Feminism, reproductive labour, and the gendered welfare state in Britain's National Insurance Act of 1911

In 1911, numerous women's organizations, of varying political interests, mounted a campaign against the National Insurance Bill. Such opposition emerged despite feminist support for increased welfare provision in general and especially for the maternity benefit that the Bill proposed to introduce. Feminists criticized National Insurance for discriminating against women, especially its failure to recognize the economic contribution of women's unwaged reproductive labour. They lobbied and campaigned for a series of amendments, some of which were successful. Feminist opposition to National Insurance sheds new light on an ongoing historiographical debate over the degree to which women were able to influence early welfare states prior to enfranchisement. Their activities cannot be easily contained within a framework of 'maternalist feminism', and call into question distinctions between 'maternalist'/'social' feminism and 'equality' feminism, and middle-class and working-class women's agendas. Instead, feminist campaigns around National Insurance reveal an early analysis of 'social reproduction' (the origins of which are usually traced back only to 'second wave' feminism) whereby British feminists participated in international conversations contesting the gendered definitions of work that went on to inform insurance-based welfare states across Europe

Feminism · Opposition (politics) · Political science · Politics · Sociology · Welfare · Welfare state · Gender Studies · Historical Economic and Social Studies · Historical Gender and Feminism Studies · Historical Studies on Reproduction, Gender, Health, and Societal Changes · Law

• Challenging welfare mythmaking

  Open Access•Ruth Patrick, Tracey Jensen•Critical Social Policy•2025

  Add to list