Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Roadblocks to citizenship

Selection Effects of Restrictive Naturalisation Rules

Bibliographic Data

ID3647329
AuthorsKristian Kriegbaum Jensen (0000-0003-2299-9516, Aalborg University, corresponding author), Per Mouritsen (Aarhus University), Emily Cochran Bech (0000-0001-6062-8199, Ramboll (Denmark)), Tore Vincents Olsen (0000-0001-7933-4908, Aarhus University)
Year2021
Volume47
Issue5
Pages1047-1065
Publication date2021-04-04
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueNew Community (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0047-9586 • E-ISSN: 1469-9451
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/1369183x.2019.1667757
OpenAlexW2955664724
LanguageEN
Citations received32
References cited30

With rising requirements for citizenship across Western Europe, Denmark is one of the restrictive ‘leaders,’ with tough rules for language ability, economic self-support, and a clean criminal record. But what do these restrictions mean for newcomers’ ability to qualify, and how does this differ between different types of immigrants? Using register data on refugees and family migrants who immigrated to Denmark between 2001 and 2009, we show that tough language requirements exclude more people than self-support and crime rules, and many cannot qualify even after 13 years in the country. Across groups, education level at entry is the biggest predictor of whether and when newcomers qualify. These findings raise questions about the liberal nature of such requirements and about the future of democratic inclusion in Western Europe

Citizenship · Law and economics · Linguistics · Naturalisation · Political science · Sociology · Computer Science · Diaspora, migration, transnational identity · Law · Migration and Labor Dynamics · Migration, Refugees, and Integration · Philosophy · Artificial Intelligence

  • Migrants and Welfare States

    Open Access•Christian Albrekt Larsen•Migrants and Welfare States•2022

  • Do integration requirements undermine egalitarianism?

    Open Access•Helga Eggebø, Vilde Hernes et al.•The End of Norwegian Egalitarianism…•2023

  • Between a rock and a hard place

    Open Access•Marte Nordanger, Birgitta Ljung Egeland•Linguistics and Education•2024

  • (Un)conditional? The role of integration and psychological predispositions in citizens’ attitudes toward immigrant enfranchisement

    Open Access•Alyssa M Taylor, Mia Katharina Gandenberger•Political Studies•2026

  • Gatekeeping through citizenship testing

    Open Access•Nina Carlsson•Political Research Exchange•2026

  • Are Occupations “Bundles of Skills”? Identifying Latent Skill Profiles in the Labor Market Using Topic Modeling

    Open Access•Marie Labussière, T Bol•Sociological Science•2026

  • Standardised integration requirements for naturalisation

    Open Access•D Sredanovic•Comparative Migration Studies•2024

  • Citizenship by Choice, Not Necessity

    Open Access•Nils Witte, Frederik Peters•Population Space and Place•2025

  • Integration practices of Turkish families in the UK

    Tuncay Bilecen, Fethiye Tilbe et al.•The History of the Family•2025

  • Impact des contextes législatif, politique et économique du pays d’origine sur la naturalisation. Le cas des ressortissant·e·s de l’Union européenne en Suisse

    Open Access•Aurélie Pont, P Wanner•Revue européenne des migrations…•2023

  • The Impact of the Legislative, Political and Economic Context of the Country of Origin on Naturalisation. The Case of EU Nationals in Switzerland

    Open Access•Aurélie Pont, P Wanner•Revue européenne des migrations…•2023

  • A new way to serve democracy

    Andreas Albertsen, Andreas Brøgger Albertsen et al.•Critical Review of International…•2025

  • Language learning in liminal spaces

    Open Access•Marte Nordanger, Edit Bugge•British Journal of Sociology of…•2025

  • The causal effect of liberalizing legal requirements on naturalization intentions

    Open Access•Y Kosyakova, A Damelang•Social Forces•2025

  • Citizenship Acquisition and Labour Market Outcomes Among Immigrants in Italy

    Open Access•Davide Gritti, Filippo Gioachin et al.•International Migration•2025

  • Who deserves exceptions in times of crisis? A comparison of policy responses to mitigate negative consequences for unemployed people and immigrants during the Covid-19 pandemic

    Open Access•Vilde Hernes, Anne Balke Staver•Critical Social Policy•2024

  • A Citizen Just Like You

    Open Access•Alicia Poole, Thomas Soehl•International Migration Review•2023

  • Who Wants to Become Italian? A Study of Interest in Naturalisation among Foreign Migrants in Italy

    Open Access•Elisa Barbiano Di Belgiojoso, Livia Elisa Ortensi•European Journal of Population /…•2022

  • No trade-off between parent choice and democratic citizenship

    Per Mouritsen, Nanna Vestergaard Ahrensberg et al.•British Journal of Sociology of…•2023

  • Citizenship, Math and Gender

    Open Access•Marina Murat•Kyklos•2025

  • Who can become a full member of the club?—Results from a conjoint survey experiment on public attitudes about the naturalisation of non‐EU migrants in Germany, the Netherlands, Sweden and Denmark

    Open Access•Troels Fage Hedegaard, Christian Albrekt Larsen•Scandinavian Political Studies•2022

  • Introduction

    Open Access•Matteo Bonotti, Nina Carlsson et al.•Nations and Nationalism•2022

  • Citizenship, language tests, and political participation

    Open Access•Matteo Bonotti, Louisa Willoughby•Nations and Nationalism•2022

  • Citizenship Studies

    Open Access•W Goodman, Sara Wallace Goodman•Annual Review of Political Science•2023

  • Integration as a Precondition for Enfranchisement? Swiss Public Opinion on Noncitizen Voting Rights

    Open Access•Alyssa M Taylor•Swiss Political Science Review•2025

  • The symbolic violence of citizenship tests

    Open Access•Sara A Karim•Citizenship Studies•2024

  • Working together or apart? Exposure between natives and migrants in Danish workplaces from 1996 to 2019

    Open Access•Lanciné Eric Nestor Diop, Christian Albrekt Larsen•New Community•2025

  • Earned citizenship and fairness

    Kristian Kriegbaum Jensen, Lasse Nielsen•New Community•2024

  • It must be really difficult for the less privileged'. How class affects the legal consciousness of immigrants in Norway

    Open Access•Mariann Stærkebye Leirvik, Tone Maia Liodden et al.•New Community•2025

  • The Power of Ambiguity

    Open Access•Eline Delmarcelle•Revue européenne des migrations…•2023

  • Timing of citizenship acquisition and immigrants' children educational outcomes

    Open Access•Marie Labussière•European Sociological Review•2024

  • Long-Term Heterogeneity in Immigrant Naturalization

    Open Access•Maarten Vink, A Tegunimataka et al.•European Sociological Review•2021

  • Immigration and Membership Politics in Western Europe

    Open Access•W Goodman, Sara Wallace Goodman•Immigration and Membership…•2014

  • Critical Evidence

    Open Access•Kenji Hakuta, Ellen Bialystok et al.•Psychological Science•2003

  • Age Constraints on Second-Language Acquisition

    Open Access•James Emil Flege, Grace H Yeni-Komshian et al.•Journal of Memory and Language•1999

  • A Theory of Justice

    Open Access•John Rawls•Theory of Justice•1999

  • The Politics of Citizenship in Europe

    Open Access•Marc M Howard•Politics of Citizenship in Europe•2009

  • Factors affecting degree of foreign accent in an L2

    Open Access•Thorsten Piske, I Mackay et al.•Journal of Phonetics•2001

  • Scandinavian exceptionalism? Civic integration and labour market activation for newly arrived immigrants

    Open Access•Karen N Breidahl•Comparative Migration Studies•2017

  • Comparative Citizenship

    C Joppke•Law & Ethics of Human Rights•2008

  • Life below a `Language Threshold

    Open Access•Anika Liversage•European Journal of Women s Studies•2009

  • Rights or Identity? Naturalization Processes among “Labor Migrants” in Germany

    Open Access•Claudia Diehl, Michael Blohm•International Migration Review•2003

  • The North American Naturalization Gap

    Open Access•I Bloemraad•International Migration Review•2002

  • The Influence of Partner Choice and Country of Origin Characteristics on the Naturalization of Immigrants in Sweden

    Open Access•J Helgertz, P Bevelander•International Migration Review•2017

  • Explaining Immigrant Naturalization

    Open Access•Philip Q Yang•International Migration Review•1994

  • Immigrant Naturalization in the Context of Institutional Diversity

    Open Access•Maarten Vink, Maarten Peter Vink et al.•International Migration•2013

  • Beyond national models

    C Joppke•West European Politics•2006

  • Explaining access to citizenship in Europe

    Open Access•Jaap Dronkers, Maarten Vink et al.•European Union Politics•2012

  • The resilience of citizenship traditions

    Open Access•Per Mouritsen•Ethnicities•2013

  • Habitus, rules of the labour market and employment strategies of immigrants in Vancouver, Canada

    Harald Bauder•Social & Cultural Geography•2005

  • Required to assimilate? The content of citizenship tests in five countries

    Ines Michalowski•Citizenship Studies•2011

  • The ecology of immigrant naturalisation

    Frederik Peters, Floris Peters et al.•New Community•2016

  • Determinants of Positive Naturalisation Intentions among Germany's Labour Migrants

    Oshrat Hochman•New Community•2011

  • Does Mandatory Integration Matter? Effects of Civic Requirements on Immigrant Socio-economic and Political Outcomes

    W Goodman, Sara Wallace Goodman et al.•New Community•2015

  • Liberalism and Citizenship Acquisition

    James Hampshire•New Community•2011

  • Explaining the Naturalisation Practices of Turks in Germany in the Wake of the Citizenship Reform of 1999

    Merih Anil•New Community•2007

  • Politics and Group Belonging

    Dani Carrillo•New Community•2015

  • Becoming a Citizen in the United States and Canada

    I Bloemraad•Social Forces•2006

  • Asian Immigrants' Reliance on Social Ties in a Multiethnic Labor Market

    J Sanders, Jimy M Sanders et al.•Social Forces•2002

  • Neoliberal communitarian citizenship

    Open Access•Friso Van Houdt, Semin Suvarierol et al.•International Sociology•2011

Unique citing works32
Citations per year6,4
Citation span2021 - 2026 (6)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 32

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae