Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Power, Space, and the Body

A Critical Assessment of Foucault's Discipline and Punish

Bibliographic Data

ID4475809
AuthorsFelix Driver (0000-0003-0318-4282, University of Cambridge, corresponding author)
Year1985
Volume3
Issue4
Pages425-446
Publication date1985-12-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEnvironment and Planning D Society and Space (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0263-7758 • E-ISSN: 1472-3433
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1068/d030425
OpenAlexW2036244369
LanguageEN
Citations received62
References cited25

The work of Michel Foucault has recently been subjected to considerable scrutiny. This paper is an examination of his book, Discipline and Punish, which describes an historical transformation in the exercise of power. The themes (section 2) and the significance (section 3) of the book are discussed in terms of Foucault's conception of history and power. In the rest of the paper, its implications are examined more closely, through four categories: 'institutions', 'the economy', 'law and the state', and 'struggle and strategy'. Under these headings are discussed the connections and contradictions between Foucault's analysis and more conventional Marxist or Weberian approaches. Although Foucault's perspectives cannot be 'incorporated' within such theories of power, they are far from being completely incompatible with them

Epistemology · Marxist philosophy · Michel foucault · Political science · Politics · Power (physics) · Scrutiny · Section (typography · Sociology · Space (punctuation) · State (computer science) · Development, Ethics, and Society · Feminism, Gender, and Sexuality Studies · Foucault, Power, and Ethics · Law · Philosophy

  • Governamentalidade E Geografia

    Open Access•Rafael Galvão Almeida, Rafael Gonçalves de Almeida•Espaço e Cultura•2013

  • The Spatial Development of the Modern Stadium

    Open Access•John Bale•International Review for the…•1993

  • History, Geography and the ‘Still Greater Mystery’ of Historical Geography

    Chris Philo•Human Geography•1994

  • Therapeutic Landscapes in Hospital Design

    Open Access•Steven Curti, Sarah Curtis et al.•Environment and Planning C…•2007

  • Novel Insights into Sports History

    Open Access•K E James•Histories•2025

  • Antagonism to Protagonism

    Open Access•Shalini Bhawal, Manjula S Salimath•Journal of Business Ethics•2022

  • Space, Knowledge and Power

    Stuart Elden, Jeremy W Crampton•Space, Knowledge And Power•2016

  • Hegemonía, gubernamentalidad, territorio. Apuntes metodológicos para una historia social de la planificación

    Open Access•Álvaro Sevilla Buitrago•Empiria Revista de metodología de…•2013

  • State Apparatus

    Open Access•Felix Driver•Environment and Planning A…•1985

  • Resilience Behind Barriers

    Open Access•N Ganapathy, Vineeta Sinha•Urban Science•2025

  • Governmentality, the Local State, and the Commons

    Open Access•Marina Pera, Iolanda Bianchi•Social Inclusion•2021

  • Foucault's population geographies

    Open Access•Stephen Legg•Population Space and Place•2005

  • Are schools panoptic

    Open Access•Michael Gallagher, Micheal Gallagher•Surveillance & Society•2010

  • Indigenous Fijian masculinity and tourism as a liminoid experience (Nadi, Fiji)

    Open Access•K E James, Sheikh Ali Tanzil•Journal of Tourism and Cultural…•2025

  • Global benchmarking

    Open Access•Silvia Naydenova•Globalizations•2025

  • Property and the governance of the family farm in rural Australia

    Open Access•M Voyce•Journal of Sociology•2007

  • Culture, government and spatiality

    Open Access•Clive Barnett•International Journal of Cultural…•1999

  • Accumulating populations

    Open Access•C Philo•International Journal of…•2001

  • The rural panopticon

    Open Access•C Philo, Hayden Lorimer et al.•Journal of Rural Studies•2016

  • Discursive-technical landscaping and policing the body (politic) in Azerbaijan

    Open Access•Karli-Jo Storm•Geografiska Annaler Series B…•2023

  • Carceral layers in a geropsychiatric unit in Finland

    Virve Repo•Geografiska Annaler Series B…•2019

  • Beyond dualism – the social construction of nature and the natural and social construction of human beings

    Open Access•Judith Gerber•Progress in Human Geography•1997

  • Between modernism and postmodernism

    Open Access•Lawrence D Berg•Progress in Human Geography•1993

  • Historical geography 2007—2008

    Open Access•Robert J Mayhew•Progress in Human Geography•2008

  • Famine

    Open Access•Callum Williams•Scottish Journal of Political…•2015

  • Russia's penal peripheries

    Open Access•Judith Pallot•Transactions of the Institute of…•2005

  • Governmentality, subject‐building, and the discourses and practices of devolution in the UK

    Open Access•Mike Raco•Transactions of the Institute of…•2003

  • Torture and the Ticking Bomb

    Matthew G Hannah, Matthew Hannah•Annals of the Association of…•2006

  • The Birth of the Clinic

    Open Access•Chris Philo•Area•2000

  • The contamination of personal space

    Open Access•David Sibley, Bettina Van Hoven•Area•2009

  • Panopticon citizenship

    Chandraprakash Yoganathan, Ioana Vrăbiescu•Citizenship Studies•2026

  • At home, he’s a pet, at work he’s a colleague and my right arm

    Charles Knight, Katherine J C Sang et al.•Culture and Organization•2019

  • A swamp and its subjects

    Open Access•Bjørn Sletto, Bjørn Ingmunn Sletto•Geoforum•2004

  • Building [dis]trust in Covid discourses

    Open Access•Konstantin A Galkin, Oksana A Parfenova•Ekologiya Cheloveka (Human Ecology•2023

  • A strong and prosperous condition' - the geography of state building and social reform in Peter the Great's Russia

    Open Access•Denis J B Shaw•Political Geography•1999

  • The geopolitics of South African cities

    Open Access•Jennifer Robinson•Political Geography•1997

  • Practising state consolidation in early modern England and Wales

    Open Access•Rhys Dafydd Jones, Rhys Jones•Political Geography•2004

  • The geopolitics of the police

    Open Access•Steve Herbert•Political Geography•1996

  • Space and Government

    Open Access•Margo Huxley•Geography Compass•2008

  • The gaze without eyes

    Open Access•Hille Koskela•Progress in Human Geography•2000

  • A 'new Foucault' with lively implications - or 'the crawfish advances sideways

    Open Access•C Philo•Transactions of the Institute of…•2012

  • Cam Era' - the contemporary urban Panopticon

    Open Access•Hille Koskela•Surveillance & Society•2002

  • Prison geographies

    Open Access•Bloch, Enrique Alan Olivares‐pelayo•Geography Compass•2024

  • How (Not) to be Governed

    Open Access•Louisa Cadman•Environment and Planning D…•2010

  • An Occasion for Geography

    Open Access•David Matle, David Matless•Environment and Planning D…•1992

  • Dark Panopticon. Or, Attack of the Killer Tomatoes

    Open Access•Marcus A Doel, Duncan Clarke et al.•Environment and Planning D…•1999

  • Foucault's Geography

    Open Access•C Philo•Environment and Planning D…•1992

  • Public Space and the Public Sphere

    Open Access•Philip Howell•Environment and Planning D…•1993

  • The Power of Water

    Open Access•Michael Ekers, Alex Loftus•Environment and Planning D…•2008

  • What Does Not Kill You

    Open Access•Reecia Orzeck•Environment and Planning D…•2007

  • Spaces of Surveillant Simulation

    Open Access•Graham, Stephen Graham•Environment and Planning D…•1998

  • Disciplining De Facto Development

    Open Access•Katie Meehan, Katharine Meehan•Environment and Planning D…•2013

  • A Perfect System of Control'? State Power and 'Native Locations' in South Africa

    Open Access•Jennifer Robinson•Environment and Planning D…•1990

  • Culture, Geography, and the Arts of Government

    Open Access•Clive Barnett•Environment and Planning D…•2001

  • Geography's Empire

    Open Access•Felix Driver•Environment and Planning D…•1992

  • Technology, Power, and Space-The Means and Ends of Geographies of Technology

    Open Access•Steve Hinchliffe•Environment and Planning D…•1996

  • Scripting the Compound

    Open Access•J Crush•Environment and Planning D…•1994

  • Security Here is Not Safe

    Open Access•Karen M Morin•Environment and Planning D…•2013

  • Working the System

    Open Access•George Revill•Environment and Planning D…•1994

  • Practising architectures

    J M Jacobs, Peter Merriman•Social & Cultural Geography•2011

  • Foucault, the Museum and the Diagram

    Open Access•Kevin Hetherington•The Sociological Review•2011

  • The Territorial Trap of the Territorial Trap

    Open Access•Nisha Shah•International Political Sociology•2012

  • Punishment and Social Structure

    Georg Rusche, Otto Kirchheimer et al.•Punishment and Social Structure•1939

  • Max Weber

    Reinhard Bendix•Max Weber•1977

  • From Marx to Nietzsche? Neo-Conservatism, Foucault, and Problems in Contemporary Political Theory

    Open Access•Anthony Giddens•Profiles and Critiques in Social…•1982

  • Ideology and Consciousness

    Anthony Giddens•Central Problems in Social Theory•1979

  • Languages of Class

    Open Access•Gareth Stedman Jones•Languages of Class•1984

  • The Prison and the Factory

    Open Access•D Melossi, Massimo Pavarini•The Prison and the Factory•1981

  • The Anatomy of Capitalist Societies

    Open Access•John Urry•The Anatomy of Capitalist Societies•1981

  • Foucault, Marxism and Critique

    Barry Smart•Foucault, Marxism and Critique•2013

  • Michel Foucault

    Open Access•Mark Cousins, Athar Cousins Mark Hussain et al.•Michel Foucault•1984

  • Is there a Future for Marxism

    Open Access•Alex Callinicos•Is There a Future for Marxism?•1982

  • Michel Foucault

    Hubert L Dreyfus, Michel Foucault et al.•Michel Foucault•1983

  • Archaeology of Knowledge

    Michel Foucault•Archaeology of Knowledge•2013

  • State Apparatus

    Open Access•Felix Driver•Environment and Planning A…•1985

  • Prisons and Panopticons

    Open Access•Bill Forsythe•Social Policy and Administration•1984

  • The rise of Western rationalism

    Wolfgang Schluchter•The rise of Western rationalism•1985

  • Discipline and Punish

    Raffaella D’amico•Telos•1978

  • State, Civil Society, and Total Institutions

    Michael Ignatieff•Crime and Justice•1981

  • Commodity Form and Legal Form

    Open Access•Isaac D Balbus•Law & Society Review•1977

  • A Contemporary Critique of Historical Materialism

    Open Access•Anthony Giddens•Contemporary Critique of…•1981

  • Max Weber on Law in Economy and Society

    Max Rheinstein, Edward Shils•Harvard Law Review•1955

  • Sex, Politics and Society

    Jeffrey Weeks•Sex, Politics and Society•2014

  • Power, Interests and the Outcomes of Struggles

    Open Access•Barry Hinde, Barry Hindess•Sociology•1982

  • The Nouvelle Philosophie and Foucault

    Peter Dews•Economy and Society•1979

  • Foucault, sociology, and the problem of human agency

    Open Access•Barry Smart•Theory and Society•1982

Unique citing works62
Citations per year1,51
Citation span1985 - 2026 (42)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 60

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae