Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Problem with Solutions

Development Failures in Bangladesh and the Interests They Obscure

Bibliographic Data

ID3775337
AuthorsKimberley Anh Thomas (0000-0002-9600-385X, Temple University, corresponding author)
Year2020
Volume110
Issue5
Pages1631-1651
Publication date2020-09-02
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueAnnals of the American Association of Geographers (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 2469-4452 • E-ISSN: 2469-4460
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/24694452.2019.1707641
OpenAlexW3006168135
LanguageEN
Citations received9
References cited85

Long described as the “largest poorest” country, Bangladesh has been a prime target for massive infusions of foreign aid for decades. Through historical and ethnographic investigation, I document how flood control and agricultural intensification projects underwritten by foreign institutions exacerbate vulnerability to water crises in Bangladesh. These ostensibly pro-poor water governance and economic development programs engender cycles of crop loss, groundwater and soil salinization, reduced fisheries, and impeded navigation that erode agrarian livelihoods, thereby reproducing the conditions and rationale for continued flows of aid dollars into the country. Shifting attention away from depoliticized problems and solutions, I develop the concept of the interest-shed as a broadly applicable method for intervening in cycles of failure by examining the interests that they serve. This framework can also be used in the planning process by enabling differently situated groups to evaluate how proposed schemes include, ignore, or prioritize their interests

Agrarian society · Agriculture · Annexation · Corporate governance · Development economics · Economic growth · Economics · Environmental planning · Geography · Livelihood · Natural resource economics · Political science · Child Nutrition and Water Access · Hydropower, Displacement, Environmental Impact · Law · Water Governance and Infrastructure · Finance

  • Disingenuous natures and post-truth politics

    Open Access•Gregory L Simon•Geoforum•2021

  • The politics of climate adaptation in Nepal

    Open Access•Suman Acharya•World Development•2026

  • Land matters

    Open Access•Joel E Correia•Climate and Development•2024

  • In harm’s way

    Open Access•Bishawjit Mallick, Kimberly G Rogers et al.•AMBIO•2022

  • Encountering mobility (in)justice through the lived experiences of fishing communities in Dakar and Saint Louis, Senegal

    Sarah Walker, Elena Giacomelli•Mobilities•2024

  • Accumulation by adaptation

    Open Access•Kimberley Anh Thomas•Geography Compass•2024

  • Compelled to Compete

    Open Access•Kimberley Anh Thomas•Development and Change•2023

  • Globalized Climate Precarity

    Open Access•Laurie Parsons, Ricardo Safra De Campos et al.•Annals of the American…•2024

  • Environmental precarity, the state and contract farming in the Mekong Delta

    T H Ho, Thuy Ho et al.•The Journal of Peasant Studies•2025

  • Political Ecologies of the State

    Open Access•Katie Meehan, Olivia C Molden•The Wiley Blackwell Companion to…•2015

  • The Will to Improve

    Tania Murray Li•Will to Improve•2007

  • Assemblage Geographies

    Paul Robbins, Brian Marks et al.•The Sage Handbook of Social…•2010

  • Four billion people facing severe water scarcity

    Open Access•Mesfin M Mekonnen, Arjen Y Hoekstra•Science Advances•2016

  • The Political Economy and Political Ecology of the Hydro‐Social Cycle

    Open Access•E Swyngedouw•Journal of Contemporary Water…•2009

  • Adaptive governance, ecosystem management, and natural capital

    Open Access•L Schultz, Carl Folke et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2015

  • Depoliticized Environments

    Open Access•E Swyngedouw•Royal Institute of Philosophy…•2011

  • Defining, researching and struggling for water justice

    Margreet Zwarteveen, Margreet Z Zwarteveen et al.•Water International•2014

  • Land Degradation and Society

    Harold Brookfield, Piers Blaikie et al.•Land Degradation and Society•2015

  • Anti-Politics Machine

    James Ferguson•The anti-politics machine•2010

  • The Middle East Water Question

    J A Allan, Tony Allan•The Middle East Water Question•2001

  • Water Resource Management in a Vulnerable World

    Daanish Mustafa•Water Resource Management in a…•2013

  • The Political Ecology of Climate Change Adaptation

    Marcus Taylor•Political Ecology of Climate…•2014

  • Floods, cyclones, drought and climate change in Bangladesh

    Hugh Brammer•International Journal of…•2016

  • Rule of Experts

    Timothy Mitchell•Rule of Experts: Egypt,…•2002

  • Integration through Compartmentalization? Pitfalls of 'Poldering' in Bangladesh

    Joshua Warner, Jeroen Warner•Nature and Culture•2010

  • Flood research in Bangladesh in retrospect and prospect

    Open Access•Bimal Kanti Paul•Geoforum•1997

  • After the Bangladesh Flood Action Plan

    Hugh Brammer•Environmental Hazards•2010

  • Is adaptation reducing vulnerability or redistributing it

    Open Access•Aaron Atteridge, Elise Remling•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2017

  • Climate change and migration

    Katha Kartiki•Gender & Development•2011

  • International relations theory and water do mix

    Open Access•Joshua Warner, Mark Zeitoun•Political Geography•2008

  • Discourse and desalination

    Open Access•James Mcevoy, Margaret Wilder et al.•Global Environmental Change•2011

  • Coercing conservation

    Open Access•Nancy Lee Peluso•Global Environmental Change•1993

  • Maladaptation

    Open Access•Jon Barnett, Saffron O''Neill•Global Environmental Change•2009

  • The causal structure of vulnerability

    Open Access•Jesse Ribot, Jesse C Ribot•GeoJournal•1995

  • Human responses to riverine hazards in Bangladesh

    Open Access•C Emdad Haque, M Q Zaman•World Development•1993

  • Contradictions at the confluence of commerce, consumption and conservation; or, an REI shopper camps in the forest, does anyone notice

    Open Access•Gregory L Simon, Peter S Alagona•Geoforum•2012

  • The Global Politics of Water Grabbing

    Jennifer C Franco, Jennifer Franco et al.•Third World Quarterly•2013

  • Uneven Urbanisation

    Open Access•Bosman Batubara, Marcelle Kooy et al.•Antipode•2018

  • Flows in formation

    Open Access•Kian Goh•Urban Studies•2020

  • Food Bungle in Bangladesh

    Donald F Mchenry, Kai Bird•Foreign Policy•1977

  • The Natural Environment

    Open Access•Joseph L Fisher•The Annals of the American…•1967

  • Historical political ecology

    Open Access•Diana K Davis, Diana Davis•Geoforum•2009

  • Suffering for water, suffering from water

    Open Access•Farhana Sultana•Geoforum•2011

  • Transgressing Scales

    Open Access•Emma S Norman, Karen Bakker•Annals of the Association of…•2009

  • Development Capital

    Susan M Robert, Susan M Roberts•Annals of the Association of…•2014

  • Rivers of Life

    M Q Zaman•Asian Survey•1993

  • Powerful assemblages

    Open Access•John Allen•Area•2011

  • More-than-human social geographies

    Open Access•Ruth Panelli•Progress in Human Geography•2009

  • The anti-politics machine

    James Ferguson•The anti-politics machine•1994

  • The politics of hydropower

    Open Access•Karen Bakker•Political Geography•1999

  • Rethinking transboundary waters

    Open Access•Chris Sneddon, Coleen Fox•Political Geography•2006

  • Going with the flow

    Open Access•Joshua Warner, Jeroen Warner et al.•Water Policy•2008

  • Social geography

    Open Access•Rachel Pain•Progress in Human Geography•2004

  • The territorial trap

    John Agnew•Review of International Political…•1994

  • On assemblages and geography

    Open Access•Ben Anderson, Matthew Kearnes et al.•Dialogues in Human Geography•2012

  • Assemblages and Actor-networks

    Open Access•Marguerite Müller, Martin Müller•Geography Compass•2015

  • UN Water Report 2012

    Open Access•E Swyngedouw•Development and Change•2013

  • Beyond water, beyond boundaries

    Open Access•Jean-Philippe Venot, Jean‐philippe Venot et al.•Geographical Journal•2011

  • Distributional and Social Impacts of Flood Control in Bangladesh

    Paul M Thompson, Parvin Sultana•Geographical Journal•1996

  • Risk and the Neoliberal State

    Open Access•Ben Wisner•Disasters•2001

  • Threatening Dystopias

    Kasia Paprocki•Annals of the American…•2018

  • "Arrested Development? The Promises and Paradoxes of "Selling Nature to Save It

    Jason Dempsey, Jessica Dempsey et al.•Annals of the American…•2016

  • Beyond "the State" and Failed Schemes

    Open Access•Tania Murray Li•American Anthropologist•2005

  • Water Sustainability

    B Orlove, Steven C Caton•Annual Review of Anthropology•2010

  • Life in a shrimp zone

    Kasia Paprocki, Jason Cons•The Journal of Peasant Studies•2014

  • Land grabs and primitive accumulation in deltaic Bangladesh

    Shapan Adnan•The Journal of Peasant Studies•2013

Unique citing works9
Citations per year1,8
Citation span2021 - 2026 (6)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 7

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae