Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Fragile subjectivities

Constructing Queer Safe Spaces

Bibliographic Data

ID3977484
AuthorsG Hartal (0000-0002-5084-5680, McGill University, corresponding author)
Year2017
Pages1-20
Publication date2017-06-08
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueSocial & Cultural Geography (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1464-9365 • E-ISSN: 1470-1197
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/14649365.2017.1335877
OpenAlexW2624208623
LanguageEN
Citations received36
References cited63

This paper uses framing theory to challenge previous understandings of queer safe space, their construction, and fundamental logics. Safe space is usually apprehended as a protected and inclusive place, where one can express one's identity freely and comfortably. Focusing on the Jerusalem Open House, a community center for LGBT individuals in Jerusalem, I investigate the spatial politics of safe space. Introducing the contested space of Jerusalem, I analyze five framings of safe space, outlining diverse and oppositional components producing this negotiable construct. The argument is twofold: First, I aim to explicate five different frames for the creation of safe space. The frames are: fortification of the queer space, preserving participants' anonymity, creating an inclusive space, creating a space of separation for distinct identity groups, and controlling unpredictable influences on the participants in the space. Second, by unraveling the basic reasoning for each frame and its related affects I show how all five frames are anchored in liberal logics and reflect specific ways in which we comprehend how queer subjectivities produce/are produced through safe space and its discourse

Aesthetics · Anonymity · Argument (complex analysis · Computer security · Epistemology · Framing (construction · Identity (music · Queer · Queer theory · Sociology · African Sexualities and LGBTQ+ Issues · Computer Science · Engineering · Gender Studies · Jewish and Middle Eastern Studies · LGBTQ Health, Identity, and Policy · Philosophy

  • Contradictory connectivity and hybrid spaces

    Open Access•Justin R Ellis, Jane Goodman-Delahunty et al.•Gender Place & Culture•2026

  • Towards a conceptual model of queer social safety

    Open Access•Cristiano Scandurra, Selene Mezzalira et al.•Culture Health & Sexuality•2026

  • Queering CoMO

    Open Access•Sarah Kammeyer, Aída Rosalia Guhlincozzi et al.•Journal of Cultural Geography•2026

  • Let’s (not) Go Outside

    Open Access•Sam Mile, Sam Miles•The Life and Afterlife of Gay…•2021

  • Queere Räume

    Open Access•Esto Mader•Queere Räume•2023

  • Re‐Imagining Inclusive and Compassionate Futures

    Open Access•Stuart Read, Anne Parfitt•Social Inclusion•2026

  • “Am I Man Enough?”

    Open Access•Himas Nur Rahmawati•Jurnal Studi Pemuda•2021

  • In defence of safer spaces

    R L Hill, Molly Megson•Punk & Post Punk•2020

  • Radical Solidarities in Punk and Queer Refusals of Safety and Inclusion Narratives in Planning

    Open Access•Sarah Gelbard•Urban Planning•2023

  • Safe/r Spaces. Ein sozio-politischer Raum – kritisch betrachtet

    Open Access•María Do Mar Castro Varela, Bahar Oghalai et al.•GENDER – Zeitschrift für…•2025

  • Safe spaces that matter

    Open Access•Deborah Mcphail, Robert Lorway et al.•SSM - Qualitative Research in…•2022

  • More-than-safety

    Alison L Bain, Julie A Podmore•Children s Geographies•2020

  • Assessing inequity in zoning bylaw

    Open Access•Agrawal, Jason Syvixay et al.•Planning Practice and Research•2023

  • Everyone as Insider–Invader

    Ye-eum Jo, Juyeon Park•Journal of Homosexuality•2026

  • Welcoming and Generative Local Welfare as an Agent for Territorial Development

    Open Access•Alice Lomonaco, Maurizio Bergamaschi et al.•Journal of International…•2023

  • Black Geographies of Respite

    Open Access•Douglas L Allen•Antipode•2020

  • The queers are all right

    Rigel Paciente, Emmanuel Philip Pranoto et al.•Culture Health & Sexuality•2024

  • Proposing the safe and brave space for organisational environment

    Open Access•Robin C Ladwig•Gender in Management An…•2021

  • Reading is fun-da- mental

    Orlando Woods•Feminist Media Studies•2022

  • Conceptualisations and implications of safety

    Open Access•Sarah Musubika•European Journal of Intercultural…•2025

  • Atmosphere of Canadian Queer Theatre Festivals

    Open Access•Alan Chaffe, Craig M Mcgill et al.•Sexuality & Culture•2026

  • Queer asylum politics of separation in Germany

    Open Access•Lotte J Hiller•Gender Place & Culture•2021

  • Creating queer safe space

    Andrew Mccartan, Catherine Jean Nash•Gender Place & Culture•2022

  • Israeli feminist geography

    Tovi Fenster, Chen Misgav•Gender Place & Culture•2019

  • Remapping visibility

    Do Own Kim•Communication Monographs•2025

  • Straight(ening) Salsa? The heterosexual matrix, romance and disciplinary spaces

    Stefanie Claudine Boulila•Leisure Studies•2020

  • LGBTQ+ leisure in conservative tourism destinations

    Ajay Jose, Sonia Mathew et al.•Tourism Recreation Research•2026

  • Resilient queer subjects

    Open Access•G Hartal•Geoforum•2024

  • The Life and Afterlife of Gay Neighborhoods

    Open Access•Alex Bitterman, Daniel Baldwin He•The Life and Afterlife of Gay…•2021

  • Asexual geographies

    Open Access•Rachel Bayer•Gender Place & Culture•2025

  • From social integration to social emplacement

    Melissa Moralli, Pierluigi Musarò et al.•International Review of Sociology•2023

  • The construction of safe space

    Open Access•Esther Mcintosh, Sharon Jagger•Journal of Gender Studies•2024

  • Small Stories, Big Impact

    Open Access•Chani Goldengreen, Hadar Netz•Journal of Homosexuality•2025

  • Negotiating the Paradoxical Binaries of 'Safety' in Queer Spaces

    Open Access•K Charlton•Journal of Homosexuality•2025

  • Logging into the rehearsal stage

    Open Access•Robin Todd West•Journal of Gender Studies•2024

  • Schutz- und Sorgepraktiken

    Open Access•Lotte J Hiller•Geographica Helvetica•2024

  • The Wiley‐Blackwell Companion to Cultural Geography

    Open Access•Nuala C Johnson, Richard H Schein et al.•Wiley-Blackwell Companion to…•2013

  • On Not Excluding Half of the Human in Human Geography

    Janice Monk, Susan Hanson•The Professional Geographer•1982

  • Gender and the City

    Open Access•Tovi Fenster•A Companion to Feminist Geography•2005

  • The People's Property?

    Don Mitchell, Lynn A Staeheli•The People's Property?•2007

  • Gender, identity, and place

    Linda Mcdowell•Gender, identity, and place•1999

  • Frame analysis

    Erving Goffman, José Luis Rodríguez•Frame Analysis•1986

  • Feminism and geography

    Gillian Rose•Feminism and geography•1993

  • Geographies of Exclusion

    David Sibley•Geographies of Exclusion•2002

  • Closet Space

    Michael P Brown•Closet Space•2005

  • This Bridge We Call Home

    Gloria Anzaldúa, Analouise Keating•This bridge we call home•2002

  • Queer Methods and Methodologies

    Kath Browne, Catherine Jean Nash•Queer Methods and Methodologies•2010

  • Contested Cities in the Modern West

    Open Access•A Hepburn, A C Hepburn•Contested Cities in the Modern West•2004

  • Social theory and the politics of identity

    Craig Calhoun, Craig J Calhoun•Social theory and the politics of…•1994

  • The Lesbian and Gay Studies Reader

    David M Halperin, Henry Abelove•Lesbian and Gay Studies Reader•2012

  • Undoing Gender

    Judith Butler•Undoing Gender•2004

  • Constructing gender, constructing the urban

    Liz Bondi, Damaris Rose•Gender Place & Culture•2003

  • The politics of holding

    G Hartal•Gender Place & Culture•2016

  • Queers in the American City

    Petra Leisenring Doan•Gender Place & Culture•2007

  • Lesbians in the Crowd

    Julie A Podmore•Gender Place & Culture•2001

  • Making space for queer youth

    Christopher G Schroeder, Christopher Schroeder•Gender Place & Culture•2012

  • Space, sexual violence and social control

    Open Access•Rachel Pain•Progress in Human Geography•1991

  • Gender, Identity and Place

    Open Access•Marion Markwick•Women s Studies International Forum•2000

  • A tale of two cities

    Open Access•Nurit Alfasi, Tovi Fenster•Cities•2005

  • Matter out of place

    Beverley Skeggs•Leisure Studies•1999

  • Constructing sexual citizenship

    Open Access•D Richardson•Critical Social Policy•2000

  • Desiring Sameness? The Rise of a Neoliberal Politics of Normalisation

    Open Access•D Richardson•Antipode•2005

  • Toward a postmodern understanding of separatism

    Ian Barnard•Women s Studies•1998

  • Gender, Race, Age and Fear in the City

    Open Access•Rachel Pain•Urban Studies•2001

  • Revisiting fear and place

    Open Access•Hille Koskela, Rachel Pain•Geoforum•2000

  • Trans experiences in lesbian and queer space

    Open Access•Catherine Jean Nash•Canadian Geographies /…•2011

  • Womyn’s separatist spaces

    Open Access•K Browne•Transactions of the Institute of…•2009

  • Questioning Safe Space

    Open Access•Barbara S Stengel, Lisa Weems•Studies in Philosophy and Education•2010

  • The Geopolitics of Neighbourhood

    Haim Yacobi, Wendy Pullan•Geopolitics•2014

  • Safe Space

    Open Access•The Roestone Collective•Antipode•2014

  • Doing cultural geography

    Open Access•Andrew Crampton•Political Geography•2003

  • Critical geographies and the uses of sexuality

    Open Access•N Oswin•Progress in Human Geography•2008

  • Safe Space

    Christina B Hanhardt, Youngmin Choe•Safe Space•2013

  • Genderbashing

    Open Access•Ki Namaste•Environment and Planning D…•1996

  • God, Globalization, and Geopolitics

    Open Access•Haim Yacobi•Environment and Planning A…•2012

  • Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers

    J N L Baker•Geographical Journal•1966

  • Coming out of Geography

    Open Access•J Binnie•Environment and Planning D…•1997

  • The Political Place of Locality Studies

    Open Access•D Massey•Environment and Planning A…•1991

  • Stuck at the Front Door

    Open Access•Carolyn Whitzman•Environment and Planning A…•2007

  • Gone 'underground'? Lesbian visibility and the consolidation of queer space in Montréal

    Julie A Podmore•Social & Cultural Geography•2006

  • The Discomfort of Strangers

    Greg Noble•Journal of Intercultural Studies•2005

  • Some Spatial Politics of Queer-Feminist Research

    Chen Misgav•Journal of Homosexuality•2016

  • Safe Spaces

    Open Access•Ruth Lewis, Elizabeth A Sharp et al.•Sociological Research Online•2015

  • Jerusalem Assassinated Rabin and Tel Aviv Commemorated him

    Open Access•Vinitzky-Seroussi, Vered Vinitzky‐seroussi•City & Society•1998

  • The intimate insider

    Open Access•Jodie Taylor•Qualitative Research•2011

  • Celebration and Suppression

    Morris Bernstein, Mary Bernstein•American Journal of Sociology•1997

Unique citing works36
Citations per year5,14
Citation span2019 - 2026 (8)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 33

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae