The Shaker Church and the Indian Way in Native Northwestern California

The Indian Shaker Church originated on Puget Sound in 1882 and was brought into Native northwestern California in 1926. Outsider scholars have often reduced it to the status of a minor crisis cult or revitalization movement, as opposed to a real-that is, traditional-Indian religion. Reports that California Shakers rejected all indigenous ceremonialism as sinful and anti-Christian while asserting that the new religion was a purely Native way, best closed to non-Indians, appeared to support this view (Barnett 1957: 142-143). While converted elders quietly defended the Church as a continuation of ways (in Gould and Furukawa 1966: 59) they seemed, to some, to be deluding themselves in a struggle to maintain their Indian identities while becoming pseudo-Christians. But even outsiders do well to listen closely to what the elders say and to think long on it, as local people well know. The notion that the Shaker Church is a continuation of an authentic Indian spirituality-an evolution of it, as a Church member said to me in 1978-rings false only as long as we viewmodern NativeAmerican history in terms of polarities-Indian/Christian, traditionalist/Shaker, this faction/that faction, and the rest (as anthropologists once did habitually). Perhaps it helps to view Native/European as the typal opposition, of which all the others are tokens, and to remember that it was, first, racist Europeans who insisted on its validity? But this, too, is over simple: the Indian Shakers themselves have insisted on a rigid us/ them, inside/outside dichotomy (Gould and Furukawa 1966: 57-64), whether such oppositional dualism was traditional or the result of acculturation to European modes of thought (e.g., Buckley 1984). Something more complex may be going on here, revealed in part by the powerful reemergence of indigenous ceremonialism that has occurred in northwestern California as elsewhere in Indian Country during the past two decades. The contemporary emergence of forms of religious life that non-Indian anthropologists and Native people alike once viewed as utterly gone should alert us to the possibility that, yes, innovations like the Shaker Church have indeed been continuations of Native traditions, and that-perhaps more difficult to see-reemergent traditions are themselves continuations or evolutions of modern innovations like the Shaker Church. That is, theoretically, that such seemingly diametrically op

Acoustics · Archaeology · Ethnology · Geography · Native american · Shaker · Archaeology and Natural History · History · Latin American and Latino Studies · Mormonism, Religion, and History

• Puchuxwavaats Uapi (To Know About Plants)

  Richard W Stoffle, Richard Stoffle et al.•Human Organization•1999

  Add to list

• World Renewal. A Cult System of Native Northwest California . A. L. K roeber and E. W. G ifford

  Open Access•Erminie W Voegelin•American Anthropologist•1951

  Add to list

• Indian Shakers

  Evon Z Vogt, H G Barnett et al.•American Sociological Review•1958

  Add to list

• Yurok speech registers and ontology

  Open Access•Thomas Buckley•Language in Society•1984

  Add to list

• Shamanism in the Shaker Religion of Northwest America

  Marian W Smith•Man•1954

  Add to list

• From American Indian to Indian American

  Open Access•John H Bushnell•American Anthropologist•1968

  Add to list