Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Avoiding cultural trauma

Climate Change and Social Inertia

Bibliographic Data

ID4328366
AuthorsRobert J Brulle (0000-0003-3852-3379, Institute at Brown for Environment & Society, Brown University, Providence, RI, USA, corresponding author), Kari Marie Norgaard (0000-0002-6801-4551, University of Oregon)
Year2019
Volume28
Issue5
Pages886-908
Publication date2019-07-29
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueEnvironmental Politics (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0964-4016 • E-ISSN: 1743-8934
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/09644016.2018.1562138
OpenAlexW2911091905
LanguageEN
Citations received81
References cited60

The failure of societies to respond in a concerted, meaningful way to climate change is a core concern of the social science climate literature. Existing explanations of social inertia display little coherence. Here, a theoretical approach is suggested that integrates disparate perspectives on social inertia regarding climate change. Climate change constitutes a potential cultural trauma. The threat of cultural trauma is met with resistance and attempts to restore and maintain the status quo. Thus, efforts to avoid large-scale social changes associated with climate change constitute an effort to avoid cultural trauma, and result in social inertia regarding climate change at individual, institutional, and societal levels. Existing approaches to social inertia are reviewed. An intellectual framework utilizing the work of Pierre Bourdieu is proposed to integrate these different levels of social interaction. Social processes that maintain social order and thus avoid cultural trauma create social inertia regarding climate change

Climate change · Environmental ethics · Inertia · Political science · Social change · Social order · Sociology · Status quo · Climate Change Communication and Perception · Cultural Differences and Values · Law · Psychology · Social and Cultural Dynamics · Social Psychology · Ecology

  • Emotionalising hope in times of climate change

    Open Access•Åsa Wettergren•Emotions and Society•2024

  • Shrinking futures

    Isabella Clark•Families Relationships and…•2024

  • Emociones y emergencia climática

    Open Access•Irene Abigail Rodríguez Gudiño, Alice Poma•Sociedad y Ambiente•2023

  • Adaptation confusion? A longitudinal examination of the concept “climate change adaptation” in Norwegian municipal surveys

    Torbjørn Selseng, Marit Klemetsen et al.•Weather, Climate, and Society•2021

  • Making sense of the spectrum of climate denial

    Kari Marie Norgaard•Critical Policy Studies•2019

  • A Question of Utter Importance

    Kristoffer Ekberg, Martin Hultman•Environment and History•2021

  • Planning for the past

    Open Access•Vanessa Bowden, Daniel Nyberg et al.•Global Environmental Change•2019

  • Populistische Narrative der Energiewende und die Zukunft der Demokratie

    Open Access•Fritz Reusswig, Wiebke Lass et al.•Umkämpfte Zukunft•2022

  • Learning to Live with Climate Change

    Open Access•Blanche Verlie•Learning to Live with Climate…•2021

  • Contextual Theology

    Open Access•Sigurd Bergmann, Mika Vähäkangas•Contextual Theology•2020

  • Young People as Agents of Sustainable Society

    Open Access•Päivi Honkatukia, Tiina Rättilä•Young People as Agents of…•2023

  • The Process of Eco-Anxiety and Ecological Grief

    Open Access•Panu Pihkala•Sustainability•2022

  • Anxiety and the Ecological Crisis

    Open Access•Panu Pihkala•Sustainability•2020

  • Three Decades of Climate Mitigation

    Open Access•Isak Stoddard, Kevin Anderson et al.•Annual Review of Environment and…•2021

  • The Impact of Climate Change on Mental Health and Emotional Wellbeing

    Open Access•Emma Lawrance, RHIANNON THOMPSON et al.•International Review of Psychiatry•2022

  • Environment Actors Confronting a Post Climate-Related Disaster Scenario

    Open Access•Neide P Areia, Alexandre Oliveira Tavares et al.•International Journal of…•2021

  • “No research on a dead planet”

    Open Access•Aaron Thierry, Laura Horn et al.•Frontiers in Education•2023

  • Code red for humanity or time for broad collective action? Exploring the role of positive and negative messaging in (de)motivating climate action

    Open Access•Marjolaine Martel-Morin, Erick Lachapelle•Frontiers in Communication•2022

  • “Heading for Extinction”

    Open Access•Aaron Thierry•Frontiers in Communication•2023

  • Amplified injustices and mutual aid in the Covid-19 pandemic

    Open Access•Finn Mclafferty Bell•Qualitative Social Work•2021

  • El potencial educativo de la teoría de las representaciones sociales aplicada al cambio climático

    Open Access•Harumi Takano-Rojas, Alicia Castillo et al.•Revista Española de Pedagogía•2025

  • Too little, too late? Sociological reflections on religious responses to climate crisis

    Open Access•Kari Marie Norgaard•Dialog•2024

  • “We’re Going Under”

    Vanessa Bowden, Daniel Nyberg et al.•Environmental Communication•2021

  • The smell of polluted leisure in the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Cécile Evers•Frontiers in Sports and Active…•2025

  • From partial to integrated perspectives

    Open Access•Anne Pender•Earth System Governance•2023

  • The Role of Cynicism in Social Responses to the Climate Emergency

    Open Access•D J Davidson•Socius Sociological Research for…•2024

  • British heatwave discourse (1985–2023)

    Open Access•Thijs Van Dooremalen, P S Smith•Environmental Sociology•2025

  • Climate change risks and global warming dangers

    J Sonnett•Environmental Sociology•2021

  • Acting on climate change concerns

    Open Access•Susan Irwin, Katy Wright•Environmental Sociology•2024

  • Walking for Joy? Using a living laboratory to shift to more climate-friendly lifestyles in Santiago, Chile

    Open Access•Lake Sagaris, Rosario Palacios•Energy Research & Social Science•2024

  • Archetypes of system transition and transformation

    Open Access•I Fazey, Graham Leicester•Energy Research & Social Science•2022

  • Informing strategic climate action

    J T Roberts, Robert J Brulle et al.•Critical Policy Studies•2024

  • A Maritime Sociology for Sustainability Science

    Open Access•Constantino Villarroel Rios, Benjamín B Chicaguala•Current Opinion in Environmental…•2024

  • Emotional pathways to climate change responses

    Open Access•D J Davidson, Maik Kecinski•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2021

  • Shared pretenses for collective inaction

    Diana Stuart, Brian Petersen et al.•Globalizations•2021

  • The insidious toxicity of investor-state arbitration Gabriel Resources vs Romania

    Open Access•Irina Velicu, IONUȚ CODREANU et al.•Globalizations•2026

  • Digital–environmental habitus of families in England in times of pandemic

    Open Access•Maria Laura Ruiu, Gabriele Ruiu et al.•New Media & Society•2023

  • Institutional trauma across the Americas

    Open Access•Laura Robinson•International Journal of Cultural…•2022

  • Towards climate justice? Young climate activists in Finland on fairness and moderation

    Mikko Piispa, Tomi Kiilakoski•Journal of Youth Studies•2021

  • Doing Hope”

    Open Access•Finn Mclafferty Bell, Mary Kate Dennis et al.•Affilia•2021

  • The social life of climate projects

    Open Access•Malcolm Araos, Ankit Bhardwaj et al.•Sociological Forum•2024

  • Planetarianism Now

    Open Access•Marek Oziewicz•Pedagogy in the Anthropocene•2022

  • A Framework for Trauma-Informed Climate Research

    Open Access•Sandra Engstrom, Amy Krings•Ecopsychology•2025

  • Les traces de l’école dans les appréhensions écologiques du futur chez les jeunes Français

    Open Access•Tomas Legon•Emulations - Revue de sciences…•2024

  • Thinking beyond the ecological present

    Open Access•Tracey Skillington•European Journal of Social Theory•2023

  • Climate Change and Society

    Thomas Dietz, Rachael Shwom et al.•Annual Review of Sociology•2020

  • Getting to the heart of transformation

    Open Access•Coleen Vogel, Karen O’brien•Sustainability Science•2021

  • Finding shared meaning in the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Gail Hochachka•Sustainability Science•2021

  • Environmental and climate news in the eyes of parents as audiences

    Open Access•Thomas Roberts, Maria-Nerina Boursinou et al.•Environmental Sociology•2026

  • Tourists’ climate change denial? A view from Norway

    Open Access•Bente Heimtun, Arvid Viken•Tourist Studies•2026

  • The effects of climate change awareness on mental health

    Open Access•Çiçek Ediz, Derya Yanık et al.•International Journal of Social…•2023

  • Thinking Catastrophic Thoughts

    Open Access•Susan Kassouf•The American Journal of…•2022

  • Obstructing change

    Open Access•Vanessa Bowden, Daniel Nyberg et al.•Environmental Politics•2026

  • Between climates of fear and blind optimism

    Open Access•Lena Maria Schlegel•Geographica Helvetica•2022

  • Transition or Interregnum? Two Ways of Understanding Politics in the Anthropocene

    Open Access•Mathias Thaler•Political Studies•2026

  • How Western Buddhists Combine Buddhism and Climate Activism

    Open Access•Johannes Cairns, Panu Pihkala et al.•Contemporary Buddhism•2024

  • The Mundane Dialectic of Enlightenment

    Open Access•R Gunderson•Human Studies•2020

  • Tourism mobilities and climate crisis dilemmas

    Open Access•Arvid Viken, Bente Heimtun•Annals of Tourism Research•2024

  • When concern is not enough

    Open Access•Gail Hochachka•AMBIO•2024

  • A political‐economic theory of relevance

    Open Access•R Gunderson, Diana Stuart et al.•Journal for the Theory of Social…•2019

  • Powerless, Stupefied, and Repressed Actors Cannot Challenge Climate Change

    Open Access•R Gunderson•Journal for the Theory of Social…•2022

  • The intersection of digital practices and environmental orientations

    Maria Laura Ruiu, Gabriele Ruiu et al.•Journal of Information…•2026

  • Standing firm against rising waters

    Andrea Svennevig Hyldig•NORMA•2025

  • Beyond transformative community engagement

    Open Access•Jacob A E Nielsen, Kostas Stavrianakis et al.•Local Environment•2026

  • Bridging Perspectives

    Open Access•Émilie Tremblay, Sandra Harrisson•Culture Medicine and Psychiatry•2026

  • Climate change trauma and collective dissociation

    Open Access•Deborah Oluwaseun Shomuyiwa, Don-Eliseo Lucero-Prisno et al.•Cambridge Prisms Global Mental…•2025

  • Feelings of (eco-) grief and sorrow

    Open Access•Leonie Holthaus•European Journal of International…•2023

  • Coping with transition pain

    Open Access•Kristina Bogner, Barbara Kump et al.•Environmental Innovation and…•2024

  • Blueprint of a smokescreen

    Open Access•Tobia Spampatti, Tobias Brosch et al.•British Journal of Psychology•2025

  • New York City as 'fortress of solitude' after Hurricane Sandy

    Daniel Aldana Cohen•Environmental Politics•2021

  • It seems that climate change is already harming us all

    Open Access•M Banuet-Martinez, A J Hernandez-Velasco et al.•Social Science & Medicine•2025

  • At the heart of human politics

    Matthew Benjamin Cole•Environmental Politics•2022

  • Comfort in chaos

    Open Access•Hannah Della Bosca•Environment and Planning D…•2023

  • La preocupación social por el cambio climático en España

    Open Access•Ramón Ramos Torres, Ramón Ramos Torre et al.•Política y Sociedad•2022

  • Truth and power

    Vanessa Bowden, Daniel Nyberg et al.•Environmental Politics•2020

  • It's not just climate

    Open Access•Michael J Albert•Environmental Politics•2025

  • How Do Religions and Religiosity Matter for Climate Anxiety

    Open Access•Emre Toros•Religions•2025

  • Disrupting the Complacency

    Open Access•Timothy J Haney•Socius Sociological Research for…•2021

  • Voices of emergency

    Open Access•Anna Clot-Garrell•Current Sociology•2024

  • How 'Ceremonial Openness' Prevents Organizational Change

    Open Access•I Ladegaard, Annika Rieger•Social Problems•2024

  • Melting Worlds' and 'Climate Myths

    Open Access•A Meyer, Z Sokolickova•Ethnos•2024

  • Networks in Contention

    Open Access•Jennifer Hadden•Networks in Contention•2015

  • Environmental Melancholia

    Renee Lertzman•Environmental Melancholia•2015

  • Climate Capitalism

    Open Access•Peter Newell, Marisa Paterson et al.•Climate Capitalism•2010

  • Political Contestation in Global Production Networks

    Dena Levy, David L Levy•Academy of Management Review•2008

  • Challenging Climate Change

    Riley E Dunlap, Aaron M Mccright•Climate change and society•2015

  • The Road to Paris

    Karin Bäckstrand, Eva Lövbrand•Journal of Environmental Policy &…•2019

  • The Trauma of Social Change

    Piotr Sztompka•Cultural Trauma and Collective…•2004

  • Toward a Theory of Cultural Trauma

    Jeffrey C Alexander•Cultural Trauma and Collective…•2004

  • Depoliticized Environments

    Open Access•E Swyngedouw•Royal Institute of Philosophy…•2011

  • Sustainable Practices

    Elizabeth Shove, Nicola Spurling•Sustainable Practices•2013

  • The Hysteresis Effect as Creative Adaptation of the Habitus

    Open Access•Ron Kerr, Robinson et al.•Organization•2009

  • Making Sense of Corporate Environmentalism

    Open Access•Simone Pulver•Organization & Environment•2007

  • Ecological Habitus

    Open Access•Debbie Kasper, Debbie V S Kasper•Organization & Environment•2009

  • Rethinking classical theory

    Rogers Brubaker•After Bourdieu•2006

  • Climate Change as Social Drama

    Open Access•Philip Smith, Philip L Smith et al.•Climate Change As Social Drama•2015

  • Is This America

    Ron Eyerman•Is This America?•2015

  • Outline of a Theory of Practice

    Open Access•Pierre Bourdieu, Richard Nice•On Violence•2007

  • Discourses of Global Climate Change

    Jonas Anshelm, Martin Hultman•Discourses of Global Climate Change•2014

  • Routledge Handbook of the Climate Change Movement

    Matthias Dietz, Heiko Garrelts•Routledge Handbook of the Climate…•2014

  • Avoiding Politics

    Open Access•Nina Eliasoph•Avoiding Politics•1998

  • Living in Denial

    Kari Marie Norgaard•Living in Denial•2011

  • The Logic of Practice

    Pierre Bourdieu•The Logic of Practice•1990

  • How climate change research undermines trust in everyday life

    Open Access•Chloe H Lucas, Peat Leith et al.•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2015

  • Institutional inertia and climate change

    Open Access•Johan Munck Af Rosenschöld, Jaap G Rozema et al.•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2014

  • Clarifying anti-reflexivity

    Open Access•Riley E Dunlap•Environmental Research Letters•2014

  • What shapes perceptions of climate change? New research since 2010

    Open Access•Elke U Weber•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2015

  • Barriers to effective climate change mitigation

    Open Access•Lauren Rickards, John Wiseman et al.•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2014

  • Habitual behaviors or patterns of practice? Explaining and changing repetitive climate‐relevant actions

    Open Access•Tim Kurz, Benjamin Gardner et al.•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2014

  • Psychology's contributions to understanding and addressing global climate change

    Janet K Swim, Paul C Stern et al.•American Psychologist•2011

  • The dragons of inaction

    Robert Gifford•American Psychologist•2011

  • Analysing responses to climate change through the lens of reflexivity

    Open Access•D J Davidson, Debra Davidson•British Journal of Sociology•2012

  • A Theory of Practice for Social Movements

    Randolph Haluza-Delay, Randolph Haluza‐delay•Mobilization An International…•2008

  • Theories of Climate Change

    Clive Hamilton•Australian Journal of Political…•2012

  • Talk of the Enemy

    Graham Knight, Josh Greenberg•Social movement studies•2011

  • On the perpetuation of ignorance

    Steven Shepherd, Aaron C Kay•Journal of Personality and Social…•2012

  • Inaction and environmental crisis

    Open Access•Matthew Adams•Psychoanalysis Culture & Society•2014

  • Anxiety and defense in sustainability

    Open Access•Peliwe Pelisa Mnguni, Peliwe Mnguni•Psychoanalysis Culture & Society•2010

  • Social dreaming and ecocentric ethics

    Open Access•Jonathan Gosling, Peter Case•Organization•2013

  • Beyond the ABC

    Open Access•Elizabeth Shove•Environment and Planning A…•2010

  • Stumbling towards collapse

    Terry Leahy, Vanessa Bowden et al.•Environmental Politics•2010

  • Neoliberal climate policy

    Robert Macneil, Marisa Paterson et al.•Environmental Politics•2012

  • Depoliticizing adaptation

    Elise Remling•Environmental Politics•2018

  • Searching for 'the political' in environmental politics

    Anneleen Kenis, Matthias Lievens•Environmental Politics•2014

  • Social movements, field frames and industry emergence

    M Lounsbury, M Ventresca et al.•Socio-Economic Review•2003

  • Dictionary of the History of Ideas

    James Collins, James Daniel Collins•Thought•1974

  • An Invitation of Reflexive Sociology

    Open Access•Dany Lacombe, Pierre Bourdieu et al.•The Canadian Journal of Sociology•1993

  • Apocalypse Forever

    Open Access•E Swyngedouw•Theory Culture & Society•2010

  • Capital Contests

    Open Access•Dena Levy, David L Levy et al.•Latin American Politics and Society•1998

  • The Missing Key

    Open Access•Marc Garcelon•Sociological Theory•2010

  • Network Analysis, Culture, and the Problem of Agency

    Mustafa Emirbayer, Jeff Goodwin•American Journal of Sociology•1994

  • Pragmatism, Bourdieu, and collective emotions in contentious politics

    Open Access•Mustafa Emirbayer, Chad Alan Goldberg et al.•Theory and Society•2005

  • Rethinking classical theory

    Open Access•Rogers Brubaker•Theory and Society•1985

Unique citing works81
Citations per year11,57
Citation span2019 - 2026 (8)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 74

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae