Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

These People Could Be Anyone

Fear, Contempt (and Empathy) in a British Immigration Removal Centre

Bibliographic Data

ID3624969
AuthorsAlexandra Hall (0000-0002-1946-0715)
Year2010
Volume36
Issue6
Pages881-898
Publication date2010-07-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueNew Community (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0047-9586 • E-ISSN: 1469-9451
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/13691831003643330
OpenAlexW2004857624
LanguageEN
Citations received55
References cited44

Detention is proliferating as a governmental response to human mobility in the 'war on terror'. Theoretical engagements with spaces of detention and enclosure have been influenced by Agamben's work on the camp and the sovereign exception. Such a view focuses on the abject 'bare life' that is produced by the sovereign decision. Drawing on ethnographic fieldwork among staff at a UK immigration removal centre, the paper makes the case for 'going inside' the detention centre. It examines the everyday life of detention through the lens of emotion, with a focus on fear and contempt. Exploring these emotions as forms of judgement or construal can unravel staff dispositions towards the detainees, and can demonstrate the ways in which emotion shapes the treatment the detainees receive. The paper argues for emotion as an analytical tool; in the case of detention, it can supplement abstract accounts of 'the camp

Contempt · Disgust · Immigration detention · Judgement · Criminal Justice and Corrections Analysis · Migration, Refugees, and Integration · Political Theology and Sovereignty

  • Encounters of Despair

    Open Access•L M Borrelli•Anthropologica•2021

  • The geographical scales of fear

    Open Access•Mirjam Cecília Sági, Mirjam Sági•Hungarian Geographical Bulletin•2022

  • Geographies of state violence

    Open Access•Devran Koray Öcal•Progress in Human Geography•2026

  • Reactive limits to diaspora enfranchisement policies

    Anca Turcu•Diaspora Studies•2018

  • Policing the Borders Within

    Ana Aliverti•Policing the Borders Within•2021

  • Inside Asylum Bureaucracy

    Open Access•Julia Dahlvik•Inside Asylum Bureaucracy•2018

  • Quality of life among immigrants in Swedish immigration detention centres

    Open Access•Soorej Jose Puthoopparambil, Magdalena Bjerneld et al.•Global Health Action•2015

  • Detainees, staff, and health care services in immigration detention centres

    Open Access•Soorej Jose Puthoopparambil, Magdalena Bjerneld•Global Health Action•2016

  • Migration-related detention centers

    Open Access•Francesca Esposito, José Ornelas et al.•BMC International Health and…•2015

  • Bordering encounters, sociality and distribution of the ability to live a ‘normal life’

    Open Access•D Dzenovska•Social Anthropology•2014

  • Tracing the circulation of emotions in Swiss migration enforcement

    Open Access•L M Borrelli•Identities•2024

  • Sensuous Ethnography

    Sadaf Javdani•Visual Anthropology•2016

  • Blood, sweat and tears

    Open Access•L M Borrelli, William Walters•Environment and Planning C…•2024

  • Ambiguous goals, uneven implementation – how immigration offices shape internal immigration control in Germany

    Open Access•Caroline Schultz•Comparative Migration Studies•2020

  • Paradoxical infrastructures of asylum

    Open Access•Zachary Whyte, Rebecca Campbell et al.•Migration Studies•2018

  • Countering isolation with the use of technology

    Kate Coddington, A Mountz•Journal of the Indian Ocean Region•2014

  • Doing research in immigration removal centres

    Open Access•Mary Bosworth, Blerina Kellezi•Criminology & Criminal Justice•2016

  • Techniques of legitimation

    Open Access•Thomas Ugelvik•Crime Media Culture An…•2016

  • Law and Refugee Crises

    Open Access•Silvia Pasquetti, Noemi Casati et al.•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2019

  • Coerced to Leave

    Open Access•Ines Hasselberg•Surveillance & Society•2014

  • Female Asylum Seekers

    Open Access•Maria De Angelis•Social Policy and Society•2019

  • The politics of fear and empathy

    M Zembylas•European Journal of Intercultural…•2012

  • Affect and authority in immigration detention

    Open Access•Mary Bosworth•Punishment & Society•2018

  • Punishment on arrival

    Open Access•Claudia McHardy•Punishment & Society•2021

  • In search of recognition

    Open Access•Mary Bosworth, Gavin Slade•Punishment & Society•2014

  • Intercultural empathy among Norwegian students

    Trond Solhaug, Audrey Osler•International Journal of…•2017

  • Reassessing the camp/prison dichotomy

    Open Access•Ettore Asoni•Progress in Human Geography•2022

  • Conceptualizing detention

    Open Access•A Mountz, Kate Coddington et al.•Progress in Human Geography•2012

  • Yes, But Somebody Has to Help Them, Somehow

    Open Access•Francesca Esposito, José Ornelas et al.•International Migration Review•2021

  • Shaping Borders

    Open Access•Federica Infantino•The Annals of the American…•2023

  • Border Control and the Degradation of Labour

    Open Access•Mary Bosworth•The British Journal of Criminology•2024

  • Power and Purpose in an Immigration Removal Centre

    Open Access•Dominic Aitken•The British Journal of Criminology•2024

  • Abnormal bordering

    Open Access•Amalia Campos-Delgado•The British Journal of Criminology•2021

  • Empathy, morality, and criminality

    Irene I Vega•New Community•2018

  • Detention and its discontents

    Sarah Walker•New Community•2019

  • They Will Destroy Themselves Wanting Purely American

    Leah Montange•Annals of the American…•2023

  • Subjectivity and identity in detention

    Open Access•Mary Bosworth•Theoretical Criminology•2012

  • Deportation limbo

    Open Access•A Lindberg•Deportation Limbo•2023

  • Performing Homeland Security within the US Immigrant Detention System

    Open Access•Nancy Hiemstra•Environment and Planning D…•2014

  • Hunger strikes, detainee protest, and the relationality of political subjectivization

    Leah Montange•Citizenship Studies•2017

  • On Detention and Skill

    Open Access•Natasha N Iskander, Natasha Iskander•American Behavioral Scientist•2019

  • Building and blurring the intimate boundaries of nation, race and geopolitics in a suburb neighbouring a UK immigration removal centre

    Open Access•C Leddy-Owen•Environment and Planning D…•2016

  • Stuck in the middle

    Open Access•Sarah Turnbull•Time & Society•2016

  • The trauma of exploitation

    Open Access•Felicity Collins, Christina Stringer•Environment and Planning A…•2023

  • Examining the 'National Risk Assessment for Detention' process

    Stephanie J Silverman, Esra Stephanie Kaytaz et al.•New Community•2022

  • Visa Officers as Gatekeepers of a State's Borders

    Vic Satzewich•New Community•2014

  • All quiet on the 'Eastern front'? Controlling transit migration in Latvia and Lithuania

    A Lindberg, L M Borrelli•New Community•2021

  • How cities shape refugee centres

    Noemi Casati•New Community•2018

  • Under pressure

    Open Access•G Perl•New Community•2025

  • The affective economy of removal

    Strasser, Martin Sökefeld•New Community•2025

  • Desiring 'foreign talent

    P Yang•New Community•2018

  • "On board the quarantine-ship as "floating hotspot

    Open Access•Elena Giacomelli, Sarah Walker•Ethnography•2022

  • Judgement and Ambivalence in Migration Work

    Open Access•Robin Vandevoordt•Sociology•2018

  • With a Heavy Heart

    Open Access•Helga Eggebø•Sociology•2013

  • Repressive Compassion

    Open Access•B Kalir•PoLAR Political and Legal…•2019

  • Securing Borders

    Anna Pratt•Securing Borders•2006

  • Refugees and Exile

    Liisa H Malkki•Annual Review of Anthropology•1995

  • Loving Nature

    Kay Milton•Loving Nature•2003

  • Hiding from Humanity

    Martha C Nussbaum, Martha Nussbaum•Hiding from Humanity•2009

  • Emotions

    Open Access•Robert C Roberts•Emotions•2003

  • Abject Spaces

    Open Access•Engin F Isin, Engin Isin et al.•The Logics of Biopower and the…•2007

  • Discipline and Punish

    Open Access•Michel Foucault•On Violence•2007

  • Discipline and Punish

    Michel Foucault, Simon Prebble•Surveiller et punir•2019

  • Geographies of Exclusion

    David Sibley•Geographies of Exclusion•2002

  • Asylum–Seekers and National Histories of Detention

    Open Access•Alison Bashford, Carolyn Strange•Australian Journal of Politics &…•2002

  • Meanings, Feelings and Human Ecology

    Kay Milton•Mixed Emotions•2020

  • Isolation and exclusion in the modern world

    Alison Bashford, Carolyn Strange•Isolation•2010

  • Passions and Powers

    Maruška Svašek, Zlatko Skrbis•Identities•2007

  • Homo Sacer

    Giorgio Agamben•Homo Sacer•2020

  • Potential Politics and the Primacy of Preemption

    B Massumi•Theory & Event•2007

  • The detention of asylum seekers in the UK

    Open Access•MARGARET S MALLOCH, Margaret Malloch et al.•Punishment & Society•2004

  • Vigilant Visualities

    Open Access•Louise Amoore•Security Dialogue•2007

  • The return of the Camp

    Open Access•C Minca•Progress in Human Geography•2005

  • Epilogue The Scandal of the Refugee

    Open Access•Michael Dillon•Refuge Canada s Journal on Refuge•1998

  • A Sledgehammer to Crack a Nut

    Open Access•Liza Schuster•Social Policy and Administration•2005

  • Affect – an ethnocentric encounter? Exploring the ‘universalist’ imperative of emotional/affectual geographies

    Open Access•Divya P Tolia-Kelly, Divya P Tolia‐kelly•Area•2006

  • Shattering Silence

    Begoña Aretxaga•Shattering Silence•1997

  • After or beyond feeling? A consideration of affect and emotion in geography

    Open Access•Deborah Thien•Area•2005

  • Questioning affect and emotion

    Open Access•Ben Anderson, Paul Harrison•Area•2006

  • Language and the Politics of Emotion

    C Lutz, Catherine A Lutz et al.•Language and the politics of…•1990

  • Upheavals of Thought

    Open Access•Martha C Nussbaum, Martha Nussbaum•Upheavals of Thought: The…•2001

  • Biometric borders

    Open Access•Louise Amoore•Political Geography•2006

  • The neurotic citizen

    Engin F Isin, Engin Isin•Citizenship Studies•2004

  • From refugee camps to gated communities

    B Diken•Citizenship Studies•2004

  • Deportation, Expulsion, and the International Police of Aliens

    William Walters•Citizenship Studies•2002

  • Becoming and Being Hopeful

    Open Access•Ben Anderson•Environment and Planning D…•2006

  • Affective Economies

    Sara Ahmed•Social Text•2004

  • Formations of Violence

    Allen Feldman•Formations of violence•1991

  • Unnatural Emotions

    C Lutz, Catherine A Lutz•Unnatural emotions•1988

  • Meaning and Feeling in the Anthropology of Emotions

    Open Access•John Leavitt•American Ethnologist•1996

  • Pera Peras Poros

    Open Access•Mustafa Dikeç•Theory Culture & Society•2002

  • Migrant "Illegality" and Deportability in Everyday Life

    N De Genova, Nicholas P De Genova•Annual Review of Anthropology•2002

  • Respect for outsiders? respect for the law? the moral evaluation of high scale issues by US immigration officers

    Open Access•Josiah Mcc Heyman•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•2000

  • At the extremes of exclusion

    A Bloch, Liza Schuster•Ethnic and Racial Studies•2005

Unique citing works55
Citations per year3,93
Citation span2012 - 2026 (15)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 54

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae