The sheer brutality of it all produces a kind of numbness in the reader. Then again, perhaps detachment is the only way to endure such terror. The face on the book’s cover depicts a person suffering unspeakable torment. Consider it preparation for what follows within its pages. Virginia Parobek Lancaster, Ohio Balla. In the Name of the Father and Other Stories. Trans. Julia & Peter Sherwood. London. Jantar. 2017. 129 pages. I wanted to like Balla’s In the Name of the Father, I really did. I was intrigued by the promise of a Slovak Kafka; I wanted to experience the Eastern European, post-Socialist take on magical realism. I wanted to celebrate the literature of a small nation. But, in the end, I was too distracted by Balla’s careless misogyny to be swept away by his whimsy. Part of the fun of reading Balla is not guessing what will happen next, but trying to figure out what’s already happened and just exactly what he’s talking about. There is something charming about all his non sequiturs and the chimerical world they construct. He has a wry take on nationalism, traditional values, and democracy-building; it’s refreshing the way he is willing—excited, even—to take jabs at them. But the thrust of the story is that the protagonist is mean to his sons and mean to his wife yet still feels sorry for himself for having to live in a world that doesn’t understand him. There’s the priest who badgers the wife into dutifully submitting to her husband’s sexual demands. The father whose lecherous glare makes the son hate him and, we’re supposed to believe, turns the son into a philanderer whose own licentiousness makes his sons hate him in turn. Balla relies on the hyperbole of increasingly cruel situations to let his reader in on the joke. You see, he doesn’t really believe these things; this is all in jest. The problem is, it’s just not that funny. It’s a tired joke for a white man to make. I don’t believe Balla wanted to write a collection of chauvinist short stories, nor do I believe the Sherwoods set out to translate one. Those would be weird goals to have. That the sexism is tongue-in-cheek is undeniable, yet so is the fact that it is real and printed on the page. “Contagion,” the last story, is by far the best, and the only one that doesn’t include a male-female relationship. Not having a female character to deny agency allows Balla to shine in his absurdism. Ali Kinsella Kyiv, Ukraine Grégoire Bouillier. Le dossier M, Livre 1. Paris. Flammarion. 2017. 880 pages. There’s something quirky, something darkly hilarious, about everything Grégoire Bouillier decides to set on the page. Not only are the scenarios he describes something out of a madman’s fantasy (his earlier
Art · Art history · Literature · Persecution · Politics · Psyche · Psychoanalysis · History · Law · Psychology · Themes in Literature Analysis
| Highly cited | No |
|---|