Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Peculiarities of Mexican History

Mexico Compared to Latin America, 1821-1992

Bibliographic Data

ID3210231
AuthorsAlan Knight (corresponding author)
Year1992
Volume24
IssueS1
Pages99-144
Publication date1992-03-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Latin American Studies (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0022-216X • E-ISSN: 1469-767X
PublisherCambridge University Press (CUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1017/s0022216x00023804
OpenAlexW2143876052
LanguageEN
Citations received18
References cited154

This is a piece of comparative history, not an exercise in folkloric whimsy. It does not attempt to probe the secrets oflo mexicano, la mexicanidad, or any of the other quasi-metaphysical concepts which litter the field of Mexican cultural history.1Nor does it pay too much attention to those more positivistic analyses which try to encapsulate Mexican (political) culture in terms of statistical comparisons.2Rather, it offers some comparative generalisations about Mexican history in the national period, stressing both broad patterns of socio-economic development and specific politico-cultural factors. Thus - for better or worse - its model is Barrington Moore rather than, say, Octavio Paz or Gabriel Almond. It also draws inspiration - and borrows its title - from the work of E. P. Thompson, which in turn has been developed by Eley and Blackbourn in the German context, Corrigan and Sayer in the English.3Its purpose is to offer some explanations of the distinctiveness (as well as the commonality) of Mexico's history, compared to the history of Latin America, in the national period.4Let us begin at the end. In the last fifty years, Mexico has experienced relatively rapid economic growth coupled with relative political and social stability.5The achievements of the 'stabilised development' of the 1950s and 1960s are well known: a solid regime, rapid growth rates, low inflation, rising per capita income.6And, while the 1980s were a decade of relative stagnation, Mexico's relative position within Latin America has not deteriorated.7Furthermore, the prospects for future development - of a capitalist kind, with all that that entails - look better now than they did in the late 1980s; all the more if the Free Trade Agreement with the U.S.A. is concluded, as now seems probable

Archaeology · Context (archaeology) · Development economics · Economic history · Economics · Geography · Latin Americans · Political science · Politics · History · History and Politics in Latin America · Law · Political and Social Dynamics in Chile and Latin America · Politics and Society in Latin America

  • La infraestructura y la logística en la historia económica

    Open Access•Guillermo Guajardo Soto•América Latina en la Historia…•2015

  • Peasants into Patriots

    Alan Knight•Mexican Studies/Estudios Mexicanos•1994

  • Public Health, Yellow Fever, and the Making of Modern Tampico

    Glen David Kuecker•Urban History Review•2008

  • The Vanguard of the Atlantic World

    Open Access•J E Sanders•Latin American Research Review•2011

  • The Vanguard of the Atlantic World

    Open Access•J E Sanders•Vanguard of the Atlantic World•2014

  • Explaining the Great Continuity

    James Mahoney•Patrimonial Capitalism and Empire•2015

  • The Vanguard of the Atlantic World

    James E Sanders•Vanguard of the Atlantic World•2014

  • Making Mexico

    Open Access•Kif Augustine-Adams, Kif Augustine‐Adams•Law and History Review•2009

  • Nationalist Exclusion and Ethnic Conflict

    Open Access•Andreas Wimmer•Nationalist Exclusion and Ethnic…•2002

  • Organized labor under military rule

    Open Access•John P Tuman•Studies in Comparative…•1994

  • A ritual of integration

    Open Access•Guillermo Merelo•Asian and Pacific migration journal•2018

  • State Infrastructural Power and Nationalism

    Open Access•M Vom Hau•Studies in Comparative…•2008

  • Hapsburg) Law and (Bourbon) Order

    Open Access•Michael C Scardaville•The Americas A Quarterly Review…•1994

  • Nationalism, economic crisis and ‘realistic revolution’ in 1980s Mexico

    Open Access•Randal Sheppard•Nations and Nationalism•2011

  • Medical Research Participation as Citizenship

    Open Access•E Wentzell•American Anthropologist•2015

  • Long-Run Development and the Legacy of Colonialism in Spanish America

    James Mahoney•American Journal of Sociology•2003

  • The cautious critique of foundational violence in Ignacio Manuel Altamirano'sEl Zarco

    Ryan Long•Journal of Latin American…•2007

  • Unfinished Imagined Communities

    Open Access•José Itzigsohn, M Vom Hau•Theory and Society•2006

  • Coffee and capitalism in the Venezuelan Andes

    William Roseberry•Coffee and capitalism in the…•1983

  • The labyrinth of solitude

    Octavio Paz•The labyrinth of solitude: life…•1962

  • Frontier expansion and peasant protest in Colombia, 1850-1936

    Catherine Legrand•Frontier expansion and peasant…•1986

  • Chilean rural society from the Spanish conquest to 1930

    Arnold J Bauer•Chilean rural society from the…•1975

  • Zapata and the Mexican Revolution.

    John Womack•Zapata and the Mexican Revolution.•1969

  • Politics, culture, and class in the French Revolution

    Lynn Avery Hunt•Politics, culture, and class in…•1984

  • Hacienda and market in eighteenth-century Mexico

    Eric Van Young•Hacienda and market in…•1981

  • Where the dove calls

    Thomas E Sheridan•Where the dove calls•1988

  • Class and society in central Chiapas

    Robert Wasserstrom•Class and society in central…•1983

  • Elites and Democratic consolidation in Latin America and Southern Europe

    John Higley, Richard Gunther•Elites and Democratic consolidation…•1992

  • Distant Neighbors

    Alan Riding•Distant Neighbors•1989

  • Revolution from above

    Ellen Kay Trimberger•Revolution from above•1978

  • The plural society in the British West Indies

    M G Smith•The plural society in the British…•1965

  • Roots of Insurgency

    Open Access•Brian R Hamnett•Roots of Insurgency•1986

  • The Cambridge history of Latin America

    Leslie Bethell•The Cambridge history of Latin…•1984

  • Guatemalan Indians and the State

    Arturo Arias, W George Lovell et al.•Guatemalan Indians and the State•1990

  • Justice by Insurance

    Woodrow Borah•Justice by Insurance•1983

  • The Limits of State Autonomy

    Nora Hamilton•Limits of State Autonomy•1982

  • The Rational Peasant

    Samuel L Popkin•Rational Peasant•1979

  • Seven Interpretive Essays on Peruvian Reality

    Jose Carlos Mariategui, Marjory Urquidi•Seven Interpretive Essays on…•1971

  • Trade, tribute, and transportation

    Ross Hassig•Trade, tribute, and transportation•1985

  • The Indian Christ, the Indian King

    Victoria Reifler Bricker•Indian Christ, the Indian King•1981

  • Popular Movements and Political Change in Mexico

    Joe Foweraker, Ann L Craig•Popular Movements and Political…•1990

  • Domination and Cultural Resistance

    Roger Neil Rasnake•Domination and Cultural Resistance•1988

  • The Peculiarities of German History

    David Blackbourn, Geoff Eley•The peculiarities of German history•1984

  • Democracy in Developing Countries

    Naomi Chazan, Christian Coulon et al.•Democracy in Developing Countries•1988

  • Outcasts in Their Own Land

    John Womack, Rodney D Anderson•The American Historical Review•1977

  • The Economies of Mexico and Peru during the Late Colonial Period, 1760-1810

    Brian R Hamnett, Nils Jacobsen et al.•Hispanic American Historical Review•1988

  • Chilean Rural Society from the Spanish Conquest to 1930

    Anthony Mcfarlane, Arnold J Bauer•The Economic History Review•1976

  • The Invention Of Tradition

    Eric Hobsbawm, Terence O Ranger•Invention of Tradition•2012

  • The Origins of Capitalist Development

    Robert Brenner•Introduction to the sociology of…•1982

  • The Defense of Community in Peru's Central Highlands

    Florencia E Mallon•Defense of Community in Peru's…•1983

  • Kinship, Business, and Politics

    David W Walker•Kinship, Business, and Politics•1986

  • Revolutionary Mexico

    John Mason Hart•Revolutionary Mexico•1987

  • Profile of Man and Culture in Mexico

    Peter G Earle, Samuel Ramos et al.•Profile of Man and Culture in…•1962

  • Intellectual Foundations of the Nicaraguan Revolution

    Donald Clark Hodges•Intellectual Foundations of the…•1986

  • The Rebellious Century

    Charles Tilly, Louise A Tilly et al.•Rebellious Century•1975

  • The Mexican Revolution

    James W Wilkie•Mexican Revolution•1970

  • The Idea of Race in Latin America, 1870-1940

    Alan Knight, Aline Helg et al.•Idea of Race in Latin America,…•1990

  • Peasant Nationalism and Communist Power

    Chalmers Johnson, Chalmers A Johnson•Peasant Nationalism and Communist…•1962

  • The Mexican Republic

    Stanley C Green•Mexican Republic•1987

  • Ranchero Revolt

    Ian Jacobs•Ranchero Revolt•1982

  • Ethnicity and Class Conflict in Rural Mexico

    Frans J Schryer•Ethnicity and Class Conflict in…•1990

  • Authoritarianism and Corporatism in Latin America

    James Malloy, James M Malloy•Authoritarianism and Corporatism…•1976

  • Revolution in History

    Open Access•Roy Sydney Porter, Roy Porter et al.•Revolution in History•1986

  • Quetzalcoatl and Guadalupe

    R C Padden, Jacques Lafaye et al.•The American Historical Review•1978

  • El trabajo y los trabajadores en la historia de México

    Woodrow Borah•Hispanic American Historical Review•1981

  • Dictaduras y dictadores

    John H Williams•Hispanic American Historical Review•1987

  • Outcasts in Their Own Land

    Stanley R Ross•Hispanic American Historical Review•1977

  • Transportes y comercio entre México y Veracruz, 1519-1910

    Arthur Schmidt•Hispanic American Historical Review•1978

  • The Mexican Petroleum Industry in the Twentieth Century

    Linda B Hall•Hispanic American Historical Review•1995

  • Modern Brazil

    Ronald H Chilcote•Hispanic American Historical Review•1991

  • Land and Society in Revolutionary Mexico

    Alan Knight•Mexican Studies/Estudios Mexicanos•1991

  • Cuba

    Susan Eckstein, Susan E Eckstein et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1979

  • Democracy in Mexico

    Julian Samora, Pablo González Casanova et al.•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1972

  • Unions and Politics in Mexico

    E A Cebotarev, Ian Roxborough•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1989

  • The Poverty of Theory and Other Essays

    Michael Scrivener•Telos•1979

  • The Limits of State Autonomy

    Open Access•Walter L Goldfrank•Political Science Quarterly•1984

  • Latin American Affairs

    Alex Eaglestone•International Affairs•1971

  • Colombia

    W O Galbraith•International Affairs•1968

  • Violence in Colombia

    Abraham F Lowenthal, Charles Bergquist et al.•Foreign Affairs•1992

  • Dominant Powers and Subordinate States

    John C Campbell, Jan F Triska et al.•Foreign Affairs•1986

  • The Invention of Argentina

    Nicolas Shumway•Invention of Argentina•1991

  • Critique of Arnold J. Bauer’s “Rural Workers in Spanish America

    Brian Loveman•Hispanic American Historical Review•1979

  • Rafael Carrera

    Open Access•Keith L Miceli•The Americas A Quarterly Review…•1974

  • The Revolutionary Process in Mexico

    Open Access•Richard Bradley•Latin American Anthropology Review•1992

  • Protest and Response in Mexico

    Kenneth F Johnson, Evelyn P Stevens•Hispanic American Historical Review•1975

  • The Caste War of Yucatán

    Nelson Reed•The Caste War of Yucatán•2002

  • The Aztecs Under Spanish Rule

    Charles Gibson•The Aztecs Under Spanish Rule•1964

  • Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy

    Barrington Moore, Jr Barrington Moore•Social Origins of Dictatorship…•1974

  • State and Society in Mexico

    Open Access•Susan Kaufman Purcell, John F H Purcell•World Politics•1980

  • Land and Labour in Mexican Rural Insurrections

    Simon Miller•Bulletin of Latin American Research•1991

  • The Mexican Revolution

    Alan Knight•Bulletin of Latin American Research•1985

  • Parliament and People in Seventeenth-Century England

    Christopher Hill•Past & Present•1981

  • Le Mexique

    Open Access•Torcuato S Di Tella, François-Xavier Guerra•Desarrollo Económico•1986

  • Region and Class in Modern Peruvian History

    C Kay, Rory Miller•Bulletin of Latin American Research•1988

  • Social Revolution

    Alan Knight•Bulletin of Latin American Research•1990

  • Puebla de los Angeles

    Simon Miller, Guy P C Thomson•The Economic History Review•1991

  • El Estado en América Latina. Teoría y práctica

    Open Access•Jorge Alonso, Pablo González Casanova•Revista Mexicana de Sociología•1991

  • The Fiscal Problems of Nineteenth-Century Colombia

    Open Access•Malcolm Deas•Journal of Latin American Studies•1982

  • The Mexican Hacienda between the Insurgency and the Revolution

    Open Access•Simon Miller•Journal of Latin American Studies•1984

  • Bulwarks of Patriotic Liberalism

    Open Access•Guy P C Thomson•Journal of Latin American Studies•1990

  • The 1893bogotazo

    Open Access•David Sowell•Journal of Latin American Studies•1989

  • Coffee and Capitalism in the Venezuelan Andes

    Arthur Morris, Arthur S Morris et al.•Bulletin of Latin American Research•1985

  • Cuba

    Murdo J Macleod, Levi Marrero•Hispanic American Historical Review•1976

  • Labor in Latin America

    Paul E Sigmund, Charles Bergquist•Hispanic American Historical Review•1987

  • The Rational Peasant. The Political Economy of Rural Society in Vietnam

    William J Duiker, Samuel L Popkin•Pacific Affairs•1980

  • The Myth of the Revolution

    Douglas W Richmond, Ilene V O''Malley et al.•Hispanic American Historical Review•1988

  • Guatemalan Indians and the State, 1540-1988

    James D Sexton, James Sexton et al.•Hispanic American Historical Review•1992

  • Campesinos y reformas

    Claude Morin, Rodolfo Pastor•Hispanic American Historical Review•1989

  • Kinship, Business, and Politics

    Doris M Ladd, David W Walker•Hispanic American Historical Review•1988

  • The Politics of Penury

    David W Walker, David Walker et al.•Hispanic American Historical Review•1988

  • Reform in Oaxaca, 1856-76

    Frank S Falcone, Charles R Berry•Hispanic American Historical Review•1981

  • Between Silver and Guano

    Timothy E Anna, Paul Gootenberg•Hispanic American Historical Review•1990

  • Region and Class in Modern Peruvian History

    Michael J Gonzales, Rory Miller•Hispanic American Historical Review•1988

  • Red Against Blue

    James W Park, Helen Delpar•Hispanic American Historical Review•1982

  • Textiles and Capitalism in Mexico

    Jan Bazant, Richard J Salvucci•Hispanic American Historical Review•1988

  • Economic Change and Rural Resistance in Southern Bolivia, 1889-1930

    Dwight B Heath, Eric D Langer•Hispanic American Historical Review•1990

  • On the Periphery of Nineteenth-Century Mexico

    Cynthia Radding, Stuart F Vo et al.•Hispanic American Historical Review•1983

  • The Most Precious Fruit of the Revolution

    Jim Handy•Hispanic American Historical Review•1988

Unique citing works18
Citations per year0,56
Citation span1994 - 2018 (25)
Citation velocityhistorical
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 13

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae