Artistic Crimes and Misdemeanours

Denis Dutton claimed that, to grasp why it matters to the artistic value of a painting like The Disciples at Emmaus that it was painted by van Meegeren in the first half of the twentieth century rather than by Vermeer in the seventeenth century, we need to locate what van Meegeren did in a wider class of 'artistic crimes' involving 'misrepresented artistic performances'. I begin by clarifying how the notions of 'artistic performance' and 'misrepresentation' are to be understood in the context of Dutton's paper. I survey a range of examples of misrepresented artistic performances in Dutton's sense, and ask when they involve 'artistic crimes'. I then seek a principled way of justifying what seem to be our clear intuitions-apparent in our artistic practice-as to which 'misrepresented artistic performances' are artistic crimes and which are not

Aesthetics · Art · Art history · Context (archaeology · Misrepresentation · Painting · Value (mathematics · Visual arts · Art History and Market Analysis · Computer Science · History · Law · Law in Society and Culture