"A Comment on "Savonarola, Florence, and the Millenarian Tradition

It appears to me that the strength of Professor Weinstein's inquiry is predicated upon the concreteness of his approach and his unwillingness to take refuge in those abstractions which are not infrequently found in the realm of Medieval and Renaissance studies. Therefore, the hypothesis that he advances stems from data, rather than from an unverifiable assumption about the nature of man or of thought in the Quattrocento. Another quality which is evident in his paper is his commitment to a type of research which is essentially an adventure. This figure of speech is intended to suggest that he is trying to isolate and then delineate a problem. In this instance, the unknown quantity is the boundary line that separates the historical from the a-historical. As a result of his search, he is compelled to modify the interpretations of Garin and Cantimori. His explanation is based upon the decisive role that historical circumstance and Florentine tradition (possibly two facets of a single entity) played in forging the prophetic message of Savonarola. Therefore, he locates the center of gravity of the Dominican's teachings "in tempore," rather than in the a-historical "world of ideas." For Professor Weinstein, the boundaries of Savonarola's prophecies are generated by "the fervor of daily events." Not only does this view appear to be valid, for the reasons advanced by the speaker, but there are also factors that are peripheral to his central argument which lend it further authenticity

Adventure · Archaeology · Argument (complex analysis) · Art · Art history · Boundary line · Concreteness · Epistemology · Literature · Millenarianism · Political science · Quality (philosophy) · Realm · Sociology · Anthropology · Computer Science · History · Law · Medieval and Early Modern Justice · Medieval Literature and History · Philosophy · Renaissance and Early Modern Studies

• Florence and the Despots Some Aspects of Florentine Diplomacy in the Fourteenth Century

  Open Access•N Rubinstein•Transactions of the Royal…•1952

  Añadir item

• Three Cases Concerning the Restitution of Usury in Florence

  Open Access•Marvin B Becker•The Journal of Economic History•1957

  Añadir item