Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Backlash against Democracy Promotion

Bibliographic Data

ID3256285
AuthorsThomas Carothers (corresponding author)
Year2006
Volume85
Issue2
Pages55
Publication date2006-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueForeign Affairs (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0015-7120 • E-ISSN: 2327-7793
PublisherJSTOR (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.2307/20031911
OpenAlexW2606447365
LanguageEN
Citations received120

IN JANUARY, Russian President Vladimir Putin signed into law a controversial new bill imposing heightened controls on local and foreign nongovernmental organizations (NGOS) operating in the country. The new legislation, which requires all NGOS in Russia to inform the government in advance about every project they intend to conduct, is another marker of the country's dispiriting slide back toward authoritarianism. The law is also a sign of an equally disturbing and much broader trend. After two decades of the steady expansion of democracy-building programs around the world, a growing number of governments are starting to crack down on such activities within their borders. Strongmen-some of them elected officials-have begun to publicly denounce Western democracy assistance as illegitimate political meddling. They have started expelling or harassing Western NGOS and prohibiting local groups from taking foreign finds-or have started punishing them for doing so. This growing backlash has yet to coalesce into a formal or organized movement. But its proponents are clearly learning from and feeding off of one another. The recent color revolutions in Georgia, Ukraine, and Kyrgyzstan and the widespread suspicion that U.S. groups such as the National Democratic Institute (NDI), the International Republican Institute

Backlash · Democracy · Democracy promotion · Democratization · Development economics · Economics · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Promotion (chess) · Artificial Intelligence · Computer Science · Law · Political Conflict and Governance · Russia and Soviet political economy

  • Some Remarks on the Five Criteria of Democracy

    Open Access•Panagiotis Petratos•Athens Journal of Humanities and…•2022

  • State, regime, and government in the Kyrgyz Republic (1991–2010)

    Sally N Cummings, Shairbek Juraev et al.•East European Politics•2013

  • The normative challenge of interaction

    Open Access•Annika Elena Poppe, Jonas Wolff•Global Constitutionalism•2013

  • Counterterrorism and the New American Exceptionalism

    Michael Vlahos•The Review of Faith & International…•2012

  • NGO laws after the colour revolutions and the Arab spring

    Leah Gilbert, Payam Mohseni•Mediterranean Politics•2018

  • Disabling dissent

    Leah Gilbert, Payam Mohseni•Contemporary Politics•2018

  • Two at one blow? The EU and its quest for security and democracy by political conditionality in the Western Balkans

    Solina Richter, Solveig Richter•Democratization•2012

  • Questioning democracy promotion

    Elena Korosteleva•Democratization•2012

  • Lowest Common Denominator Norm Institutionalization

    Oisín Tansey•Global Governance A Review of…•2018

  • Venezuela

    Open Access•Javier Corrales, Graeme Orr et al.•Journal of democracy•2007

  • NGO networks in Central Asia and global civil society

    Charles Buxton•Central Asian Survey•2009

  • Localizing the NGO Delivery of Health from the Outside In

    Open Access•Amanda Murdie, Morgan Barney•Daedalus•2023

  • Democratic Backsliding in Africa?

    Open Access•Leonardo R Arriola, Lise Rakner et al.•Democratic Backsliding in Africa?•2022

  • Hostile Forces

    Jamie J Gruffydd-Jones•Hostile Forces•2022

  • United Nations Peacekeeping and the Politics of Authoritarianism

    Open Access•Sarah Von Billerbeck, Birte Julia Gippert et al.•United Nations Peacekeeping and…•2025

  • Athenian Democracy at War

    Open Access•David M Pritchard•Athenian Democracy at War•2018

  • Violence against Women in Politics

    Mona Lena Krook•Violence Against Women in Politics•2020

  • Popular Value Perceptions and Institutional Preference for Democracy in “Confucian” East Asia

    Young-Hee Chang, YoungHee Chang et al.•Asian perspective•2017

  • Courage, Principle and Ambition

    Robert M Pre, R M Press•Journal of Human Rights Practice•2011

  • Challenge of Localization under Restrictive Government Rule

    Open Access•Dima M Toukan•Global Studies Quarterly•2024

  • Closing Space for International Democracy and Human Rights Support

    Thomas Carothers•Journal of Human Rights Practice•2016

  • Practices of Policy Orientation

    Open Access•Leonie Holthaus, Jonas Wolff•International Studies Review•2022

  • Korea-European Union relations

    Robert E Kelly•International Relations of the…•2011

  • Covenants, Constitutions, and Distinct Law Types

    Open Access•Anthony J Demattee•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2019

  • American hýbris

    Open Access•Alessandro Badella, Alessandro Badella Alessandro Badella•International Journal of Cuban…•2014

  • Główne podejścia teoretyczne do analizy „kolorowych rewolucji” na obszarze postradzieckim

    Open Access•Liana Hurska-Kowalczyk•Przegląd Wschodnioeuropejski•2021

  • American hýbris

    Open Access•Alessandro Badella, Alessandro Badella Alessandro Badella•International Journal of Cuban…•2015

  • The Crisis in the Rise of Representative Liberal Democracy to Populist Authoritarianism with Post-Truth Politics

    Open Access•Nihal UMAR, Gencay SAYLAN•Revista de Cercetare si…•2021

  • Post-election performance of political parties in Ghana’s Fourth Republic

    Open Access•Joseph Darmoe, Kingsley S Agomor et al.•Cogent Social Sciences•2024

  • Deter and Engage

    Open Access•Ulrich Kühn•New Perspectives•2015

  • Closing the closing space

    Jan Hornat•Global Affairs•2016

  • Toward a Coherent Framework

    Open Access•Anthony J Demattee•Nonprofit Policy Forum•2019

  • Contesting the hegemony of democracy promotion

    Joel Lazarus•Critical Policy Studies•2014

  • Resilience of the Communist Party of Vietnam's Authoritarian Regime since Đổi Mới

    Open Access•Hai Hong Nguyen•Journal of Current Southeast…•2016

  • Keeping threat at arm’s length

    Christopher Linebarger, Angela D Nichols et al.•Dynamics of Asymmetric Conflict•2019

  • Can America Finance Freedom? Assessing U.S. Democracy Promotion via Economic Statecraft

    Open Access•Stephen Collins•Foreign Policy Analysis•2009

  • Building Security Where there is No Security

    Open Access•Richard Hill, Jonathan Temin et al.•Journal of Peacebuilding &…•2007

  • Constructing a Framework of Authoritarian Diffusion

    Open Access•Thomas Ambrosio•International Studies Perspectives•2010

  • Public opinion on human rights in Putin-era Russia

    T P Gerber•Journal of Human Rights•2017

  • The domestic origins of human rights trials

    Alan J Simmons•Journal of Human Rights•2016

  • Images and perceptions of human rights defenders in Russia

    Polina Malkova•Journal of Human Rights•2020

  • Punishment and political systems

    Open Access•Leonidas K Cheliotis, Sappho Xenaki•Punishment & Society•2016

  • Zwischen Regulierung und Repression

    Open Access•Thomas Richter, Jessica Johansson et al.•Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft•2021

  • A case for global democracy? Arms exports and conflicting goals in democracy promotion

    Open Access•Pavel Dufek, Michal Mochtak•Journal of International…•2017

  • Les défis de la consolidation dans les nouvelles démocraties

    Gerard Alexander•Revue internationale de politique…•2011

  • The International Dimension of Autocratisation

    Antonino Castaldo, Marcelo Camerlo•Global Society•2025

  • Lockdown of expression

    Open Access•Felix S Bethke, Jonas Wolff•Democratization•2023

  • International democracy promotion across two waves

    Open Access•Julia Leininger•Democratization•2026

  • India and Democracy Promotion

    Open Access•Yeshi Choedon•India Quarterly A Journal of…•2015

  • Who survived? Ethiopia's regulatory crackdown on foreign-funded NGOs

    Kendra Dupuy, Kendra E Dupuy et al.•Review of International Political…•2014

  • Nationalism and authoritarianism in Russia

    Open Access•Taras Kuzio•Communist and Post-Communist…•2016

  • Forging Democracy in the Flames

    Open Access•Paulina Pospieszna, Patrice C Mcmahon•Communist and Post-Communist…•2024

  • Russia's Identity

    Richard Sakwa•Europe Asia Studies•2011

  • Catching the ‘Shanghai Spirit’

    Thomas Ambrosio•Europe Asia Studies•2008

  • Bashing about Rights’? Russia and the ‘New’ EU States on Human Rights and Democracy Promotion

    Rick Fawn•Europe Asia Studies•2009

  • Co-optation or Empowerment? The Fate of Pro-Democracy NGOs after the Rose Revolution

    Brian Grodsky•Europe Asia Studies•2012

  • Gas Supply and EU–Russia Relations

    Evert Faber Van Der Meulen•Europe Asia Studies•2009

  • Russia's Post-Orange Revolution Strategies to Increase its Influence in Former Soviet Republics

    Sinikukka Saari•Europe Asia Studies•2014

  • Russia, the West and the 2007–2008 Electoral Cycle

    Peter J S Duncan•Europe Asia Studies•2012

  • Democratic decline in the EU and its effect on democracy promotion in Central Asia

    Open Access•Anna-Lena Hönig, Shirin Tumenbaeva•Cambridge Review of International…•2022

  • Emerging donors

    Andrew F Cooper, Asif B Farooq et al.•Cambridge Review of International…•2015

  • An unwilling client

    William Lafi Youmans•Cambridge Review of International…•2015

  • Democracy promotion, post-truth politics and the practices of political expertise

    Michael Christensen•Cambridge Review of International…•2020

  • The Venezuelan Government and the Global Field

    Open Access•Timothy M Gill•Sociological Forum•2015

  • A Pragmatic Actor — The US Response to the Arab Uprisings

    Daniela Huber•Journal of European Integration•2014

  • The geo-constitution

    Open Access•Jane Wills•Progress in Human Geography•2018

  • Aid Effectiveness in Times of Political Change

    Open Access•Emmanuel Frot, Anders Olofsgård et al.•World Development•2013

  • Regional organisations and enduring defective democratic members

    Open Access•Mathew Davies•Review of International Studies•2017

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Elin Bjarnegård•European Journal of Development…•2020

  • Contending Orders

    Geoffrey Swenson•Contending Orders•2022

  • Why civil resistance works

    Maria J Stephan, Erica Chenoweth•Choice Reviews Online•2012

  • Unpacking U.S. Democracy Promotion in Bolivia

    Open Access•Neil Burron•Latin American Perspectives•2012

  • Economic globalisation, relative power, and post-cold war democratisation

    Jingnan Liu•Cambridge Review of International…•2024

  • Nashi, Youth Voluntarism, and Potemkin NGOs

    J Hemment•Slavic Review•2012

  • Decoding Russia’s 2018 Presidential Elections

    Open Access•Archana Upadhyay•International Studies•2018

  • Beyond Autocracy Promotion

    Open Access•Katsiaryna Yakouchyk•Political Studies Review•2019

  • Great powers, civil society and authoritarian diffusion in Central Asia

    Charles E Ziegler•Central Asian Survey•2016

  • Authoritarian regimes in democratic regional organisations? Exploring regional dimensions of authoritarianism in an increasingly democratic West Africa

    Edward Stoddard•Journal of Contemporary African…•2017

  • Fear of democracy or revolution

    Fiona Hill, Kevin Jones et al.•The Washington Quarterly•2006

  • Advancing the freedom agenda

    Jennifer L Windsor, Jennifer Windsor•The Washington Quarterly•2006

  • Why Civil Resistance Works

    Maria J Stephan, Erica Chenoweth•International Security•2008

  • Unpacking the world cultural toolkit in socialist Venezuela

    Timothy M Gill•Third World Quarterly•2017

  • The micro-politics of norm contestation between the OSCE and Kazakhstan

    Rico Isaacs•Third World Quarterly•2018

  • Moldova Between Europe and Russia

    Luke March, Graeme P Herd•Post-Soviet Affairs•2006

  • Shifting Imperial Strategies in Contemporary Latin America

    Open Access•Timothy M Gill•Journal of Historical Sociology•2019

  • Russia’s Night Wolves, Migrating Memory and Europe’s Eastern Frontier

    Open Access•Molnar, Virág Molnár et al.•European Journal of Sociology•2021

  • Three dilemmas of hybrid regime governance

    Nikolay Petrov, Maria Lipman et al.•Post-Soviet Affairs•2014

  • Are Female Political Leaders Role Models? Lessons from Asia

    Open Access•Shan-Jan Sarah Liu•Political Research Quarterly•2018

  • The Determinants of US Public Opinion Towards Democracy Promotion

    Open Access•Dawn Brancati•Political Behavior•2014

  • The Power and Limits of Russia’s Strategic Narrative in Ukraine

    Open Access•Joanna Szostek•Perspectives on Politics•2017

  • Hugo Chavez and President Bush's Credibility Gap

    Open Access•N Scott Cole, Neil Cole•International Political Science…•2007

  • Political Participation and Regime Stability

    Open Access•Joakim Ekman•International Political Science…•2009

  • Military Size and the Effectiveness of Democracy Assistance

    Open Access•Jesse Dillon Savage•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2017

  • Anti-Americanism, Authoritarian Politics, and Attitudes about Women's Representation

    Open Access•Sarah Sunn Bush, Amaney A Jamal et al.•International Studies Quarterly•2015

  • Density and Decline in the Founding of International NGOs in the United States

    Open Access•Sarah Sunn Bush, Jennifer Hadden•International Studies Quarterly•2019

  • International Politics and the Spread of Quotas for Women in Legislatures

    Open Access•Sarah Sunn Bush•International Organization•2011

  • D-Minus Elections

    Open Access•Judith G Kelley, Judith Kelley•International Organization•2009

  • India as a democracy promoter? New Delhi's involvement in Nepal's return to democracy

    Sandra Destradi•Democratization•2012

  • Spoiler or facilitator of democratization

    Laure Delcour, Kataryna Wolczuk•Democratization•2015

  • From neo-corporatism to delegative corporatism? Empowerment of NGOs during early democratization

    Brian Grodsky•Democratization•2009

Unique citing works120
Citations per year6
Citation span2006 - 2026 (21)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 108

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae