Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Aesthetic surgery as false beauty

Bibliographic Data

ID4367408
AuthorsR Holliday (0000-0002-8796-1853, University of Leeds, corresponding author), Jacqueline Sanchez Taylor (University of Leeds)
Year2006
Volume7
Issue2
Pages179-195
Publication date2006-08-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueFeminist Theory (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1464-7001 • E-ISSN: 1741-2773
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/1464700106064418
OpenAlexW2108355365
LanguageEN
Citations received49
References cited27

This article identifies a prevalent strand of feminist writing on beauty and aesthetic surgery and explores some of the contradictions and inconsistencies inscribed within it. In particular, we concentrate on three central feminist claims: that living in a misogynist culture produces aesthetic surgery as an issue predominantly concerning women; that pain - both physical and psychic - is a central conceptual frame through which aesthetic surgery should be viewed; and that aesthetic surgery is inherently a normalizing technology. Engaging with these 'myths', we explore the tensions uncovered through a historical analysis of the practices of aesthetic surgery as well as the challenges to feminist claims offered by post-feminism. In particular we seek to destabilize the connection in feminist writing between beauty and passivity. We argue that through aesthetic references to denigrated black and working-class bodies, young women may mobilize aesthetic surgeries to reinscribe active sexuality on the feminine body

Aesthetics · Art · Beauty · Feminism · Human sexuality · Literature · Mythology · Psychic · Sociology · Visual arts · Body Image and Dysmorphia Studies · Empathy and Medical Education · Gender Studies · Gender, Feminism, and Media · Medicine

  • It’s Quickly Over and Easily Accessible

    Open Access•Ivana Lovrić, Mateja Plenković•Studia Universitatis Babeş-Bolyai.…•2025

  • O profilu zainteresiranih estetičara ili studenata grada Zagreba otvorenih za estetsku kirurgiju

    Open Access•Ivana Lovrić, Paula Zujić et al.•Kroatologija•2023

  • Moderating Glamour

    Open Access•Katherine Farrimond•Open Screens•2025

  • Fitting the vulvas

    Brigita Miloš•Northern Lights Film and Media…•2023

  • Structural injustice and the Requirements of Beauty

    Open Access•Heather Widdows•Journal of Social Philosophy•2021

  • The uncanny valley

    Open Access•Feona Attwood•International Journal of Cultural…•2014

  • Glamour modelling and the marketing of self-sexualization

    Open Access•Maddy Coy, Maria Garner•International Journal of Cultural…•2010

  • Clouded judgments? Aesthetics, morality and everyday life in early 21st century culture

    Open Access•Giselinde Kuipers, Thomas Franssen et al.•European Journal of Cultural…•2019

  • Celebrity Biometrics

    Luciana Ugrina•Fashion Theory•2014

  • Beautiful face, beautiful place

    R Holliday, David Bell et al.•Gender Place & Culture•2013

  • Female Genital Cosmetic Surgery

    Open Access•Leonore Tiefer•Feminism & Psychology•2008

  • Stark raving fat

    Open Access•Brenda R Weber•Feminism & Psychology•2012

  • Past and Future Perfect? Beauty, Affect and Hope

    R Coleman, Mónica Moreno Figueroa•Journal for Cultural Research•2010

  • A glamorous feminism by design

    Sarah Elsie Baker, Sarah Baker•Cultural Studies•2017

  • Fake breasts and power

    Open Access•Jacqueline Sanchez Taylor•Women s Studies International Forum•2012

  • Understanding choice

    Open Access•Hua Ma•Women s Studies International Forum•2026

  • Expressive Surfaces

    Open Access•M D R Jones, Meredith Jones•Theory Culture & Society•2017

  • A second youth

    Open Access•Taina Kinnunen•Sociology of Health & Illness•2010

  • Influences of Emerging Beauty Industry for Men on Construction of Masculinities of Male Students of Dhaka City

    Open Access•Abu Saleh Mohammad Sowad•Masculinities & Social Change•2017

  • The Power of Beauty in Reality Plastic Surgery Shows

    Open Access•Shu‐Yueh Lee, Shu-Yueh Lee•Communication Culture and Critique•2009

  • Tweakments

    Open Access•A Dowrick, R Holliday•Sociology Compass•2022

  • Genre Transvestites

    Open Access•Brenda R Weber, Karolyn Steffens•The Journal of Popular Culture•2010

  • Latina bodies in the era of elective aesthetic surgery

    Open Access•Hilda Lloréns•Latino Studies•2013

  • I, Robot?’ Or how transgender subjects are dehumanised

    Saoirse O’shea, Saoirse Caitlin O’Shea•Culture and Organization•2018

  • Man Made Plastic

    Open Access•R Holliday, Allie Cairnie•Journal of Consumer Culture•2007

  • Bikinis and Bandages

    Open Access•David Bell, R Holliday et al.•Tourist Studies•2011

  • Encoding material female bodies through cosmetic surgeries

    Chakshu Gupta, Isha Malhotra•Medical Humanities•2024

  • The Becoming of Bodies

    R Coleman•Feminist Media Studies•2008

  • Gays, Gaze and Aunty Gok

    Shaira Kadir, Joanna Tidy•Feminist Media Studies•2011

  • Aesthetic Capital

    Open Access•Tammy L Anderson, Catherine Grunert et al.•Sociology Compass•2010

  • For speaking against silence

    Open Access•Mark Griffiths•Transactions of the Institute of…•2017

  • Nature, wellbeing and the transformational self

    Open Access•Jo Little•Geographical Journal•2014

  • "Why Does She Have to Wear Make-up? She Looks Better Natural!" Staged Photos and Sexual Subjectivities

    Emma Phillips•Australian Feminist Studies•2022

  • Homeless women Don't wear Prada

    Open Access•Harriet Earle-Brown•Geography Compass•2022

  • Scales of care and responsibility

    Stephen Atkinson, Sarah Atkinson•Social & Cultural Geography•2011

  • Aesthetic surgery and the expressive body

    Open Access•Rachel Alsop, Kathleen Lennon•Feminist Theory•2018

  • Gender, Globalization and Aesthetic Surgery in South Korea

    Open Access•R Holliday, Joanna Elfving-Hwang•Body & Society•2012

  • Breast Surgery as a Gender Technology

    Gerard Coll-Planas, Marta Cruells et al.•Studies in Gender and Sexuality•2017

  • Weaving relational webs

    Open Access•C Pedwell•Feminist Theory•2008

  • Special Section on Sex and Surgery

    Open Access•Kristin Zeiler•Feminist Theory•2013

  • Pampering, well-being and women's bodies in the therapeutic spaces of the spa

    Jo Little•Social & Cultural Geography•2013

  • The Free-Flying Natural Woman Boobs of Yore'? the Body Beyond Representation in Feminist Accounts of Objectification

    Open Access•H Mccann•Feminist Review•2020

  • Mujeres de coto en Guadalajara, Jalisco

    Open Access•Misael Camus, Manuela Camus Bergareche•Amerika•2013

  • Commodifying femininity

    Veronica Hopner, Kerry Chamberlain•Journal of Gender Studies•2020

  • Shining a light on the grey zones of gender construction

    C Greco•Journal of Gender Studies•2016

  • Negotiating beauty

    Open Access•Hua Ma•Journal of Gender Studies•2025

  • Buying and Selling Breasts

    Open Access•Jacqueline Sanchez Taylor•The Sociological Review•2012

  • Rethinking Fat

    Open Access•Carla Rice•Culture Studies ↔ Critical…•2015

  • Formations of Femininity

    Eric Plemons•Medical Anthropology•2017

  • The politics and poetics of transgression

    Allon White, Peter Stallybrass•The politics and poetics of…•1986

  • Adorned in Dreams

    Elizabeth Wilson•Adorned in Dreams•1985

  • Unbearable Weight

    Susan Bordo•Unbearable Weight•2003

  • In the Flesh

    Open Access•Victoria L Pitts•In the Flesh•2003

  • Beauty and Misogyny

    Sheila Jeffreys•Beauty and Misogyny•2005

  • Sexual Dissidence

    Jonathan Dollimore•Sexual dissidence•1991

  • The Body Social

    Anthony Synnott•Body Social•2002

  • The Beauty Industry

    Paula Black•The Beauty Industry•2004

  • Rabelais and his world

    Mikhail Bakhtin, H Iswolsky•Applied Theatre Reader•2020

  • Feminism Confronts Technology

    Judy Wajcman•Feminism Confronts Technology•1991

  • The gender/sexuality reader

    Micaela Di Leonardo, Roger N Lancaster•The gender/sexuality reader•1997

  • The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life

    Erving Goffman•The Presentation of Self in…•1990

  • The Routledge Companion to Feminism and Postfeminism

    Sarah Gamble•The Routledge Companion To…•2004

  • Feminism and Youth Culture

    Open Access•A Mcrobbie•Feminism and youth culture•1991

  • Leaky Bodies and Boundaries

    Margrit Shildrick•Leaky bodies and boundaries•1997

  • Formations of Class and Gender

    Beverley Skeggs, Bev Skeggs et al.•Formations of class and gender•2002

  • Undoing Gender

    Judith Butler•Undoing Gender•2004

  • Reading the Popular

    John Fiske•Reading the Popular•2006

  • Feminism and Youth Culture

    Angela Mcrobbie•Feminism and Youth Culture•2000

  • Women and the Knife

    Open Access•Kathryn Pauly Morgan, Kathryn Morgan•Hypatia•1991

  • Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema

    Laura Mulvey•Screen•1975

  • The body social

    Anthony Synnott•The body social•1993

  • Pornography, Men Possessing Women

    Janice Winship, Andrea Dworkin et al.•Feminist Review•1982

  • Telling feminist stories

    Open Access•Clare Hemmings•Feminist Theory•2005

  • Imperial Leather

    Anne Mcclintock•Imperial Leather•2013

  • Making the Body Beautiful

    Open Access•Grant Jewell Rich•Anthropology of Consciousness•2000

Unique citing works49
Citations per year2,58
Citation span2007 - 2026 (20)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 49

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae