The Uses of Aesthetic Testimony

Dados Bibliográficos

ID4158094
AutoresC Thi Nguyen (0000-0001-8062-5446, Utah Valley University, autor correspondente)
Ano2017
Volume57
Fascículo1
Páginas19-36
Data de publicação2017-01-01
Peer ReviewedSim
Open AccessNão
TipoARTICLE
PeriódicoThe British Journal of Aesthetics (JOURNAL)
Identificadores do periódicoISSN: 0007-0904 • E-ISSN: 1468-2842
EditoraOxford University Press (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1093/aesthj/ayw089
OpenAlexW2589233331
IdiomaEN
Citações recebidas17

The current debate over aesthetic testimony typically focuses on cases of doxastic repetition — where, when an agent, on receiving aesthetic testimony that p, acquires the belief that p without qualification. I suggest that we broaden the set of cases under consideration. I consider a number of cases of action from testimony, including reconsidering a disliked album based on testimony, and choosing an artistic educational institution from testimony. But this cannot simply be explained by supposing that testimony is usable for action, but unusable for doxastic repetition. I consider a new asymmetry in the usability aesthetic testimony. Consider the following cases: we seem unwilling to accept somebody hanging a painting in their bedroom based merely on testimony, but entirely willing to accept hanging a painting in a museum based merely on testimony. The switch in intuitive acceptability seems to track, in some complicated way, the line between public life and private life. These new cases weigh against a number of standing theories of aesthetic testimony. I suggest that we look further afield, and that something like a sensibility theory, in the style of John McDowell and David Wiggins, will prove to be the best fit for our intuitions for the usability of aesthetic testimony. I propose the following explanation for the new asymmetry: we are willing to accept testimony about whether a work merits being found beautiful; but we are unwilling to accept testimony about whether something actually is beautiful

Action (physics · Aesthetics · Art · Cognitive psychology · Complicity · Doxastic logic · Epistemology · Illusion · Painting · Political science · Repetition (rhetorical device · Sensibility · Set (abstract data type · Visual arts · Aesthetic Perception and Analysis · Computer Science · Ethics, Aesthetics, and Art · Law · Philosophy · Psychology · Visual Culture and Art Theory