Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Conflicting Environmental Visions of the Rural

Windfarm Development in Mid Wales

Bibliographic Data

ID4446286
AuthorsMichael Wood (0000-0002-6216-142X), Michael Woods (0000-0003-3813-4138, Aberystwyth University, corresponding author)
Year2003
Volume43
Issue3
Pages271-288
Publication date2003-07-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueSociologia Ruralis (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0038-0199 • E-ISSN: 1467-9523
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/1467-9523.00245
OpenAlexW1980648085
LanguageEN
Citations received79
References cited13

The development of wind turbine power stations in rural locations has become an increasingly controversial issue with conflict revolving around representations of nature and the balance that should be struck between the preservation of a local environment and landscape, and the wider concern of tacking climate change through reducing fuel dependency. As such, conflicts over 'windfarm' development provide a rare insight into how political actors negotiate and rationalise the often closed relationship between nature, environment and rurality that lies at the core of much contemporary rural policy and planning strategy. This paper explores these themes through examination of the debate that surrounded proposals to build Europe's largest 'windfarm' at Cefn Croes in Wales. By deconstructing the rhetoric employed by both sides in the conflict, the paper demonstrates how 'nature' is constructed in different ways to allow both lobbies to claim the environmental high ground, how lay discourses are contrasted with technical discourses, and how landscape is connected to the changing rural economy

Balance (ability) · Geography · Mosaic · Negotiation · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Power (physics) · Rhetoric · Rural area · Rurality · Sociology · Vision · Law · Rural development and sustainability · Social Acceptance of Renewable Energy · Urbanization and City Planning

  • Public engagement with offshore renewable energy

    Open Access•Bouke Wiersma, Patrick Devine‐wright•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2014

  • Stewardship and everyday governance

    Open Access•Kadri Kasemets•Sociologia Ruralis•2024

  • The Routledge Companion to Rural Planning

    Oane Visser, Max Spoor et al.•The Routledge Companion to Rural…•2019

  • Disintegrated development at the rural–urban fringe

    Open Access•A J Scott, Alister Scott et al.•Progress in Planning•2013

  • Not in Anyone’s Backyard? Civil Society Attitudes towards Wind Power at the National and Local Levels in Portugal

    Open Access•Ana Delicado, Luís Junqueira et al.•Science & Technology Studies•2014

  • Community perceptions of renewable energies in Portugal

    Open Access•Ana Delicado, Elisabete Figueiredo et al.•Energy Research & Social Science•2015

  • Are the impacts of wind energy reversible? Critically reviewing the research literature, the governance challenges and presenting an agenda for social science

    Open Access•Rebecca Windemer, Richard Cowell•Energy Research & Social Science•2021

  • Decarbonisation of industrial clusters

    Open Access•Patrick Devine‐wright•Energy Research & Social Science•2022

  • Planetary rural geographies

    Open Access•Chi-Mao Wang, Damian Maye et al.•Dialogues in Human Geography•2023

  • The sociology of global climate change

    Open Access•Stephen C Zehr•Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews…•2014

  • Localism and the Environment

    Open Access•David J He•Sociology Compass•2008

  • Cool Rationalities and Hot Air

    John Barry, Geraint Ellis et al.•Global Environmental Politics•2008

  • Introduction. Between Absence and Presence

    Rhys Dafydd Jones, John P Robinson et al.•Space and Polity•2012

  • Moving to or from a carbon dependent countryside

    Open Access•Martin Phillips, Jennifer Dickie•Journal of Transport Geography•2018

  • Conflicts of power, landscape and amenity in debates over the British Super Grid in the 1950s

    Open Access•Katrina Navickas•Rural History•2019

  • Changing community relations in southeast China

    Open Access•Yanqiang Du, Pingyang Liu et al.•Agriculture and Human Values•2020

  • Deconstructing rural protest

    Open Access•Michael Woods, Mike Woods•Journal of Rural Studies•2003

  • A Habermasian analysis of local renewable energy deliberations

    Open Access•Stewart Fast•Journal of Rural Studies•2013

  • The politics of place

    Open Access•Ángel Paniagua Mazorra, Angel Paniagua•Journal of Rural Studies•2009

  • Wind farms in rural areas

    Open Access•Max Munday, Gabriel Bristow et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2010

  • Conceptualizing rural energy transitions

    Open Access•M Naumann, David Rudolph•Journal of Rural Studies•2019

  • Rural geography III

    Open Access•Michael Woods, Mike Woods•Progress in Human Geography•2011

  • Flying lessons

    Open Access•P Adey, Lucy Budd et al.•Progress in Human Geography•2007

  • Mobile phone masts

    Open Access•Frances Drake•Public Understanding of Science•2006

  • Emerging Renewable Energy Landscapes in Southern European Countries

    Marina Frolova, María-José Prados et al.•Renewable Energies and European…•2015

  • Landscapes of Energies, a Perspective on the Energy Transition

    Open Access•Alain Nadaï, María-José Prados et al.•Renewable Energies and European…•2015

  • Harnessing Community Energies

    Gordon Walker, Sue Hunter et al.•Global Environmental Politics•2007

  • The ground beneath our feet is still holding strong

    Open Access•Naama Zohar, Avi Shnider et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2025

  • Climate Change and Society

    Thomas Dietz, Rachael Shwom et al.•Annual Review of Sociology•2020

  • Exploring the Local Sustainability of a Green Economy in Alpine Communities

    Open Access•Natalia Magnani•Mountain Research and Development•2012

  • The role of place in energy transitions

    Open Access•Richard Cowell•Geoforum•2020

  • What does it mean to nurture ‘good intentions between city and country’? Performances of rural–urban relations in community-supported agriculture

    Open Access•John Spanier•Geoforum•2025

  • Spatial imaginaries underpin community objections to shale gas exploration in the UK

    Open Access•Stacia S Ryder, Stacia Ryder et al.•Geoforum•2025

  • The politics of the rural and relational values

    Open Access•George Holmes, James Clemoes et al.•Geoforum•2022

  • Windfalls for whom? The evolving notion of ‘community’ in community benefit provisions from wind farms

    Open Access•Gabriel Bristow, Gillian Bristow et al.•Geoforum•2012

  • Theorizing energy landscapes for energy transition management

    Open Access•Kirby Calvert, Kirsten Greer et al.•Geoforum•2019

  • Constructing a ‘landscape justice’ for windfarm development

    Open Access•Kelvin Mason, Paul Milbourne•Geoforum•2014

  • Explaining “Nimby” Objections to a Power Line

    Open Access•Patrick Devine‐wright, Patrick Devine-Wright•Environment and Behavior•2012

  • Many ways to say ‘no’, different ways to say ‘yes’

    Geraint Ellis, John Barry et al.•Journal of Environmental Planning…•2007

  • Technologies in Place

    Open Access•Carly Mclachlan•The Sociological Review•2009

  • Uncommon Ground

    Open Access•Bregje Van Veelen, Claire Haggett•Sociologia Ruralis•2016

  • Nimby by another name? A reply to Wolsink

    Open Access•P Hubbard•Transactions of the Institute of…•2006

  • Beyond the public in controversies

    Open Access•Elisabeth van de Grift, Eefje Cuppen•Energy Research & Social Science•2022

  • Stakeholders perception of attitudes towards major landscape changes held by the public

    Open Access•Elke Rogge, Joost Dessein et al.•Land Use Policy•2011

  • Wind power planning in France (Aveyron), from state regulation to local planning

    Open Access•Alain Nadaï, Olivier Labussière•Land Use Policy•2009

  • Exploring the landscape of wind farm developments; local area characteristics and planning process outcomes in rural England

    Open Access•Dan Van Der Horst, David Toke•Land Use Policy•2010

  • Conceptualising ‘shadow landscape’ in political ecology and rural studies

    Open Access•Raymond L Bryant, Ángel Paniagua Mazorra et al.•Land Use Policy•2011

  • Future-proofing the farm

    Open Access•Lee-Ann Sutherland, Lee‐ann Sutherland et al.•Land Use Policy•2014

  • The environmental dimension in the constitution of new social groups in an extremely depopulated rural area of Spain (Soria)

    Open Access•Ángel Paniagua Mazorra, Angel Paniagua•Land Use Policy•2008

  • Wind power planning, landscapes and publics

    Open Access•Alain Nadaï, Dan Van Der Horst•Land Use Policy•2010

  • Wind power, landscape and strategic, spatial planning—The construction of ‘acceptable locations’ in Wales

    Open Access•Richard Cowell•Land Use Policy•2010

  • Offshore wind power development as affected by seascape values on the German North Sea coast

    Open Access•Kira Gee•Land Use Policy•2010

  • Redefining the ‘Rural Question’

    Open Access•Michael Woods•Social Policy and Administration•2006

  • Accommodating New Housing Development in Rural Areas? Representations of Landscape, Land and Rurality in Ireland

    Karen Foley, Mark Scott•Landscape Research•2014

  • Housing Conflicts in the Irish Countryside

    Mark Scott•Landscape Research•2012

  • Landscapes of Threat? Exploring Discourses of Stigma around Large Energy Developments

    Karen Parkhill, Karen A Parkhill et al.•Landscape Research•2014

  • Carbon Claims and Energy Landscapes

    Dan Van Der Horst, James Evans•Landscape Research•2010

  • Local Rights to Landscape in the Global Moral Economy of Carbon

    Dan Van Der Horst, Saskia Vermeylen•Landscape Research•2011

  • Making Space for Wind Farms

    Open Access•David Rudolph, Julia Kirch Kirkegaard•Antipode•2019

  • Undoing Nature

    Open Access•A Fiona D Mackenzie, Alison Mackenzie•Antipode•2008

  • Invalid theory impedes our understanding

    Open Access•M Wolsink•Transactions of the Institute of…•2006

  • The changing cultural and economic values of wind energy landscapes

    Open Access•Stewart Fast, Warren Mabee et al.•Canadian Geographies /…•2015

  • A Territorial Perspective on Urban and Regional Energy Transitions

    Open Access•Benedikt Walker•International Journal of Urban…•2022

  • Social Acceptance of Renewable Energy

    Open Access•Stewart Fast•Geography Compass•2013

  • Plural and hybrid environmental values

    Brad Jessup•Environmental Politics•2010

  • Energy transition, rural transformation and local land-use planning

    Open Access•Kirby Calvert, Emily Smit et al.•Environment and Planning E Nature…•2021

  • Qualified, absolute, idealistic, impatient

    Open Access•Stewart Fast•Environment and Planning A…•2015

  • Wind Energy on the Isle of Lewis

    Open Access•Janet Fisher, Katrina Brown•Environment and Planning A…•2009

  • Tourists' perceptions of wind turbines

    Open Access•Prince, Solène Prince et al.•Tourism Geographies•2024

  • Protesting Mobile Phone Masts

    Open Access•Frances Drake•Science Technology & Human Values•2011

  • Geographical trajectories, biographical determinants and (new) place political elites in selected remote rural areas of north-central Spain

    Open Access•Ángel Paniagua Mazorra, Angel Paniagua•Geographical Journal•2015

  • Reconciling Windfarms with Rural Place Identity

    Open Access•Rebecca Wheeler•Sociologia Ruralis•2017

  • Organic Views of Nature

    Open Access•Becky Mansfield•Sociologia Ruralis•2004

  • Belonging to and in the Shale Gas Fields. A Case-Study of the Noordoostpolder, the Netherlands

    Open Access•Michiel Köhne, Elisabet Dueholm Rasch•Sociologia Ruralis•2018

  • The agencies of landscape in rural gentrification

    Open Access•Martin Phillips, Darren Smith et al.•Sociologia Ruralis•2021

  • On the Environmental Embeddedness of Redneck Identity and Politics

    Open Access•Jordan Fox Besek, Jeanine Cunningham•Sociologia Ruralis•2020

  • Les éoliennes

    Open Access•Christine Hugh-Jones•Terrain•2013

  • Ambiente, paisagem, património e economia

    Open Access•Ana Delicado, Luís Silva et al.•Revista crítica de ciências…•2013

  • Opportunity or Threat

    Open Access•Mick Lennon, Mark Scott•Sociologia Ruralis•2017

  • Childerley

    Michael Bell•Childerley•1994

  • Wind, energy, landscape

    Gordon G Brittan•Philosophy and Geography•2001

  • Wind, energy, landscape

    Gordon G Brittan, Gordon G Brittan Jr•Philosophy and Geography•2001

  • Researching rural conflicts

    Open Access•Michael Woods, Mike Woods•Journal of Rural Studies•1998

  • Talking about rurality

    Open Access•Keith Halfacree, Keith H Halfacree•Journal of Rural Studies•1995

  • Lay discourses of the rural

    Open Access•Oliver Jones, Owain Jones•Journal of Rural Studies•1995

  • Earth First! and the Anti-Roads Movement

    Bron Taylor•Environmental Ethics•2001

  • The Matter of Nature

    Open Access•Margaret Fitzsimmons•Antipode•1989

  • Social Constructions of Nature

    Carolyn M Harrison, Carolyn Harrison et al.•Transactions of the Institute of…•1994

  • Bargaining with Nature

    Sarah Whatmore, Susan Boucher•Transactions of the Institute of…•1993

  • Discourses of power and rurality

    Open Access•Michael Wood, Michael Woods et al.•Political Geography•1997

  • The Contested Redefinition of the Countryside. An Analysis of Rural Discourses in The Netherlands

    Open Access•Jaap Frouws•Sociologia Ruralis•1998

Unique citing works79
Citations per year3,43
Citation span2003 - 2025 (23)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 77

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae