Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Democratic Partisanship

From Theoretical Ideal to Empirical Standard

Bibliographic Data

ID3399255
AuthorsLise Esther Herman (0000-0001-9796-5922, London School of Economics and Political Science, corresponding author)
Year2017
Volume111
Issue4
Pages738-754
Publication date2017-11-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Political Science Review (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0003-0554 • E-ISSN: 1537-5943
PublisherCambridge University Press (CUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1017/s0003055417000247
OpenAlexW2737957293
LanguageEN
Citations received23
References cited85

In recent years, a number of scholars have taken parties and partisanship as objects of normative theorizing. They posit partisanship as a fundamentally democratic practice and develop a model of what partisans can do at their best to contribute to liberal democracy. However, the standards the literature puts forth remain insufficiently specified to serve as empirical benchmarks. This article further conceptualizes this model of democratic partisanship and offers a theoretical framework within which to empirically evaluate the democratic merits of partisan discourses. It establishes a series of indicators for assessing the extent to which partisan discourse displays two main qualities: cohesiveness and respect for political pluralism. The article then discusses the implications of using this theoretical framework as a basis for empirical studies and shows how the model can thereby benefit both political scientists and theorists

Democracy · Economics · Empirical research · Epistemology · Ideal (ethics · Law and economics · Normative · Pluralism (philosophy · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Positive economics · Sociology · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Law · Political Philosophy and Ethics · Populism, Right-Wing Movements

  • Shades of Negativity in European Parliament Debates

    Open Access•Lise Esther Herman, Julian Hoerner et al.•Government and Opposition•2026

  • The Determinants of Fiscal Health

    Ricardo Gómez, Ricardo Corrêa Gomes et al.•International Journal of Public…•2026

  • Robust CEO Activism and Two-Sided Alignment

    Open Access•Dorothee Maria Winkler, Florian Überbacher et al.•Journal of Business Ethics•2026

  • Politics of Last Resort

    Jonathan White•Politics of Last Resort•2019

  • The virus of polarization

    Open Access•Fabiana Schmid, Oliver Treib et al.•Political Research Exchange•2022

  • Between militant democracy and citizen vigilantism

    Open Access•Tore Vincents Olsen, Juha Tuovinen•Global Constitutionalism•2023

  • Mapping ideological diversity from inside parties

    Open Access•Florence Écormier-Nocca•French Politics•2020

  • Can partisans be pluralist? A comparative study of party member discourse in France and Hungary

    Open Access•Lise Esther Herman•The British Journal of Politics…•2020

  • Democracy and pluralism after European integration

    Open Access•Bertjan Wolthuis, Ben Crum et al.•Critical Review of International…•2025

  • Extraordinary partisanship in the European Union

    Open Access•Markus Patberg•Constellations•2020

  • An Ideal of Nonfactionalism for Party Politics

    Emilee Booth Chapman•The Journal of Politics•2024

  • Resisting Abusive Legalism

    Lise Esther Herman, Russell Muirhead•Representation•2021

  • New Challenges for a Normative Theory of Parties and Partisanship

    Emilee Booth Chapman•Representation•2021

  • What Kind of Electoral System Sustains a Politics of Firm Commitments

    Jonathan White•Representation•2021

  • Populist Democrats? Unpacking the Relationship Between Populist and Democratic Attitudes at the Citizen Level

    Open Access•Andrei Zaslove, Andrej Zaslove et al.•Political Studies•2024

  • Populist but Pluralist? Populist Attitudes and Preferences for Political Pluralism in Parliament and Government

    Open Access•Victor Ellenbroek, Maurits J Meijers et al.•Parliamentary Affairs•2023

  • Dancing with the devil? Emmanuel Macron, Marine Le Pen and the articulation of a new political divide in France

    Open Access•Lise Esther Herman, Marta Lorimer•Nations and Nationalism•2024

  • The Myth of Mayoral Leadership in Local Government Resource Allocation

    Open Access•Ralph C Gomes, Ricardo C Gomes et al.•Journal of Public Administration…•2022

  • The Democratic Production of Political Cohesion

    Open Access•R Bellamy, Matteo Bonotti et al.•Contemporary Political Theory•2019

  • The populist leader's two bodies

    Open Access•David Ragazzoni•Constellations•2020

  • Perceptions and Conceptions of Democracy

    Open Access•Tom Ulbricht•Comparative Political Studies•2018

  • The Political Theory of Parties and Partisanship

    Open Access•Russell Muirhead, Nancy L Rosenblum•Annual Review of Political Science•2020

  • Shrinking the space for civil society

    Open Access•Patrick Müller, Peter Slominski•New Community•2022

  • Parties and party systems

    Giovanni Sartori•Parties and party systems•1976

  • Pathologies of Rational Choice Theory

    Donald Green, Ian Shapiro•Pathologies of Rational Choice…•1996

  • Representative Democracy

    Nadia Urbinati•Representative Democracy•2006

  • The Idea of a Party System

    Richard Hofstadter•Idea of a Party System•1969

  • The Good Representative

    Open Access•Suzanne Dovi•Good Representative•2007

  • The Promise of Party in a Polarized Age

    Russell Muirhead•Promise of Party in a Polarized Age•2014

  • Chapter 5

    Paul M Sniderman, Sean M Theriault•Studies in Public Opinion•2004

  • An economic theory of democracy

    Anthony Downs•An economic theory of democracy•1985

  • Critical Citizens

    Pippa Norris•Critical citizens•1999

  • Handbook of Party Politics

    Richard Katz, Richard S Katz et al.•Handbook of Party Politics•2006

  • Liberal Pluralism

    Open Access•William A Galston•Liberal Pluralism•2002

  • Liberalism and the Moral Life

    Nancy L Rosenblum•Liberalism and the Moral Life•1989

  • Communication Yearbook 34

    Charles T Salmon•Communication Yearbook 34•2010

  • The Meaning of Partisanship

    Jonathan White, Lea Ypi•Meaning of Partisanship•2016

  • The Moral Distinctiveness of Representative Democracy

    George Kateb•Ethics•1981

  • Electoral Change in Advanced Industrial Democracies

    Scott E Flanagan, Russell J Dalton et al.•Electoral Change in Advanced…•1985

  • The State as Cultural Practice

    Mark Bevir, Roderick A W Rhodes•The State As Cultural Practice•2010

  • The Practice of Liberal Pluralism

    Open Access•William A Galston•Practice of Liberal Pluralism•2004

  • Democratic Phoenix

    Open Access•P Norris•Democratic Phoenix•2002

  • Inclusion and Democracy

    Open Access•Bill Jordan•Authoritarianism and How to…•2020

  • Inclusion and Democracy

    Iris Marion Young•Readings in Planning Theory•2015

  • Membership and Morals

    Nancy L Rosenblum•Membership and Morals•1998

  • Meeting Democracy

    Open Access•Donatella Della Porta, Dieter Rucht•Meeting Democracy•2013

  • Building Blocs

    Cedric De Leon, Manali Desai et al.•Building Blocs•2020

  • Post-Communist Party Systems

    Open Access•Herbert Kitschelt, Zdenka Mansfeldová et al.•Post-Communist Party Systems•1999

  • Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy

    Gaël Fain, Joseph Alois Schumpeter et al.•Capitalism, socialism, and…•2010

  • Political Liberalism vs. “The Great Game of Politics”

    Russell Muirhead, Nancy L Rosenblum•Perspectives on Politics•2006

  • Partisanship and public reason

    Matteo Bonotti•Critical Review of International…•2014

  • Partisanship and independence

    Nancy L Rosenblum•Critical Review of International…•2014

  • Populism and technocracy

    Christopher J Bickerton, Carlo Invernizzi Accetti•Critical Review of International…•2015

  • Transnational partisanship

    Jonathan White•Critical Review of International…•2014

  • Authorisation and Authenticity

    Open Access•Michael Saward•Journal of Political Philosophy•2008

  • A Deliberative Model of Intra‐Party Democracy

    Open Access•Fabio Wolkenstein•Journal of Political Philosophy•2015

  • The Comparative Analysis of Electoral and Partisan Politics

    Herbert Kitschelt•West European Politics•2010

  • Post-Communist Democratization

    Open Access•John S Dryzek, Robert Legvold et al.•Post-Communist Democratization•2002

  • The Common Good

    Open Access•William A Galston•Daedalus•2013

  • How unstable? Volatility and the genuinely new parties in Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Allan Sikk•European Journal of Political…•2005

  • Programmatic Party Cohesion in Emerging Postcommunist Democracies

    Open Access•Herbert Kitschelt, Regina Smyth•Comparative Political Studies•2002

  • Democracy and political theory

    Claude Lefort•Essais sur le politique•1988

  • The spirit of compromise

    Amy Gutmann•The spirit of compromise•2012

  • The impact of party organisational changes on democracy

    Elin Haugsgjerd Allern, Karina Kosiara-Pedersen et al.•West European Politics•2007

  • Continuous Institutional Innovation and the Pragmatic Conception of Democracy

    Open Access•Archon Fung•Polity•2012

  • Conceptualising Political Parties

    Open Access•Matteo Bonotti•Politics•2011

  • Partisanship and Political Obligation

    Open Access•Matteo Bonotti•Politics•2012

  • The Empirical Theorists of Democracy and Their Critics

    Open Access•Quentin Skinner•Political Theory•1973

  • Problems, Methods, and Theories in the Study of Politics, or What's Wrong with Political Science and What to Do About it

    Open Access•Ian Shapiro, Ян Шапиро•Political Theory•2002

  • Representation as Advocacy

    Open Access•Nadia Urbinati•Political Theory•2000

  • What Can Democratic Participation Mean Today

    Open Access•Mark E Warren•Political Theory•2002

  • Opinion Structure of Political Parties

    Open Access•John D’arcy May•Political Studies•1973

  • Rethinking the Modern Prince

    Open Access•Jonathan White, Lea Ypi•Political Studies•2010

  • The Political Psychology of Contemporary Anti‐Politics

    Open Access•David Weltman, M Billig•Political Psychology•2001

  • A Defense of Party Spirit

    Russell Muirhead•Perspectives on Politics•2006

  • The Mindsets of Political Compromise

    Open Access•Amy Gutmann, D F Thompson et al.•Perspectives on Politics•2010

  • Democratic Theorists and Party Scholars

    Ingrid Van Biezen, Michael Saward•Perspectives on Politics•2008

  • The decline of membership-based politics

    Open Access•Ingrid Van Biezen, Thomas Poguntke•Party Politics•2014

  • From the Politics of State-Building To Programmatic Politics

    Open Access•Tim Haughton, Sharon Fisher•Party Politics•2008

  • Ideological misfits

    Open Access•Emilie Van Haute, R Kenneth Carty•Party Politics•2012

  • A Deliberative Defence of Intra-Party Democracy

    Open Access•Jan Teorell•Party Politics•1999

  • The Democratic Disconnect

    Open Access•Roberto S Foa, Yascha Mounk•Journal of democracy•2016

  • Re-evaluating the post-communist success story

    Open Access•Lise Esther Herman•European Political Science Review•2016

  • The role of agency in cleavage formation

    Open Access•Zsolt Enyedi•European Journal of Political…•2005

  • The Representative Claim

    Michael Saward•2010

  • The Party in Time

    Open Access•Jonathan White•British Journal of Political…•2017

  • How Parties Shape Class Politics

    Open Access•Geoffrey M Evans, Geoffrey Evans et al.•British Journal of Political…•2012

  • A Normative Turn in Political Science

    Open Access•John Gerring, Joshua C Yesnowitz et al.•Polity•2006

  • The Cartel Party Thesis

    Open Access•Richard S Katz, Peter Mair•Perspectives on Politics•2009

  • Political Preference Formation

    Open Access•James N Druckman•American Political Science Review•2004

  • Rethinking Representation

    Open Access•Joanna Mansbridge, Jane Mansbridge•American Political Science Review•2003

  • Theories of Political Justification

    Open Access•Sherrie Chamber, Simone Chamber et al.•Philosophy Compass•2010

  • On Partisan Political Justification

    Open Access•Jonathan White, Lea Ypi•American Political Science Review•2011

  • Framing Public Opinion in Competitive Democracies

    Open Access•Dennis Chong, James N Druckman•American Political Science Review•2007

  • Does Attack Advertising Demobilize the Electorate

    Open Access•Stephen Ansolabehere, Sharad Iyengar et al.•American Political Science Review•1994

  • Political Science and World Stabilization

    Open Access•Quincy Wright•American Political Science Review•1950

  • Toward a Mobilization Conception of Democratic Representation

    Open Access•Lisa Disch•American Political Science Review•2011

  • Political Science and the Three New Institutionalisms

    Open Access•Peter A Hall, Rosemary C R Taylor•Political Studies•1996

Unique citing works23
Citations per year2,88
Citation span2018 - 2026 (9)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 22

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae